Calculation of Dynamical Response Functions Using a Bound-state Method
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Calculation of Dynamical Response Functions Using a Bound-state Method".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate a method to extract response functions (dynamical polarisabilities) directly from a bound-state approach applied to calculations of perturbation-induced reactions This approach uses the Stochastic Variational Method to solve the inhomogeneous Schrödinger equation that gives the response of the wave function to an external field The method is powerful because it takes advantage of the randomness of the SVM, using integrated response instead of folding with a smearing function The core idea involves starting with a bound-state approach where any response calculated is naturally discrete, resulting in a sum of delta functions Instead of folding the response with a smearing function, the method uses the integrated response, which turns the sum of delta distributions into a step-wise continuous function of energy A smooth function is then fitted to this stepwise continuous function, and its derivative provides an approximation to the physical response function The paper shows that this approach reproduces analytical results where known, and analyzes details for various models Validation with Simple Models The method was tested using a simple model of two particles interacting via a Pöschl-Teller potential, where excellent agreement with analytic results was found For this model, the integrated response distribution is continuous and approximated by a smooth differentiable function that can be used to reconstruct the response function itself The results for the integrated response function track the analytical results remarkably well, even when compared to calculations using a hyperspherical harmonics approach Application to Physical Systems The method was applied to a more realistic two-body system, namely deuteron break-up using the Argonne V18 potential, where the agreement with experimental data is very good The results for the strength functions FJ closely track those from the Lorentz integral transform (LIT) and show small differences that are considered minor The calculation of the total photodisintegration cross section agrees well with experimental data extracted from EXFOR Challenges in Complex Systems When moving to a three-body system, the integrated response distribution shows scatter directly above the three-particle threshold, which is not immediately clear from channel coupling alone The lack of spectral density below zero energy is attributed to states that carry no or very little dipole response While the SVM method shows good description for the two-body break-up channel below threshold, a larger ensemble of calculations is required above this threshold due to the spread of different bases The paper concludes that the approach is effective for simple structureless two-body problems and provides an alternative to the LIT method, especially for systems of three or more particles The ultimate goal is to apply this method to photodisintegration of light nuclei including 3H, 3He and 4He Future work will focus on the treatment of resonant structure in the continuum Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge support from various funding bodies including the UK Science and Technology Funding Council and the US Department of Energy The work was also supported by an award from the Columbian College of Arts and Sciences Additional funds were provided by a High Intensity Gamma-Ray Source at TUNL and George Washington University The authors are indebted to G.
Kai: Orlandini and W.
Mira: Leidemann for discussions and encouragements.
Kai: References
1: W.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Calculation of Dynamical Response Functions Using a Bound-state Method". It basically proposes a way to get those response functions, which are the dynamical polarisabilities, directly from a bound-state approach when you're doing calculations for reactions induced by external fields.
Mira: That sounds like they're trying to bypass some of the usual methods for getting these things. I mean, what is the core idea here? What do they claim they can do that's different?
Lev: They start with a bound-state approach where you calculate any response, and that naturally gives you something discrete, which turns out as a sum of delta functions. Then they integrate this over energy and fit a smooth function to the resulting stepwise continuous one.
Kai: So they aren't folding the response with some kind of smearing function; they are using this integrated response instead. That turns that sum of delta distributions into a step-wise continuous function of energy, which you can then fit with a smooth function and take its derivative to get the final approximation for the physical response function.
Mira: So it sounds like the key is turning a discrete sum into something continuous, which makes fitting easier and gives you that derivative as your answer. But what kind of basis are they using for this? What are the assumptions underpinning this approach?
Lev: They use the Stochastic Variational Method to solve the inhomogeneous Schrödinger equation, and they mention that it takes advantage of the randomness inherent in the SVM when calculating these responses, which is a powerful feature.
Kai: That sounds like you’re trying to leverage some sort of stochastic sampling here instead of just relying on deterministic basis expansions. How does that translate into something practical for what we're trying to measure?
Mira: It means they are using the randomness of the SVM, which is good because it gives them a way to handle the response, but they're using this integrated response instead of folding with a smearing function. That’s an assumption about how that integration works that needs checking.
Paper summary: Lev: They show that this approach reproduces analytical results where those results are already known, and they also analyze the details for a variety of models. They test it on some simple models, like one using the Pöschl-Teller potential twenty-one <ref:2303.09361#pg3>.
Kai: A simple model is fine for checking consistency, but how does this method handle more complex physics? I mean, what about the real world calculations we need to do?
Mira: They apply it to a more realistic two-body system called deuteron break-up using the Argonne V18 potential. The agreement they get with experimental data is quite good there.
Lev: For that deuteron case, they say that the strength functions FJ track those from the Lorentz integral transform very closely, with only small differences in areas where the response is small. The calculation for the total photodisintegration cross section also agrees well with experimental data extracted from EXFOR.
Kai: So you're saying it works reasonably well for a realistic two-body system when compared to established methods like the LIT, which is interesting because that’s what people usually use now.
Mira: It seems the method reproduces analytical results where known and analyzes details for various models, which is important groundwork. But they also hit some snags when they move to three-body systems.
Lev: When they try a three-body system, the integrated response distribution shows scatter directly above the three-particle threshold, and that's not immediately clear just from channel coupling alone. Also, there's a lack of spectral density below zero energy because those states carry no or very little dipole response.
Kai: So they found this approach is good for simple structureless two-body problems, but when you go to three bodies, the results get scatter right above the threshold, and they need a much larger ensemble of calculations above that threshold because of how the different bases spread out.
Mira: The conclusion of this paper is that while it's effective for simple two-body problems and provides an alternative to the LIT method especially for systems with three or more particles, they are pointing toward applying this to photodisintegration of light nuclei like three hydrogen, three helium, and four helium.
Paper summary: Lev: The main thing here is that they offer a different path—an alternative—to the Lorentz integral transform method when you're dealing with systems involving several particles. It’s not just about getting one number; it’s about how you structure the whole calculation to manage those continuum effects in a new way.
Kai: So, it sounds like this paper is offering a different mathematical handle for calculating response functions that avoids some of the folding issues we see elsewhere, especially as we move toward heavier light nuclei where three or more particles are involved.
Mira: Exactly. The title "Calculation of Dynamical Response Functions Using a Bound-state Method" suggests they're building something from the ground up using these bound states, rather than just applying an existing transform to a known calculation.
Lev: What this means for us is that if we want to push these calculations into three-body territory, we might need to adopt this method because it seems better suited for handling those continuum features in a way that doesn't immediately break down like they did above zero energy.
Kai: So the implication is that the structure of the response itself, when viewed through this integrated response lens, gives you a smoother path than relying on discrete basis expansions or standard transforms. It’s about using the nature of the bound state sum to your advantage.
Mira: It's definitely about using that sum of delta functions and turning it into something continuous before fitting it, which is a clever mathematical trick to approximate the physical response function.
Lev: And while they show good agreement for simple models and even realistic two-body ones like the deuteron break-up, the paper flags that when you go to three bodies, you still have these difficulties with threshold scattering. That's the caveat we need to keep in mind.
Kai: So it’s a method that’s very promising for structureless systems and providing a new toolset for tackling more complex few-body problems like photodisintegration of light nuclei, provided you can manage the complexity above zero energy.
Mira: That's the gist of it. The paper gives us an alternative way to calculate these polarizabilities that seems robust enough for initial testing but clearly needs more work when dealing with the full complexity of three-body continuum physics.
Conclusion: Kai: So this paper, "Calculation of Dynamical Response Functions Using a Bound-state Method," it’s all about finding how to get those response functions, which are basically dynamical polarisabilities, directly from a bound state approach when you calculate reactions from an external field.
Mira: Yeah, that’s what they do. They use this bound state starting point to figure out the response of the wave function to an external field. It’s about bypassing some of the usual ways we think about these calculations.
Lev: From my side, it seems like they take a discrete sum from a bound state and turn it into something continuous, which is then fitted by taking its derivative to get the physical response function. It’s a clever way to approximate what we actually measure.
Kai: So they use this stochastic variational method for solving the equation, and they leverage that randomness because it helps them with the integrated response instead of folding with some smearing function. That’s a big technical step for handling the physics in this way.
Mira: And they show that this integrated response distribution smooths out into a continuous function, which lets them fit a smooth function and then take its derivative as an approximation to the physical response function. It turns a sum of delta functions into something usable.
Lev: The validation is pretty solid for simple models, like that two particle system with the Pöschl-Teller potential. They get excellent agreement with what we already know from analytic results there, even when you compare it to some other methods like hyperspherical harmonics.
Kai: But they also apply it to something more realistic, the deuteron break-up using the Argonne V18 potential. The agreement with experimental data for those strength functions is very good, and the total photodisintegration cross section matches what’s seen in EXFOR.
Mira: That’s good for two particles, but they run into trouble when you move to three particle systems. They see scatter directly above the three particle threshold that isn't explained just by channel coupling alone.
Lev: Exactly. And there’s a lack of spectral density below zero energy because those states don't carry much dipole response at all. So it seems like the method is great for simple two body problems, but it needs more calculation to handle the complexity above that threshold.
Kai: So, in conclusion, this approach offers an alternative to methods like the Lorentz integral transform when you’re dealing with systems of three or more particles. It provides a new way to structure those calculations that handles continuum effects differently.
Mira: The authors are aiming for applications on light nuclei like three hydrogen, three helium, and four helium photodisintegration in the future. That’s where the real test will be for this method.
Lev: For now, it looks like a strong tool for structureless two particle problems, but we definitely need to see how they handle that continuum above zero energy in those bigger systems.
Niels R. Walet, Jagjit Singh, Johannes Kirscher, Michael C. Birse, Harald W. Grießhammer, Judith A. McGovern
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester · Center for Nuclear Studies, Department of Physics, The George Washington University · Department of Physics, SRM University-AP
nucl-th
Submitted: 2023-03-16
Updated: 2023-03-16
Journal ref: Few-Body Syst 64, 56 (2023)
DOI: 10.1007/s00601-023-01824-x
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: We investigate a method to extract response functions (dynamical polarisabilities) directly from a bound-state approach applied to calculations of perturbation-induced reactions This approach uses…
Key concepts
- Stochastic Variational Method (SVM)
- A computational technique used here that leverages randomness in the calculation. It helps solve complex quantum problems by sampling different states stochastically, which is powerful for obtaining integrated responses.
- Integrated Response
- Instead of folding the response with a smearing function, this method uses the integrated response. This turns a discrete sum of delta functions into a continuous, step-wise function of energy.
- Response Function (Dynamical Polarisability)
- These are quantities that describe how a quantum system responds to an external field. The paper aims to calculate these dynamical polarisabilities directly from bound-state calculations.
- Lorentz Integral Transform (LIT)
- The paper presents an alternative approach to the LIT method, particularly useful for systems of three or more particles, offering a different way to analyze reaction cross sections.
Terminology
Summary
We investigate a method to extract response functions (dynamical polarisabilities) directly from a bound-state approach applied to calculations of perturbation-induced reactions This approach uses the Stochastic Variational Method to solve the inhomogeneous Schrödinger equation that gives the response of the wave function to an external field The method is powerful because it takes advantage of the randomness of the SVM, using integrated response instead of folding with a smearing function
Methodology for Response Extraction
The core idea involves starting with a bound-state approach where any response calculated is naturally discrete, resulting in a sum of delta functions Instead of folding the response with a smearing function, the method uses the integrated response, which turns the sum of delta distributions into a step-wise continuous function of energy A smooth function is then fitted to this stepwise continuous function, and its derivative provides an approximation to the physical response function The paper shows that this approach reproduces analytical results where known, and analyzes details for various models
Validation with Simple Models
The method was tested using a simple model of two particles interacting via a Pöschl-Teller potential, where excellent agreement with analytic results was found For this model, the integrated response distribution is continuous and approximated by a smooth differentiable function that can be used to reconstruct the response function itself The results for the integrated response function track the analytical results remarkably well, even when compared to calculations using a hyperspherical harmonics approach
Application to Physical Systems
The method was applied to a more realistic two-body system, namely deuteron break-up using the Argonne V18 potential, where the agreement with experimental data is very good The results for the strength functions FJ closely track those from the Lorentz integral transform (LIT) and show small differences that are considered minor The calculation of the total photodisintegration cross section agrees well with experimental data extracted from EXFOR
Challenges in Complex Systems
When moving to a three-body system, the integrated response distribution shows scatter directly above the three-particle threshold, which is not immediately clear from channel coupling alone The lack of spectral density below zero energy is attributed to states that carry no or very little dipole response While the SVM method shows good description for the two-body break-up channel below threshold, a larger ensemble of calculations is required above this threshold due to the spread of different bases
Conclusion and Outlook
The paper concludes that the approach is effective for simple structureless two-body problems and provides an alternative to the LIT method, especially for systems of three or more particles The ultimate goal is to apply this method to photodisintegration of light nuclei including 3H, 3He and 4He Future work will focus on the treatment of resonant structure in the continuum
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge support from various funding bodies including the UK Science and Technology Funding Council and the US Department of Energy The work was also supported by an award from the Columbian College of Arts and Sciences Additional funds were provided by a High Intensity Gamma-Ray Source at TUNL and George Washington University The authors are indebted to G. Orlandini and W. Leidemann for discussions and encouragements.
References
[1] W. Horiuchi, Y. Suzuki, and D. Baye, Strength Function in Continuum with a Square Integrable Basis, Few-Body Systems 50, 455 (2011)
[2] V. D. Efros, Method to solve integral equations of the first kind with an approximate input, Physical Review E 86, 016704 (2012), publisher: American Physical Society
[3] L. E. Marcucci, J. Dohet-Eraly, L. Girlanda, A. Gnech, A. Kievsky, and M. Viviani, The Hyperspherical Harmonics Method: A Tool for Testing and Improving Nuclear Interaction Models, Frontiers in Physics 8 (2020)
[4] C. Drischler, M. Quinonez, P. G. Giuliani, A. E. Lovell, and F. M. Nunes, Toward emulating nuclear reactions using eigenvector continuation, Physics Letters B 823, 136777 (2021)
[5] X. Zhang and R. J. Furnstahl, Fast emulation of quantum three-body scattering, Physical Review C 105, 064004 (2022), publisher: American Physical Society
[6] J. D. Walecka, Theoretical Nuclear And Subnuclear Physics, second edition ed. p. 0 (World Scientific Publishing Co Pte Ltd, London, 2004)
[7] W. Leidemann, The lorentz integral transform (lit) method, International Journal of Modern Physics E 18, 1339 (2009), publisher: World Scientific Publishing Co. p. 0
[8] W. Leidemann and G. Orlandini, Modern ab initio approaches and applications in few-nucleon physics with A ≥ 4, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 68, 158 (2013)
[9] W. Leidemann, V. D. Efros, and V. Y. Shalamova, The inversion of the Lorentz integral transform with controlled resolution, SciPost Physics Proceedings, 037 (2020)
[10] M. A. Marchisio, N. Barnea, W. Leidemann, and G. Orlandini, Efficient Method for Lorentz Integral Transforms of Reaction Cross Sections, Few-Body Systems 33, 259 (2003)
[11] V. D. Efros, W. Leidemann, G. Orlandini, and E. L. Tomusiak, Longitudinal electron scattering response functions of 3H and 3He, Physical Review C 69, 044001 (2004), publisher: American Physical Society
[12] V. D. Efros, W. Leidemann, G. Orlandini, and N. Barnea, The Lorentz integral transform (LIT) method and its applications to perturbation-induced reactions, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 34, R459 (2007), publisher: IOP Publishing
[13] V. D. Efros, W. Leidemann, and V. Y. Shalamova, On Calculating Response Functions Via Their Lorentz Integral Transforms, Few-Body Systems 60, 35 (2019)
[14] G. Bampa, W. Leidemann, and H. Arenhövel, Photon scattering with the Lorentz integral transform method, Physical Review C 84, 034005 (2011), publisher: American Physical Society
[15] S. Bacca, H. Arenhövel, N. Barnea, W. Leidemann, and G. Orlandini, Ab initio calculation of 7Li photodisintegration, Physics Letters B 603, 159 (2004)
[16] S. Bacca, N. Barnea, W. Leidemann, and G. Orlandini, Role of the Final-State Interaction and Three-Body Force on the Longitudinal Response Function of 4He, Physical Review Letters 102, 162501 (2009)
[17] S. Bacca and S. Pastore, Electromagnetic reactions on light nuclei, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 41, 123002 (2014)
[18] J. E. Sobczyk and A. Roggero, Spectral density reconstruction with Chebyshev polynomials, Physical Review E 105, 055310 (2022), publisher: American Physical Society
[19] Y. Suzuki and K. Varga, Stochastic Variational Approach to Quantum-Mechanical Few-Body Problems (Springer Science & Business Media, 1998) google-Books-ID: BpyTpm1VLx8C
[20] J. Mitroy, S. Bubin, W. Horiuchi, Y. Suzuki, L. Adamowicz, W. Cencek, K. Szalewicz, J. Komasa, D. Blume, and K. Varga, Theory and application of explicitly correlated Gaussians (Reviews of Modern Physics 85)
[21] G. Pöschl and E. Teller, Bemerkungen zur Quantenmechanik des anharmonischen Oszillators, Zeitschrift f¨ur Physik 83, 143 (1933)
[22] S. Flügge, Practical Quantum Mechanics, 1999th ed. p. 1 (Springer, Berlin; New York, 1998)
[23] J. Lekner, Reflectionless eigenstates of the sech squared potential, American Journal of Physics 75, 1151 (2007), publisher: American Association of Physics Teachers
[24] Actually, integrating on both sides of the negative imaginary axis until z = −i as well
[25] R. B. Wiringa, V. G. J. Stoks, and R. Schiavilla, Accurate nucleon-nucleon potential with charge-independence breaking, Physical Review C 51, 38 (1995)
[26] N. Otuka, E. Dupont, V. Semkova, B. Pritychenko, A. Blokhin, M. Aikawa, S. Babykina, M. Bossant, G. Chen, S. Dunaeva, R. Forrest, T. Fukahori, N. Furutachi, S. Ganesan', Z., Ge., O., Gritzay., M., Herman,, Slavaˇc,, Kát¯o,, B Lalremruata,, Y Lee,, A Makinaga,, K Matsumoto,, M Mikhaylyukova, G Pikulina, V Pronyaev, A Saxena, O Schwerer, S Simakov, N Soppera, R Suzuki, S Tak´acs', X Tao', S Taova', F T´ark´anyi', V Varlamov. Towards a more complete and accurate experimental nuclear reaction data library (exfor): International collaboration between nuclear reaction data centres (nrdc), Nuclear Data Sheets 120, 272 (2014)
[27] J. L. Ballot and M. Fabre de la Ripelle, Application of the hyperspherical formalism to the trinucleon bound state problems, Annals of Physics 127, 62 (1980)
[28] J.-M. Normand, A Lie group: rotations in quantum mechanics (North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam [etc. p. 3 p. 3], 1980) oCLC: 1014534474
[29] J.-M. Normand, A Lie group: rotations in quantum mechanics (North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam [etc.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Precision response function extraction from bound-state calculations: The improved AI system can reliably extract physical response functions by taking an ensemble of integrated response functions from stochastic variational method calculations and fitting a smooth function to that ensemble, then differentiating it to obtain the final approximation to the physical response function, as described in Section VII.
-
Robust handling of threshold behavior in coupled-channel problems: The system will be capable of extracting robust results even for cases with multiple thresholds in coupled-channel problems by leveraging the stochastic nature of the SVM, overcoming difficulties encountered by methods like LIT which struggle with these features.
-
Accurate modeling of three-body continuum dynamics: The AI can accurately describe the response in a three-particle continuum, including systems with multiple thresholds, by comparing calculations from different basis sets like hyperspherical harmonics and stochastic variational method results to ensure reliable description of the strength distribution above thresholds.
-
Direct comparison with experimental data for few-body reactions: The system can perform direct comparisons between calculated cross sections and experimental data, such as those from EXFOR, showing excellent agreement with the LIT results when using appropriate approximations for the response functions.
-
High-fidelity calculation of coupled-channel dynamics: The AI can tackle complex coupled-channel problems involving two-body bound states and three-body continua by systematically increasing complexity in potential models and basis sets, providing a better description of the excitation spectrum compared to simpler methods like hyperspherical harmonics for cluster structures.
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations