Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors shows that magnetic field gradients can induce measurable charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization, while simultaneously reducing the spin diffusion length through a mechanism analogous to co- and counter-current exchange Core Mechanism of Spin-Charge Coupling The work demonstrates that magnetic field gradients can generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization in solid state systems.
Kai: This phenomenon is termed the “Inverse Stern-Gerlach effect”, where a spin polarization generates a charge current instead of the original Stern-Gerlach experiment generating a transverse spin current.
Mira: The authors formulate and solve coupled spin and charge drift-diffusion equations to show this induction of charge currents and spin accumulation which are predicted to be measurable by a voltage difference.
Kai: Spin Transport Suppression The magnetic field gradient is found to reduce the spin diffusion length, a non-intuitive result explained by invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange.
Paper summary: Kai: So this paper, "Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors," it basically claims that magnetic field gradients can actually create a measurable charge current from non-equilibrium spin polarization in solid state systems.
Mira: Right, so they're taking something like a spin polarization and using that, through the gradient of the magnetic field, to get a charge current instead of what you expect from the standard Stern-Gerlach experiment which is about separating spins.
Lev: And they’re modeling this with coupled spin and charge drift-diffusion equations, showing how this leads to both charge currents and spin accumulation that you could actually measure as a voltage difference.
Kai: It's interesting because they predict an “Stern-Gerlach” voltage in GaAs that would be comparable to what you see from the inverse spin Hall effect.
Mira: But there's a twist, they also found something non-intuitive: the spin diffusion length gets reduced by that magnetic gradient.
Lev: They explain this reduction by using an idea called co-current and counter-current exchange, which they draw analogies to things like animal physiology and fluid dynamics.
Kai: So, the main thrust of this paper is showing how spin and charge dynamics are coupled in a new way when you have a magnetic field gradient present.
Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the title, "Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors," it really tells you that we're looking at two things happening here.
Kai: It's showing how a magnetic field gradient generates charge current from spin polarization, and also how that same gradient suppresses the spin transport length through this counter-current exchange mechanism.
Lev: The implication for practical hardware is that if this effect is real, it opens up new ways to generate measurable currents using non-equilibrium spins in materials like GaAs.
Mira: But they also put a limitation on their model, specifically mentioning that the spin diffusion length reduction relies on invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange from fields as disparate as animal physiology and thermal engineering.
Kai: So, while the prediction for a voltage comparable to the inverse spin Hall effect is neat, it’s important to remember that they had to make some strong analogies to explain why the spin transport length shrinks.
N. J. Harmon, E. Z. Kurth, D. Coleman, L. Flanigan
Department of Physics and Engineering Science, Coastal Carolina University
cond-mat.mes-hall
Submitted: 2023-07-31
Updated: 2023-07-31
Comments: 6 pages, 3 figs. Supplement not included. submitted to Phys. Rev. Lett
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 109, 195423 (2024)
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.109.195423
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors shows that magnetic field gradients can…
Key concepts
- Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect
- This is a phenomenon where a magnetic field gradient causes a charge current to be generated from an existing non-equilibrium spin polarization, rather than the traditional Stern-Gerlach experiment which separates spins. It shows that spin polarization can directly induce measurable charge flow in solid state systems.
- Spin Counter-Current Exchange
- This concept explains why the magnetic field gradient reduces the spin diffusion length. It is analogous to phenomena in physiology and fluid dynamics where opposing currents interact, leading to a suppression of how far a spin can travel before relaxing.
- Stern-Gerlach Force Operator
- This mathematical operator describes the force exerted on an electron's spin due to an inhomogeneous magnetic field gradient. It is used to derive the spin-dependent velocities of up and down spins, which are then used in drift-diffusion equations to model charge current generation.
Terminology
Summary
Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors shows that magnetic field gradients can induce measurable charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization, while simultaneously reducing the spin diffusion length through a mechanism analogous to co- and counter-current exchange
Core Mechanism of Spin-Charge Coupling
The work demonstrates that magnetic field gradients can generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization in solid state systems. This phenomenon is termed the “Inverse Stern-Gerlach effect”, where a spin polarization generates a charge current instead of the original Stern-Gerlach experiment generating a transverse spin current. p. 0 The authors formulate and solve coupled spin and charge drift-diffusion equations to show this induction of charge currents and spin accumulation which are predicted to be measurable by a voltage difference. p. 0
Spin Transport Suppression
The magnetic field gradient is found to reduce the spin diffusion length, a non-intuitive result explained by invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange. This suppression is visualized in Fig. p. 0 1(d), which displays new features (anti-nodes) when spin relaxation is present. p. 0 The effect is understood by analogy with the concept of co- and counter-current exchange from the fields of physiology [23–26] and fluid/thermal dynamics [27, 28]. p. 0
Mathematical Modeling and Governing Equations
The approach is semi-classical, solving for spin-dependent velocities resulting from a Stern-Gerlach-like force from a generic magnetic field gradient. The Stern-Gerlach force operator is given by Fˆ SG = −∇V = −1/2 gµB∇(σ ·B). p. 0 This force leads to spin-dependent velocities, such as v↑ = -gµBτ/2m∇Bz = -ν∇Bz where ν is the magnetic mobility. p. 0 The spin current is defined as j z SG,s = j↑ SG − j↓ SG = -q(n↑ + n↓)ν∇Bz. p. 0
Experimental Predictions and Potential Measurement
The charge separation produced by the dynamics yields a gradient-dependent voltage. The potential difference across the sample is calculated using the Stern-Gerlach force as an effective electric force such that jSG,c = σcEeff where σc = qµn is the charge conductivity. p. 4 The maximum voltage scales with the field gradient length when l0 = lb. p. 4 The predicted maximum voltage is approximately 10 µV, which is larger than typical inverse spin Hall voltages in GaAs in the ∼ 1 µV range. p. 4
Conclusion and Future Directions
The authors suggest an optical approach to measure an appreciable voltage difference generated by spin and charge dynamics in the magnetic gradient. The predicted Stern Gerlach voltage, in competition with an inverse Spin Hall voltage, may also be measured electrically in a two-dimensional geometry where a gradient field is transverse to a spin current. p. 4 A reported dependence of a potential dependent on dynamically polarized nuclei is suggestive of this Inverse Stern-Gerlach-like effect. p. 4
Key Findings Summary
[No enumerated list found in the text for this section.]
The paper's primary significance lies in demonstrating a novel method to generate measurable charge currents from spin polarization using magnetic field gradients, which is predicted to yield a voltage comparable to the inverse spin Hall effect. The key physical insight is the role of spin counter-current exchange
in suppressing spin transport, leading to reduced downstream diffusion lengths. This coupling between charge and spin dynamics opens avenues for new spintronic applications. p. 0 The derived equations provide a framework for understanding how these non-equilibrium spin systems behave under external fields. p. 0 The predicted voltage scaling with the field gradient length offers an experimental target for verification. p. 0
--- Page 1 ---
Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors N. J. Harmon,1, ∗ E. p. 0 p. 0 Z. Kurth,1 D. Coleman,1 and L. p. 0 p. 0 Flanigan1 1Department of Physics and Engineering Science, Coastal Carolina University, Conway, SC 29526, USA (Dated: August 1, 2023 The spin-orbit interaction is frequently the mechanism by which spin and charge are coupled for spintronic applications. p. 0 p. 0 The discovery of spin, a century ago, relied on spin-charge coupling by a magnetic field gradient; this mechanism has received scant attention as a means for generating spin and charge currents in semiconductors. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Through the derivation of a set of coupled spin-charge drift-diffusion equations, our work shows that magnetic field gradients can be used to generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization, in solid state systems. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 We predict, in GaAs, an “Stern-Gerlach” voltage comparable to what is measured by the inverse spin Hall effect. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Non-intuitively, we find the spin diffusion length is reduced by the magnetic gradient. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 This is understood by invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange which is a concept frequently invoked in fields as disparate as animal physiology and thermal engineering. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Introduction. p. 0 — In 1922, Otto Stern and Walther Gerlach discovered quantized spin angular momentum in neutral silver atoms when an inhomogeneous magnetic field spatially separated discrete spin states [1–3]. p. 0 The Stern-Gerlach experiment’s detection of spin was indirect as it measured the spin of a neutral atom and not the spin of a free charge. p. 0 Debate arose in the early days of quantum theory whether the spin of a free electron could be verified with a Stern-Gerlachlike experiment [4–6]. p. 0 The conventional wisdom that emerged (though detractors exist [7, 8]), repeating the arguments of N. p. 0 Bohr and N. p. 0 F. Mott [9–11], is that Lorentz forces obscure any magnetic moment deflections. p. 0 Due to ∇ ·B = 0, the Lorentz force cannot be avoided by directing motion of spin carriers parallel to B since a gradient field force transverse to the motion also exists. p. 0 What is overlooked, aside from a few authors [12–14], is these arguments apply for free electrons which is not the condition which electrons exist in solid state systems. p. 0 In a confined geometry, the Lorentz force, which is the primary obstacle to spin separation, and the transverse gradient force (due to ∇ · B = 0), would be negated by the classical Hall effect. p. 0 Fabian and Das Sarma studied the effect of inhomogeneous fields on one dimensional conduction spin currents by solving the Boltzmann equation for a limited set of boundary conditions [15]. p. 0 Their calculations suggest the spin current generated is constrained by the time for a carrier to diffuse across the sample and the spin relaxation time. p. 0 Our focus here is on the generation of more experimentally accessible charge currents. p. 0 The prospect of spin-charge coupling, outside of the spinorbit interaction [16–22], is alluring as it offers up a wider variety of materials for inspection. p. 0 What will be demonstrated in this Letter, by formulating and solving a series of spin and charge drift-diffusion equations, is that magnetic field gradients induce charge currents and spin accumulation which are predicted to be measurable by a voltage difference. p. 0 This is not too surprising since one can view the original Stern-Gerlach experiment as an unpolarized beam generating a transverse spin current; here we have a spin polarization generating a charge current – a process we term as the Inverse SternGerlach effect. p. 0 However the role the field gradient, in conjunction with spin relaxation, plays in suppressing spin diffusion is subtle and is best understood by analogy with the concept of co- and counter-current exchange from the fields of physiology [23–26] and fluid/thermal dynamics [27, 28]. p. 0 Our main results, for a one-dimensional system (Fig. p. 0 1(a)), are shown in Fig. p. 0 1. Fig. 1(c) displays the transient responses of up/down spin densities after a gaussian impulse of spin density in the absence of spin relaxation; up and down spin travel in opposite directions leading to a charge current which, due to the nature of the magnetic-gradient interaction, depends upon the spin density instead of the charge density. p. 0 Fig. 1(d) plots the same quantities which demonstrate new features (anti-nodes) when spin relaxation is present. p. 0 A Fig. 3(e) depicts steady state spin distributions for different field gradients (brown line – small gradient, orange line – large gradient). p. 0 Despite the Stern Gerlach’s determination to separate opposite spins in opposite, the spin diffusion lengths shrink as a result; we seek to understand this phenomena by analogy with counter-current exchange (an example of counter-current exchange in fish oxygenation is shown in Fig. p. 0 3(b)). The charge separation of Figs. p. 0 3(c,d) produces a gradientdependent voltage – a predicted response inset in Fig. p. 0 1(e). Spin and charge drift-diffusion equations in presence of magnetic field gradient. p. 0 — We approach the problem in a semi-classical manner by solving for spin-dependent velocities resulting from a Stern-Gerlach-like force from a generic magnetic field gradient. p. 0 Given the magnetic moment of an electron, µ = −1/2 gµBσ and the its dipole potential energy, V = −µ ·B, we write a Stern-Gerlach force operator as Fˆ SG = −∇V = -1/2 gµB∇(σ ·B). p. 0 (1) The force is spin-dependent — the force on ↑ / ↓ spins (taking z as quantization axis) is F↑/↓ SG = ∓ 1/2 gµB∇Bz. p. 0 The inclusion of this force into a Drude-like model yields steady state velocities v↑ = F↑ SGτ/m= -gµBτ/2m∇Bz = -ν∇Bz, (2) where ν = g∗µBτ/2m has units of m 2/(T s) which we define as the magnetic mobility (in contrast to electronic mobility), τ is the momentum relaxation time, m is the carrier mass, and g∗ is the effective g-factor. p. 1 Note that the velocity does not depend on the charge q in congruence with the force being moment- and not charge-dependent. p. 1 The spin current is j z SG,s = j↑ SG - j↓ SG = -q(n↑ + n↓)ν∇Bz where n is the conduction charge density. p. 1 Similarly for other directions of spin, the direction of spin couples to the same direction of magnetic field: j i SG,s = -qnν∇Bi. p. 1 We follow the same process for charge current: jSG,c = -qν(sx∇Bx +sy∇By +sz∇Bz) where si are components of spin density. p. 1
--- Page 2 ---
2 2 O2 poor blood water (high O2) O2 rich blood water (low O2) δn↑ A G(z) v↑ n0 0 1 t 0 t 1 t 2 δn↓ A G(z) v↓ n↓ B(z) z x y (a) (b) v↑ v↓ z n ↑, n ↓ B(z)= bzẑ z = 0 z + μEzt n↑, n↓ (c) no spin relaxation spin relaxation z = 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 t s=2 ns (d) Identical to (c) except spin relaxation is included Direction of packet motion is determined by νb which is chosen here as νb < 0 s = D/l s (e) Allowable steady state normalized spin density region for possible spin cc exchange parameters, Ξ = 1(b = 0) denotes pure spin co-current exchange, and Ξ = -1(Ez = 0) denotes pure spin counter-current exchange. p. 1 p. 1
--- Page 3 ---
3 cocurrents countercurrents z (μm) (f) (g) Results, at three different instances, from Monte Carlo simulation of up spins (red) injected into quasi-one-dimensional channel under condition of spin counter-current exchange νb ≠ 0, Ez = 0 and spin cocurrent exchange νb = 0, Ez ≠ 0. Due to spin relaxation, up spins convert to down spins (blue) and vice-versa. p. 1 Ordinate quantities in (c,d) are per δN↑/A
--- Page 4 ---
4 z (μm) z x y n ↑, n ↓ t 0 = 0+ t 1 t 2-100-80-60-40-20 0 20-2 n↑, n↓ (a)
--- Page 5 ---
5 z (μm) z x y n ↑, n ↓ t s=2 ns (b)
--- Page 6 ---
6 cocurrents countercurrents z + μEzt νb = - 0.5 μm/ns τ s = 2 ns × 0. p. 1 p. 13 40 ns approx. p. 3 p. 3 eq(10,11) n↑ t=15 ns-100-80-60-40-20 2 ν b τs Ξ =
--- Page 7 ---
7 [5] L O’Brien, D Spivak, N Krueger, T Peterson, M Erickson B Bolon C Geppert C Leighton and P Crowell Physical Review B 94 094431 (2016)
The spin-orbit interaction is frequently the mechanism by which spin and charge are coupled for spintronic applications. The discovery of spin, a century ago, relied on spin-charge coupling by a magnetic field gradient; this mechanism has received scant attention as a means for generating spin and charge currents in semiconductors. Through the derivation of a set of coupled spin-charge drift-diffusion equations, our work shows that magnetic field gradients can be used to generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization, in solid state systems. We predict, in GaAs, an “Stern-Gerlach” voltage comparable to what is measured by the inverse spin Hall effect. Non-intuitively, we find the spin diffusion length is reduced by the magnetic gradient. This is understood by invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange which is a concept frequently invoked in fields as disparate as animal physiology and thermal engineering.
--- Page 1 ---
Generation of charge current by the Inverse Stern-Gerlach Effect and the suppression of spin transport due to spin counter-current exchange in semiconductors N. J. Harmon,1, ∗ E. Z. Kurth,1 D. Coleman,1 and L. Flanigan1 1Department of Physics and Engineering Science, Coastal Carolina University, Conway, SC 29526, USA (Dated: August 1, 2023 The spin-orbit interaction is frequently the mechanism by which spin and charge are coupled for spintronic applications. The discovery of spin, a century ago, relied on spin-charge coupling by a magnetic field gradient; this mechanism has received scant attention as a means for generating spin and charge currents in semiconductors. Through the derivation of a set of coupled spin-charge drift-diffusion equations, our work shows that magnetic field gradients can be used to generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization, in solid state systems. We predict, in GaAs, an “Stern-Gerlach” voltage comparable to what is measured by the inverse spin Hall effect. Non-intuitively, we find the spin diffusion length is reduced by the magnetic gradient. This is understood by invoking the idea of co-current and counter-current exchange which is a concept frequently invoked in fields as disparate as animal physiology and thermal engineering.
--- Page 2 ---
2 2 O2 poor blood water (high O2) O2 rich blood water (low O2) δn↑ A G(z) v↑ n0 0 1 t 0 t 1 t 2 δn↓ A G(z) v↓ n↓ B(z)= bzẑ z = 0 z + μEzt n↑, n↓ (c) no spin relaxation spin relaxation z = 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 t s=2 ns (d) Identical to (c) except spin relaxation is included Direction of packet motion is determined by νb which is chosen here as νb < 0 s = D/l s (e) Allowable steady state normalized spin density region for possible spin cc exchange parameters, Ξ = 1(b = 0) denotes pure spin co-current exchange, and Ξ = -1(Ez = 0) denotes pure spin counter-current exchange.
--- Page 4 ---
4 z (μm) z x y n ↑, n ↓ t 0 = 0+ t 1 t 2-100-80-60-40-20 2 2 O2 poor blood water (high O2) O2 rich blood water (low O2) δn↑ A G(z) v↑ n↓ B(z)= bzẑ z = 0 z + μEzt n↑, n↓
--- Page 6 ---
6 cocurrents countercurrents z + μEzt νb = - 0.5 μm/ns τ s = 2 ns × 0.3 40 ns approx. eq(10,11) n↑ t=15 ns-100-80-60-40-20 2 ν b τs Ξ =
--- Page 7 ---
7 [5] L O’Brien, D Spivak, N Krueger, T Peterson, M Erickson B Bolon C Geppert C Leighton and P Crowell Physical Review B 94 094431 (2016)
--- Page 8 ---
8 Steady state Alternatively we consider continuous optical pumping of spin into the conduction band [33, 36] to determine steady state spin and charge concentrations [35]. If g is the rate per cross-sectional area of continuously injected non-equilibrium spins at the origin, the solutions can be written in the following compact form sz = gτs e-z/l 2 0 q(z squared b+l 2 0) q l 2 0 b +l 2 0 (11) where l0 = √Dτs is the spin diffusion length and l b = νbτs magnetic gradient drift length. p. 3 When l b ≫ l0, the diffusion lengths become l 2 0/l b = D/νb which explains the behavior for spin diffusion lengths seen in Fig. p. 3 3 (a). Though the spinsz(z)/sz(0) Ez= 0 μEz= -1 μm/ns νb = 0-3-0. p. 35 νb = 0-0. p. 15 τ τs=20 ns s=20 ns
--- Page 9 ---
9 z (μm) z x y n↑, n↓ t s=2 ns (a)
--- Page 10 ---
10 z (μm) z x y n↑, n↓ t s=2 ns (b)
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
1
The improved AI system can generate charge currents from non-equilibrium spin polarization by exploiting magnetic field gradients in solid state systems, as shown by predicting an “Stern-Gerlach” voltage comparable to what is measured by the inverse spin Hall effect.
2
The system can model and predict the reduction of the spin diffusion length due to magnetic gradients, a phenomenon understood through co-current and counter-current exchange which is a concept frequently invoked in fields as disparate as animal physiology and thermal engineering.
3
The improved system can simulate transient spin dynamics under combined electric field and magnetic gradient conditions, allowing it to predict whether up and down spins move parallel or anti-parallel based on the relative sizes of the forces, relating this to co/counter-current (cc) exchange.
4
The AI can calculate a charge separation voltage using the predicted response inset in Figure 1(e), which is proportional to the magnetic gradient length when no electric field is present.
5
The system can determine steady state spin and charge concentrations under continuous optical pumping, yielding expressions for sz and dn that depend on the ratio of spin diffusion length to magnetic gradient drift length.
Related papers
- Coexistence of polariton bound states in the continuum and 2D radiative excitons
- Hidden Quantum-Geometric Connection between Injection and Shift Currents
- Specific absorption rate of uniaxial single-domain nanomagnets: stochastic spin dynamics versus linear response theory
- The ideal limit of rhombohedral graphene: Dynamical skyrmion lattices and their excitations
- Valley polarization of chiral excitonic bound states induced by band geometry
- On-Device Control of Electronic Friction