Disorder as a route to topological spin textures in amorphous magnets
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Disorder as a route to topological spin textures in amorphous magnets".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Topological spin textures in magnetic materials such as skyrmions and hopfions are interesting manifestations of geometric structures in real materials, concurrently having potential applications as information carriers The authors propose an ab initio spin Hamiltonian to accurately represent the diversity of structural and magnetic properties in the exemplar amorphous FeGe Monte Carlo simulations of our amorphous Hamiltonian find emergent skyrmions that are driven by frustrated geometric and magnetic exchange, consistent with those observed in experiment Driving Mechanisms in Amorphous Systems The study investigates the origin and driving mechanisms behind the formation of spin textures in amorphous systems with their range of chemical and structural distributions The authors address fundamental questions such as whether topological spin textures in amorphous materials are formed by DMI or local frustration introduced by disorder They find that the diversity of local structural motifs results in a large range of exchange interactions, far beyond those found in crystalline materials Furthermore, they observe the formation of large-scale emergent structures in amorphous materials, far beyond the relevant interaction length-scale in the systems Structural and Magnetic Property Analysis The researchers analyze calculated amorphous bond length distributions and magnetic moments and compare them with those of the crystalline case They find that the 1NN distance is reduced (∼2.50Å) with respect to the crystalline case (∼2.88Å) The right histogram shows that Fe ions can host magnetic moments ranging from-1.80µB to 2.05µB with a majority of them being around 0µB and the average magnetic moment of Fe ions in the five amorphous snapshots range from 0.52µB to 0.79µB in the collinear limit which is in good agreement with the experimental average magnetic moment of Fe ions of 0.75µB They find that ferromagnetic interactions to be dominant in the studied amorphous structures however we also find some antiferomagnetic interactions resulting in an overall ferrimagnetic ordering in the collinear limit Exchange Interactions and Anisotropy Dependence The analysis of local coordination environment reveals that the average moment increases as a function of the number of Fe neighbors, and decreases with increasing Ge neighbors They calculate the single-ion anisotropy on each Fe finding it can reach as large as 0.4 meV (on average) Importantly, their results suggest that the assumption that J and DMI only depend on pair distance, J(ri j), does not hold in amorphous materials They find pairs having different J and DMI values even though with the same separation (see Fig.
Kai: S3) Emergent Topological Textures The Monte Carlo simulations predict that topological spin textures are formed due to the isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in contrast with the driving mechanism crystalline systems where it is due to DMI or long-range interactions They find that any magnetic amorphous system could host nanoscale topological spin textures because of their inherent frustrated and disordered structure Their results further indicate that topological spin textures are formed due to their complicated nearest-neighbor magnetic exchange coupling coefficients The size of the skyrmions was found to vary from ∼26Å3 to ∼ 221Å3, for example, the size of the skyrmion that is enlarged in Fig.
Mira: 4(a) is ∼ 5.5Å ×7.3Å ×5.5Å In summary, they developed an ab initio amorphous spin Hamiltonian to describe the magnetic and topological spin textures of amorphous FeGe Their results reveal that the magnetic exchange interactions (Jαα and DMI) depend both on the separation between the magnetic species and on their respective magnetic moments They find a range of magnetic interactions in amorphous systems whose magnitude is highly dependent on the local coordination environment of each ion, and varies from site to site Based on their MC simulations that incorporated all of this structural and magnetic complexity, they find that topological spin textures are formed due to the isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in contrast with the driving mechanism crystalline systems where it is due to DMI or long-range interactions They hope their predictions will motivate further exploration of magnetic amorphous systems and will be put to use to design novel quantum devices All first-principles calculations were carried out within the framework of Density Functional Theory (DFT) as implemented in Vienna Ab-Initio Software Package (VASP) For the crystalline case, they used the generalized gradient approximation, with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof exchange-correlation functional and an effective Hubbard U parameter of 1.5 eV for the localized 4p electrons of the Ge ions They selected a Hubbard U value of 1.5eV to best reproduce the lattice parameters and Fe magnetic moments in experiment They used ab-initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations with the NVT ensemble as implemented in VASP using a time-step of 2 fs Computational Details For the amorphous case, they used the local-density approximation (LDA) to have the average magnetic moments of the Fe ions closer to the experimental value of 0.75 µB They chose to use LDA exchange-correlation functional for the study of amorphous structures in their manuscript and hereafter The parallel tempering Monte Carlo (MC) simulations were performed using the extracted magnetic parameters and the Hamiltonian of Eqs.
Kai: (1 and 2) from the manuscript They used supercells of different size for the crystalline structures, 64×64×2, 128×128×4, 24×24×24, and 40×40×3 References Fert et al.
Title and authors: Kai: So, to recap what we just covered, the paper titled "Disorder as a route to topological spin textures in amorphous magnets" proposes an ab initio spin Hamiltonian derived from first-principles calculations to describe the magnetic and topological properties of amorphous FeGe.
Mira: They use this Hamiltonian to run Monte Carlo simulations on this model, comparing it directly against the crystalline counterpart to see how disorder changes the physics.
Lev: The key finding is that they found emergent spin structures, like skyrmions, in their simulations that match what has been seen experimentally in FeGe thin films.
Kai: They specifically simulated supercells as large as forty times forty times forty and they confirmed the existence of these textures <ref:2311.07725#pg3,simulated supercells as large as 40>.
Mira: But they also admit a limitation: because of the computational limits and the finite size effects from their unit cell size, they didn't find chiral spiral spin structures in their calculations, so they refer to previous micromagnetic simulations for that.
Lev: That's a fair point; running those kinds of large simulations on real hardware would take significant overhead, but for this study, it confirms the mechanism is there.
Kai: So what does this mean for us right now? It means disorder isn't just noise; it’s a structural feature that can actively drive these specific topological textures in materials like FeGe.
Mira: It suggests that we don't need perfect crystal symmetry to see these kinds of complex magnetic ordering, as long as the disorder creates enough frustration.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if we were trying to model a real amorphous system, this Hamiltonian framework tells us exactly what kind of complexity—the site-by-site exchange variation—we would have to account for in our error models.
Kai: It sets a baseline for how complex the physics gets when you move away from perfect translational symmetry.
Mira: So, the next big thing here is looking at how this framework can predict textures in other amorphous magnetic systems, not just FeGe.
The paper's summary: Lev: Now let's talk about what they suggest for improvement, because that’s where the real physics lies. They propose developing an ab initio spin Hamiltonian that incorporates site-by-site descriptions of exchange interactions.
Kai: That means moving away from assuming a single J value based only on the distance between two atoms, which is what they found doesn't hold in amorphous materials.
Mira: The improvement hinges on using a form for the exchange coupling that depends not just on distance, but also explicitly on the magnetic moments of those specific ions, denoted as J(ri j, mi, mj).
Lev: By using that specific form—the J depending on moment and separation—they can model those geometrically frustrated spin interactions driven by local environments rather than just relying on crystal symmetry or long-range interactions.
Kai: That moves the physics from a simpler description to one that acknowledges the local chemical and structural disorder, which is what really makes amorphous materials unique.
Mira: This allows AI systems to describe the diversity of local structural motifs more accurately because they are capturing those site-dependent magnetic properties.
Lev: For running this on real hardware, incorporating this level of complexity means the overhead for error correction would land heavily in modeling these local interactions correctly during the simulation steps.
Kai: It’s a trade-off between accuracy and computational cost, but if we want to predict those emergent phases, we have to build that level of detail into our model.
Mira: So, the practical improvement is shifting from a static parameter set to a dynamic one where every interaction parameter is defined by the local environment it exists in.
The paper's improvements: Kai: We're wrapping up this look at "Disorder as a route to topological spin textures in amorphous magnets" and summarizing what we found about the system.
Mira: Basically, they developed an ab initio amorphous spin Hamiltonian for FeGe, used Monte Carlo simulations to find skyrmions that match experiments, and concluded that topological spin textures are formed due to isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in amorphous systems.
Lev: The implication is that even in a disordered system like FeGe, the structure itself can generate these interesting magnetic states through frustration and disorder.
Kai: It means we don't need perfect crystal symmetry to see these kinds of complex magnetic ordering if the local interactions are complicated enough.
Mira: The main takeaway is that the magnetic exchange interactions, both J alpha alpha and DMI, depend on both the separation between different magnetic species and their respective magnetic moments.
Lev: And this dependence on the local coordination environment means the magnitude of these interactions varies from site to site, which is crucial for real materials.
Kai: So, we’ve seen that disorder isn't just a random perturbation; it’s an active ingredient in creating novel topological spin textures that have potential applications as information carriers.
Mira: This work motivates further exploration of magnetic amorphous systems and how their structural complexity leads to these kinds of emergent phenomena.
Lev: And for us, it gives us a specific, complex model to test the limits of our simulations when we try to model real-world disordered magnetism.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at "Disorder as a route to topological spin textures in amorphous magnets" and what this paper actually built, it’s an ab initio spin Hamiltonian for amorphous FeGe.
Mira: They used that Hamiltonian to run Monte Carlo simulations and found emergent skyrmions that match experimental observations in FeGe thin films.
Lev: The key point is they showed that these textures are driven by the frustrated geometric and magnetic exchange, which is consistent with what we see in experiments.
Kai: They even simulated huge supercells, up to forty times forty times forty, and they confirmed these structures exist within the model.
Mira: But they also pointed out a limitation because of the simulation size that they didn't find chiral spiral spin structures in their calculations, so they mentioned micromagnetic simulations for that part.
Lev: That's a fair point; running those kinds of large simulations on real hardware would take significant overhead, but it confirms the mechanism is present in this model.
Kai: So what does this mean for us right now? It means disorder isn't just noise; it’s a structural feature that can actively drive these specific topological textures in materials like FeGe.
Mira: It suggests that we don't need perfect crystal symmetry to see these kinds of complex magnetic ordering if the disorder creates enough frustration.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if we were trying to model a real amorphous system, this Hamiltonian framework tells us exactly what kind of complexity—the site-by-site exchange variation—we would have to account for in our error models.
Kai: It sets a baseline for how complex the physics gets when you move away from perfect translational symmetry.
Mira: So the next big thing here is looking at how this framework can predict textures in other amorphous magnetic systems, not just FeGe.
Lev: I think that’s where it gets interesting because applying this method to a new material would immediately tell us what kind of computational cost we’re looking at for error correction.
Kai: Exactly, and that's what we need to keep in mind when designing the next generation of magnetic simulation tools.
Mira: It really shows how structural complexity translates directly into magnetic phase diversity.
Lev: And it's a good reminder that even with disorder, there are still specific, predicted topological phases waiting to be found.
Kai: That’s where we’ll be next week when we look at sequential retrieval in dense associative memory and see how different kinds of structural complexity drive those dynamics.
Temuujin Bayaraa, Sinead M. Griffin
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory · Molecular Foundry Division
cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.dis-nn
Submitted: 2023-11-13
Updated: 2026-10-27
Comments: Version2 has substantial improvement over the first version. We addressed the inconsistency between theory and experimental results with new results and figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: Topological spin textures in magnetic materials such as skyrmions and hopfions are interesting manifestations of geometric structures in real materials…
Key concepts
- Ab initio Spin Hamiltonian
- A mathematical model derived from first principles (DFT) used to describe the magnetic behavior of the FeGe material. It is designed to capture how structural disorder affects the exchange interactions between atoms, allowing for accurate simulation of magnetic properties in amorphous systems.
- Local Coordination Environment
- This refers to the specific arrangement and number of neighboring atoms surrounding a central iron (Fe) ion. The study found that an Fe ion's magnetic moment changes based on how many Fe neighbors it has versus Ge neighbors, highlighting how local structure dictates magnetic behavior.
- Isotropic Exchange Coupling Coefficients
- These are the coefficients describing the strength of magnetic interactions between neighboring atoms in the amorphous material. The key finding is that these isotropic coefficients drive topological spin textures in amorphous systems, contrasting with crystalline systems where DMI or long-range interactions are primary drivers.
Terminology
Summary
Topological spin textures in magnetic materials such as skyrmions and hopfions are interesting manifestations of geometric structures in real materials, concurrently having potential applications as information carriers The authors propose an ab initio spin Hamiltonian to accurately represent the diversity of structural and magnetic properties in the exemplar amorphous FeGe Monte Carlo simulations of our amorphous Hamiltonian find emergent skyrmions that are driven by frustrated geometric and magnetic exchange, consistent with those observed in experiment
Driving Mechanisms in Amorphous Systems
The study investigates the origin and driving mechanisms behind the formation of spin textures in amorphous systems with their range of chemical and structural distributions The authors address fundamental questions such as whether topological spin textures in amorphous materials are formed by DMI or local frustration introduced by disorder They find that the diversity of local structural motifs results in a large range of exchange interactions, far beyond those found in crystalline materials Furthermore, they observe the formation of large-scale emergent structures in amorphous materials, far beyond the relevant interaction length-scale in the systems
Structural and Magnetic Property Analysis
The researchers analyze calculated amorphous bond length distributions and magnetic moments and compare them with those of the crystalline case They find that the 1NN distance is reduced (∼2.50Å) with respect to the crystalline case (∼2. p. 288Å) The right histogram shows that Fe ions can host magnetic moments ranging from-1. p. 280µB to 2. p. 205µB with a majority of them being around 0µB and the average magnetic moment of Fe ions in the five amorphous snapshots range from 0. p. 252µB to 0. p. 279µB in the collinear limit which is in good agreement with the experimental average magnetic moment of Fe ions of 0. p. 275µB They find that ferromagnetic interactions to be dominant in the studied amorphous structures however we also find some antiferomagnetic interactions resulting in an overall ferrimagnetic ordering in the collinear limit
Exchange Interactions and Anisotropy Dependence
The analysis of local coordination environment reveals that the average moment increases as a function of the number of Fe neighbors, and decreases with increasing Ge neighbors They calculate the single-ion anisotropy on each Fe finding it can reach as large as 0.4 meV (on average) Importantly, their results suggest that the assumption that J and DMI only depend on pair distance, J(ri j), does not hold in amorphous materials They find pairs having different J and DMI values even though with the same separation (see Fig. p. 2 S3)
Emergent Topological Textures
The Monte Carlo simulations predict that topological spin textures are formed due to the isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in contrast with the driving mechanism crystalline systems where it is due to DMI or long-range interactions They find that any magnetic amorphous system could host nanoscale topological spin textures because of their inherent frustrated and disordered structure Their results further indicate that topological spin textures are formed due to their complicated nearest-neighbor magnetic exchange coupling coefficients The size of the skyrmions was found to vary from ∼26Å3 to ∼ 221Å3, for example, the size of the skyrmion that is enlarged in Fig. 4(a) is ∼ 5.5Å ×7.3Å ×5.5Å
Conclusion and Outlook
In summary, they developed an ab initio amorphous spin Hamiltonian to describe the magnetic and topological spin textures of amorphous FeGe Their results reveal that the magnetic exchange interactions (Jαα and DMI) depend both on the separation between the magnetic species and on their respective magnetic moments They find a range of magnetic interactions in amorphous systems whose magnitude is highly dependent on the local coordination environment of each ion, and varies from site to site Based on their MC simulations that incorporated all of this structural and magnetic complexity, they find that topological spin textures are formed due to the isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in contrast with the driving mechanism crystalline systems where it is due to DMI or long-range interactions They hope their predictions will motivate further exploration of magnetic amorphous systems and will be put to use to design novel quantum devices
Methods
All first-principles calculations were carried out within the framework of Density Functional Theory (DFT) as implemented in Vienna Ab-Initio Software Package (VASP) For the crystalline case, they used the generalized gradient approximation, with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof exchange-correlation functional and an effective Hubbard U parameter of 1.5 eV for the localized 4p electrons of the Ge ions They selected a Hubbard U value of 1. p. 55eV to best reproduce the lattice parameters and Fe magnetic moments in experiment They used ab-initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations with the NVT ensemble as implemented in VASP using a time-step of 2 fs
Computational Details
For the amorphous case, they used the local-density approximation (LDA) to have the average magnetic moments of the Fe ions closer to the experimental value of 0.75 µB They chose to use LDA exchange-correlation functional for the study of amorphous structures in their manuscript and hereafter The parallel tempering Monte Carlo (MC) simulations were performed using the extracted magnetic parameters and the Hamiltonian of Eqs. p. 6 (1 and 2) from the manuscript They used supercells of different size for the crystalline structures, 64×64×2, 128×128×4, 24×24×24, and 40×40×3
References
Fert et al. Magnetic skyrmions: advances in physics and potential applications Griffin & Spaldin On the relationship between topological and geometric defects Sampaio et al. p. 0 Nucleation, stability and current-induced motion of isolated magnetic skyrmions in nanostructures Dzyaloshinsky A thermodynamic theory of “weak” ferromagnetism of antiferromagnetics Moriya Anisotropic superexchange interaction and weak ferromagnetism Zhang et al. p. 6 Room-temperature helimagnetism in FeGe thin films Streubel et al. p. 6 Experimental Evidence of Chiral Ferrimagnetism in Amorphous GdCo Films Singh et al. p. 6 Characterizing Temporal Heterogeneity by Quantifying Nanoscale Fluctuations in Amorphous Fe-Ge Magnetic Films Wu et al. p. 7 Ultra-small topological spin textures with size of 1. p. 73nm at above room temperature in Fe78Si9B13 amorphous alloy Montoya et al. p. 7 Transport properties of dipole skyrmions in amorphous Fe/Gd multilayers Mizoguchi Magnetism in Amorphous Alloys Chappert et al. p. 7 Appearance of magnetism in amorphous Y1-xFex Lee & Heiman Magnetism in rare earth-transition metal amorphous alloy films Cochrane et al. p. 7 Magnetic and transport properties of amorphous NiY and FeY Sherrington & Kirkpatrick Solvable Model of a Spin-Glass Handrich A Simple Model for Amorphous and Liquid Ferromagnets Binder & Stauffer Monte Carlo simulation of a three-dimensional spin glass Walker & Walstedt Computer Model of Metallic Spin-Glasses Litterst Susceptibility of non-crystalline ferromagnetic FeF2 Lines A computer model for amorphous Fe Moorjani Kishin Coey Magnetic glasses Buschow On the difference in the magnetic properties of amorphous alloys and intermetallic compounds Coey et al. Amorphous magnetic order Kaneyoshi T Introduction to Amorphous Magnets COEY & DAVID Current trends in amorphous magnetism Petrakovski˘ı G A Amorphous magnetic materials Aharony Critical behavior of amorphous magnets Kaneyoshi T Introduction to Amorphous Magnets Kaneyoshi T Amorphous Magnetism Belokon et al. p. 8 Magnetic phase transition in an amorphous alloy The theory of random fields of exchange interaction Santos-Filho et al. p. 8 Monte carlo study of the phase diagram of disordered fepal1−p alloys A site-diluted isotropic heisenberg model Plascak et al. p. 8 Ising model for disordered ferromagnetic Fe−Al alloys Fähnle Monte Carlo study of phase transitions in bond- and site-disordered Ising and classical Heisenberg ferromagnets Savchenko et al. p. 8 Diversity of states in a chiral magnet nanocylinder Ma et al. p. 8 Robust Formation of Ultrasmall Room-Temperature Neél Skyrmions in Amorphous Ferrimagnets from Atomistic Simulations Moskvin et al. p. 8 Complex Chiral Modulations in FeGe Close to Magnetic Ordering Yu et al. p. 8 Real-space observation of a two-dimensional skyrmion crystal Muhlbauer et al. p. 8 Skyrmion Lattice in a Chiral Magnet Grytsiuk et al. p. 8 Ab initio analysis of magnetic properties of the prototype B20 chiral magnet FeGe Grytsiuk & Blügel Micromagnetic description of twisted spin spirals in the B20 chiral magnet FeGe from first principles Borisov et al. p. 8 Heisenberg and anisotropic exchange interactions in magnetic materials with correlated electronic structure and significant spin-orbit coupling Turgut et al. p. 8 Topological spin dynamics in cubic FeGe near room temperature Zheng et al. p. 8 Experimental observation of chiral magnetic bobbers in B20-type FeGe Kovács et al. p. 8
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Ab initio spin Hamiltonian development can be improved to incorporate site-by-site descriptions of exchange interactions, as this is necessary because
chemical and structural disorder in amorphous systems leads to a distribution of magnetic properties.
This allows AI systems to accurately describe thediversity of local structural motifs
and predict emergent correlated phases beyond the crystalline limit. -
Monte Carlo simulations can be enhanced by using the derived J(ri j, mi, mj) form for exchange coupling, moving beyond the assumption that
J and DMI only depend on pair distance.
This improved Hamiltonian allows AI to modelgeometrically frustrated spin interactions
driven by local environments rather than just crystal symmetry or long-range interactions. -
The system can be used to predict topological spin textures in any amorphous magnetic system by finding that
topological spin textures are formed due to the isotropic exchange coupling coefficients in contrast with the driving mechanism crystalline systems where it is due to DMI or long-range interactions.
This capability enables AI to identify potential topological phases in new, unstudied amorphous materials. -
AI systems can be trained on the relationship between local coordination environment and magnetic moment, since
the average moment increases as a function of the number of Fe neighbors, and decreases with increasing Ge neighbors.
This allows for more accurate prediction of magnetic properties based on structural disorder in amorphous alloys.
Sources
- Transport properties of dipole skyrmions in amorphous FeGd multilayers
- Skyrmion Lattice in a Chiral Magnet
- Ab initio analysis of magnetic properties of prototype B20 chiral magnet FeGe
- Micromagnetic description of twisted spin spirals in the B20 chiral magnet FeGe from first principles
- Heisenberg and anisotropic exchange interactions in magnetic materials with correlated electronic structure and significant spin-orbit coupling
- Topological spin dynamics in cubic FeGe near room temperature
- Elucidating the local atomic and electronic structure of amorphous oxidized superconducting niobium films
- Observation of spin-momentum locked surface states in amorphous Bi$_{2}$Se$_{3}$
- TB2J: a python package for computing magnetic interaction parameters
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion