Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction

arXiv:2409.16052 · hep-ex, cs.LG · Submitted 2024-09-24 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction explores integrating super-resolution techniques into an LHC-like reconstruction pipeline to effectively enhance calorimeter granularity and suppress noise This study finds that this software preprocessing step significantly improves reconstruction quality without physical changes to the detector Calorimeter performance is generally characterized by energy resolution, but spatial resolution (inversely related to granularity) assumes a crucial role in dense collision environments Low-granularity calorimeters have limited imaging capabilities, constraining the performance of pattern reconstruction in PFlow algorithms such as assigning energy deposits to tracks and identifying neutral hadrons Superresolution (SR) techniques offer the potential to go beyond the spatial resolution intrinsic to the calorimeter design by reconstructing high-resolution (HR) data from low-resolution (LR) inputs This approach aims to enhance PFlow objects and, thereby, that of higher-level objects used in physics analyses such as jets, leptons, and photons Model Architecture and Methodology The core concept of the super-resolution model is inspired by the work

14: The data is represented as graphs, where each low-resolution graph is expanded into a high-resolution graph, with each low-resolution cell divided into fη × fφ high-resolution cells The model employs a transformer-based architecture to predict the vector field vt This process begins by upsampling the low-resolution graph through repetition, which serves as the conditional input Subsequently, a copy of the high-resolution graph, initialized with random values x0, is created This combined input is fed into a transformer network generating a neighborhood-aware representation that aids in understanding the energy deposition profile of the incident particles Particle Flow Model Integration A novel particle flow (PFlow) model is presented that builds on HGPflow principles but replaces iterative learning with a supervised attention mechanism The model processes detector data from cells using a transformer network to generate a neighborhood-aware representation The second branch focuses on kinematic prediction by learning the fractional energy distribution of each cell over the particles This distribution, referred to as the incidence matrix in HGPflow

22: , is predicted using an attention-like framework where particles and cells are processed through two MLPs to obtain key (K) and query (Q) vectors Performance Evaluation Quantitative assessment showed that the network trained with predicted high-resolution cells shows either comparable or improved performance relative to the one trained with low-resolution measured cells across cardinality prediction Furthermore, when evaluating kinematic values derived from incidence predictions, the model trained on predicted high-resolution cells shows a marked improvement in residuals for pT, η, and φ The predicted high-resolution cells closely match the truth HR cell distributions and offer significant improvements over noisy low-resolution data across all three substructure observables considered The work demonstrates that super-resolution can indeed enhance reconstruction by faithfully replicating high-resolution cell distributions Utilizing these high-resolution cells for particle flow substantially enhances both particle cardinality and kinematics performance Future directions plan to investigate more realistic physics setups, including hadronic showers, and explore superresolution in the lateral direction Acknowledgement We would like to thank Dmitrii Kobilianskii for fruitful discussions on flow matching implementation, and Kyle Cranmer and Yihui Ren for their valuable insights The code used for the analyses presented in this paper is available on GitHub The dataset generated and analysed during this study can be accessed through Zenodo (DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15582324) References

1: Lyndon Evans and Philip Bryant, LHC Machine, JINST, 3:S08001, 2008

3: ATLAS collaboration, Jet reconstruction and performance using particle flow with the ATLAS Detector, Eur.

Kai: Phys.

Mira: J.

Kai: C, 77(7):466, 2017

8: Chao Dong et al., Image super-resolution using deep convolutional networks, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 38(2):295–307, 2016

14: Chitwan Saharia et al., Image super-resolution via iterative refinement, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 45(4):4713–4726, 2023

28: Ricky T.

Title and authors: Kai: So, we’re looking at this paper called "Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction" by Kakati, Dreyer, and Gross. It’s about using super-resolution techniques on a graph representation of calorimeter data to fix noise and improve reconstruction quality in experiments like the LHC.

Mira: Right, so the authors are basically saying that even if you have a low-granularity calorimeter—which is common because of cost—you can use this software preprocessing step, this super-resolution thing, to get better results without actually changing the detector itself.

Lev: That’s interesting because usually when we talk about improving resolution, we think about getting better hardware or maybe better noise suppression in the electronics before it even hits the software layer.

Kai: Exactly. This paper is pointing to a software fix that works on top of existing data, using graph structures to handle those irregular shapes and sparsity in the signals. It’s about going beyond what the physical design of the detector allows us to see.

Mira: And they propose a new transformer-based particle flow model specifically designed around this super-resolution idea, which is what makes their reconstruction chain interesting for us as theorists.

Lev: I wonder how much overhead this adds when you try to run it on real hardware, like the kind we’re developing for error correction, because I know these graph neural networks can get heavy quickly.

Kai: That’s a fair concern, Lev, but the paper shows that the network predicts a vector field v t, and it starts by upsampling the low-resolution graph through repetition as a conditional input to guide the process.

Mira: And they use this to predict high-resolution cells by dividing each low-resolution cell into f eta times f phi high-resolution cells, which is their core super-resolution mechanism.

Lev: So they’re essentially reconstructing a finer grid of data that wasn't physically measured, and then feeding that reconstructed structure into the particle flow algorithm.

Kai: Yes, and this entire process is framed as denoising the energy deposits; they claim this preprocessing step significantly improves reconstruction quality across the board without needing any physical changes to the detector or its construction.

Mira: The paper shows that when they train their model with these predicted high-resolution cells, they get comparable or better performance in terms of particle cardinality prediction compared to training on only the low-resolution measured cells.

Lev: Comparable is good, but for us running real hardware, we need a clearer picture of how much benefit you actually get versus the complexity of generating those HR data structures.

Kai: The paper goes further and shows that when evaluating kinematic values derived from these incidence predictions—like p T, eta, and phi —the model trained on the predicted high-resolution cells shows a marked improvement in residuals compared to what you get from the low-resolution measured cells.

Mira: So, they aren't just improving how many particles we count; they’re getting better kinematic predictions for those particles too, which is crucial for things like identifying jets and leptons accurately.

Lev: Better residuals on p T, eta, and phi means the errors in reconstructing particle momentum and direction are smaller when you use this approach, which is a tangible improvement for any physics analysis downstream.

Kai: And they support that with substructure observables too; the predicted high-resolution cells closely match the true distributions of observables C two C three and D two across all three variables they tested <ref:2409.16052#pg2>.

Mira: So, to summarize, the key contribution of "Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction" is showing that super-resolution can be applied successfully at collider experiments by using a transformer-based particle flow model that denoises energy deposits and provides better particle reconstruction quality and kinematic predictions.

Lev: It sounds like it’s a very effective software tool to bridge the gap between imperfect detector granularity and the high precision needed for event reconstruction, though we'd want to see how robust it is when dealing with more complex, real-world hadronic showers.

Kai: That’s what they plan to investigate next; they suggest that future work should look at more realistic physics setups, specifically hadronic showers, and explore applying this super-resolution idea in the lateral direction as well.

Mira: So, while the immediate result is a significant improvement in particle flow performance using predicted high-resolution cells, the long-term potential is to use these refined models for much more complex event interpretation.

Lev: It’s clear that this software preprocessing step offers a way to gain better event reconstruction quality without demanding costly physical upgrades to the detector itself, which is a big win for experimental planning.

Kai: So, that’s our rundown of "Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction," where they demonstrate how super-resolution can faithfully replicate high-resolution cell distributions to substantially enhance both particle cardinality and kinematics performance in particle flow algorithms.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is about taking that messy calorimeter data from a collider, which is inherently low resolution, and applying super-resolution to clean it up using graph structures before we even get to the particle flow reconstruction part.

Mira: Exactly. Think of it like having a blurry photo of a structure and using an AI model to reconstruct what the high-resolution version probably looked like based on the fuzzy pixels you have.

Lev: So, they are essentially training an AI to predict a finer grid, say f eta by f phi cells, from your original low-resolution input graph. That sounds like a heavy computational load for real hardware when you think about it.

Kai: It is computationally intensive initially, but the paper shows that this transformer architecture learns a vector field, v t, which helps guide the reconstruction process through this upsampling.

Mira: And the main claim is that this predicted high-resolution cell distribution actually matches the true high-resolution data pretty closely when you look at substructure observables like C two and D two.

Lev: Matching those distributions is one thing, but what about the real world? When you’re trying to run error correction codes, how much does this prediction error translate into something that breaks your hardware requirements?

Kai: The authors show that when they use these predicted high-resolution cells for particle flow, their performance for particle cardinality—how many particles we count—is comparable or actually better than using only the measured low-resolution cells.

Mira: And it’s not just counting things better; they look at kinematic values too, like p T, eta, and phi. They found a marked improvement in the residuals for those specific kinematic variables when they use the predicted high-resolution cells instead of the measured ones.

Lev: So you’re saying this prediction step actually helps refine the momentum and angle estimates before you even feed them into your final reconstruction steps?

Kai: That’s what it suggests; it's a preprocessing step that fundamentally improves how we interpret those energy deposits, making the resulting particle flow objects much more accurate.

Mira: It means for someone analyzing the data, this could translate to cleaner jets and leptons, which is pretty important for separating signal from background in those analyses.

Lev: So what’s the catch here? The paper mentions they are not making any physical changes to the detector itself, just using software preprocessing. That’s a big win for experimentalists who can't go back to the factory.

Kai: Right, that’s the point—it’s about improving reconstruction quality without needing new hardware installations.

Mira: So, this isn't just a theoretical exercise; it’s showing a practical path to get higher fidelity event reconstruction using existing detector data and smart AI modeling.

Lev: It would take us to test if this level of prediction error is acceptable for real-time error correction systems, but the performance gains they show on kinematics are definitely something worth checking on our side.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we’re looking at how this super-resolution approach actually changes things for event reconstruction, beyond just fixing noise in individual cells or just getting better particle counts.

Mira: Right, so they show that by predicting these high-resolution cell distributions, the whole particle flow model gets a significant boost in accuracy across the board.

Lev: What I’m hearing is that this isn't just a minor tuning; it’s improving how we think about the underlying structure of what happened at the collision.

Kai: Exactly, because they prove that when you use those predicted high-resolution cells, you get much better kinematic predictions for things like p T, eta, and phi.

Mira: That means the reconstructed particles have a smaller spread around their true values. It’s less uncertainty in where the particle came from or how fast it was going.

Lev: So if we think about running this on real hardware, that reduction in residual error means our error correction codes might need to operate with tighter constraints, which is a subtle but important overhead change for us.

Kai: It’s about getting cleaner signals upfront so the subsequent steps don't have to work as hard to compensate for noisy input.

Mira: And they link this directly back to substructure observables—things like C two, C three, and D two. They show that the predicted high-resolution cells match these true distributions across all those variables pretty well.

Lev: Matching those distributions is a strong signal that the AI model is learning something physically meaningful about how energy deposits are distributed in space and time.

Kai: It means we’re not just guessing; the model is replicating the spatial structure of the shower better than what we see directly from our low-resolution sensors.

Mira: The implication for us as theorists is that we can trust these reconstructed jets and leptons a bit more when we try to use them for physics interpretations, because their input data quality has been systematically improved.

Lev: So the numbers suggest this predictive step adds a lot of fidelity back into the system, even if it requires running a transformer network on top of our existing graph representation.

Kai: It’s about trading some computational complexity for a noticeable gain in reconstruction accuracy across particle identification and kinematics.

Mira: This moves us closer to having an AI-assisted reconstruction pipeline that leverages the inherent structure of the detector data more effectively, even when the detector itself is coarse.

Lev: It still feels like a software layer improvement, but if this level of fidelity holds up under more complex showers, it could be a way to get better results without waiting for hardware upgrades.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper "Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction" shows that applying super-resolution techniques in a graph format can substantially improve particle flow reconstruction accuracy by predicting high-resolution cell distributions and kinematic values.

Mira: Right. The big picture is that we get cleaner jets and leptons because the AI model learns to replicate the true spatial structure of the energy deposits, even when our sensors are low resolution.

Lev: It’s a software solution that trades some computational cost for a much more accurate way to interpret messy detector signals before they hit our final reconstruction algorithms.

Kai: This means for us working on qubit fidelity, it’s interesting because it shows how we can use structured AI to improve the output of inherently noisy measurement systems without changing the hardware.

Mira: I think it really changes how we view event reconstruction; instead of just accepting the low resolution as a hard limit, we can use this method to go beyond that intrinsic limitation.

Lev: I'm still looking at how robust this prediction is when you try to deploy it on real hardware with tight latency requirements for error correction, because that’s where the practical overhead lands.

Kai: Yeah, so the challenge for us next is seeing if we can build a system that handles these graph predictions efficiently enough to run in real-time on our cryogenics setups.

Mira: And I think it opens up avenues for applying similar AI approaches to other areas of condensed matter physics where spatial structure is key.

Lev: We’ll keep watching how they handle those hadronic showers in future work, because that’s the next big hurdle for any real-world implementation.

Nilotpal Kakati, Etienne Dreyer, Eilam Gross

Weizmann Institute of Science, Israel

hep-ex, cs.LG

Submitted: 2024-09-24

Updated: 2026-10-29

Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, 4 tables; published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, 072010 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/2bjm-w5yq

Code: https://github.com/nilotpal09/SuperResolutionHEP

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction explores integrating super-resolution techniques into an LHC-like reconstruction pipeline to effectively enhance…

Key concepts

Super-Resolution (SR)
A technique used to reconstruct a high-resolution image or data set from a lower-resolution input. In this context, it means taking the coarse energy measurements from a calorimeter cell and using an AI model to predict what the finer, high-resolution energy distribution should look like.
Graph Representation
The detector data is modeled as a graph where each low-resolution measurement is treated as a node. This structure allows the AI model to handle complex, irregular spatial arrangements of energy deposits more effectively than traditional methods by relating neighboring cells.
Particle Flow (PFlow) Model
A method used in particle physics to assign energy deposits in a detector to specific particles (like jets or leptons). The paper uses a novel PFlow model that incorporates the super-resolved cell data, allowing it to make more accurate decisions about which particles are present and their properties.
Transformer Architecture
A type of deep learning model inspired by natural language processing that excels at understanding relationships between different parts of data. The transformer is used here to learn neighborhood-aware representations of energy deposition profiles, helping the system understand how nearby cells relate to each other.

Terminology

Summary

Denoising Graph Super-Resolution towards Improved Collider Event Reconstruction explores integrating super-resolution techniques into an LHC-like reconstruction pipeline to effectively enhance calorimeter granularity and suppress noise This study finds that this software preprocessing step significantly improves reconstruction quality without physical changes to the detector

Motivation for Super-Resolution in Physics

Calorimeter performance is generally characterized by energy resolution, but spatial resolution (inversely related to granularity) assumes a crucial role in dense collision environments Low-granularity calorimeters have limited imaging capabilities, constraining the performance of pattern reconstruction in PFlow algorithms such as assigning energy deposits to tracks and identifying neutral hadrons Superresolution (SR) techniques offer the potential to go beyond the spatial resolution intrinsic to the calorimeter design by reconstructing high-resolution (HR) data from low-resolution (LR) inputs This approach aims to enhance PFlow objects and, thereby, that of higher-level objects used in physics analyses such as jets, leptons, and photons

Model Architecture and Methodology

The core concept of the super-resolution model is inspired by the work [14] The data is represented as graphs, where each low-resolution graph is expanded into a high-resolution graph, with each low-resolution cell divided into fη × fφ high-resolution cells The model employs a transformer-based architecture to predict the vector field vt This process begins by upsampling the low-resolution graph through repetition, which serves as the conditional input Subsequently, a copy of the high-resolution graph, initialized with random values x0, is created This combined input is fed into a transformer network generating a neighborhood-aware representation that aids in understanding the energy deposition profile of the incident particles

Particle Flow Model Integration

A novel particle flow (PFlow) model is presented that builds on HGPflow principles but replaces iterative learning with a supervised attention mechanism The model processes detector data from cells using a transformer network to generate a neighborhood-aware representation The second branch focuses on kinematic prediction by learning the fractional energy distribution of each cell over the particles This distribution, referred to as the incidence matrix in HGPflow [22], is predicted using an attention-like framework where particles and cells are processed through two MLPs to obtain key (K) and query (Q) vectors

Performance Evaluation

Quantitative assessment showed that the network trained with predicted high-resolution cells shows either comparable or improved performance relative to the one trained with low-resolution measured cells across cardinality prediction Furthermore, when evaluating kinematic values derived from incidence predictions, the model trained on predicted high-resolution cells shows a marked improvement in residuals for pT, η, and φ The predicted high-resolution cells closely match the truth HR cell distributions and offer significant improvements over noisy low-resolution data across all three substructure observables considered

Conclusion and Outlook

The work demonstrates that super-resolution can indeed enhance reconstruction by faithfully replicating high-resolution cell distributions Utilizing these high-resolution cells for particle flow substantially enhances both particle cardinality and kinematics performance Future directions plan to investigate more realistic physics setups, including hadronic showers, and explore superresolution in the lateral direction

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank Dmitrii Kobilianskii for fruitful discussions on flow matching implementation, and Kyle Cranmer and Yihui Ren for their valuable insights The code used for the analyses presented in this paper is available on GitHub The dataset generated and analysed during this study can be accessed through Zenodo (DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15582324)

References

[1] Lyndon Evans and Philip Bryant, LHC Machine, JINST, 3:S08001, 2008

[3] ATLAS collaboration, Jet reconstruction and performance using particle flow with the ATLAS Detector, Eur. Phys. J. C, 77(7):466, 2017

[8] Chao Dong et al., Image super-resolution using deep convolutional networks, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 38(2):295–307, 2016

[14] Chitwan Saharia et al., Image super-resolution via iterative refinement, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 45(4):4713–4726, 2023

[28] Ricky T. Q. Chen et al., Neural ordinary differential equations, In S. p. 4

Where the paper says it

This transformation is governed by the following neural ordinary differential equation (ODE): dx dt = vθ (x,t), (1) where vθ is the vector field parameterised by a neural network and t ∈ [0,1]. Flow Matching, as proposed in [29], is a technique for training continuous normalizing flows that aims to match the learned flow vθ (t, x) induced by the differential equations of the model with a target flow ut (x).

Bengio, H. Wallach, H. Larochelle, K. Grauman, N. Cesa-Bianchi, and R Garnett editors Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, volume 31 Curran Associates Inc. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Introduction The energy and precision frontiers of high energy physics are driven by technological advances both in generating particle beams and in recording and reconstructing particle collisions. Detectors at current and future collider facilities are designed to extract precise information about outgoing particles using extensive arrays of sensors, including calorimeter layers.

, 2018

[31] Ricky T. Q. Chen, torchdiffeq, https://github. p. 4

Where the paper says it

We chose σ to be 10−4 following the original paper. We used the torchdiffeq [31] library with the Dormand-Prince (dopri5) solver for generation.

com/rtqichen/torchdiffeq

[37] J. Pata et al., MLPF: Efficient machine-learned particle-flow reconstruction using graph neural networks, Eur. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Related work Calorimeter SR was first explored in [15], which demonstrated a proof-of-concept using a neural network-based method with a simplified detector and physics setup. Since then, SR has found various applications in particle physics, such as enhancing jet constituent images with generative adversarial networks for improved jet property estimation [16], employing normalizing flows for upsampling calorimeter showers for fast simulation [17], and producing high-resolution photon shower images [18].

Phys. J. C, 81(5):1–14, 2021

[43] Andrew J Larkoski et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Denoising energy deposits: The AI system can suppress electronic noise that distorts recorded energy deposits by training a model to denoise each cell, leading to improved energy resolution for individual calorimeter cells.

  2. Graph-based architecture: The system uses a graph representation where the number of nodes is upscaled, allowing it to handle irregular geometry and sparsity in recorded signals better than traditional methods.

  3. Novel transformer-based particle flow algorithm: The AI can predict a high-granularity graph of calorimeter cells, which enables the reconstruction of finer details such as nearby particles, improving overall particle flow accuracy.

  4. Improved particle reconstruction quality: The integration of super-resolution techniques into the pipeline results in improved particle reconstruction quality and interpretability through a novel transformer-based PFlow model.

  5. Enhanced event level energy resolution: By utilizing ensemble sampling, the system can produce predicted high-resolution cell energies that result in a residual distribution much closer to zero with a narrower spread compared to low-resolution measured cell energies.

  6. Superior particle cardinality prediction: The model trained on predicted high-resolution cells shows either comparable or improved performance relative to the one trained on low-resolution measured cells for particle cardinality, especially as the true cardinality increases.

  7. Better kinematic prediction: The system can calculate proxy kinematics such as pT, eta, and phi with marked improvement when using predicted high-resolution cells compared to measured low-resolution cells for particle flow.

  8. Substructure analysis enhancement: The predicted high-resolution cells closely match the true distribution of substructure observables C2, C3, and D2 across all three variables considered in the study, offering significant improvements over noisy low-resolution data.

Abstract

In preparation for Higgs factories and energy-frontier facilities, future colliders are moving toward high-granularity calorimeters to improve reconstruction quality. However, the cost and construction complexity of such detectors is substantial, making software-based approaches like superresolution an attractive complementary tool. This study explores integrating superresolution techniques into an LHC-like reconstruction pipeline to effectively enhance calorimeter granularity and suppress noise. We find that this software preprocessing step significantly improves reconstruction quality at fixed detector granularity, narrowing the performance gap to a finer calorimeter without closing it. To demonstrate its impact, we propose a novel transformer-based particle-flow model that offers improved particle reconstruction quality and interpretability. Our results serve as a proof of concept, demonstrating the potential of superresolution to enhance reconstruction in collider environments.

Related papers