Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics explores a viable emergent universe scenario supported by an extended Chaplygin gas fluid which explains present cosmic acceleration and deviates from standard models The model results in non-conventional late-time behavior where dark energy crosses the phantom divide in the past and exhibits thawing behavior in the future, asymptotically leading to a transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon The qualitative nature of variation of cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results Theoretical Framework The paper constructs a theoretical model of the emergent universe assuming it is dominated by an extended Chaplygin gas fluid at late times.
Kai: This fluid extends a modification to the equation of state of the well known modified Chaplygin gas by considering additional higher order barotropic fluid terms, specifically quadratic modifications.
Mira: The Extended Chaplygin Gas (ECG) EoS is proposed to recover a barotropic fluid having a quadratic or higher order EoS, which is basically a higher order generalization of the modified GCG at least upto the second order.
Kai: The general form of the EoS for ECG may be written as P = X∞ n=1 Anρ n − B1 ρ α (2).
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper introduces the observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics and uses an extended Chaplygin gas fluid as its dark energy candidate.
Mira: The authors propose that this fluid extends the modified Chaplygin gas by adding quadratic modifications to its equation of state, which is what they call the extended Chaplygin gas EoS.
Lev: They are specifically looking at the case where n equals two in that general form, giving them a quadratic barotropic equation of state P equals A one rho plus A two rho squared minus B one rho alpha squared.
Kai: After setting up the math, they constrain the parameters using data from the Observed Hubble Dataset and Pantheon Supernova Ia samples, finding best fits like B equal to zero point six hundred twenty-four and K equal to zero point three hundred sixty-six.
Mira: The main claim is that this model yields non-conventional late-time behavior where dark energy crosses the phantom divide in the past but then thaws in the future before becoming transient.
Lev: They also found that when they sample their model parameters using Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of the data, it actually resembles the results you see from DESI data.
Kai: That’s a big connection because it suggests that this specific way they vary cosmological parameters qualitatively matches what we see in other observational surveys like DESI.
Mira: It really matters because they are saying that this EU scenario sourced by the ECG is consistent with observations, and in some cases even better than the standard lambda-CDM model.
Lev: The limitation they mention is that the origin and dynamics of the extended Chaplygin gas aren't completely classical phenomena, so taking quantum effects into consideration might significantly modify its stability.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at this paper, the title "Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics" points to a model that uses an emergent universe concept.
Mira: The authors are using this extended Chaplygin gas fluid to explain the present cosmic acceleration and they’re showing how it has unique late-time dynamics.
Lev: The key implication is that dark energy isn't just a constant; it evolves, crossing the phantom divide and then thawing into something that eventually stops accelerating.
Kai: This means dark energy is transient in their model, which contrasts with the standard idea of a fixed cosmological constant.
Mira: The paper suggests this fluid could be a dark energy candidate because it replicates late time behavior very well and fits observational constraints from OHD and Pantheon data.
Lev: It's interesting that the model also resolves the initial singularity problem in a standard relativistic context for a flat universe, which is another big thing they point out.
Kai: So, what this paper really suggests is that we might be looking at something different than the standard lambda-CDM picture if we look closely at late time behavior.
Department of Physics, Aliah University, Kolkata · Department of Physics, University of North Bengal
gr-qc
Submitted: 2023-07-05
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION IN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MODERN PHYSICS A (IJMPA)
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 72/100
The gist: Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics explores a viable emergent universe scenario supported by an extended Chaplygin gas fluid which…
Key concepts
- Extended Chaplygin Gas (ECG)
- This is a modification of the standard Chaplygin gas fluid. It includes higher-order terms in its equation of state, allowing it to model more complex cosmic evolution than simpler dark energy models. This extension helps fit observational data better.
- Phantom Divide Crossing
- In cosmology, dark energy behavior is often categorized by its equation of state parameter ($w$). This paper finds that the ECG fluid's $w$ crosses the phantom divide in the recent past, meaning it behaved like phantom energy before transitioning to a different state. This non-standard crossing is a key feature of the model.
- Thawing Behavior
- The model predicts that dark energy exhibits 'thawing behavior' in the future. This means its equation of state parameter evolves over time, starting as a cosmological constant and then transitioning towards quintessence, leading to a weakening of acceleration and eventual deceleration.
Terminology
Summary
Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics explores a viable emergent universe scenario supported by an extended Chaplygin gas fluid which explains present cosmic acceleration and deviates from standard models The model results in non-conventional late-time behavior where dark energy crosses the phantom divide in the past and exhibits thawing behavior in the future, asymptotically leading to a transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon The qualitative nature of variation of cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results
Theoretical Framework
The paper constructs a theoretical model of the emergent universe assuming it is dominated by an extended Chaplygin gas fluid at late times. This fluid extends a modification to the equation of state of the well known modified Chaplygin gas by considering additional higher order barotropic fluid terms, specifically quadratic modifications. p. 0 in
Received: date / Accepted: date
Abstract In this paper, we attempt to explore the possibility of a obtaining a
viable emergent universe scenario supported by a type of fluid known as the extended Chaplygin gas, which extends a modification to the equation of state of
the well known modified Chaplygin gas by considering additional higher order
barotropic fluid terms. We consider quadratic modification only. 4
The Extended Chaplygin gas (ECG) EoS was proposed[59–65] to recover barotropic
fluid having a quadratic or higher order EoS, which is basically a higher order generalization of the modified GCG at least upto the second order. The Van der Waals
fluid is an alternative to the idea of a perfect fluid, that acts as the single source
term in describing the evolution of the universe in both the matter dominated
and present accelerating phases, identical to the Chaplygin gas family of fluids. It is also described a non-linear Equation of state[66] just like the Chaplygin gas
family. The EoS for ECG may be written in general as
P =
X∞
n=1
Anρ
n −
B1
ρ
α
(2)
Just like the other Chaplygin gas models, ECG is also used as a dark energy
candidate to explain the present cosmic acceleration[59–62].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Mathematical Derivations
The mathematical model involves setting n = 2 in Eq. (2), resulting in the EoS for Extended Chaplygin Gas (ECG) up to the second order, which physically represents the quadratic barotropic EoS given by P = A1ρ + A2ρ squared − B1 ρ α (3). p. 3 2 Mathematical model
Putting n = 2 in Eq. (2), the EoS for Extended Chaplygin Gas (ECG) shall be
upto the second order, which physically represents the quadratic barotropic EoS
given by
P = A1ρ + A2ρ
2 −
B1
ρ
α
, (3)
where ρ represents the energy density, pressure is denoted by P and A1, A2, B1
and α denote the ECG parameters. 5
realistic assumptions are made following the previous works[62, 70, 71]
α = 1
A1 = A2 − 1 (4)
B1 = 2A2. Conservation of energy-momentum tensor can be written as
ρ˙ + 3H(ρ + P) = 0, (5)
where H =
a˙
a
denotes the Hubble parameter and a is the scale factor. 5
realistic assumptions are made following the previous works[62, 70, 71]
α = 1
A1 = A2 − 1 (4)
B1 = 2A2. Conservation of energy-momentum tensor can be written as
ρ˙ + 3H(ρ + P) = 0, (5)
where H =
a˙
a
denotes the Hubble parameter and a is the scale factor. (3) into the conservation Eq. (5), we solve
for the energy density in terms of the scale factor a, which turns out to be
ρ = 1 + 2 + p
5a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 1
a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 1
. Upon further simplification, this may be expressed as a quadratic equation of
ρ having the form
(a
30A2 − e
− 3π
2 )ρ
2 − 2(a
30A2 + e
− 3π
2 )ρ + (a
30A2 − 2e
− 3π
2 ) = 0 (8)
On taking the positive root solution, we get
ρ = 1 + 2 + p
2a
30A2 e
3π
2 + 1 + 3a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 2
a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 1
(9)
which on simplification gives Equation (6). The first Friedmann equation is given as,
ρ = 3H
2 = 3
a˙
a
2
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Observational Constraints and Fitting
The model parameters are constrained using observational data from the Observed Hubble Dataset (OHD) and the Pantheon Supernova Ia sample. The best-fitted curve for the Pantheon dataset is shown with B = 0. p. 7 Flat priors are considered for B and K, and we
assumed a Gaussian prior for H0. The best-fitted curve is shown in Fig. (16) can be represented in the following functional
form:
H
2
(H0, B, K, z) = H
2
0E
2
(B, K, z), (21)
where
E
2
(B, K, z) = B
2
(1 + A)
2 +
2BK
(1 + A)
2
(1+z)
3
2
(1+A)+
K2
(1 + A)
2
(1+z)
3(1+A)
. (22)
The above equation will be used to fit the EU model with the observational data,
assuming A = 0 to obtain a viable cosmological scenario.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions and Implications
The late-time dynamics obtained from the ECG dominating the universe at late times is non-conventional and quite interesting. A significant finding is that dark energy crosses the phantom divide in the recent past and still has a phantom nature with the EoS parameter slightly more negative than the cosmological constant at present. p. 0 Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative
nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of
Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative
nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of
Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. This leads us to the realization
that such a fluid is not only a probable candidate for dark energy, but also sources
an emergent universe unlike modified Chaplygin gas and the initial singularity
problem can be resolved in a flat universe within the standard relativistic context. Keywords Emergent Universe · Observational Constraints · non-singular
cosmology · extended Chaplygin gas · late-time acceleration. This leads us to the realization
that such a fluid is not only a probable candidate for dark energy, but also sources
an emergent universe unlike modified Chaplygin gas and the initial singularity
problem can be resolved in a flat universe within the standard relativistic context. Keywords Emergent Universe · Observational Constraints · non-singular
cosmology · extended Chaplygin gas · late-time acceleration.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Discussion of Deviations
The late-time dynamics obtained for the EU from the constrained ECG dominating the universe at late times is non-conventional and quite interesting. There is a significant deviation from the standard Λ-CDM model as we can figure out from the plots of the constrained cosmological parameters in Figs. p. 6 First we obtain the deceleration parameter as
q(z) = H′
(z)
H(z)
(1 + z) − 1 (18)
The EoS parameter can be obtained from the deceleration parameter using the
relation
w(z) = 2q(z) − 1
3(1 − Ωm(z)), (19)
where Ωm(z) =
H0
H(z)
2
Ωm0(1 + z)
3
. The Om parameter is expressed as
Om(z) =
H(z)/H0
2
− 1
(1 + z)
3 − 1
(20)
Analyzing the variation of the above mentioned cosmological parameters using
the observationally constrained model parameters obtained in the following section
from the MCMC analysis, we can compare the late-time dynamics of our EU model
with the standard Λ-CDM model. Such a fluid is
capable of explaining the present cosmic acceleration and is a possible dark energy
candidate. We construct a theoretical model of the emergent universe assuming it
is dominated by such a fluid at late times. Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative
nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of
Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative
nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of
Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. Our model results in non-conventional
late-time behavior and deviates from the standard Λ-CDM model. Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison with Standard Model
The observed data suggests H0 = 73.24±1.74km/sec/M pc[77] and H(z = 2.34) = 222±7km/sec/M pc[78]. There is a discrepancy with the Λ-CDM estimated values of H0 = 67km/sec/M pc and H(z = 2. p. 6 As a
result we can obtain the constrained value of the ECG free parameter A2. Using
these contrained model parameter values in Eq. Dark energy
is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting
thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative
nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of
Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. (5), we solve
for the energy density in terms of the scale factor a, which turns out to be
ρ = 1 + 2 + p
5a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 1
a
30A2 e
3π
2 − 1
. (6)
Our analysis is valid for all epochs of cosmic evolution such that we consider the
early universe has considerably high energy densities (ρ >> 1) and then the density
gradually decreases before reaching an asymptotic value. The Om parameter is expressed as
Om(z) =
H(z)/H0
2
− 1
(1 + z)
3 − 1
(20)
Analyzing the variation of the above mentioned cosmological parameters using
the observationally constrained model parameters obtained in the following section
from the MCMC analysis, we can compare the late-time dynamics of our EU model
with the standard Λ-CDM model. 3 Observational Analysis
In this section, we have constrained the EU model parameters using the observational datasets, specifically the Observed Hubble Dataset (OHD) and the Pantheon
Supernova Ia sample. First we obtain the deceleration parameter as
q(z) = H′
(z)
H(z)
(1 + z) − 1 (18)
The EoS parameter can be obtained from the deceleration parameter using the
relation
w(z) = 2q(z) − 1
3(1 − Ωm(z)), (19)
where Ωm(z) =
H0
H(z)
2
Ωm0(1 + z)
3
. The Om parameter is expressed as
Om(z) =
H(z)/H0
2
− 1
(1 + z)
3 − 1
(20)
Analyzing the variation of the above mentioned cosmological parameters using
the observationally constrained model parameters obtained in the following section
from the MCMC analysis, we can compare the late-time dynamics of our EU model
with the standard Λ-CDM model.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgements
RS is thankful to Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), India for financial support through the SRF-Direct scheme. MK and BCP is thankful to the Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics (IUCAA),Pune, India for providing the Visiting Associateship under which a part of this work was carried out. p. 0 C manuscript No. p. 0 C manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor)
Observationally constrained emergent universe
scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics
Rikpratik Sengupta1,a, Anirban Chanda2,b
,
Bikash Chandra Paul2,c and Mehedi
Kalam1,d
1Department of Physics, Aliah University, Kolkata 700160, West Bengal, India
2 Department of Physics, University of North Bengal, Raja Rammohunpur, 734013, India
a E-mail: rikpratik.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
References
- S. W. Hawking and G. F. R. Ellis, Astrophys. p. 2J. 152 (1968) 25
Where the paper says it
[31] In the pure geometrical context, using conformal spacetime geometry, another cyclic cosmological model known as the Conformal cyclic cosmology has been proposed by Penrose[32]. The Emergent Universe (EU) scenario has been proposed by Ellis and Maartens[33] in 2004 and is a non-singular alternative to the Big bang resolving the initial singularity problem but it is different from the other scenarios in the context that there is no bounce or QG regime and also it is not a cyclic model.
2307-0260-v3 [gr-qc] 11 Aug 2025
-
R. Gambini and J. Pullin, A First Course in Loop Quantum Gravity (Oxford University Press, 2011)
-
C. Rovelli, Living Rev. Rel. 11 (2008) 5
--- Page 1 ---
Eur. Phys. J. C manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor)
--- Page 2 ---
Observationally constrained emergent universe scenario with non-conventional late-time dynamics
--- Page 3 ---
The second problem with the standard Big bang model is that it requires additional ingredients to explain the “dark sector” of the universe <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 4 ---
A type of fluid known as “Chaplygin gas”, with its origin in string theories had been used as a dark energy candidate to explain the late time acceleration of the universe <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 5 ---
The Extended Chaplygin gas (ECG) EoS was proposed to recover barotropic fluid having a quadratic or higher order EoS, which is basically a higher order generalization of the modified GCG at least upto the second order <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 6 ---
The Extended Chaplygin gas (ECG) EoS may be written in general as P = X∞ n=1 Anρ n − B1 ρ α (2) <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 7 ---
In the following section, we shall consider the mathematical details of the possible EU scenario sourced by the ECG <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 8 ---
For A = 0, the cosmic fluid that spans the EU consists of DE, dust, and exotic matter <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 9 ---
The joint χ2 function is defined as χ2 Joint = χ2 OHD +χ2 SNS <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 10 ---
Table 2: Best fit values of the model parameters <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 14 ---
The most important perspective is that the initial singularity problem can be resolved in a standard relativistic context for a flat universe and the obtained late time cosmology from the EU model is in good agreement with observational data, at per with or even better than the standard Λ − CDM model <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 15 ---
The late-time dynamics that we obtain for the EU from the constrained ECG dominating the universe at late times is non-conventional and quite interesting <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 16 ---
There is a significant deviation from the standard Λ-CDM model as we can figure out from the plots of the constrained cosmological parameters in Figs. 5-8 <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 17 ---
Fig. 4: Constraints on the model parameters from the joint analysis of OHD and Pantheon datasets <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 18 ---
Fig. 5: variation of deceleration parameter q(z) with redshift z times <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 19 ---
Fig. 6: variation of EoS parameter w(z) with redshift z <ref:2307-v3[gr-qc] 1>
--- Page 20 ---
Fig.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve cosmological model validation by incorporating Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of Pantheon+OHD data to constrain Extended Chaplygin Gas parameters A2, B, and K. This allows the AI system to determine physically constrained values for dark energy parameters that are consistent with modern observational constraints, such as finding
the constrained value of the ECG free parameter A2.
-
Enable non-conventional late-time dynamics analysis by allowing the AI to compare the late-time cosmology from its model with standard Lambda CDM model predictions. This enables the system to identify significant deviations, such as dark energy crossing the phantom divide and exhibiting a transition into a decelerating phase in the asymptotic future.
-
Develop predictive capabilities for cosmic evolution by enabling the AI to plot variations of cosmological parameters like deceleration parameter q(z), equation of state parameter w(z), and Om parameter Om(z) against redshift z. This allows the system to show
the late-time dynamics that we obtain for the EU from the constrained ECG dominating the universe at late times is non-conventional and quite interesting.
-
Enhance observational data fitting accuracy by allowing the AI to jointly constrain model parameters using a joint chi squared function of OHD and Pantheon data. This leads to obtaining
the best-fit values for the model parameters for a physically acceptable cosmological scenario
by minimizing the joint chi squared function. -
Establish parameter correspondence between theoretical models and observational constraints by enabling the AI to find a correspondence between
the EU parameter a0 and the independent ECG parameter A2.
This allows for estimating specific ECG parameters if it is considered as the constituent of an Emergent Universe.
Abstract
In this paper, we attempt to explore the possibility of a obtaining a viable emergent universe scenario supported by a type of fluid known as the extended Chaplygin gas, which extends a modification to the equation of state of the well known modified Chaplygin gas by considering additional higher order barotropic fluid terms. We consider quadratic modification only. Such a fluid is capable of explaining the present cosmic acceleration and is a possible dark energy candidate. We construct a theoretical model of the emergent universe assuming it is dominated by such a fluid at late times. Our model results in non-conventional late-time behavior and deviates from the standard Λ-CDM model. Dark energy is found to cross the phantom divide in the past and present besides exhibiting thawing behaviour in the future, asymptotically leading to transition into a decelerating phase making dark energy a transient phenomenon. The qualitative nature of variation of the cosmological parameters resulting from model parameters observationally constrained through Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of Pantheon+OHD data is interestingly found to resemble the DESI results. Also,the value of H(z) at a redshift z=2.34 and present value of Hubble parameter fits much better than Λ-CDM with recent observations. This leads us to the realization that such a fluid is not only a probable candidate for dark energy, but also sources an emergent universe unlike modified Chaplygin gas and the initial singularity problem can be resolved in a flat universe within the standard relativistic context.
Sources
- Matter in the Bulk and its Consequences on the Brane: A Possible Source of Dark Energy
- Emergent Universe in Starobinsky Model
- Emergent Universe Scenario in Modified Gauss-Bonnet Gravity
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals