Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down

arXiv:2407.04743 · astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.HE, gr-qc, hep-th · Submitted 2024-07-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down".

Title and authors: Vera: So we're diving into this paper now called "Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down." Basically, the authors are looking at how these strings attached to spinning black holes can actually take away rotational energy and angular momentum.

Jocelyn: That sounds intense. So what they're focusing on here is how these strings affect two different types of black holes: primordial ones and supermassive ones.

Subrahmanyan: The core idea seems to be that if these cosmic strings have a tension greater than ten minus twenty then the spins of large primordial black holes, specifically those with mass greater than thirty solar masses, should end up near zero <ref:2407.04743#pg1,the spins of large primordial black holes>.

Vera: That's a really specific prediction. I mean you know PBHs are formed from things in the very early universe, and this paper suggests the strings act like a brake on their rotation after they get spun up by accretion.

Jocelyn: And it brings in some interesting physics about how these strings interact with the black hole's spacetime, using something called a generalization of the Penrose Process for energy extraction.

Subrahmanyan: I’m curious about those numbers they mentioned, like how long it takes for a primordial black hole to spin down based on the string tension mu. It seems like that time scales inversely with mu squared in some cases, which is pretty dramatic.

Vera: Right, and they give us a timescale for spin-down of a thirty solar mass primordial black hole as being around one year divided by ten to the eleven times that string tension mu <ref:2407.04743#pg1>. That's a very quick process if the strings are strong enough.

Jocelyn: But then they also look at supermassive black holes, and their spin-down is much slower unless the string tension mu is quite small, less than ten minus eighteen <ref:2407.04743#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: So there's a distinction here based on the string's tension. If mu is greater than ten minus twenty we expect near-zero spin for large primordial black holes, but if it’s smaller, they stay near extremal spin instead <ref:2407.04743#pg1>.

Title and authors: Vera: It really sets up a test for us observationally. We can look at the spin of a very large primordial black hole and see if it matches this prediction based on its mass and the assumed string tension.

Jocelyn: And they also looked at how a cosmic string might interact with something as huge as Sagittarius A star, the supermassive black hole at our center.

Subrahmanyan: The estimate for the time it would take for a cosmic string to collide with Sagittarius A star is given by three times ten to nine years multiplied by mu minus eighteen times solar mass squared divided by point five power of two and point five minus one power of one which is about mu minus eighteen solar mass squared divided by two and a half <ref:2407.04743#pg2>.

Vera: That formula involves the dimensionless parameter eta p, which they say depends on the properties of the string network itself, like its density. So that's not just a simple collision time.

Jocelyn: And they also looked at how this energy extraction process might show up in pulsar timing measurements around Sgr A star. They suggested that if a pulsar orbits Sagittarius A star, its period would increase at a rate proportional to ten to the six times mu.

Subrahmanyan: That's interesting because it suggests that only very light strings, with mu less than ten minus eighteen have any real chance of being captured by Sagittarius A star in this scenario <ref:2407.04743#pg3>.

Vera: So the observational signature for us isn't just a direct detection of the string itself, but rather measuring a change in spin or period that we can only see if the string tension is in a certain range.

Jocelyn: And they also look at how this impacts accreting supermassive black holes, where the spin changes are much smaller, around ten to nine years to one power of minus nine times solar mass to two, so it's not easily measurable for us right now.

Title and authors: Subrahmanyan: It seems the paper points toward a test: large primordial black holes should be nearly unspun if cosmic strings exist with tension greater than ten minus twenty which helps distinguish them from standard accretion spin-up scenarios <ref:2407.04743#pg1,with tension greater than 10>.

Vera: The authors point out that the difficulty for stellar-mass black holes is that the chance of them encountering a cosmic string is quite small, and even if they did, the spin down would be too fast to measure accurately.

Jocelyn: But for supermassive black holes, because of their size and the long timescale, there's a much better shot at seeing this spin-down effect if those strings are present.

Subrahmanyan: The paper really highlights that the details depend on a lot of things: the properties of the cosmic strings, how dense that network is, and even how far apart these primordial black holes are from each other.

Vera: So, in summary for this paper on "Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down," it gives us a clear threshold on string tension for predicting zero spin in large primordial black holes.

Jocelyn: And it also lays out how we might look for a signature around Sagittarius A star by tracking the period of an orbiting pulsar, though they admit that signal is likely too small even for high-precision measurements.

Subrahmanyan: The key test is this: large primordial black holes should have almost no spin if cosmic strings exist and with very high spins if they do not, which is a very clean way to probe string existence.

Vera: So the paper suggests that we can use the observed spin state of massive primordial black holes as a definitive test for whether those cosmic strings are out there.

Jocelyn: It’s a lot of heavy lifting to connect these early universe objects with string theory predictions, but it gives us concrete things to look for in our next generation of gravitational wave and timing observations.

Subrahmanyan: Indeed, the paper on "Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down" provides a framework connecting high energy physics defects to observable black hole properties across different mass scales.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, to wrap up what we just talked about, the main point of this paper is that if there are cosmic strings with a certain tension, say greater than ten minus twenty, then large primordial black holes with masses bigger than thirty solar masses should have spins close to zero.

Jocelyn: It's like the strings act like a brake on these massive objects after they get spun up by matter falling onto them. So you’re looking at this test where we measure the spin of a giant primordial black hole and see if it matches what we expect based on the string tension.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly, that's the big prediction: large primordial black holes should be nearly unspun if cosmic strings with tension greater than ten minus twenty exist.

Vera: And they also look at supermassive black holes, like Sgr A star, and how a cosmic string might interact with it by affecting the orbit of a pulsar around it.

Jocelyn: They model how the period of that orbiting pulsar would change due to this energy extraction, and they find that only very light strings, with tension less than ten minus eighteen, have a real chance of being captured by Sgr A star in this scenario.

Subrahmanyan: So there's a tension here between the black hole mass and the string tension that determines whether we expect near-zero spin or high spin.

Vera: And it really sets up a test for us observationally, because if we see a large primordial black hole with almost no spin, it suggests cosmic strings are out there with that specific tension.

Jocelyn: But they also point out the difficulty of seeing this effect around supermassive black holes; the spin-down is much slower unless those strings are really light.

Subrahmanyan: The paper mentions that for stellar-mass black holes, it’s hard to see because it’s unlikely they’ll even encounter a cosmic string, and if they do, the spin down would be too fast to measure accurately.

Vera: So the observation hinges on these massive primordial black holes being nearly unspun when we look at them.

Jocelyn: And that leads us to ask what kind of observations might actually settle this: how do we know if those large primordial black holes are spinning near zero or near extremal spin?

The paper's improvements: Tom: So we've looked at what this paper does—it sets a benchmark for string tension based on how large primordial black holes spin down, and now we're going to look at how the authors suggest making it even better.

Vera: The improvements focus on getting more precise predictions for those primordial black hole spins, which is crucial since that’s our observational test.

Jocelyn: They suggest a clearer way to distinguish between the two extremes: large primordial black holes should show almost no spin if cosmic strings with tension greater than ten minus twenty exist, and very high spins if they don't.

Subrahmanyan: That gives us a definitive test for the existence of these strings across different mass scales.

Vera: And they also have these ideas about modeling the accretion process itself. They propose tracking how a large primordial black hole’s mass and spin evolve over time if it has been spun up by matter falling onto it.

Jocelyn: That way, we can calculate what that spin *should* be after some time, giving us a comparison point against the cosmic string prediction.

Subrahmanyan: It also brings in the idea of modeling when two primordial black holes connected by a cosmic string might get pulled toward each other and eventually merge.

Vera: That’s interesting because it moves beyond just looking at individual black holes and starts to consider how these strings affect larger structures in the early universe.

Jocelyn: So, the improvements are about tightening up the theoretical predictions so we can use our pulsar timing and spin measurements as a more powerful tool.

Subrahmanyan: It’s about connecting these high energy physics concepts directly to observable black hole properties across different mass scales with a clearer signal.

Conclusion: Vera: So we've covered how this paper on "Searching for cosmic strings via black hole spin-down" predicts that large primordial black holes should have nearly zero spin if those strings are present with tension greater than ten minus twenty.

Jocelyn: It really boils down to using the spin of a massive object as a direct probe for the existence and tension of these cosmic strings.

Subrahmanyan: That's what it is, this result connects high energy physics defects to observable black hole properties across different mass scales.

Vera: The implication is that we might be able to use observations of giant primordial black holes to constrain the parameters of string theory in a way that’s totally new.

Jocelyn: And they also showed how we can look for these strings around supermassive black holes by tracking pulsar timing signals, even though the signal is pretty faint.

Subrahmanyan: The real impact here is setting a clear threshold; if we measure near-zero spin on a large black hole, it strongly suggests the existence of cosmic strings in that tension range.

Vera: It’s a very clean way to test for these exotic objects, but they also admit the details depend on things like the string network density and how far apart these primordial black holes are.

Jocelyn: That means future observations need to be very careful about those environmental factors if we want to get a real handle on the physics.

Subrahmanyan: Ultimately, this work gives us a roadmap for using black hole spin measurements as a definitive test for string existence in the early universe.

Department of Chemistry and Physics SUNY Old Westbury Department of Physics Long Island University Department of Physics Virginia Tech

astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.HE, gr-qc, hep-th

Submitted: 2024-07-03

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 12 pages; v2 Title modified and references added; v3 Expanded discussion of accretion-model dependence and PBH string-survival statistics, references added, published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 103039

DOI: 10.1103/rm9k-sj82

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

The gist: Cosmic strings that are attached to rapidly spinning black holes can extract significant amounts of rotational energy and angular momentum…

Key concepts

Penrose Process
This is a mechanism in general relativity where energy can be removed from a rotating black hole. In this context, a cosmic string dragged by the black hole can utilize this process to extract rotational energy and angular momentum, causing the string to lose energy.
Cosmic String Tension (µ)
Tension refers to the intrinsic strength of a cosmic string. The paper uses this value to predict how effectively strings remove spin from black holes. A higher tension means more energy can be extracted, leading to faster spin-down effects on black holes.
Primordial Black Hole Spin Evolution
Primordial black holes (PBHs) formed with cosmic strings are expected to gain spin through accretion but are then spun down by the strings. The study predicts that if string tension is high (above 10^-20), these large PBHs will end up with near-zero spin, offering a way to distinguish them from other black holes.

Terminology

Summary

Cosmic strings that are attached to rapidly spinning black holes can extract significant amounts of rotational energy and angular momentum, and this study investigates its effect on primordial black holes and supermassive black holes. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: Cosmic strings that are attached to rapidly spinning black holes can extract significant amounts of rotational energy and angular momentum. Here we study the effect on primordial black holes, which are expected to form with one or more cosmic strings attached.

The paper argues that if cosmic strings have a tension greater than 10−20, the spins of large primordial black holes should be observed to be near zero. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Although large primordial black holes are predicted to rapidly spin up due to accretion soon after forming, we argue that cosmic strings will spin them down again. We show that if there are cosmic strings with tension greater than 10−20, the spins of large primordial black holes of mass greater than 30M⊙ should consequently be observed to be near zero.

Energy Extraction Mechanisms

The paper reviews the mechanism by which cosmic strings remove energy from black holes, specifically detailing how they can extract rotational energy and angular momentum via a generalization of the Penrose Process.

  1. The Penrose process is a mechanism in classical general relativity by which energy can be removed from a rotating black hole. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    Finally, we discuss open questions and future directions in section 5. 2 Energy extraction by cosmic strings The Penrose Process [21] is a mechanism in classical general relativity by which energy can be removed from a rotating black hole.

  2. A long, relativistic CS with one end entering the ergosphere is dragged around by the black hole, and if it is rigidly rotating with an angular velocity ω less than the angular velocity omegah of the BH, there is an outward radial flow of angular momentum and energy along the string. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    In particular, a long, relativistic CS with one end entering the ergosphere is dragged around by the black hole. If the CS is rigidly rotating with an angular velocity ω that is less than the angular velocity Ωh of the BH, i.

  3. The energy extraction rate for a CS with tension µ can be written as dE/dt = µqω. p. 4

    Where the paper says it

    For a CS with tension µ, the energy extraction rate is dE/dt = µqω. Restoring the dimensionful constants, this can be written as [19]: dE dt = 4.

  4. For typical values of a, q, and ω, the final three factors of (2. p. 4

    Where the paper says it

    As the black hole loses rotational energy to the string, its total mass decreases. For typical values of a, q, and ω, the final three factors of (2.

    3) are order one. p. 2
    Where the paper says it

    A stellar-mass BH presents a small target, and the chance of capturing a CS is extremely low; the expected time to capture a single cosmic string would be far longer than the age of the universe. However, for a supermassive black hole, such as Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), and for very low cosmic string tension, µ ≲ 10−18, there is an order-one probability for one or more collisions during the black hole’s lifetime.

Primordial Black Hole Spin Evolution

The study argues that cosmic strings would have effectively spun down primordial black holes being observed in the present epoch.

  1. PBHs formed with cosmic strings attached are expected to be spun up by accretion, but subsequently spun down by those strings. p. 2

    Where the paper says it

    However, if the PBH formed with cosmic strings attached, then after being spun up by accretion, the PBH would subsequently be spun down by those strings. As a result, later observations would find high-mass PBHs with very small angular momentum, in contrast to the prediction of [35].

  2. For a 30M⊙ mass PBH, the spin-down time is given by tSD ≈ 1 yr / 10−11 µ. p. 4

    Where the paper says it

    For a stellar mass black hole with, say, MBH = 30M⊙, the approximate spin-down time (2. 5) gives tSD ≈ 1 yr 10−11 µ .

  3. If there are cosmic strings with µ > 10−20, PBHs with mass larger than 30M⊙ will be observed to have near-zero spin. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    This allows us to establish a clear prediction and a definitive test for the existence of cosmic strings in an unprobed range of string tensions. If there are cosmic strings with µ > 10−20, PBHs with mass larger than 30M⊙ will be observed to have near-zero spin.

  4. Otherwise, these high mass PBHs will instead have near-extremal spin. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    If there are cosmic strings with µ > 10−20, PBHs with mass larger than 30M⊙ will be observed to have near-zero spin. Otherwise, according to [35], these high mass PBHs will instead have near-extremal spin.

Supermassive Black Hole Spin Down

The paper discusses the possibility of observing the cosmic string-induced spin down of a supermassive black hole via pulsar timing measurements.

  1. The expected time for a CS collision with Sgr A∗ is estimated in [24] as tc = 3 × 109 yr µ−18 M−2. p. 8

    Where the paper says it

    Cosmic strings tend to cluster in galactic halos [64] where the BHs are located, improving the chances for a collision. The expected time for a CS collision was estimated in [24] as tc = 3 × 109 yr µ 10−18 2 M MSgrA∗ −2.

    5 (η(p))−1.

  2. For a supermassive BH, the spin down process is much slower, especially for small µ. p. 4

    Where the paper says it

    5) gives tSD ≈ 106 yr µ 10−11 −1 . 7) The spin down of a supermassive BH is a much slower process, especially for small µ.

  3. The period of a pulsar orbiting Sgr A∗ would be increasing at a rate of P˙ ∼ 106 µ. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    For a pulsar with period P = 10 yr, the period would be increasing at a rate of P˙ ∼ 106 µ. Only sufficiently light strings, with µ < 10−18, would have a significant chance of being captured by Sgr A*, implying the effect on the period would be quite small: P˙ ≲ 10−12 .

  4. Only sufficiently light strings, with µ < 10−18, would have a significant chance of being captured by Sgr A∗. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    For a pulsar with period P = 10 yr, the period would be increasing at a rate of P˙ ∼ 106 µ. Only sufficiently light strings, with µ < 10−18, would have a significant chance of being captured by Sgr A*, implying the effect on the period would be quite small: P˙ ≲ 10−12 .

Observational Signatures and Tests

The paper outlines the observational consequences for detecting cosmic strings through black hole spin measurements.

  1. For accreting supermassive BHs, the spin is only decreasing at a rate of ˙a/a ≈ 10−9 yr−1, which is not good enough to measure the spin to one part in 109. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    3, for example X-ray reflection spectroscopy for an accreting supermassive BH. However, the spin is only decreasing at a rate of ˙a/a ≈ 10−9 yr−1 and the accuracy of these techniques is not nearly good enough to measure the spin to one part in 109 [36].

  2. Observing a pulsar orbiting close to Sgr A∗ and looking for out-spiraling due to energy being extracted from the black hole by the cosmic string is proposed, although the signal is likely too small even for high-precision pulsar observations. p. 2

    Where the paper says it

    We propose a technique by which the energy lost by the BH could be detected by its effect on a pulsar orbiting the BH. However, in addition to finding an appropriate pulsar sufficiently close to the BH, the precision of pulsar timing measurements would need to improve significantly in order to detect the mass loss due to phenomenologically viable cosmic strings with µ < 10−11 .

  3. The test for cosmic strings exists in that large PBHs should be observed with almost no spin if cosmic strings exist and with very high spins if they do not. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    This allows us to establish a clear prediction and a definitive test for the existence of cosmic strings in an unprobed range of string tensions. If there are cosmic strings with µ > 10−20, PBHs with mass larger than 30M⊙ will be observed to have near-zero spin.

Discussion and Open Questions

The discussion highlights an inverse “goldilocks” problem where the extremes may be preferred avenues for observation.

  1. The prospects of observing the spin-down of stellar-mass black holes are dim because the likelihood of such a black hole encountering a cosmic string is quite small, and second, the spin down would be quite fast and unlikely to be observed. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    We show that if there are cosmic strings with tension greater than 10−20, the spins of large primordial black holes of mass greater than 30M⊙ should consequently be observed to be near zero. We also investigate the effect on a supermassive black hole of capturing a cosmic string and the possibility of observing the subsequent spin down by its effect on a pulsar orbiting the black hole.

  2. A supermassive black hole suffers from neither of these problems because its size makes for a significant probability of encountering a cosmic string and for a long spin-down time. p. 2

    Where the paper says it

    A stellar-mass BH presents a small target, and the chance of capturing a CS is extremely low; the expected time to capture a single cosmic string would be far longer than the age of the universe. However, for a supermassive black hole, such as Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), and for very low cosmic string tension, µ ≲ 10−18, there is an order-one probability for one or more collisions during the black hole’s lifetime.

  3. The paper notes that the details are complicated and depend on the properties of the cosmic strings, the density of the CS network, and the distance between PBHs. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Once the number of strings drops to 2, the chance that they then intersect can become very low [25]. The details are complicated and depend on the properties of the cosmic strings, the density of the CS network, and the distance between PBHs.

  4. Future investigations should consider scenarios where two PBHs connected by a cosmic string would get pulled toward each other and eventually merge. p. 6

    Where the paper says it

    If, for example, a string connects two black holes, they can be pulled toward each other, eventually merging into a single larger black hole with no cosmic string. However, if the typical distance between PBHs is large, the string pulling the PBHs together will have to compete with the cosmological expansion.

Acknowledgments

The work was supported by the National Science Foundation grants PHY1820733, PHY-2000398, PHY-2310608 (MSL); AST-2011731 (MK); PHY-2011383, PHY-2308861 (SL); and AST-2011757 (JS).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise prediction of primordial black hole spin based on cosmic string tension: The improved system can determine that if there are cosmic strings with tension greater than 10 minus 20, the spins of large primordial black holes of mass greater than 30Msun should consequently be observed to be near zero.

  2. Detection strategy for supermassive black hole spin-down: The AI can model the expected period increase of an orbiting pulsar due to mass loss and compare this predicted change against current observational limits to determine if it would have a significant chance of being captured by Sgr Astar for specific string tensions.

  3. Distinguishing PBHs from astrophysical black holes: The system can use the spin prediction as a definitive test, stating that Large PBHs should be observed with almost no spin if cosmic strings exist and with very high spins if they do not.

  4. Modeling accretion-spin feedback on primordial black holes: The improved system can track the evolution of PBH mass and spin, calculating that a large PBH M greater than 30Msun observed any time after z = 10 would be expected to have near-extremal spin if it has been spun up by accretion.

  5. Constraint setting for cosmic string tension: The system can establish a clear threshold for the existence of cosmic strings, concluding that If there are cosmic strings with mu greater than 10 minus 20, PBHs with mass larger than 30Msun will be observed to have near-zero spin.

Abstract

Cosmic strings that are attached to rapidly spinning black holes can extract significant amounts of rotational energy and angular momentum. Here, we study the effect on primordial black holes, which are expected to form with one or more cosmic strings attached. Although large primordial black holes of mass greater than O (10 M) are predicted to rapidly spin up due to accretion soon after forming, we argue that cosmic strings will spin them down again. We show that if there are cosmic strings with tension greater than 10-20, and, provided at least one remains attached, the spins of large primordial black holes should consequently be observed to be near zero. We also investigate the effect on a supermassive black hole of capturing a cosmic string and discuss the possibility of observing the subsequent spin down by its effect on a pulsar orbiting the black hole.

Sources

Related papers