Relativistic Elasticity II
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Relativistic Elasticity II".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This paper introduces relativistic elasticity as a diffeomorphism invariant field theory on spacetime, providing a formal structure for studying deformable solids in a gravitational context.
Kai: The work is significant because it shifts the perspective from the material picture to an Eulerian viewpoint, emphasizing spacetime diffeomorphisms and leading to new variational identities specific to elasticity.
Mira: Formal Structure of Lagrangian Theory The paper begins by introducing the Lagrangian theory of maps from spacetime into another manifold, establishing the fundamental requirement for diffeomorphism invariance in the Lagrange function L.
Kai: The expansion of this invariance leads to relations between derivatives and the metric, specifically showing that under certain conditions, L depends only on f and its derivatives.
Paper summary: Kai: To recap, Relativistic Elasticity II lays out the foundation by treating elasticity as a field theory on spacetime rather than just a material problem, emphasizing diffeomorphism invariance throughout.
Mira: They establish that this invariance is the guiding principle, which completely bypasses the usual issue of material frame indifference in standard treatments of nonrelativistic elasticity.
Lev: The main thrust here is building this geometric structure, showing how the theory works on a general spacetime background before diving into specific solutions or results.
Kai: They introduce the Lagrangian theory of maps from spacetime into another manifold, which is the starting point for establishing that diffeomorphism invariance in the Lagrange function L.
Mira: That invariance then leads to relations between derivatives and the metric, showing that under certain conditions, L only depends on the field and its derivatives.
Lev: That dependency structure then gives rise to a canonical stress energy tensor defined as T mu nu equals partial u mu partial f A times partial L over d nu f A minus L times delta mu nu; it’s the link to gravity.
Kai: Then they move into defining configurations, requiring the map derivative, which has maximal rank everywhere and makes the field surjective with level sets being timelike curves.
Mira: They also introduce uncontorted configurations, which are defined by that condition where u mu partial mu h A B is zero, meaning those particle world lines have no shear and no expansion.
Lev: That lack of shear and expansion is important because it implies that the stuff HAB can be seen as a simple pull-back of a Riemannian metric G on the manifold B.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at Relativistic Elasticity II, it’s clear they are establishing the formal groundwork for studying deformable solids within general relativity using this spacetime field theory approach.
Mira: The authors are making a significant move by emphasizing the Eulerian viewpoint and diffeomorphism invariance as the main structuring principle for their work.
Lev: What this means practically is that you can study bodies in curved spacetime without having to constantly worry about how your material frame is being dragged around, because the theory handles that automatically.
Kai: The paper sets up these new variational identities, which are what allow them to derive the field equations and boundary conditions for these systems.
Mira: Ultimately, this work points toward a way of formulating relativistic elasticity that is inherently consistent with the geometry of spacetime itself.
Lev: It’s about getting the theory closed when you couple it to gravity, leading to existence theorems for small gravitational fields, which is where things get interesting for real physics.
University of Vienna
gr-qc
Submitted: 2023-03-10
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 28 pages, In Special Issue of Class. Quantum Gravity on 'Focus on the Mathematics of Gravitation in the Non-Vacuum Regime', small typos corrected
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: This paper introduces relativistic elasticity as a diffeomorphism invariant field theory on spacetime, providing a formal structure for studying deformable solids in a gravitational context.
Key concepts
- Diffeomorphism Invariance
- This principle ensures that the physical laws describing the deformable solid remain unchanged when coordinates in spacetime are arbitrarily transformed. It is a fundamental requirement for formulating a field theory on curved spacetime, ensuring that measurements are independent of how we label points in space and time.
- Untortured Configurations
- These are specific physical states where the world lines of particles within the material have no shear or expansion. Mathematically, this means the quantity $u^ u abla_ u HAB$ is zero, which simplifies the description of strain and relates it to a Riemannian metric on a target manifold.
- Stress-Energy Tensor ($T^{ ho u}$)
- This tensor describes the distribution of energy and momentum within the elastic material. In this theory, it is derived from the Lagrangian and directly related to Einstein's field equations, linking the material properties of the solid to its gravitational influence in spacetime.
Terminology
Summary
This paper introduces relativistic elasticity as a diffeomorphism invariant field theory on spacetime, providing a formal structure for studying deformable solids in a gravitational context. p. 0 Despite its introductory purpose, the
present work has new material, in particular related to the formal structure of the theory. Keywords: Relativistic Elasticity
1 Introduction
Elasticity theory is the branch of continuum mechanics dealing with deformable
solids, which are ideal in the sense that dissipative processes can be ignored. Furthermore the standard literature sees the theory primarily as a branch of mechanics,
which results in a preference of the material picture. In contrast we view elasticity as a field theory on spacetime, which makes the
spacetime (’Eulerian’) - as opposed to the material - viewpoint, where diffeomorphism invariance is manifest, the method of choice.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Formal Structure of Lagrangian Theory
The paper begins by introducing the Lagrangian theory of maps from spacetime into another manifold, establishing the fundamental requirement for diffeomorphism invariance in the Lagrange function L. The expansion of this invariance leads to relations between derivatives and the metric, specifically showing that under certain conditions, L depends only on f and its derivatives. p. 8 Affine transformations leaving M = (R
4
, e, τ ) invariant form the 10 dimensional Galilei group. Associated with a configuration f : M → B is the 4-velocity v
µ∂µ, uniquely given
by v
µ∂µf
A = 0 and v
µ
τµ = 1, so
v
µ
∂µ = ∂t + V
i
∂i = ∂t − φ
i
A ∂if
A
, where φ
i
A ∂jf
A = δ
i
j (28)
and
(∂µf
A
)dxµ = (∂if
A
)(dxi − V
i
dt) (29)
The field ψ
µ
A is now defined by
ψ
µ
A(∂νf
A
) = δ
µ
ν − v
µ
τν (30)
which gives
ψ
µ
A∂µ = φ
i
A∂i (31)
Note: both ψ
µ
A and KAB = (∂µf
A)(∂ν f
B)e
µν depend only on spatial derivatives
of f. Theorem:
(F1) the canonical stress-energy tensor Tµ
ν = (∂µf
A)
∂L
∂ν fA −L δµ
ν
satisfies gνρTµ
ρ =
Tµν , where Tµν = 2 ∂L
∂gµν − Lgµν , that is the r. side of the Einstein equations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Kinematics of Configurations
The paper defines a configuration as a field f: (M, g) → B where ∂µfA has everywhere maximal rank and f is surjective with level sets timelike curves in M. It then introduces concepts like uncontorted configurations, which are those where the particle world lines are shear- and expansionfree, defined by the condition uµ∂µHAB = 0. p. 6 To explain the relation with
more standard terminology recall the decomposition
hµ
µ
′
hν
ν
′
∇(µ′uν
′) = σµν +
1
3
hµνΘ (17)
into shear σµν and divergence Θ = ∇µu
µ
. So a configuration is uncontorted iff
its particle world lines are shear- and expansionfree. So
uncontortedness is equivalent to
u
µ
∂µHAB = 0 or u
µ
∂µH
AB = 0 , (19)
which in turn means that there exists a Riemannian metric GAB(X) on B so that
HAB(x) = GAB(f(x)), i. hµν is the pull-back of G under f.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Variational Identities and Field Equations
A central result is the variational identity (40), which states that δρ − ∇µ(ρ ψµAδf A) = Tµν∇µ(ψνAδf A). This identity implies that the Euler-Lagrange equations are given by ψµA∇νTµν = 0, which is equivalent to ∇νTµν = 0. p. 3 This identity is a special case of the Belinfante-Rosenfeld theorem (see [14] and
references therein. )
(F2) The Euler-Lagrange equations for the action S =
R
M
L
√
−g d4x imply
∇νTµ
ν = 0 and the latter 4 equations are in general not independent. For
example, when m = 3, the Lagrangian is then of the form
L = (H
A
A, HA
BH
B
A, det(H
A
B)) (8)
Then the theory is also invariant under diffeomorphisms of N. Furthermore the
exact Euler-Lagrange expression is
− EA = Mµν
AB∇µ∂ν f
B
(9)
where
∇µ∂νf
A = ∂µ∂ν f
A − Γ
ρ
µν ∂ρf
A + ΓA
BC(∂µf
B
)(∂ν f
C
), (10)
where ΓA
BC are the Christoffel symbols of GAB.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Relativistic Elasticity in the Limit
The paper discusses the nonrelativistic limit, where the stored energy function is expanded as ǫ = m0c squared + W(f, HAB) + O(1/c 2). In this limit, a renormalized Lagrangian breaks Galilean invariance but preserves the equations of motion which have a spacetime form. p. 8 4 Galilean configurations
A Galilean spacetime is affine R
4 with the degenerate contravariant metric e
µν ∂µ∂ν =
δ
ij∂i∂j and covector τµdxµ = dt annihilated by e
µν. Affine transformations leaving M = (R
4
, e, τ ) invariant form the 10 dimensional Galilei group. 5 we describe a formulation in this spirit, due to Tahvildar-Zadeh [10], of
elasticity in the so-called isotropic case. The next two sections concern the subjects of the nonrelativistic limit and linearization at a stressfree state.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Coupling to Gravity and Boundary Conditions
The theory is extended to include coupling with gravity, where the coupled system becomes closed, leading to existence theorems for small gravitational fields. The boundary conditions at the matter-vacuum interface are derived from natural boundary conditions, requiring Tµνmνf−1(∂B) be zero. p. 1 Moreover: for whatever field
is present in the vacuum region surrounding the body, the material picture is a
priori not even defined. On the other hand the natural (in a sense described later)
boundary conditions at the matter-vacuum interface render this a free boundary,
and this, for the actual solution of problems, makes an intermediate use of the
material picture - in which this boundary is fixed - indispensable. ate for freely floating bodies. Our treatment is based on the variational identity
(95), which is in turn based on (5).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Time Independent Problems
For time independent configurations, the reduced action is derived from the quotient space Q and involves a potential V, breaking diffeomorphism invariance but leading to evolution equations like Dj (V tij) + ρ DiV = 0. The linearized operator for small rotations has a kernel consisting of Euclidean Killing vectors, and existence theorems are established under appropriate constitutive conditions.
Elasticity la la Tahvildar-Zadeh
The paper describes an alternative formulation of elasticity in the isotropic case, replacing the 12 partial derivatives with 9 independent quantities like 4-velocity uµ and a symmetric tensor γµν describing strain. This system is closed and leads to a total of 6 independent first-order equations for the material manifold. p. 1 But
fluids in the Eulerian picture are usually described by the 4-velocity, energy density and pressure, all viewed as fields on M, which obey a 1st order system of
partial differential equations (PDE’s). There is no material manifold and no configurations.Where the paper says it
Nonrelativistic Limit
In the nonrelativistic limit, the particle number density k is defined as det(∂ifA) when using a volume form of constant curvature. The stress-energy tensor Tµν is then given by Tµν = kvµvν + 2k∂W/∂HAB (∂ρfA)(∂σfB)eµρeνσ. p. 3 The identity (2) has further important implications. Theorem:
(F1) the canonical stress-energy tensor Tµ
ν = (∂µf
A)
∂L
∂ν fA −L δµ
ν
satisfies gνρTµ
ρ =
Tµν , where Tµν = 2 ∂L
∂gµν − Lgµν , that is the r. The paper [4] had been remarkably silent about
what should be considered the basic dynamical variables of the theory. Then,
in the work of Kijowski and Magli [6], came the realization that the relativistic
version of the classical theory of hyperelastic materials is fundamentally a theory - derivable from an action principle - of maps subject to some conditions,
which are sometimes called back-to-label maps and called here configurations,
1Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Elastic Causality, Wellposedness
The paper establishes conditions for local wellposedness by showing that the operator MµνAB ∂µ∂ν fB + l.o. is regularly hyperbolic with respect to a subcharacteristic covector and a timelike vector. p. 5 Timelike fibers means we are dealing with massive particles. Given a configuration f
A, there is then - subject to time orientation - a unique
vector field u
µ
, s. Inserting this back into (2) yields that actually L =
L(f
A, HBC), which ends the proof. Note that (4) also means that Tµν has no mixed vertical-horizontal components.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Bodies Surrounded by Vacuum
When the body B is compact, the action is integrated over f−1(B), leading to a theorem that provides boundary conditions for freely floating bodies, namely ψµATµνmνf−1(∂B) = 0. This condition corresponds to the matter-vacuum interface where the stress-energy tensor drops sharply. p. 1 Moreover: for whatever field
is present in the vacuum region surrounding the body, the material picture is a
priori not even defined. On the other hand the natural (in a sense described later)
boundary conditions at the matter-vacuum interface render this a free boundary,
and this, for the actual solution of problems, makes an intermediate use of the
material picture - in which this boundary is fixed - indispensable.Where the paper says it
Material Picture
The final section rewrites the equations in terms of ADM variables and introduces a material Lagrangian Lmat, whose Euler-Lagrange equations yield boundary conditions ∂ǫ/∂(∂AΦi)nB = 0. Local wellposedness is guaranteed if the initial configuration satisfies the material version of the previous hyperbolicity condition. p. 1 The next two sections concern the subjects of the nonrelativistic limit and linearization at a stressfree state. 8
there is a quick account of causality and local wellposedness, which largely draws
on [11].Where the paper says it
For time independent problems, a reduced action is considered where diffeomorphism invariance is broken, and one finds evolution equations like Dj (V tij) + ρ DiV = 0. The linearized operator has a kernel consisting of at least the 6 elements of the form δfA = ξi∂if˚A. p. 5 3 Geometry of configurations
We now specialize to the case N = B called material manifold or body, a domain
in R
3 with smooth boundary or all of R
3
, thought of as the collection of elements
making up the material. Note: no further structure is imposed on B to start
with. The paper [4] had been remarkably silent about
what should be considered the basic dynamical variables of the theory. Then,
in the work of Kijowski and Magli [6], came the realization that the relativistic
version of the classical theory of hyperelastic materials is fundamentally a theory - derivable from an action principle - of maps subject to some conditions,
which are sometimes called back-to-label maps and called here configurations,
1Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Coupling to Gravity
In the time independent case coupled to gravity, the total self-force and total self-torque on the body due to gravity should be zero. This is true due to U(x) = -G Z f−1(B)n(x′)x − x′d3x'. Existence theorems are obtained for small G and configurations close to stressfree states. p. 6 In the case of configurations there is available a slightly weaker concept, which,
for reasons explained below, we call uncontorted configurations and which is the
analogue of Riemannian submersions in the case gµν is Riemannian. Uncontorted
configurations are as close as configurations can get to being isometries.Where the paper says it
Dynamics
The evolution problem for interacting elastic bodies is discussed, highlighting issues with corner conditions and transmission conditions which imply regularity constraints on the gravitational initial data. The compatibility of these with GR initial value constraints remains an open issue. p. 1 This gives rise to a considerable departure from practically all the standard treatments of nonrelativistic elasticity. So, for example, by
working with a diffeomorphism invariant theory on a general spacetime, the issue
of ’material frame indifference’ (see [1] and [2]) is completely bypassed.Where the paper says it
Acknowledgement
The author expresses indebtedness to long-term collaborator Bernd G. Schmidt for initiating the interest in this field. p. 0 Schmidt
Abstract
This paper is based on a series of talks given at the ESI program on
’Mathematical Perspectives of Gravitation Beyond the Vacuum Regime’ in
February 2022. It is meant to be an introduction to the field of relativistic elasticity for readers with a good base in the mathematics of General
Relativity with no necessary previous of knowledge of elasticity either in
the classical or relativistic domain.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can model deformable solids in general relativity by treating elasticity as a field theory on spacetime, allowing it to bypass
material frame indifference
by using diffeomorphism invariance as a primary principle. -
Improved AI system can solve problems involving configurations, which are defined as
surjective submersions with timelike fibers,
enabling the simulation of massive particle behavior in curved spacetime. -
Improved AI system can handle the transition between Eulerian and Lagrangian perspectives, allowing it to describe fluids using 4-velocity and energy density fields on a manifold without requiring a material manifold or configurations.
-
Improved AI system can implement formulations for isotropic elasticity by replacing the
3 times 4 = 12 partial derivatives of configurations
withthe 3+6=9 independent quantities given by 4-velocity u mu and a symmetric tensor gamma mu nu describing 'strain'.
-
Improved AI system can perform linearization at a stressfree state to derive quasilinear systems of PDEs for the configuration, using constitutive assumptions like
q delta AB delta CD + 2r delta C(A delta B)D
to define the elastic Lagrangian Lijkl. -
Improved AI system can analyze causality and local wellposedness by identifying the operator as
regularly hyperbolic w.r. to (xi mu, X nu)
and checking conditions likeM mu nu AB xi mu xi mu is negative definite.
-
Improved AI system can solve boundary value problems in the material picture by using the condition that
the normal stress on an a priori unknown timelike hypersurface in spacetime
vanishes at the matter-vacuum interface. -
Improved AI system can handle time independent problems by using ADM variables or their equivalent, such as
V i = gij Yj
and analyzing the resulting reduced action whereS[f; h ij, V] = Z f-1(B) rho V sqrt h d3x.
Abstract
This paper is based on a series of talks given at the ESI program on 'Mathematical Perspectives of Gravitation Beyond the Vacuum Regime' in February 2022. It is meant to be an introduction to the field of relativistic elasticity for readers with a good base in the mathematics of General Relativity with no necessary previous of knowledge of elasticity either in the classical or relativistic domain. Despite its introductory purpose, the present work has new material, in particular related to the formal structure of the theory.
Sources
- Relativistic elastodynamics
- Static elastic shells in Einsteinian and Newtonian gravity
- Dynamical compact elastic bodies in general relativity
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals