An Empirical Calibration of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch Distance Method in the Near Infrared. II. JWST NIRCam Wide Filters

arXiv:2406.03532 · astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2024-06-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "An Empirical Calibration of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch Distance Method in the Near Infrared. II. JWST NIRCam Wide Filters".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents an empirical calibration for using the Tip of the Red Giant Branch distance method in near-infrared filters with JWST NIRCam wide filters to extend its feasible distance range to approximately 50 Mpc.

Vera: Calibration Methodology The study standardizes the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W.

Jocelyn: The methodology involves characterizing the slope and zero-point of the TRGB by assuming it is described by a line with a single slope in the linear model mNIR,rect = mNIR − β

(NIRblue − NIRred) − γ: .

Vera: The process for measuring the slope in a given CMD is split up into three parts: first, locate the starting point for β and γ; second, iterate to optimize β; third, use Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to find our final value with uncertainties.

Title and authors: Vera: So, what's actually in this paper? It’s essentially an empirical calibration for using the tip of the red giant branch distance method in near-infrared filters with JWST NIRCam wide filters to extend its feasible distance range to about fifty megaparsecs.

Jocelyn: It’s about taking that standard candle we use—the TRGB—and figuring out exactly how those different JWST filters affect its brightness so we can get better distances out there.

Subrahmanyan: The implication for us is that if this calibration holds up, it means we can start using JWST to measure distances to galaxies in a much larger volume than before, which is huge for mapping the universe's structure.

Vera: Right. They are showing how the TRGB brightness depends on the color of the stars at that tip, and they’ve mapped out exactly how those colors change across their different filters.

Jocelyn: So they give specific recommendations on which filter combinations you should use depending on how precise you need your distance measurement to be.

Subrahmanyan: Which leads into what the paper suggests for the next steps—which filter pairs are best for high precision versus when you can settle for lower precision or shorter integration times.

The paper's summary: Vera: The core of this paper is setting up a method to standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity and age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST short wavelength filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength filters F277W, F356W and F444W.

Jocelyn: They’re using a linear model where they assume the TRGB luminosity is described by a line with one slope in the color difference between the near-infrared blue and red colors.

Subrahmanyan: They detail how to measure that slope by breaking it into three parts: first locating where to start for the zero point and color pivot, then iterating to optimize that slope, and finally using Monte Carlo simulations to find their final value with uncertainties.

Vera: They also discuss how the brightness of the TRGB changes based on whether the stars are at bluer colors or redder colors, which can either be constant or decrease modestly in redder bands like the I band, or increase from bluer to redder wavelengths.

Jocelyn: It’s important because that color dependence is what you have to account for when choosing your filters carefully and discussing the use cases for each combination they test.

Subrahmanyan: This whole process moves us from a simple distance measurement to a calibrated one that accounts for the specific photometric properties of the JWST instruments.

The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors provide specific filter recommendations based on your required precision—for instance, if you need high precision, say less than one percent in distance, they recommend measuring it in F090W versus F090W minus F150W or F115W versus F115W minus F277W.

Jocelyn: If you can tolerate lower precision, like over one point five percent distance error, or if you need shorter integration times, they suggest pairing either the F115W or the F150W with the F356W filter.

Subrahmanyan: They also warn us not to recommend using the F444W filter for precision TRGB measurements because it has lower angular resolution, which limits how well you can resolve those stars at greater distances.

Vera: To verify their results, they re-measured distances to each field in their individual color-magnitude diagrams and compared them to the HST F814W distances that they used as anchors for the calibrations.

Jocelyn: And they showed that the precision of using F090W versus F150W is quite good, demonstrating that three out of five points intersect the one to one line within their uncertainties.

Subrahmanyan: This validation step is crucial because it checks if their derived calibrations are actually consistent with established distance anchors from HST.

Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap up, the most precise and robust TRGB measurements come from using the F090W and F150W combinations, or the F115W and F277W pairs. If you’re willing to accept lower precision or need faster integration times for your science goals, they suggest pairing either of those with the F356W filter.

Jocelyn: The range of distances they cover is from minus four point three magnitudes in the F090W to minus six point four magnitudes in the F444W, which is about two magnitudes overall.

Subrahmanyan: These new calibrations are a first step for the community because they give us concrete tools to measure robust distances to galaxies using JWST data.

Vera: We’ve also seen that when comparing this calibration to another study, Anand et al., the zero points were consistent within their uncertainties, which gives us confidence in these new numbers.

Jocelyn: And they determined the final absolute calibration for the JWST F090W TRGB using the geometric distance to NGC four thousand two hundred fifty-eight and a weighted foreground-extinction-corrected average of the apparent TRGB magnitude in that galaxy.

Subrahmanyan: I just want to add that they noted there’s a modest metallicity dependence over the color range in these data, so we can't ignore that when we apply these corrections across different stellar populations.

Vera: It’s good to have this groundwork laid for using JWST for distance measurements, and it sets a baseline for how we should approach those observations moving forward.

Max J B Newman, Kristen B W McQuinn, Evan D Skillman, Martha L Boyer, Roger E Cohen, Andrew E Dolphin

Rutgers University Department of Physics and Astronomy · Space Telescope Science Institute Department of Physics and Astronomy School of Physics and Astronomy Institute for Astrophysics Raytheon Steward Observatory University of Arizona Department of Astrophysical Sciences Princeton University The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution for Science

astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2024-06-05

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 25 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: 2024ApJ...975..195N

DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad79f8

Code: https://github.com/spacetelescope/jwst

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: The paper presents an empirical calibration for using the Tip of the Red Giant Branch distance method in near-infrared filters with JWST NIRCam wide filters to extend its feasible distance range to…

Key concepts

TRGB Luminosity Standardization
The paper standardizes the TRGB brightness by using stellar colors as a proxy for age and metallicity. This allows researchers to create color-based corrections that account for how the TRGB magnitude changes based on the star's color, which is crucial for accurate distance calculations across different filters.
Color-Based Corrections
These are mathematical adjustments derived from the study that correct the raw TRGB magnitudes measured in specific JWST filters. The correction is based on a linear model relating the TRGB magnitude to the difference between two color indices, helping to compensate for variations in stellar properties.
Filter Combinations for Precision
The study recommends specific filter pairs depending on desired accuracy. For high precision (≤ 1%), it suggests using F090W vs F090W−F150W or F115W vs F115W−F277W, while lower precision science can use other pairings like F356W.
Multi-wavelength Behavior
The TRGB brightness changes depending on the star's color. It can stay relatively constant at bluer colors but decrease slightly in redder colors, or increase when moving to longer infrared wavelengths. This behavior dictates which filter combinations are best suited for a specific science goal.

Terminology

Summary

The paper presents an empirical calibration for using the Tip of the Red Giant Branch distance method in near-infrared filters with JWST NIRCam wide filters to extend its feasible distance range to approximately 50 Mpc. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Draft version June 12, 2024 Typeset using LATEX twocolumn style in AASTeX631 An Empirical Calibration of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch Distance Method in the Near Infrared. JWST NIRCam Wide Filters Max J.

Calibration Methodology

The study standardizes the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W. The methodology involves characterizing the slope and zero-point of the TRGB by assuming it is described by a line with a single slope in the linear model mNIR,rect = mNIR − β [(NIRblue − NIRred) − γ]. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The functional form of the slope is captured in the following linear model: mNIR,rect = mNIR − β [(NIRblue − NIRred) − γ] (1) where NIRblue and NIRred represent the blue and red filters in a CMD, mNIR (mNIR,rect) is the unrectified (rectified) apparent magnitudes of stars in either the NIRblue or NIRred filter, and β and γ are the slope and color pivot of the TRGB in a given filter, respectively. We emphasize that in our model the color pivot and the zero-point are directly related.

The process for measuring the slope in a given CMD is split up into three parts: first, locate the starting point for β and γ; second, iterate to optimize β; third, use Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to find our final value with uncertainties. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Second, we iterate to optimize β. Third, we use Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to find our final value with uncertainties.

Filter Recommendations

The paper provides recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision. For science requiring high precision (≤ 1% in distance) and robustness, it recommends measuring the TRGB in F090W vs F090W − F150W or F115W vs. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We provide recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision. For science requiring high precision (≤ 1% in distance) and robustness we recommend measuring the TRGB in F090W vs F090W − F150W or F115W vs.

F115W − F277W. p. 0
Where the paper says it

However, in the IR the TRGB luminosity depends to varying degrees on stellar metallicity and age. In this study we standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W.

If lower precision (> 1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

F115W − F277W with the caveat that even with JWST long integration times will be necessary at further distances. If lower precision (> 1.

5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, it recommends measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W. p. 0
Where the paper says it

If lower precision (> 1. 5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W.

The paper does not recommend F444W for precision TRGB measurements due to its lower angular resolution. p. 0
Where the paper says it

5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W. We do not recommend F444W for precision TRGB measurements due to its lower angular resolution.

Multi-wavelength Behavior Characterization

The brightness of the TRGB is a function of the color of the stars at the TRGB, which can manifest in two ways: approximately constant at bluer colors and modestly decreasing at redder colors (e.g., in the I band), or an increase from bluer to redder colors (e. p. 7

Where the paper says it

This color dependence, which traces the age and/or metallicity of the stars, can manifest in the magnitude of the TRGB in two ways: (1) approximately constant at bluer colors and modestly decreasing at redder colors (e. , in the I band); or (2) an increase from bluer to redder colors (e.

g., at NIR wavelengths). p. 1
Where the paper says it

When observed at wavelengths > 0. , the near-infrared (NIR)) the TRGB stars appear brighter due to bolometric corrections (BCs) by ∼ 1 − 2 magnitudes and can therefore expand the feasible range over which distances can be measured up to a factor 5 (e.

The choice of filters in which to apply the TRGB method must be carefully considered and discussed. p. 8
Where the paper says it

6 for uncertainties associate with the choice of kernel width). We then apply to the smoothed LF a Sobel filter kernel of width [-1,0,1] convolved with a Poissonian noise weighting scheme (e.

The paper presents 18 different combinations and provides detailed discussion on the use cases for each combination. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In this section we present our methodology for measuring the slope (color dependence) and the zero point (ZP) of the TRGB. Methodology: Fitting for the Slope and Zero Point of the TRGB To calibrate the TRGB across many different filter combinations, we adopted the approach detailed in Paper I in which we empirically calibrated the TRGB in each filter combination.

Precision Verification

To validate the precision of the JWST TRGB calibrations, the study re-measures distances to each field in their individual CMDs and compares them to the F814W distances used to anchor the calibrations. The fractional uncertainties tend toward greater values at the reddest filter F444W. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Each panel combines the targets with observations available in a set of filters on an absolute magnitude scale (see Table 1 for details of observations). Top to bottom: F090W to F444W (the bluest to the reddest filter in these data).

The precision of the F090W vs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this study we standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W. We provide recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision.

F150W calibration is demonstrated by showing that three of five points intersect the 1-to-1 line (black solid line) within their uncertainties. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We characterize the color dependence of the TRGB by assuming that it is described by a line with a single slope. Our slope finding method is similar to that presented in Paper I for the NIR HST filters in their calibration.

Comparison to Existing Work

The paper compares its F090W vs F090W − F150W calibration to the only other calibration in the literature, Anand et al. (2024), finding that the TRGB zero-points were consistent within the uncertainties. p. 9

Where the paper says it

2 (random displacement from the input β) and terminate the algorithm after the optimal slope value is the same on 5 separate iterations. Third, we measure our best-fit slopes, zero-points, and their associated statistical uncertainties through 1000 MC simulation trials.

The final value for the absolute calibration of the JWST F090W TRGB is determined from the geometric distance to NGC 4258 and a weighted foreground-extinction-corrected average of the apparent TRGB magnitude in NGC 4258. p. 2
Where the paper says it

From the observational side there exists only one empirical calibration of the TRGB in the JWST Near Infrared Camera (NIRCam) SW F090W filter (Anand et al. Their calibration is derived from one target, NGC 4258 and in the NIRCam F090W and F150W filters.

The paper notes that there is a modest metallicity dependence over the color range in these data. p. 2
Where the paper says it

OBSERVATIONS AND DATA 2. The Galaxy Sample In Paper I, we selected the 4 galaxies M 81, NGC 253, NGC 300, and NGC 2403 to bracket a range of metallicity and age in order to sample a wide range of stel-

Conclusion and Use Cases

The study concludes by recommending that for the most precise and robust TRGB measurements, the combinations of F090W and F150W, or F115W and F277W are ideal. If lower precision is tolerable or shorter integration times are desired for one’s science goal, it recommends pairing F115W or F150W with F356W. p. 0

Where the paper says it

If lower precision (> 1. 5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If lower precision (> 1. 5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W.

The paper provides these new TRGB calibrations to the community as a first step in measuring robust distances to galaxies with JWST. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes (MAST) hosts an incredible volume of archival NIR HST observations of galaxies that can be used to measure TRGB distances. In addition we use the HST TRGB NIR calibrations as as stepping stones to the JWST TRGB.

The range from −4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The TRGB-based distance method has been calibrated and used to measured distances to galaxies out to D ≤ 20 Mpc with the I-band equivalent Hubble Space Telescope (HST) F814W filter, and as an important rung in the distance ladder to measure the Hubble constant, H0. In the infrared (IR), the TRGB apparent magnitude ranges from 1 − 2 magnitudes brighter than in the optical, and now with the IR James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observatory the feasible distance range of the TRGB method can be extended to ∼ 50 Mpc.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The TRGB-based distance method has been calibrated and used to measured distances to galaxies out to D ≤ 20 Mpc with the I-band equivalent Hubble Space Telescope (HST) F814W filter, and as an important rung in the distance ladder to measure the Hubble constant, H0. In the infrared (IR), the TRGB apparent magnitude ranges from 1 − 2 magnitudes brighter than in the optical, and now with the IR James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observatory the feasible distance range of the TRGB method can be extended to ∼ 50 Mpc.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The TRGB-based distance method has been calibrated and used to measured distances to galaxies out to D ≤ 20 Mpc with the I-band equivalent Hubble Space Telescope (HST) F814W filter, and as an important rung in the distance ladder to measure the Hubble constant, H0. In the infrared (IR), the TRGB apparent magnitude ranges from 1 − 2 magnitudes brighter than in the optical, and now with the IR James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observatory the feasible distance range of the TRGB method can be extended to ∼ 50 Mpc.

3 mag in F090W to −6. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In addition the program includes NIRISS SW observations in the F090W, F115W, and F150W filters which will be presented in a separate paper. Our data reach to between 2 − 4 mag below the TRGB, depending on the filter.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

In addition the program includes NIRISS SW observations in the F090W, F115W, and F150W filters which will be presented in a separate paper. Our data reach to between 2 − 4 mag below the TRGB, depending on the filter.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

In addition the program includes NIRISS SW observations in the F090W, F115W, and F150W filters which will be presented in a separate paper. Our data reach to between 2 − 4 mag below the TRGB, depending on the filter.

4 mag in F444W or ∼ 2 magnitudes. p. 6
Where the paper says it

F090W the AGB spans spans more than the color width of the RGB, but is diffuse and extends only ∼ 1 mag in F090W. When the same stars are shown in F150W − F444W vs.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

F090W the AGB spans spans more than the color width of the RGB, but is diffuse and extends only ∼ 1 mag in F090W. When the same stars are shown in F150W − F444W vs.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

F090W the AGB spans spans more than the color width of the RGB, but is diffuse and extends only ∼ 1 mag in F090W. When the same stars are shown in F150W − F444W vs.

Summary of Distance Moduli Comparison and Fits to Residuals

Table 5 summarizes the distance modulus comparison and fits to residuals, showing that the mean of the residual is consistent with having a residual of ∆µ = 0. The fractional uncertainties increase from blue to red filters (up along the y-axis). p. 3

Where the paper says it

In Figure 1 we show the position of the NIRCam FOV on each target as regions (excluding WLM for which only SW were available in the filters applicable to this study). Background 3-color Galaxy Evolution Explorer (GALEX) images are created from a combination of far-ultraviolet (FUV; blue filter), near-ultraviolet (NUV; red filter) and an average of the FUV and NUV images (green filter).

The range from −4.3 mag in F090W to −6.4 mag in F444W or ∼ 2 magnitudes.

Summary of Error Budget for the NIR TRGB Calibration

Table 6 provides a breakdown of the contributions to our total error budget, both statistical and systematic. The statistical uncertainties include the ±0. p. 9

Where the paper says it

2 (random displacement from the input β) and terminate the algorithm after the optimal slope value is the same on 5 separate iterations. Third, we measure our best-fit slopes, zero-points, and their associated statistical uncertainties through 1000 MC simulation trials.

015 mag uncertainty from the HST ACS F814W zero-point (Freedman 2021) and the MC simulation JWST TRGB zero-point uncertainties. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We adopt their TRGB measurement and updated the distance modulus to use the ACS F814W zero-point from Freedman (2021). Sextans A has not been observed with the HST ACS in F814W.

The systematic uncertainties include contributions from the foreground extinction measured in F814, the sensitivity of the measured JWST TRGB zero-points to variations in the GLOESS smoothing scale τ, and the color-based luminosity correction applied to the F814 TRGB measurements. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1 mag in metallicity or age, respectively. Third, after applying a color-based slope correction (measured from their fiducial synthetic photometry) to the TRGB stars, the TRGB magnitudes measured in the JWST bands exhibit a spread of only 0.

Summary of All JWST TRGB Zero-Points

Figure 12 presents all JWST TRGB zero-point fits from Table 4, where zero-points are plotted as a function of the color pivot point (γ). The shape of the points corresponds to the magnitude filters and the color of the points corresponds to the color baseline. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Each local minimization optimizes β by maximizing (the negative of the minimum) the Sobel response at the TRGB magnitude. We assume that the largest Sobel response corresponds to the slope best characterizing the TRGB color dependence.

Summary of Corner Plots from MC Simulations

Figure 13 presents all corner plots for all JWST TRGB calibrations, showing in each corner plot the 1D histogram for the slope (β) fit, in the right panel the 1D histogram for the zero-point fit, and in the bottom left panel the 2D joint probability for the MC simulation.

Summary of Final TRGB Calibrations

Table 4 summarizes all JWST NIRCam TRGB Calibrations, including Mag Filter, Color Filters, Zero-Point, Slope, and Color Pivot. The F090W zero-point is −4. p. 1

Where the paper says it

(2012a) calibration of 0. 02 mag in the F160W zero-point and 0.

32+0.02 mag with a slope of −0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

02 mag in the F160W zero-point and 0. 04 in the slope.

18 and a color pivot of 1. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Our slope finding method is similar to that presented in Paper I for the NIR HST filters in their calibration. The functional form of the slope is captured in the following linear model: mNIR,rect = mNIR − β [(NIRblue − NIRred) − γ] (1) where NIRblue and NIRred represent the blue and red filters in a CMD, mNIR (mNIR,rect) is the unrectified (rectified) apparent magnitudes of stars in either the NIRblue or NIRred filter, and β and γ are the slope and color pivot of the TRGB in a given filter, respectively.

40. The F150W zero-point is −5. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2012a) calibration of 0. 02 mag in the F160W zero-point and 0.

72+0.02 mag with a slope of −1. p. 1
Where the paper says it

02 mag in the F160W zero-point and 0. 04 in the slope.

9 and a color pivot of 1. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Our slope finding method is similar to that presented in Paper I for the NIR HST filters in their calibration. The functional form of the slope is captured in the following linear model: mNIR,rect = mNIR − β [(NIRblue − NIRred) − γ] (1) where NIRblue and NIRred represent the blue and red filters in a CMD, mNIR (mNIR,rect) is the unrectified (rectified) apparent magnitudes of stars in either the NIRblue or NIRred filter, and β and γ are the slope and color pivot of the TRGB in a given filter, respectively.

40.

Summary of Precision in Distance Measurement

The fractional uncertainties tend toward greater values at the reddest filter F444W. The precision of the F115W − F356W calibration is 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this study we standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W. We provide recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision.

63%. The precision of the F150W − F444W calibration is 2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this study we standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W. We provide recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision.

23%. The range from −4.3 mag in F090W to −6.4 mag in F444W or ∼ 2 magnitudes.

Summary of Recommendations

For the most precise and robust TRGB measurements, the combinations of F090W and F150W, or F115W and F277W are ideal. If lower precision is tolerable or shorter integration times are desired for one’s science goal, it recommends pairing F115W or F150W with F356W. The paper does not recommend F444W for any precision TRGB measurements. p. 0

Where the paper says it

5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W. We do not recommend F444W for precision TRGB measurements due to its lower angular resolution.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Calibration recommendation system can recommend specific JWST NIRCam filter combinations based on required precision, such as recommending measuring the TRGB in F090W vs F090W − F150W or F115W vs. F115W − F277W with the caveat that even with JWST long integration times will be necessary at further distances for high precision work.

  2. The system can perform color-based luminosity corrections for TRGB measurements by applying the derived equations, such as T RGB (F090W) = −4.32 − (0.05) × [(F090W − F150W) − 1.40] mag when analyzing JWST data across different filters.

  3. The AI can select the optimal filter pair for a given science goal by comparing the advantages and disadvantages discussed in Section 5, such as recommending the combinations of F090W and F150W, or F115W and F277W are ideal for precise measurements.

  4. The system can provide a comprehensive error budget breakdown, detailing contributions from Foreground Extinction, Smoothing Scale, and the TRGB zero-point uncertainties as summarized in Table 6.

  5. The system can predict the fractional uncertainty in distance for any of the 18 calibrations by calculating it using the formula provided: σd/d = (σ∆µ / 0.461 × 10(∆µ/5+1)) × 100.

Abstract

The tip of the red giant (TRGB) is a standardizable candle and is identifiable as the discontinuity at the bright extreme of the red giant branch (RGB) stars in color-magnitude diagram (CMD) space. The TRGB-based distance method has been calibrated and used to measured distances to galaxies out to D at most20 Mpc with the I-band equivalent Hubble Space Telescope (HST) F814W filter, and as an important rung in the distance ladder to measure the Hubble constant, H 0. In the infrared (IR), the TRGB apparent magnitude ranges from 1-2 magnitudes brighter than in the optical, and now with the IR James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observatory the feasible distance range of the TRGB method can be extended to about50 Mpc. However, in the IR the TRGB luminosity depends to varying degrees on stellar metallicity and age. In this study we standardize the TRGB luminosity using stellar colors as a proxy for metallicity/age to derive color-based corrections for the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) short wavelength (SW) filters F090W, F115W, F150W and the long wavelength (LW) filters F277W, F356W, and F444W. We provide recommended filter combinations for distance measurements depending on the requisite precision. For science requiring high precision (at most1% in distance) and robustness we recommend measuring the TRGB in F090W vs F090W-F150W or F115W vs. F115W-F277W with the caveat that even with JWST long integration times will be necessary at further distances. If lower precision (>1.5% in distance) can be tolerated, or if shorter integration times are desirable, we recommend measuring the TRGB in either F115W or F150W paired with F356W. We do not recommend F444W for precision TRGB measurements due to its lower angular resolution.

Sources

Related papers