Spontaneous Motion of Liquid Droplets on Soft Gradient Surfaces

arXiv:2407.10480 · cond-mat.soft · Submitted 2024-07-15 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spontaneous Motion of Liquid Droplets on Soft Gradient Surfaces".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spontaneous motion of millimeter-sized liquid droplets on soft gels with crosslinking gradients was experimentally observed and driven by surface energy differences resulting from variations in crosslinking density Experimental Setup and Materials The study prepared soft substrates by mixing polydimethylsiloxane polymers with dimethylsiloxane copolymer crosslinkers, controlling the Young’s modulus to range between E = 0.16 kPa and 175 kPa by varying the weight ratio of the crosslinkers To create a soft gradient surface, a stiff gel film was fabricated and then replaced with a PDMS mixture containing a low density of crosslinkers to form a soft region with E1 80 kPa Droplets were composed of an aqueous mixture comprising 80 % glycerol and 20 % water, which had an effective viscosity of ηl = 48.3 ± 1.1 cSt The effective surface tension of these aqueous droplets on silicone gels was measured to be γl = 41 ± 1 mN/m, which remained unchanged during the measurement period Driving Forces and Motion Mechanism The spontaneous movement of millimeter-sized droplets was driven by the difference in equilibrium contact angles between the advancing and receding directions The net contact force acting on the droplet is given by Eq.

Kai: 3, which is expressed as Fd = Fa + Fr = κγlω

(cos Θdr − cos Θda) + (cos θea − cos θer): The maximum driving force Fdmax was found to be determined by the difference between θea and θer, as suggested by Eq.

Mira: 4, where a minimum difference between the equilibrium contact angles in the two gel regions, ∆θc = θer − θea = 1.2◦ was required to initiate spontaneous droplet motion Role of Elastocapillarity Elastocapillary effects were determined to play an insignificant role in controlling the motion of the millimeter-sized droplets because the critical droplet size that marked the crossover between regimes was characterized by le = Υs/E and thus decreased with E For millimeter-sized droplets, it was concluded that elastocapillarity played an insignificant role in driving the movements of the millimeter-sized droplets examined in this study Dissipation and Force Balance Significant dissipations from the substrates were expected when the droplets stopped shortly after crossing the boundary between soft and stiff regions, which were examined using a model described by Eq.

Kai: 6 for the power per unit length dissipated by a moving contact ridge The total dissipative force induced by the moving wetting ridges became Fdiss = Fdiss1 + Fdiss2 < 2.5 µN, which remained approximately close to or slightly lower than Fdmax throughout the experiments The spontaneous droplet migration was attributed to the surface energy gradient resulting from the spatially varying crosslinking density rather than elastocapillary effects Future works could focus on exploring systems with a continuous gradient of crosslinking density to help prevent dissipations from boundaries between sharply changing gel matrices The study demonstrated that increasing the difference of crosslinking density allowed droplets to climb a tilted plane with a steep slope Supplemental Data Additional data showed that the acceleration peaked when the droplet center arrived at the boundary between gels, w = D The maximum driving force is approximated as Fdmax ≈ 3.2 µN for a droplet with D = 3.2 mm, while Fdiss < 10 µN < Fdmax for both moving droplets The relationship Fdiss ≲ Fdmax remained valid throughout our experiments Rheological Characterization The complex moduli of soft silicone gels were described using the Chasset–Thirion model, where G∗(ω) = G′(ω) + iG′′(ω) = G0

1 + (iωτc)n: The scaling index n in Eq.

Paper summary: Kai: So wrapping up the "Spontaneous Motion of Liquid Droplets on Soft Gradient Surfaces," the authors really focused on demonstrating that the spontaneous motion isn't just a byproduct of standard elastocapillary effects like you might expect from smaller droplets >

Mira: They showed that it's specifically driven by the surface energy difference resulting from variations in crosslinking density across the substrate, and this is what matters for millimeter-sized droplets >

Lev: It’s about establishing that this mechanism is dominant over elastocapillarity when you are dealing with droplets of that size, because the critical droplet size where those regimes switch is determined by le equals epsilon over E, which gets smaller as E increases >

Kai: And they also showed that they have a novel strategy for controlling droplet dynamics on soft and dissipative interfaces based on this relationship between crosslinking density and surface energy of the substrate >

Mira: The implication for us in condensed matter is that we need to account for these complex surface energy gradients when modeling systems involving liquid films on soft materials >

Lev: For real hardware, it means if you're designing surfaces with controlled stiffness variations, you can leverage this to guide droplet movement in ways that are dependent on the local stiffness, not just simple gravity or surface tension terms >

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about liquid droplets moving on soft materials where those materials have different stiffnesses all over them >

Mira: Exactly, it’s about how they move spontaneously just because the crosslinking density changes across the surface >

Kai: The authors are looking at millimeter-sized droplets and they’ve found that the driving force comes from these surface energy differences, not some weird quantum effect or anything like that >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this is interesting because it suggests a controllable mechanism for transport on flexible substrates without needing external forces >

Kai: It seems to confirm that the spatial variation in crosslinking density is the main driver of the motion, which is what we expected based on surface energy gradients >

Mira: Yeah, but they also did some detailed work looking at how much energy gets lost when those droplets stop near a boundary between soft and stiff regions >

Lev: And they found that this dissipation force is still smaller than the driving force in most cases, which means the motion is pretty robust even with some friction involved >

Kai: So the title itself, "Spontaneous Motion of Liquid Droplets on Soft Gradient Surfaces," just sums up what they’re showing about surface energy gradients and droplet movement >

Mira: It really highlights how important it is to consider those local variations in material properties when modeling any fluid interface on a soft substrate >

Kai: Thinking about this for the future, the authors suggest that if you want to prevent a lot of that dissipation at sharp edges between stiff and soft gels, you should aim for a continuous gradient instead of an abrupt switch >

Department of Physics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology

cond-mat.soft

Submitted: 2024-07-15

Updated: 2025-01-28

DOI: 10.1063/5.0260898

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 94/100

The gist: Spontaneous motion of millimeter-sized liquid droplets on soft gels with crosslinking gradients was experimentally observed and driven by surface energy differences resulting from variations in…

Key concepts

Crosslinking Gradient
This refers to a surface where the stiffness of the material changes gradually from one region to another, created by mixing polymers with different amounts of crosslinkers. This variation in how tightly the polymer chains are linked dictates local physical properties like Young's modulus, which directly influences droplet behavior.
Surface Energy Differences
The movement of droplets is caused by imbalances in surface energy between different parts of the substrate. When a droplet moves from a region with one crosslinking density to another, the surface tension and contact angle change, creating a net force that pushes the droplet in a specific direction.
Elastocapillarity
This effect describes how the elasticity (stiffness) of soft materials influences fluid behavior at their surface. The study found this effect was insignificant for millimeter-sized droplets because the critical size needed to observe it depended on the substrate's stiffness, making it negligible in this specific experiment.

Terminology

Summary

Spontaneous motion of millimeter-sized liquid droplets on soft gels with crosslinking gradients was experimentally observed and driven by surface energy differences resulting from variations in crosslinking density

Experimental Setup and Materials

The study prepared soft substrates by mixing polydimethylsiloxane polymers with dimethylsiloxane copolymer crosslinkers, controlling the Young’s modulus to range between E = 0.16 kPa and 175 kPa by varying the weight ratio of the crosslinkers To create a soft gradient surface, a stiff gel film was fabricated and then replaced with a PDMS mixture containing a low density of crosslinkers to form a soft region with E1 80 kPa Droplets were composed of an aqueous mixture comprising 80 % glycerol and 20 % water, which had an effective viscosity of ηl = 48. p. 03 ± 1.1 cSt The effective surface tension of these aqueous droplets on silicone gels was measured to be γl = 41 ± 1 mN/m, which remained unchanged during the measurement period

Driving Forces and Motion Mechanism

The spontaneous movement of millimeter-sized droplets was driven by the difference in equilibrium contact angles between the advancing and receding directions The net contact force acting on the droplet is given by Eq. 3, which is expressed as Fd = Fa + Fr = κγlω[(cos Θdr − cos Θda) + (cos θea − cos θer)] The maximum driving force Fdmax was found to be determined by the difference between θea and θer, as suggested by Eq. p. 3 4, where a minimum difference between the equilibrium contact angles in the two gel regions, ∆θc = θer − θea = 1. p. 32◦ was required to initiate spontaneous droplet motion

Role of Elastocapillarity

Elastocapillary effects were determined to play an insignificant role in controlling the motion of the millimeter-sized droplets because the critical droplet size that marked the crossover between regimes was characterized by le = Υs/E and thus decreased with E For millimeter-sized droplets, it was concluded that elastocapillarity played an insignificant role in driving the movements of the millimeter-sized droplets examined in this study

Dissipation and Force Balance

Significant dissipations from the substrates were expected when the droplets stopped shortly after crossing the boundary between soft and stiff regions, which were examined using a model described by Eq. 6 for the power per unit length dissipated by a moving contact ridge The total dissipative force induced by the moving wetting ridges became Fdiss = Fdiss1 + Fdiss2 < 2. p. 55 µN, which remained approximately close to or slightly lower than Fdmax throughout the experiments

Conclusion

The spontaneous droplet migration was attributed to the surface energy gradient resulting from the spatially varying crosslinking density rather than elastocapillary effects Future works could focus on exploring systems with a continuous gradient of crosslinking density to help prevent dissipations from boundaries between sharply changing gel matrices The study demonstrated that increasing the difference of crosslinking density allowed droplets to climb a tilted plane with a steep slope

Supplemental Data

Additional data showed that the acceleration peaked when the droplet center arrived at the boundary between gels, w = D The maximum driving force is approximated as Fdmax ≈ 3.2 µN for a droplet with D = 3. p. 72 mm, while Fdiss < 10 µN < Fdmax for both moving droplets The relationship Fdiss ≲ Fdmax remained valid throughout our experiments

Rheological Characterization

The complex moduli of soft silicone gels were described using the Chasset–Thirion model, where G∗(ω) = G′(ω) + iG′′(ω) = G0[1 + (iωτc)n] The scaling index n in Eq. 5 typically ranges between 1/2 and 2/3 for covalently crosslinked polymer networks The fitted product of G0τc remained constant at approximately 20 Pa when k > 0. p. 48% The power per unit length dissipated by a moving contact ridge can be approximated as Pdiss ∝ G0(τcV/le)nϵ2/ω ≈ ΥsV (τcG0V/Υs)n(γl/Υs sin Θ)2 The total dissipative force induced by the moving wetting ridges became Fdiss = fdiss · D ≈ ΥsD(τcG0V/Υs)n(γl/Υs sin Θ)2 The surface stress of the soft region was obtained as Υs = 2γl/ cos (α/2) = 25. p. 43 ± 0.6 mN/m The maximum dissipative force Fdmax due to viscoelasticity of soft gels can be obtained by integrating fdiss along the contact perimeter

Supplementary Analysis

The surface tension of the glycerol–water mixture was characterized using both sessile and pendant droplet methods, and this value remained constant over a two-hour period The difference between γl1 and γl2 was due to the migration of free chains from soft gels that covered the sessile droplets The droplet dynamics on the soft substrates with E1 = 5.4 kPa and E2 = 130 kPa supplemented the results shown in Fig. p. 7 3 The maximum velocity reached is V ≈ 1. p. 72 µm/s for the droplet in Fig. p. 4 3 The maximum velocity reached is V ≈ 0. p. 74 µm for the droplet in Fig. p. 4 8 The intersecting width of the droplet with the boundary between gels (wm) was determined The advancing and receding contact angles are approximately equal, Θda ≈ Θdr

References

[1] L. Trichet, J. p. 7 L. Digabel, R. p. 7 J. Hawkins, S. p. 7 R. K. Vedula, M. Gupta, C. Ribrault, P. p. 7 Hersen, R Voituriez and B Ladoux Evidence of a large-scale mechanosensing mechanism for cellular adaptation to substrate stiffness Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109 6933 (2012)

[2] D. E. Discher, P Janmey and Y li Wang Tissue cells feel and respond to the stiffness of their substrate Science 310 1139 (2005)

[3] T Cubaud and T G Mason Capillary threads and viscous droplets in square microchannels Physics of Fluids 20 053302 (2008)

[4] Q Yuan and Y P Zhao Precursor film in dynamic wetting, electrowetting, and electro-elasto-capillarity Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 246101 (2010)

[5] R Lhermerout H Perrin E Rolley B Andreotti and K Davitt A moving contact line as a rheometer for nanometric interfacial layers Nature Communications 7 12545 (2016)

[6] N Gao F Geyer D W Pilat S Wooh D Vollmer H J Butt and R Berger How drops start sliding over solid surfaces Nature Physics 14 191 (2018)

[7] H K Khattak S Karpitschka J Snoeijer and K Dalnoki-Veress Direct force measurement of microscopic droplets pulled along soft surfaces Nature Communications 13 4436 (2022)

[8] T.-S Wong S H Kang S K Y Tang E J Smythe B D Hatton A Grinthal and J Aizenberg Bioinspired self-repairing slippery surfaces with pressure-stable omniphobicity Nature 477 443 (2011)

[9] M K Chaudhury and G M Whitesides How to make water run uphill Science 256 1539 (1992)

[10] A Lafuma and D Qu´er´e Superhydrophobic states Nature Materials 2 457 (2003)

[11] L Courbin E Denieul E Dressaire M Roper A Ajdari and H A Stone Imbibition by polygonal spreading on microdecorated surfaces Nature Materials 6 661 (2007)

[12] X Xu and T Qian Droplet motion in one-component fluids on solid substrates with wettability gradients Phys. Rev. E 85 051601 (2012)

[13] M Coux and J M Kolinski Surface textures suppress viscoelastic braking on soft substrates Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117 32285 (2020)

[14] D Paretkar X Xu C-Y Hui and A Jagota Flattening of a patterned compliant solid by surface stress Soft Matter 10 4084 (2014)

[15] A Bardall S.-Y Chen K E Daniels and M Shearer Gradient-induced droplet motion over soft solids IMA Journal of Applied Mathematics 85 495 (2020)

[16] J Bueno Y Bazilevs R Juanes and H Gomez Wettability control of droplet durotaxis Soft matter 14 1417 (2018)

[17] P E Theodorakis S A Egorov and A Milchev Stiffness-guided motion of a droplet on a solid substrate The Journal of Chemical Physics 146 244705 (2017)

[18] F Y Leong and D.-V Le Droplet dynamics on viscoelastic soft substrate Toward coalescence control Physics of Fluids 32 062102 (2020) p. 7

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise control of droplet dynamics on soft and dissipative interfaces can be achieved by systematically adjusting crosslinking density to create desired surface energy gradients, as demonstrated by the difference in crosslinking density leads to variations in the surface energy of soft gels. This allows for the design of surfaces where the imbalance in contact forces can cause large liquid droplets to move spontaneously.

  2. The improved AI system can predict spontaneous droplet motion on soft gradient surfaces by inputting Young's moduli (E1 and E2) and droplet size, allowing it to determine if the condition a minimum difference between the equilibrium contact angles in the two gel regions, delta theta c equals theta er minus theta ea equals 1.2 degree is met to initiate migration.

  3. The system can calculate the maximum driving force Fdmax using Equation 4, which shows that Fdmax was determined by the difference between theta ea and theta er, enabling prediction of the steepest slopes a millimeter-sized droplet can climb spontaneously against gravity.

Related papers