Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory

arXiv:2404.11670 · gr-qc · Submitted 2024-04-17 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules.

Kai: Theoretical Framework and Methodology Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set A causal set can be imagined as a network, where the events embedded into spacetime represent the nodes that connect if and only if they are causally related The central conjecture of CST is that this also holds for a discrete spacetime, meaning continuous spacetime volume corresponds to a finite number of causet elements which can be counted to provide the missing measure of volume The simulation uses Poisson sprinkling, where events are distributed according to Poiss(N) = (ρV) N e −ρV N!

Mira: for a given density ρ and volume V.

Kai: Black Hole Thermodynamics Modeling The study investigates the horizon molecules model, which assumes that the microstructure of a black hole that gives rise to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is formed by molecules of spacetime situated on its horizon The Bekenstein-Hawking formula states that the entropy of a black hole scales with the area A of the event horizon, SBH = A / 4l squared p, where lp = p Għ/c3 is the Planck length The number of horizon molecules Nmol is demanded to be proportional to the event horizon area, i.e Nmol ∝ A.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory," and it’s about using this new way of thinking—Causal Set Theory—to actually count the microstates that give rise to black hole entropy.

Mira: It sounds like they are taking the idea of discrete spacetime, which is a core concept in Causal Set Theory, and applying it directly to calculating the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy for a Schwarzschild black hole.

Lev: So, what this paper is really doing is moving away from just talking about area and entropy scaling with it, and instead trying to build a molecular model based on how these discrete spacetime events are distributed near the horizon.

Kai: Right. It’s about testing if this microscopic view of horizon molecules actually lines up with the macroscopic formula we already have for black hole entropy.

Mira: Exactly. The title suggests they are using a Boltzmann counting approach, which means they're trying to see if we can get a statistical measure of those microstates by looking at how many molecules are present.

Lev: It sounds like the main focus is checking the consistency between the discrete causal structure and that macroscopic entropy formula.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper sets up this numerical simulation using C++ to generate causal sets with over a million points in a non-conformally flat spacetime, which is pretty large for what they’ve done so far.

Mira: They use Poisson sprinkling to distribute these events according to a density rho equals l minus four, where l is that fundamental discreteness scale we talked about earlier.

Lev: So the key result here is they found that the horizon molecules model actually matches the Bekenstein-Hawking formula, but only up to a dimensionless constant that they interpret as being in the order of a Planck length.

Kai: That means their simulation confirms that entropy lives on the surface of the black hole because these proposed molecules straddle it to within a few Planck lengths.

Mira: They found proportionality between the number of those molecules and the horizon area A, with a proportionality constant they estimate as zero point one seven three plus or minus zero point zero zero one when they account for curvature corrections.

Lev: So, the simulation successfully connects these discrete events to the macroscopic scaling we expect from black hole thermodynamics, but that constant is where things get interesting for us.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest a few things that could make this model even more useful. They found that the Boltzmann entropy calculation gives S lambda equals zero point zero nine one plus or minus zero point zero two times the area A times the Planck length squared.

Mira: And based on that, they conclude that their fundamental discreteness scale l is estimated to be zero point six oh three plus or minus zero point zero three times a Planck length.

Lev: That estimate of l being about zero point six oh three times the Planck length is what you need to look at when you try to build real hardware, because it sets the scale for how small your fundamental units really are in this model.

Kai: And they also found that the scaling of black hole entropy up to the first order curvature correction term is estimated by n BH L equals a zero point one seven three times A over l squared minus zero point three two two L root A plus or minus something small.

Mira: That correction term, the one involving l root A, is what shows how the entropy scales when you move beyond the simplest flat spacetime approximation.

Lev: So this is useful because it gives us a way to predict how much the entropy changes when we actually consider some of the curvature effects in our simulations.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap this up, this paper confirms that using Causal Set Theory provides a molecular model for black hole entropy where these horizon molecules are localized close to the horizon within two Planck lengths.

Mira: And they've established that the scaling of those molecules matches the analytical result from Barton et al in flat spacetime approximation, even though there were some minor discrepancies when accounting for curvature corrections.

Lev: From an engineering side, this means if we are building models for black holes, we have a concrete way to test these microscopic assumptions against the macroscopic physics they already agree with.

Kai: The implication is that these horizon molecules could potentially yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation for black holes of Planckian size.

Mira: This work on "Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory" gives us a numerical anchor point to connect the discrete structure of spacetime directly to the thermodynamic properties of a horizon.

Lev: It’s interesting, but they also noted that there are discrepancies between their numerical estimate and the analytical first order curvature correction term, so further studies on those other curvature features are suggested.

Vid Homšak, *, Stefano Veroni †

Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London · PlanQC GmbH

gr-qc

Submitted: 2024-04-17

Updated: 2024-05-01

Comments: 18 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 110, 026015 (2024)

DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevD.110.026015

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed…

Key concepts

Causal Set Theory (CST)
A theory of quantum gravity where spacetime is fundamentally discrete, consisting of a network or causal set of events connected by causal relations. Continuous spacetime emerges only as a macroscopic approximation to this underlying discrete structure.
Horizon Molecules Model
This hypothesis suggests that the entropy responsible for black hole thermodynamics arises from 'molecules' of spacetime situated on the black hole's event horizon. These molecules are counted and their distribution relates directly to the black hole's area, linking microstates to macroscopic entropy.
Bekenstein-Hawking Entropy
This formula defines the entropy of a black hole as being proportional to its surface area. The paper tests if the 'horizon molecules' count provides a physical mechanism consistent with this established law of black hole thermodynamics.

Terminology

Summary

This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory Vid Homšak1, ∗ and Stefano Veroni1, † 1Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Rd, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom (Dated: May 2, 2024) This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set A causal set can be imagined as a network, where the events embedded into spacetime represent the nodes that connect if and only if they are causally related The central conjecture of CST is that this also holds for a discrete spacetime, meaning continuous spacetime volume corresponds to a finite number of causet elements which can be counted to provide the missing measure of volume The simulation uses Poisson sprinkling, where events are distributed according to Poiss(N) = (ρV) N e −ρV N! for a given density ρ and volume V. p. 1

Where the paper says it

This is possible with a Poissonian relation between the two [19, 20]. Then, the probability of having N elements in a region of volume V at density ρ is given by Poiss(N) = (ρV ) N e −ρV N!

Black Hole Thermodynamics Modeling

The study investigates the horizon molecules model, which assumes that the microstructure of a black hole that gives rise to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is formed by molecules of spacetime situated on its horizon The Bekenstein-Hawking formula states that the entropy of a black hole scales with the area A of the event horizon, SBH = A / 4l squared p, where lp = p Għ/c3 is the Planck length The number of horizon molecules Nmol is demanded to be proportional to the event horizon area, i.e Nmol ∝ A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

As pioneered by Dou and Sorkin [2], in a discrete spacetime one can connect “spacetime atoms” across the black hole horizon, under certain constraints, to form horizon molecules, and then seek in these molecules the origin of the entropy. Assuming a large number Nmol of independent molecules making up the horizon, each occupying a microstate n with probability pn, one can count them and look at their distribution to measure the Boltzmann entropy of the event horizon S = −NmolX n pn ln pn.

Numerical Simulation and Results

The authors created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date The results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length They found that entropy lives on the surface of the black hole because molecules straddle the horizon to within a few Planck lengths.

Key Findings and Implications

The numerical results show clear proportionality between the number of Λn molecules and the horizon area A, with proportionality constants estimated as a(0)L[3] = 0.173 ± 0.001 when accounting for curvature corrections The Boltzmann entropy given by Eq. p. 8

Where the paper says it

001 into Eq. (39) and using the probability distribution of Λn molecules, the Boltzmann entropy given by Eq.

(2) yields SΛ = (0. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(39) and using the probability distribution of Λn molecules, the Boltzmann entropy given by Eq. (2) yields SΛ = (0.

091 ± 0.002) Al squared, which leads to the conclusion that the discreteness scale is l = (0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date. Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length.

603 ± 0.003)lp The approach suggests that horizon molecules could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation for black holes of Planckian size

Conclusion and Future Directions

The paper confirms that the minimal assumptions of Causal Set Theory are enough to provide a molecular model of black hole entropy where the horizon molecules are localized close to the horizon within 2l distance The numerical scaling of Link molecules agrees perfectly with the analytical result obtained by Barton et al. [27] in the flat spacetime approximation However, discrepancies were found between the numerical estimate and the analytical 1st order curvature correction term Further studies are suggested for investigating other entropy models [243] and exploring other curvature features

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Prof Fay Dowker, who developed the idea of the Boltzmannian state counting in causal sets theory, for her guidance, the fun discussions, and the extensive feedback on the manuscript. They also thank Hinchi Lee, Narin Tananitaporn, Rohith Mukkapati and Olivia Ho for motivating us and whose ideas contributed to the success of our project. p. 5

Where the paper says it

However, we can derive the analytical expression for Link molecules, which are closely related to Λn. They are links crossing the horizon whose past element is maximal but one with respect to Σ 2 .

Appendix Details

Appendix A provides a mathematical proof of the final statements of Section III B 2 regarding causality in (3+1)D Schwarzschild spacetime Appendix B derives the 1st order curvature correction term a(1)L for the Schwarzschild spacetime, finding a(1)L ≈ −0.0558 Appendix C presents the Christoffel symbols of the Eddington-Finkelstein Original coordinates used in Section III A Appendix D describes other basic tests performed on the causal set simulation framework, including dimension estimation. p. 2

Where the paper says it

However, Schwarzschild coordinates are problematic as they give a mathematical singularity at r = rS, hence we use Eddington-Finkelstein original 1 (EFO) coordinates [25, 26] t ∗ = tS + 2M ln r 2M − 1 , r, θ, ϕ , (5) which are well-behaved everywhere but at the black hole singularity. This allows us to rewrite the line element into 1 The term ”original” is used to distinguish them from the better known ingoing (outgoing) coordinates with same name, often denoted as u (v).

Appendix E provides additional numerical results, confirming the validity of the simulations and showing that the molecule distribution in (2+1)D spacetime obeys a similar distribution to that in (3+1)D

References

[1] S. W. Hawking, Particle creation by black holes, Commun. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length. Furthermore, the molecules are found to straddle the horizon of the black hole to within a few Planck lengths, indicating that entropy lives on the surface of the black hole.

Math. Phys. 43, 199–220 (1975)

[2] D. Dou and R. D. Sorkin, Black-hole entropy as causal links, Foundations of Physics 33, 279 (2003)

[3] S. He and D. Rideout, A causal set black hole, Class. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory Vid Homšak1, ∗ and Stefano Veroni1, † 1Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Rd, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom (Dated: May 2, 2024) This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date.

Quantum Grav. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

26, 125015 (2009)

[4] S. W. Hawking and R. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date. Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length.

Penrose, The singularities of gravitational collapse and cosmology, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 314, 529 (1970)

[5] J. M. Bardeen, B. Carter, and S. W. Hawking, The four laws of black hole mechanics, Commun. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Black hole entropy, which is usually associated with complexity, suggests the existence of hidden degrees of freedom beyond those recognised by the no-hair theorem. Entropy is a property of statistical mechanics and is usually related to the distribution of microstates of molecules inside the object of interest.

Math. Phys. 31, 161 (1973)

[6] J. D. Bekenstein, Black holes and entropy, Phys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length. Furthermore, the molecules are found to straddle the horizon of the black hole to within a few Planck lengths, indicating that entropy lives on the surface of the black hole.

Rev. D 7, 2333 (1973)

[7] W. Israel, Event horizons in static vacuum space-times, Phys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The boundary of the black hole is the event horizon: any object crossing the horizon will inevitably keep falling towards the centre, where a singularity is present. This is a region of zero volume where curvature and density diverge, and at which any object’s worldline - the object’s trajectory in space and time - abruptly interrupts, as if ceasing to exist [4].

Rev. 164, 1776 (1967)

[8] W. Israel, Event horizons in static electrovac space-times, Commun. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The boundary of the black hole is the event horizon: any object crossing the horizon will inevitably keep falling towards the centre, where a singularity is present. This is a region of zero volume where curvature and density diverge, and at which any object’s worldline - the object’s trajectory in space and time - abruptly interrupts, as if ceasing to exist [4].

Math. Phys. 8, 245 (1968)

[9] B. Carter, Axisymmetric black hole has only two degrees of freedom, Phys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

However, as per the no-hair theorem, established via a series of contributions [7–12], black holes appear to be the simplest objects in the universe, fully specified by only 3 observables: mass M, charge Q and angular momentum J. Black hole entropy, which is usually associated with complexity, suggests the existence of hidden degrees of freedom beyond those recognised by the no-hair theorem.

Rev. Lett. 26, 331 (1971)

[10] R. M. Wald, Final states of gravitational collapse, Phys. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(20), we obtain the two differential equations dϕ du = ±du η 2 + 2Mu3 − u 2 −1/2 (27) dt∗ du = 1 u 2(2Mu − 1) " ±duη p η 2 + u 2(2Mu − 1) + 2Mu# (28) where ±du = sign(u2 − u1) (29) depends on the order in which the two events were initially chosen. Since the initial and final spatial boundary conditions (u, ϕ) are known, we can fit Eq.

Rev. Lett. 26, 1653 (1971)

[13] T. Jacobson, D. Marolf, and C. Rovelli, Black hole entropy: Inside or out? p. 0

Where the paper says it

Black hole entropy, which is usually associated with complexity, suggests the existence of hidden degrees of freedom beyond those recognised by the no-hair theorem. Entropy is a property of statistical mechanics and is usually related to the distribution of microstates of molecules inside the object of interest.

, International Journal of Theoretical Physics 44, 1807–1837 (2005)

[14] L. Bombelli, R. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Causal Set Theory This section gives an overview of CST, explains how causal sets can be approximated by a spacetime continuum and provides the relevant nomenclature. CST began in earnest by Bombelli et al.

K. Koul, J. Lee, and R. D. Sorkin, Quantum source of entropy for black holes, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Since the horizon is just a boundary in empty spacetime, this suggests that black hole entropy resides in the microstructure of spacetime itself. As pioneered by Dou and Sorkin [2], in a discrete spacetime one can connect “spacetime atoms” across the black hole horizon, under certain constraints, to form horizon molecules, and then seek in these molecules the origin of the entropy.

Rev. D 34, 373 (1986)

[15] J. D. Bekenstein, Black holes and the second law, Lettere al Nuovo Cimento 4, 737 (1973)

[16] L. Bombelli, J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Causal Set Theory This section gives an overview of CST, explains how causal sets can be approximated by a spacetime continuum and provides the relevant nomenclature. CST began in earnest by Bombelli et al.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Causal Set Theory This section gives an overview of CST, explains how causal sets can be approximated by a spacetime continuum and provides the relevant nomenclature. CST began in earnest by Bombelli et al.

Lee, D. Meyer, and R. D. Sorkin, Spacetime as a causal set, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Since the horizon is just a boundary in empty spacetime, this suggests that black hole entropy resides in the microstructure of spacetime itself. As pioneered by Dou and Sorkin [2], in a discrete spacetime one can connect “spacetime atoms” across the black hole horizon, under certain constraints, to form horizon molecules, and then seek in these molecules the origin of the entropy.

Rev. Lett. 59, 521 (1987)

[17] S. W. Hawking, Breakdown of predictability in gravitational collapse, Phys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date. Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length.

Rev. D 14, 2460 (1976)

[18] D. Malament, The class of continuous timelike curves determines the topology of spacetime, J. p. 3

Where the paper says it

(t ∗ 1 , r1, θ1, ϕ1) and E2 = (t ∗ 2 , r2, θ2, ϕ2), the method determines their causal relation by checking whether E2 lies inside the future light cone of E1. Since the boundaries of light cones are determined by null curves, the method distils itself into finding the null geodesics emanating from E1, and comparing t ∗ 2 with the times t ∗ γ when null geodesics reach the spatial position of E2 (see Fig.

Math. Phys. 18, 1399– (1977)

[19] L. Bombelli, Space-time as a causal set, Ph. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Causal Set Theory This section gives an overview of CST, explains how causal sets can be approximated by a spacetime continuum and provides the relevant nomenclature. CST began in earnest by Bombelli et al.

D. thesis, Syracuse University (1987)

[20] M. Saravani and S. Aslanbeigi, On the causal set–continuum correspondence, Classical and Quantum Gravity 31, 205013 (2014)

[21] F. Dowker, Causal sets and the deep structure of spacetime, in 100 Years of Relativity - Space-time Structure: Einstein and Beyond, edited by A. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Curvature corrections in Schwarzschild spacetime In general, the average number of molecules, for any horizon H, is given by an infinite series ⟨N⟩ = a A ℓ 2 = a (0) + a (1)(H, Σ) ℓ A + O ℓ 2 A A ℓ 2 . (36) To go beyond the flat spacetime approximation a (0) and estimate the 1st order curvature correction a (1), which depends on the structure of H and Σ, we follow the procedure described by Sec.

Ashtekar (World Scientific, [Online], 2005) pp. 445–464

[22] L. Bombelli, J. Henson, and R. D. Sorkin, Discreteness without symmetry breaking: a theorem, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 24, 2579 (2009)

[23] D. Stoyan, S. Chiu, W. Kendall, and J. Mecke, Stochastic geometry and its applications. p. 7

Where the paper says it

(c) and (d) highlight some details of (b), showing that even when events are extremely close to the null geodesics, they are only connected if and only if inside the light cone, as it should be. for each element as they could be preferable for certain applications.

, 3rd ed. (Wiley, Chichester,)

[24] S. Surya, The causal set approach to quantum gravity, Living Reviews in Relativity 22, 10. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

1007/s41114-019-0023- (2019)

[25] A. Eddington, A comparison of whitehead’s and einstein’s formulae, Nature 113, 192 (1924)

[26] D. Finkelstein, Past-future asymmetry of the gravitational field of a point particle, Phys. p. 5

Where the paper says it

We denote J as the intersection of the event horizon H and hypersurface Σ, which represents the event horizon at time tΣ, and is just a point in 1+1 dimensions. Integrating over all spacetime regions δRp in the past of the horizon and hypersurface intersection I −(J ), yields the expected number of Links ⟨NL⟩ = ρ 2 Z I−(J ) dVp V + in (p) e −ρV + in(p) .

Rev. 110, 965 (1958)

[27] C. Barton, A. Counsell, F. Dowker, D. S. W. Gould, G. Taylor, and I. Jubb, Horizon molecules in causal set theory, Phys Rev D 100 126008 (2019)

[28] C. Minz, Python-causets (2020)

[35] G. ’t Hooft, Dimensional reduction in quantum gravity, arXiv 10. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

48550/arXiv. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Entropy is a property of statistical mechanics and is usually related to the distribution of microstates of molecules inside the object of interest. It is an ongoing debate arXiv:2404.

gr-qc/9310026 (1993)

[36] L. Susskind, The world as a hologram, J. Math. Phys. 36, 6377 (1995)

[37] T. A. Thompson, C. S. Kochanek, K. Z. Stanek, C. Badenes, R. S. Post, T Jayasinghe, D W Latham, A Bieryla G Esquerdo P Berlin et al., A noninteracting low-mass black hole-giant star binary system, Science 366 637 (2019)

[38] D. J. Fixsen, The temperature of the cosmic microwave background, The Astrophysical Journal 707, 916 (2009)

[39] S. Hawking, Gravitationally collapsed objects of very low mass, Mon. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Black holes have been shown to be thermal objects endowed with a temperature and entropy [5, 6]. However, as per the no-hair theorem, established via a series of contributions [7–12], black holes appear to be the simplest objects in the universe, fully specified by only 3 observables: mass M, charge Q and angular momentum J.

Not. R. Astron. Soc. 152, 75 (1971)

[40] C. Röken, On the nature of black holes in loop quantum gravity, Class. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

Quantum Grav. 30, 015005 (2013)

[41] L. Lewin, Polylogarithms and associated functions, 1st ed. p. 0

Where the paper says it

However, as per the no-hair theorem, established via a series of contributions [7–12], black holes appear to be the simplest objects in the universe, fully specified by only 3 observables: mass M, charge Q and angular momentum J. Black hole entropy, which is usually associated with complexity, suggests the existence of hidden degrees of freedom beyond those recognised by the no-hair theorem.

(North-Holland Publishing Co., New York, 1981. p. 4
Where the paper says it

HORIZON MOLECULES This section defines horizon molecules, determines the coefficient for the scaling of number of molecules with the area of the black hole horizon and calculates the curvature corrections in Schwarzschild spacetime. In this paper, we investigated a new type of horizon molecule, the Λn molecule, which will be discussed in detail in the following subsection.

Chap. 7.)

[42] D. M. T. Benincasa, The action of a causal set, Ph. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory Vid Homšak1, ∗ and Stefano Veroni1, † 1Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Rd, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom (Dated: May 2, 2024) This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date.

D. thesis, Imperial College London (2013), chap. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory Vid Homšak1, ∗ and Stefano Veroni1, † 1Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Rd, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom (Dated: May 2, 2024) This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date.

6

[43] R. D. Sorkin and Y. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Since the horizon is just a boundary in empty spacetime, this suggests that black hole entropy resides in the microstructure of spacetime itself. As pioneered by Dou and Sorkin [2], in a discrete spacetime one can connect “spacetime atoms” across the black hole horizon, under certain constraints, to form horizon molecules, and then seek in these molecules the origin of the entropy.

K. Yazdi, Entanglement entropy in causal set theory, Class. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Boltzmannian state counting for black hole entropy in Causal Set Theory Vid Homšak1, ∗ and Stefano Veroni1, † 1Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Rd, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom (Dated: May 2, 2024) This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date.

Quantum Grav. 35, 074004 (2018)

[44] D. M. T. Benincasa and F Dowker, Scalar curvature of a causal set, Phys. p. 6

Where the paper says it

It allows for an efficient generation of causal sets in Minkowski and Schwarzschild spacetime. Curvature corrections in Schwarzschild spacetime In general, the average number of molecules, for any horizon H, is given by an infinite series ⟨N⟩ = a A ℓ 2 = a (0) + a (1)(H, Σ) ℓ A + O ℓ 2 A A ℓ 2 .

Rev. Lett. 104, 181301 (2010)

[45] M. Roy, D Sinha, and S Surya, Discrete geometry of a small causal diamond, Phys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation. INTRODUCTION Causal Set Theory (CST) is an approach to the problem of quantum gravity which assumes that continuous spacetime emerges merely as a macroscopic approximation to the fundamental discrete causal structure, a causal set.

Rev. D 87, 044046 (2013)

[46] A. Meurer, C. P. Smith, M. Paprocki, O. Certik, S B Kirpichev, M Rocklin, A Kumar S Ivanov J K Moore S Singh et al., Sympy: symbolic computing in python 3 PeerJ Computer Science 3 10. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Based on our experience, generating Schwarzschild causets is approximately 200 times slower compared to flat spacetime, which explains why other causet numerical studies did not attempt it. While we initially used the causal set package written by Minz [28], we realised that Python is too slow and decided to create our simulation framework in C++, due to its speed.

7717/peerj-cs.103 (2017)

[47] EinsteinPy Development Team, EinsteinPy: Python library for General Relativity (2021)

[48] J. Myrheim, Statistical geometry (1978)

[49] D. A. Meyer, The dimension of causal sets, Ph. p. 6

Where the paper says it

EmbeddedCauset Creates causal matrix, past/future sets, links… based on the given coordinates Shapes Functions for sprinkling coordinate points into various (hollow) shapes. SIMULATION FRAMEWORK Causet Low-level functions related to causets - ordering fraction, dimension estimator etc.

D.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Causal set theory simulation for curved spacetime allows AI systems to model black hole thermodynamics by generating causal sets in Schwarzschild spacetime with over a million points, confirming that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length.

  2. The C++ simulation framework enables AI systems to generate causal sets in non-conformally flat spacetime, allowing for a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation, which could inform models for information paradox resolution.

  3. The analysis of horizon molecules provides a probability distribution for these molecules, specifically finding that we can model the distribution very well by a falling exponential function pn = (eχ − 1) e−nχ, χ = 1.53 ± 0.03, which can be used to develop statistical models for quantum information storage within black holes.

  4. The simulation framework includes functions to estimate dimensions of causal sets, enabling AI systems to perform real-time dimensional estimation for the spacetime being modeled by a causet, verifying its embedding in D=2, 3, or 4 dimensions.

  5. The calculation of curvature corrections allows AI systems to estimate the scaling of black hole entropy up to the first order as ⟨N BH L⟩ = aL A/l squared = a(0) L A/l squared 1 − 0.322l√A + O(l 2), which improves thermodynamic predictions for black holes of physically relevant sizes.

Abstract

This paper presents the first numerical study of black hole thermodynamics in Causal Set Theory, focusing on the entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole as embodied in the distribution of proposed horizon molecules. To simulate causal sets we created a highly parallelized computational framework in C++ which allowed for the generation of causal sets with over a million points, the largest causal sets in a non-conformally flat spacetime to date. Our results confirm that the horizon molecules model is consistent with the Bekenstein-Hawking formula up to a dimensionless constant that can be interpreted as the fundamental discreteness scale in the order of a Planck length. Furthermore, the molecules are found to straddle the horizon of the black hole to within a few Planck lengths, indicating that entropy lives on the surface of the black hole. Finally, possible implications for the information paradox are drawn. In particular, we show how the horizon molecules model could yield a finite black hole temperature cut-off or even prevent full black hole evaporation.

Sources

Related papers