Introduction to the ADM formalism

arXiv:2210.10103 · gr-qc · Submitted 2022-10-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Introduction to the ADM formalism".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner.

Kai: The formulation of the theory of general relativity established by Einstein is centred around the concept of Principle of Equivalence which states: “The laws of physics are independent of the state of motion of the observer” This principle implies that these laws must be described covariantly i.e.

Mira: independent of the coordinate system Thus, it becomes clear that the covariant formulation is natural, and it allows expressing the interaction of matter with geometry in a simple and elegant manner: Gµν = κT µν A feature of the covariance of Einstein’s equations is that some of these equations represent constraints on the dynamic variables These constraints are closely related to Bianchi identities: Gµν;ν = 0 Despite the high degree of aesthetics in the covariant formulation of Einstein’s equations, in practice, a precise isolation of the equations with dynamic content from those that are constraints is unclear from this covariant way of expressing them One way to unravel the dynamics of general relativity is to view it as a Cauchy problem, i.e.

Kai: to analyze the dynamics as the evolution of a three-dimensional hypersurface where the fields are defined This way of reformulating general relativity was developed by R.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into this paper now, "Introduction to the ADM formalism." We'll talk about what those titles tell us and who wrote it.

Mira: It’s important to know that the title itself is quite direct—it’s an introduction—and it immediately signals that this paper is setting up a specific mathematical framework for general relativity.

Lev: The authors are Corichi and Núñez, and they mention their affiliation with the Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares at the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México. That gives you a sense of the background in theoretical physics.

Kai: What does this title really mean for us? It means we're about to see how to take Einstein's equations, which are usually written in terms of coordinates and metric components, and recast them into something that looks more like classical mechanics.

Mira: Right. It’s about building a Hamiltonian formulation from the ground up using this specific setup, which is what they call the ADM formalism. It’s less about solving equations right now and more about defining the variables correctly for a later step, like quantization.

Lev: For us on the hardware side, that means we're looking at how they define those dynamic variables—the lapse and shift functions—because that’s what you actually have to measure or simulate in a numerical setting.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes the core idea of the ADM formalism as moving away from just looking at the metric components directly and instead focusing on defining a specific spatial slice that evolves over time.

Mira: They spend a lot of time explaining that this approach helps isolate the dynamic content of Einstein's equations, making it much clearer what is actually driving the evolution.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, they outline how to construct canonically conjugated momenta for the dynamic variables, which means taking partial derivatives of the Lagrangian density with respect to generalized velocities.

Kai: So you take those derivatives and use them to write a Hamiltonian that has a really clear interpretation of all its terms—that's the goal of this whole construction.

Mira: The paper shows how they do this by considering slices of space-time, where each slice is three dimensions with a positive definite metric defined on it, and that evolving three dimensional metric is what becomes the dynamic variable over time.

The paper's improvements: Lev: The authors suggest an improvement in how they handle the variables by explicitly showing them as non-dynamic variables when rewriting the gravitational action in terms of them.

Kai: They argue that by treating certain geometrical objects as non-dynamic, you get a clearer dynamic content in the variational principle, which is what they were aiming for from page three <ref:2210.10103#pg3>.

Mira: It’s about making sure that when you reformulate the principle of variational general relativity using these new variables—the lapse and shift functions along with the spatial metric—you get a statement where you can see exactly what is changing.

Kai: So, they are refining the way we write down the action so that it highlights the true dynamic content rather than getting bogged down in coordinate-dependent stuff.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up, this paper introduces a systematic procedure for moving from Einstein’s covariant equations to a Hamiltonian formulation using the ADM variables, which helps isolate the dynamical parts of gravity.

Kai: It sets up the structure for defining those canonical momenta and building that Hamiltonian density, even if they note that it's in parameterized form because of how they started it out.

Lev: From my perspective on what this means for running simulations, it’s the foundation for using ADM to determine solutions numerically in a Cauchy problem setting.

Kai: And conceptually, this formalism is what allows us to move toward quantizing gravity by first isolating those true degrees of freedom, which the authors suggest is two degrees of freedom per point when linearizing the equations.

Mira: So, if you're looking at cosmology or minisuperspace—those scenarios with very few degrees of freedom—this formalism allows you to ask how Hamilton’s equations relate to a geodesic equation associated with a supermetric.

Lev: That connection is crucial because it hints at the structure needed for analyzing those constrained systems in simpler models like Bianchi type universes when the lapse and shift functions are set to one and zero.

Kai: So, we've seen how they build this framework for Hamiltonian gravity, which opens up avenues for both numerical relativity and theoretical exploration in areas like quantum gravity.

Alejandro Corichi, Ñdaró Nǩnez

Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares, Universidad Nacional Aut༿oma de México

gr-qc

Submitted: 2022-10-18

Updated: 2026-10-28

Comments: 23 pages, 3 figures. Published in 1991, in Spanish. Translated into English by Ribhu Paul. V2 has corrected typos. The authors have made no effort to update it nor its bibliography. We hope, however, that by making it publicly available it may be useful for students interested in learning the 3+1 formalism of general relativity within the ADM formalism

Journal ref: Rev. Mex. Fis. 37, No 4, 720-747 (1991)

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner.

Key concepts

Principle of Equivalence
This principle states that the laws of physics are independent of an observer's state of motion. It implies that physical laws must be described covariantly, meaning they don't change depending on the coordinate system used to describe them. This leads to a simple way to express how matter interacts with geometry.
ADM Formulation
This formulation views general relativity as a Cauchy problem—tracking the evolution of a three-dimensional hypersurface over time. It introduces ADM variables, which explicitly show the dynamic content of Einstein's equations, making it easier to build a Hamiltonian theory for studying spacetime dynamics.
Minisuperspace
This is a simplified context where the number of degrees of freedom in gravitational dynamics is at most five. In this setting, researchers can compare Hamilton's equations derived from the Hamiltonian with the geodesic equation associated with the supermetric to study gravitational dynamics.
Hamiltonian Formulation
This involves constructing a classical Hamiltonian theory by finding canonically conjugated momenta for dynamic variables (like metric components). This transformation allows for a clearer interpretation of the dynamics and is a key step in studying gravity, especially when considering quantization methods.

Terminology

Summary

The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner. p. 0

Where the paper says it

4 (1991), 720-747. (Original Translation) by Ribhu Paul ‡ c c Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, 2A & 2B, Raja Subodh Chandra Mallick Rd, Jadavpur, Kolkata - 700032, India Abstract The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner.

Introduction to the ADM Formalism

The formulation of the theory of general relativity established by Einstein is centred around the concept of Principle of Equivalence which states: “The laws of physics are independent of the state of motion of the observer” This principle implies that these laws must be described covariantly i.e. independent of the coordinate system Thus, it becomes clear that the covariant formulation is natural, and it allows expressing the interaction of matter with geometry in a simple and elegant manner: Gµν = κT µν A feature of the covariance of Einstein’s equations is that some of these equations represent constraints on the dynamic variables These constraints are closely related to Bianchi identities: Gµν;ν = 0 Despite the high degree of aesthetics in the covariant formulation of Einstein’s equations, in practice, a precise isolation of the equations with dynamic content from those that are constraints is unclear from this covariant way of expressing them One way to unravel the dynamics of general relativity is to view it as a Cauchy problem, i. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Despite the high degree of aesthetics in the covariant formulation of Einstein’s equations, in practice, a precise isolation of the equations with dynamic content from those that are constraints is unclear from this covariant way of expressing them. One way to unravel the dynamics of general relativity is to view it as a Cauchy problem, i.

e. to analyze the dynamics as the evolution of a three-dimensional hypersurface where the fields are defined This way of reformulating general relativity was developed by R. p. 1
Where the paper says it

to analyze the dynamics as the evolution of a three-dimensional hypersurface where the fields are defined. This way of reformulating general relativity was developed by R.

Arnowitt, S. p. 0
Where the paper says it

4 (1991), 720-747. (Original Translation) by Ribhu Paul ‡ c c Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, 2A & 2B, Raja Subodh Chandra Mallick Rd, Jadavpur, Kolkata - 700032, India Abstract The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner.

Deser and C. p. 0
Where the paper says it

4 (1991), 720-747. (Original Translation) by Ribhu Paul ‡ c c Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, 2A & 2B, Raja Subodh Chandra Mallick Rd, Jadavpur, Kolkata - 700032, India Abstract The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein’s general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner.

W. Misner and is known as the ADM formulation of general relativity which took its full form in the early 1960’s

Conceptual Development

The purpose of this section is to establish a relatively clear idea of what the procedures to follow will be, without having gone into details The ADM variables should explicitly show the dynamic content of Einstein’s equations and allow us to build a Hamiltonian in which all the terms have a relatively clear interpretation The construction of a classical Hamiltonian theory from this point implies the construction of canonically conjugated momenta for the dynamic variables (i.e. for the dynamic components of the metric tensor), by taking the partial derivatives of the Lagrangian density with respect to the generalized velocities It is relatively clear that there is a necessity to separate some of the coordinates (in a different sense), or alternatively a direction in space-time for the construction of a Hamiltonian One way that was designed to do this, was to consider slices of space-time so that each slice is a 3-dimensional hypersurface with a positive definite metric defined on it By providing each hypersurface with a three-dimensional metric γij determined by the way we cut the space-time, it is possible to consider the metric γij (t) of the hypersurface that evolves with t as the dynamic variable

Formal Development

The construction of a classical Hamiltonian theory from this point implies the construction of canonically conjugated momenta for the dynamic variables (i.e. for the dynamic components of the metric tensor), by taking the partial derivatives of the Lagrangian density with respect to the generalized velocities The next step is to rewrite the gravitational action in terms of these new variables That is, we need to express the curvature scalar of space-time 4R and the invariant volume element d4x√−g as a function of geometrical objects on the hypersurface and of the new variables N, Ni The non-dependence of Lagrangian density on the velocities of N and Ni allows us to consider them as non-dynamic variables In this way, we can obtain the reformulation of variational principle of general relativity with a clearer dynamic content—which is what was intended

Decomposition of Space-time into 3 + 1

The foliation will be given by the functions: xµ = Xµ(ξa, t), (3.36) where the vector connecting the points of two hypersurfaces is given by ∂t, with components in the ∂µ basis given by ∂∂t = tµ ∂∂xµ The scalar N is called a lapse function, and the vector on the hypersurface Na is known as the shif t vector These, together with the metric γab constitute the so-called ADM variables The line element between two space-time events p(xa, t) and p'(xa +dxa, t+dt), can now be decomposed into two parts: the square of the distance over the hypersurface containing p minus the square of the proper time between the hypersurfaces From this expression (3.39) we deduce the relationship between the components of the metric gµν in adapted coordinates and the variables γab, N and Na: g00 = (NaNa − N2), g0a = Na, gab = γab

Curvature Scalar

The curvature scalar 4R is given by, 4R ≡ 4Rµν µν = 4R ab ab + 2 Rµ⊥ µ⊥ Using equations (3.50), (3.48) and (3.55) we can then express the curvature scalar as: 4R = 3R + KabKab − K2 + 2(∆λ);λ In this section we have expressed both the Riemann tensor and the curvature scalar as functions of the new variables, with which we can rewrite the Einstein tensor: Gµν = Rµν − 1/2 gµνR, and thus the Einstein’s equations in vacuum: Gµν = 0

Hamiltonian Formulation

The momenta associated with the variables Nµ will be clearly equal to zero, Pµ = ∂L/∂N˙µ = 0 The Hamiltonian density can now be expressed as (πabγ˙ab − L) = N√γ(KabKab − K2 − R) + Na(2πb ab) i≡ Zd3x [NH0 + NaHa] The theory is in parameterized form since the first-order Lagrangian is not in canonical form, a form that we would have if the terms of the Hamiltonian exclusively contained variables in terms of (πab, γ˙ab) In practice, what is done to go from (3.79) to (3.80) is specification of a relation between the parameter and the coordinate q0

Applications

The object that evolves is the geometry of a 3-manifold m and this is the dynamic variable of general relativity, hence the name geometrodynamics The set in which every point is a 3-geometry and in it are all possible 3-geometries for the manifold m is known as Superspace [12] and is denoted by G Space-time is, then, the evolution (or the set if one prefers to see it that way) of 3-geometries

Cosmology

The problem has a finite number of degrees of freedom, since the coordinates 21 depend only on the parameter time and not of all the variables as in the case of a more general space-time In minisuperspace, where the number of degrees of freedom is at most five, it is possible to ask whether there is any relationship between Hamilton’s equations derived from the Hamiltonian, and the geodesic equation associated with the supermetric The 3-geometries involved in the metric (4.1) depend exclusively on the time coordinate, so the problem has a finite number of degrees of freedom, since the coordinates 21 depend only on the parameter time and not of all the variables as in the case of a more general space-time

Quantum Gravity

Until recently, one of the main motivations for building a Hamiltonian formulation (i.e. the identification of canonically conjugate variables from a Lagrangian function, and obtaining the Hamiltonian as the Legendre transform in the velocities of the Lagrangian function) consisted of the possibility for quantizing the theory To try to overcome this difficulty, one can follow two different paths, which are roughly: 1) Trying to isolate the true degrees of freedom of gravitation (which, from the linearization of the equations is known to be two degrees of freedom per point)—which is the idea followed in ADM formalism 2) Considering all variables, but imposing conditions on the state vector given by the four constraints, by demanding that the constraints (now as operators) when acting on the state vectors annul it

Geometrodynamics

The introduction of new variables and consideration of space-time formed by the evolution of metric γij (t) suggests which is the dynamic variable that evolves The action is invariant considering the diffeomorphism on the hypersurface m(t), as it does not depend on the coordinate system used on this one This fact suggests that the truly relevant property for each hypersurface m(t) is not the metric defined on it, but the intrinsic geometry of the manifold itself

Minisuperspace

In minisuperspace, where the number of degrees of freedom is at most five, it is possible to ask whether there is any relationship between Hamilton’s equations derived from the Hamiltonian, and the geodesic equation associated with the supermetric The 3-geometries involved in the metric (4.1) depend exclusively on the time coordinate, so the problem has a finite number of degrees of freedom, since the coordinates 21 depend only on the parameter time and not of all the variables as in the case of a more general space-time

The 3-geometries involved in the metric (4.1) depend exclusively on the time coordinate, so the problem has a finite number of degrees of freedom, since the coordinates 21 depend only on the parameter time and not of all the variables as in the case of a more general space-time In minisuperspace, where the number of degrees of freedom is at most five, it is possible to ask whether there is any relationship between Hamilton’s equations derived from the Hamiltonian, and the geodesic equation associated with the supermetric

The 3-geometries involved in the metric (4.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems will be able to perform numerical relativity simulations by using ADM formalism to determine solutions to Einstein’s equations in a Cauchy problem setting, as this method is explicitly mentioned for determining the solutions to Einstein’s equations numerically.

  2. The system can develop tools for studying the quantization of gravity by employing path integrals, leveraging the connection between the ADM formulation and these methods.

  3. AI systems can be used to construct theories of space of spaces by utilizing the formalism developed in this paper, which has served as the basis for the development of the theory of space of spaces.

  4. The system can analyze cosmological models by utilizing Hamiltonian formalism, specifically by considering Bianchi type universes where the lapse and shift functions take the values N = 1 and Ni = 0.

  5. AI systems can explore minisuperspace to study gravitational dynamics where the number of degrees of freedom is at most five, relating Hamilton’s equations to the geodesic equation associated with the supermetric.

Abstract

The authors present concepts and mathematical developments which give rise to the Hamiltonian formulation of Einstein's general relativity, first introduced by Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner. All the geometrical quantities needed for the construction are explicitly obtained, and examples of some of the application of the formalism are given.

Related papers