Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach

arXiv:2204.04335 · nlin.AO · Submitted 2022-04-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nonlinear Sciences. The day in nonlinear science: chaos, patterns, networks and adaptation.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Measuring and improving community resilience".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach is proposed as an indicator-based method using Fuzzy Logic to quantify community resilience within the PEOPLES framework, which accounts for data uncertainties and provides a decision-support tool for assessing and improving community resilience.

Kai: Framework Foundation The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community.

Mira: This framework consists of seven dimensions of a community, which are summarized by the acronyms PEOPLES.

Kai: These seven dimensions are Population and Demographics, Environment and Ecosystem, Organized Government Services, Physical Infrastructure, Lifestyle and Community Competence, Economic development, and Social-cultural capital.

Paper summary: Kai: So we've talked about the basic idea now, and what it claims about using Fuzzy Logic with the PEOPLES framework for resilience measurement. The paper specifically focuses on how this approach accounts for data uncertainties, which is a big part of the argument >

Mira: They build on an existing indicator-based hierarchical framework called PEOPLES, which breaks down community aspects into seven dimensions: Population and Demographics, Environment and Ecosystem, Organized Government Services, Physical Infrastructure, Lifestyle and Community Competence, Economic development, and Social-cultural capital >

Lev: It’s interesting how they take those broad categories like "Social-cultural capital" or "Organized Government Services" and try to put them into that quantifiable structure >

Kai: Right. The methodology involves three main steps: first, resilience modeling where they group the PEOPLES indicators into subgroups, then interdependency analysis to assign importance factors between these variables, and finally the inference system that uses fuzzy logic to combine everything into a final resilience index >

Mira: And they use fuzzification to handle those data uncertainties by assigning membership grades between zero and one, which lets them use descriptive knowledge instead of just hard data for quantifying those PEOPLES indicators >

Lev: That step where they assign importance factors through an interdependency analysis based on a n by n adjacency matrix sounds like it’s where the real complexity lands when you try to map out all those relationships >

Kai: It’s trying to quantify how one dimension affects another, which is necessary because the paper says that implementing their methodology really depends on those indicators and the relationships between them being easily quantifiable >

Mira: And they admit that in real-world scenarios, data collection often introduces uncertainties or a lack of knowledge, so this fuzzy approach is presented as a way to implement it even when hard data is limited >

Lev: So if you’re trying to run this on actual hardware, the uncertainty in those initial inputs would be the biggest hurdle for getting reliable results from the fuzzy inference system >

Kai: And they show off their application by using a case study of San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake to get an estimate for just one dimension, Physical Infrastructure >

Mira: And that test showed that despite the uncertainty in those indicators, their methodology can still provide good estimates of community resilience, which is what makes it useful for decision support >

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve gone through the PEOPLES framework and the fuzzy logic approach used to quantify it in this paper. The authors are essentially presenting a holistic framework for evaluating how communities respond to catastrophic events >

Mira: The main point here is that they propose this indicator-based model, enhanced by fuzzy logic inference, as a way to estimate resilience indices for communities responding to disasters >

Lev: It seems like the implication is that we can use this kind of structured approach to help decision-makers and planners assess and learn from community resilience in the face of an event >

Kai: They also mention that their results are consistent with existing evaluations in the literature, suggesting it’s a consistent way to look at things >

Mira: So what this means for the world is that it gives people a tool to assess risk by dealing explicitly with data uncertainty in a structured way, which is something many other models might overlook >

Politecnico di Torino · Delft University of Technology

nlin.AO

Submitted: 2022-04-09

Updated: 2022-04-09

Journal ref: International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 78 (2022) 103118

DOI: 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2022.103118

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach is proposed as an indicator-based method using Fuzzy Logic to quantify community resilience within the PEOPLES framework…

Key concepts

PEOPLES Framework
This is a hierarchical system that defines all aspects of a community into seven dimensions: Population and Demographics, Environment and Ecosystem, Organized Government Services, Physical Infrastructure, Lifestyle and Community Competence, Economic development, and Social-cultural capital. It serves as the foundational structure for measuring community resilience.
Fuzzy Logic Inference System
This technique is used to combine the different PEOPLES variables into a final resilience index. It accounts for data uncertainties by assigning membership grades (between 0 and 1) to variables and uses 'if-then' rules to derive a crisp output, making the measurement robust against imperfect data.
Indicator-Based Method
This methodology relies on defining specific metrics or indicators for each dimension within the PEOPLES framework. Instead of using exact hard data, it clusters these indicators and weights them based on interdependencies to create a comprehensive resilience score for the community.

Terminology

Summary

Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach is proposed as an indicator-based method using Fuzzy Logic to quantify community resilience within the PEOPLES framework, which accounts for data uncertainties and provides a decision-support tool for assessing and improving community resilience. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The primary goal of this paper is to cover the previously mentioned shortcomings of existing scientific literature by introducing a Fuzzy Logic-based method within the context of the PEOPLES framework. The proposed method utilizes the resilience indicators presented in [19] to come up with an extensive resilience model that accounts for all aspects of a community.

Framework Foundation

The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience. The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community.

This framework consists of seven dimensions of a community, which are summarized by the acronyms PEOPLES. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The PEOPLES framework consists of seven dimensions of a community divided into a set of components, each of which is in turn subdivided into several indicators. The seven dimensions are summarized by the acronyms PEOPLES as follows [4, 29] (see Figure 1): 1.

These seven dimensions are Population and Demographics, Environment and Ecosystem, Organized Government Services, Physical Infrastructure, Lifestyle and Community Competence, Economic development, and Social-cultural capital. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Cimellaro, Renschler [17] presented the PEOPLES framework, which is a theoretical top-down framework that addresses all aspects of a community. These aspects are classified under seven community dimensions: Population; Environment; Organized government services; Physical

Methodological Steps

The proposed methodology is divided into three main steps for estimating community resilience. These steps include:

  1. Resilience modeling and indicator grouping, which involves defining a hierarchical scheme for the seven dimensions of the PEOPLES framework and clustering indicators into subgroups with no more than three indicators each. p. 8

    Where the paper says it

    Hierarchical rule base model applied to PEOPLES framework 4. 1 Step 1: Resilience modeling and indicators grouping The first step of the methodology is the definition of a hierarchical scheme for the seven dimensions of the PEOPLES framework.

  2. Interdependency analysis and importance factor, where weighting factors are assigned to each variable through an interdependency analysis based on a [n x n] adjacency matrix. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Indicators belonging to a specific component are further divided into subgroups according to predefined criteria. • Interdependency analysis and importance factor: weighting factors and importance factors are allocated to each PEOPLES variable (i.

  3. Inference system, which implements the fuzzy logic inference system to combine the PEOPLES variables and obtain the final resilience index. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    , indicators, components, and dimensions) as they do not contribute equally to the overall resilience output. • Inference: the last step of the methodology is to combine the indicators through an FL inference system and obtain the final output of the framework.

Fuzzy Logic Implementation

The fuzzy logic technique is used for inference to account for data uncertainties of the analyzed indicators. The fuzzification process involves assigning different membership grades ranging between 0 and 1 to a variable x to indicate its membership in several classes (fuzzy sets). p. 6

Where the paper says it

Fuzzy logic assigns different membership grades (µ) ranging between 0 and 1 to a variable x to indicate the membership of the variable to several classes (fuzzy sets). The strength of the fuzzy logic inference system relies on the following two main features: (i) fuzzy inference system can handle both descriptive (linguistic) knowledge and numerical data; (ii) fuzzy inference system uses approximate reasoning algorithm to determine relationships between inputs by which uncertainties can be propagated throughout the process [41].

The fuzzy inference system adopts the Mamdani type, which consists of if-then statements (rules) that link the input (antecedent) to a consequent (output). p. 7
Where the paper says it

, indicators, components, and dimensions) as they do not contribute equally to the overall resilience output. • Inference: the last step of the methodology is to combine the indicators through an FL inference system and obtain the final output of the framework.

Defuzzification is performed using methods such as the center of gravity or center of area method to obtain a crisp number from the output fuzzy set. p. 4
Where the paper says it

2 PEOPLES Framework PEOPLES is a multi-layered framework developed at the Multidisciplinary Center of Earthquake Engineering Research (MCEER) that aims to identify different resilience characteristics of a community at different scales (spatial and temporal) and assess possible responses of a community by taking into account the interdependence between community levels [5]. The PEOPLES framework consists of seven dimensions of a community divided into a set of components, each of which is in turn subdivided into several indicators.

Verification and Application

To demonstrate applicability, a case study of the city of San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake is used to obtain a resilience index for the Physical Infrastructure dimension. The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework. The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework. The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators.

The proposed approach was verified by comparing the obtained R with the result given by [19], who analyzed the same case study focusing on estimation of loss of resilience LOR. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Presenting a case study to demonstrate the applicability of the introduced resilience estimation methodology. Verifying the methodology by comparing the model output with the output obtained from [19].

The final resilience index R is computed as a percentage that reflects the response of the community to the earthquake event. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework. The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators.

Conclusion and Future Work

The paper presents a holistic framework for evaluating community resilience in response to a catastrophic event. The general indicator-based resilience model is proposed to estimate the resilience index of communities. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Fuzzy Inference System (FIS) 4 Methodology to estimate community resilience The methodology proposed in this work enhances the previous work introduced by [19] by incorporating fuzzy logic in the computation process. The methodology can be divided into the following (see Figure 2): • Resilience modeling and indicator grouping: a hierarchical rule base model is built based on the structure of the PEOPLES framework.

The fuzzy logic inference method is introduced within the resilience assessment model to deal with uncertainties that may affect the indicator collection. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The proposed method utilizes the resilience indicators presented in [19] to come up with an extensive resilience model that accounts for all aspects of a community. The fuzzy logic technique is used for inference to account for the data-related uncertainties.

Future work will focus on applying the proposed approach by considering all dimensions of PEOPLES as more reliable data become available. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, Kameshwar, Cox [27] developed a probabilistic decision support framework for community resilience planning under multiple hazards using Bayesian Network. Despite the advantages of the Bayesian network, such as updating the system to which it is applied when new data and information become available,

The results have shown that the proposed approach is consistent with existing evaluations in the literature and can be easily applied to large communities. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

The results from the proposed framework are suitable for assisting decision-makers, planners, and engineers to assess and learn from the resilience of their communities in the face of a particular event. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Verifying the methodology by comparing the model output with the output obtained from [19]. The resilience quantification methodology presented in this paper can be used as a decision-support tool by decision-makers to (i) learn about the state of their communities in the face of a particular event and (ii) prioritize planning and management strategies to improve the resilience of their communities to future hazardous events.

The paper is 2204. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process. This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience.

04335.

REFERENCE

[1] Allenby, B. and J. Fink, Toward inherently secure and resilient societies. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Since resilience is a multidisciplinary concept and encompasses different research areas, several definitions of resilience can be found in the literature. The term resilience was introduced by Allenby and Fink [1] as “the ability of a system to remain in a practical state and to degrade gracefully in the face of internal and external changes”.

[2] Bruneau, M. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The term resilience was introduced by Allenby and Fink [1] as “the ability of a system to remain in a practical state and to degrade gracefully in the face of internal and external changes”. Bruneau, Chang [2], and later Cimellaro, Reinhorn [3], defined resilience as “the ability of social units to mitigate hazards, contain the effects of disasters when they occur, and carry out recovery activities to minimize social disruption and mitigate the effects of future earthquakes”.

, et al., A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities. A qualitative framework that measures resilience along with the ability to recover from seismic events is the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association framework (SPUR) [15].

[3] Cimellaro, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24, Torino, Italy (Corresponding author), Email: gianpaolo. cimellaro@polito.

P., A.M. Reinhorn, and M. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The term resilience was introduced by Allenby and Fink [1] as “the ability of a system to remain in a practical state and to degrade gracefully in the face of internal and external changes”. Bruneau, Chang [2], and later Cimellaro, Reinhorn [3], defined resilience as “the ability of social units to mitigate hazards, contain the effects of disasters when they occur, and carry out recovery activities to minimize social disruption and mitigate the effects of future earthquakes”.

Bruneau, Framework for analytical quantification of disaster resilience. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Bruneau, Chang [2], and later Cimellaro, Reinhorn [3], defined resilience as “the ability of social units to mitigate hazards, contain the effects of disasters when they occur, and carry out recovery activities to minimize social disruption and mitigate the effects of future earthquakes”. Disaster resilience is often classified into technological units and social systems [4].

[4] Renschler, C. p. 1

Where the paper says it

However, natural resources, which are an important indicator in the resilience planning process, were not considered in the proposed framework. Cimellaro, Renschler [17] presented the PEOPLES framework, which is a theoretical top-down framework that addresses all aspects of a community.

S., et al., Developing the ‘PEOPLES’resilience framework for defining and measuring disaster resilience at the community scale. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The difficulty in the data and indicators acquisition process, as well as in defining the interaction between them, makes resilience assessment so complex that it cannot be used by decision-makers and industry. To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment.

[5] Cimellaro, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24, Torino, Italy (Corresponding author), Email: gianpaolo. cimellaro@polito.

P., Urban resilience for emergency response and recovery. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The seven dimensions are summarized by the acronyms PEOPLES as follows [4, 29] (see Figure 1): 1. D1-Population and Demographics: considers the socioeconomic composition of the community and measures social vulnerabilities that could affect the emergency response and recovery systems (e.

[6] Chang, S. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The term resilience was introduced by Allenby and Fink [1] as “the ability of a system to remain in a practical state and to degrade gracefully in the face of internal and external changes”. Bruneau, Chang [2], and later Cimellaro, Reinhorn [3], defined resilience as “the ability of social units to mitigate hazards, contain the effects of disasters when they occur, and carry out recovery activities to minimize social disruption and mitigate the effects of future earthquakes”.

E. and M. Shinozuka, Measuring improvements in the disaster resilience of communities. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Examples of bottom-up approaches to quantify community resilience to natural hazards include the Conjoint Community Resilience Assessment Measure (CCRAM) [20], the Communities Advancing Resilience Toolkit (CART) [21], and the Community Resilient System [22]. Despite this robust literature, there is still considerable disagreement about the indicators that define resilience and the frameworks that are most useful for measuring it.

[7] Gilbert, S. and B.M. Ayyub, Models for the Economics of Resilience. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The scientific community is aware that the availability of data to be implemented in community resilience frameworks is one of the main issues. That is, the modeling approaches presented require accurate data to be incorporated into the models to be functional.

[8] Liu, X., E. Ferrario, and E. Zio, Resilience analysis framework for interconnected critical infrastructures. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A qualitative framework that measures resilience along with the ability to recover from seismic events is the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association framework (SPUR) [15]. It considers the recovery of buildings, infrastructures, and services to determine the resilience of physical infrastructure.

[9] Ayyub, B.M., Practical resilience metrics for planning, design, and decision making. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The full description of the tool can be found in [31]. 3 Background of Fuzzy Logic Zadeh [32] introduced the concept of fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic to address the subjectivity of human judgment in the use of linguistic terms in the decision-making process [33-35].

[10] Scherzer, S., P. Lujala, and J.K. Rød, A community resilience index for Norway: An adaptation of the Baseline Resilience Indicators for Communities (BRIC). p. 1

Where the paper says it

Based on the Hyogo Framework, Kammouh, Dervishaj [13] have introduced a quantitative method to quantify resilience at the country level. Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities.

[11] UNISDR, U. Hyogo framework for action 2005–2015: Building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The literature offers stateof-the-art approaches to quantify community resilience [5-10], most of which are indicator-based approaches. Among the available indicator-based resilience frameworks is the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) [11] [12], which is an internationally agreed top-down framework to increase the resilience of nations and communities through the implementation of detailed measures at the government and policy levels.

[12] UNISDR, U. Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030. p. 0

Where the paper says it

, humans and other systems). Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience.

[13] Kammouh, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Materials, Mechanism, Management and Design, Delft University of Technology, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CD Delft, Netherlands, Email: o. kammouh@tudelft.

, G. Dervishaj, and G. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Among the available indicator-based resilience frameworks is the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) [11] [12], which is an internationally agreed top-down framework to increase the resilience of nations and communities through the implementation of detailed measures at the government and policy levels. Based on the Hyogo Framework, Kammouh, Dervishaj [13] have introduced a quantitative method to quantify resilience at the country level.

P. Cimellaro, Quantitative framework to assess resilience and risk at the country level. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Among the available indicator-based resilience frameworks is the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) [11] [12], which is an internationally agreed top-down framework to increase the resilience of nations and communities through the implementation of detailed measures at the government and policy levels. Based on the Hyogo Framework, Kammouh, Dervishaj [13] have introduced a quantitative method to quantify resilience at the country level.

[14] Cutter, S.L., K.D. Ash, and C.T. Emrich, The geographies of community disaster resilience. p. 0

Where the paper says it

, humans and other systems). Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience.

[15] SPUR, S. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities. A qualitative framework that measures resilience along with the ability to recover from seismic events is the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association framework (SPUR) [15].

F.P.a.U.R.A., Defining what San Francisco needs from its seismic mitigation policies. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities. A qualitative framework that measures resilience along with the ability to recover from seismic events is the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association framework (SPUR) [15].

[16] Kwasinski, A., et al., A conceptual framework for assessing resilience at the community scale. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The difficulty in the data and indicators acquisition process, as well as in defining the interaction between them, makes resilience assessment so complex that it cannot be used by decision-makers and industry. To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment.

[17] Cimellaro, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24, Torino, Italy (Corresponding author), Email: gianpaolo. cimellaro@polito.

P., et al., PEOPLES: a framework for evaluating resilience. p. 1
Where the paper says it

It considers the recovery of buildings, infrastructures, and services to determine the resilience of physical infrastructure. Another hierarchical framework for evaluating community-level resilience was proposed by [16].

[18] Kammouh, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Materials, Mechanism, Management and Design, Delft University of Technology, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CD Delft, Netherlands, Email: o. kammouh@tudelft.

, et al., Deterministic and fuzzy-based methods to evaluate community resilience. p. 2
Where the paper says it

To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment. For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York.

[19] Kammouh, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Materials, Mechanism, Management and Design, Delft University of Technology, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CD Delft, Netherlands, Email: o. kammouh@tudelft.

, et al., Resilience assessment of urban communities. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities. A qualitative framework that measures resilience along with the ability to recover from seismic events is the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association framework (SPUR) [15].

[20] Cohen, O., et al., Building resilience: The relationship between information provided by municipal authorities during emergency situations and community resilience. p. 0

Where the paper says it

it Abstract Due to the increasing frequency of natural and man-made disasters worldwide, the scientific community has paid considerable attention to the concept of resilience engineering in recent years. Authorities and decisionmakers, on the other hand, have been focusing their efforts to develop strategies that can help increase community resilience to different types of extreme events.

[21] Pfefferbaum, B., R.L. Pfefferbaum, and R.L. Van Horn, Community resilience interventions: Participatory, assessment-based, action-oriented processes. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The literature offers stateof-the-art approaches to quantify community resilience [5-10], most of which are indicator-based approaches. Among the available indicator-based resilience frameworks is the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) [11] [12], which is an internationally agreed top-down framework to increase the resilience of nations and communities through the implementation of detailed measures at the government and policy levels.

[22] White, R.K., et al., A practical approach to building resilience in America’s communities. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Since resilience is a multidisciplinary concept and encompasses different research areas, several definitions of resilience can be found in the literature. The term resilience was introduced by Allenby and Fink [1] as “the ability of a system to remain in a practical state and to degrade gracefully in the face of internal and external changes”.

[23] Schultz, M. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment. For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York.

T. and E.R. Smith, Assessing the resilience of coastal systems: A probabilistic approach. p. 2
Where the paper says it

To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment. For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York.

[24] Kammouh, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Materials, Mechanism, Management and Design, Delft University of Technology, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CD Delft, Netherlands, Email: o. kammouh@tudelft.

, P. Gardoni, and G. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York. Kammouh, Gardoni [24] introduced a novel approach to assess the time-dependent resilience of engineering systems using resilience indicators through the Dynamic Bayesian Network (DBN).

P. Cimellaro, Probabilistic framework to evaluate the resilience of engineering systems using Bayesian and dynamic Bayesian networks. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York. Kammouh, Gardoni [24] introduced a novel approach to assess the time-dependent resilience of engineering systems using resilience indicators through the Dynamic Bayesian Network (DBN).

[25] Franchin, P. and F. Cavalieri, Probabilistic assessment of civil infrastructure resilience to earthquakes. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To respond to this challenge, many studies have focused on developing methods for quantifying community resilience and assessing the impacts of recovery strategies through probabilistic approaches, such as Bayesian Networks, to deal with stochastic uncertainties that can affect resilience assessment. For example, Schultz and Smith [23] developed a Bayesian network-based approach to evaluate the resilience of infrastructure networks and buildings in Jamaica Bay, New York.

[26] Cai, H. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Another Bayesian network-based approach for seismic resilience quantification was proposed by [25]. Cai, Lam [26] employed a Bayesian network to investigate interdependencies of resilience components and improve disaster resilience.

, et al., Modeling the dynamics of community resilience to coastal hazards using a Bayesian network. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Cai, Lam [26] employed a Bayesian network to investigate interdependencies of resilience components and improve disaster resilience. Furthermore, Kameshwar, Cox [27] developed a probabilistic decision support framework for community resilience planning under multiple hazards using Bayesian Network.

[27] Kameshwar, S. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Cai, Lam [26] employed a Bayesian network to investigate interdependencies of resilience components and improve disaster resilience. Furthermore, Kameshwar, Cox [27] developed a probabilistic decision support framework for community resilience planning under multiple hazards using Bayesian Network.

, et al., Probabilistic decision-support framework for community resilience: Incorporating multi-hazards, infrastructure interdependencies, and resilience goals in a Bayesian network. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Cai, Lam [26] employed a Bayesian network to investigate interdependencies of resilience components and improve disaster resilience. Furthermore, Kameshwar, Cox [27] developed a probabilistic decision support framework for community resilience planning under multiple hazards using Bayesian Network.

[28] Baraldi, P., et al., Comparing the treatment of uncertainty in Bayesian networks and fuzzy expert systems used for a human reliability analysis application. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[29] Renschler, C. p. 1

Where the paper says it

However, natural resources, which are an important indicator in the resilience planning process, were not considered in the proposed framework. Cimellaro, Renschler [17] presented the PEOPLES framework, which is a theoretical top-down framework that addresses all aspects of a community.

, et al., The PEOPLES Resilience Framework: A conceptual approach to quantify community resilience. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A fuzzy-based approach is implemented to quantify the PEOPLES indicators using descriptive knowledge instead of hard data, accounting also for the uncertainties involved in the analysis. To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework.

[30] Cutter, S.L., C.G. Burton, and C.T. Emrich, Disaster resilience indicators for benchmarking baseline conditions. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Based on the Hyogo Framework, Kammouh, Dervishaj [13] have introduced a quantitative method to quantify resilience at the country level. Another top-down resilience framework is the Baseline Resilience Indicator for Communities (BRIC) [14], which is a quantitative framework that focuses on the inherent resilience of communities.

[31] Kammouh, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Materials, Mechanism, Management and Design, Delft University of Technology, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CD Delft, Netherlands, Email: o. kammouh@tudelft.

, et al. PEOPLES: Indicator-Based Tool To Compute Community Resilience. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience. The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community.

[32] Zadeh, L. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The full description of the tool can be found in [31]. 3 Background of Fuzzy Logic Zadeh [32] introduced the concept of fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic to address the subjectivity of human judgment in the use of linguistic terms in the decision-making process [33-35].

A., Fuzzy sets. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40]. Fuzzy logic assigns different membership grades (µ) ranging between 0 and 1 to a variable x to indicate the membership of the variable to several classes (fuzzy sets).

[33] Kabir, G. and R.S. Sumi, Power substation location selection using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and PROMETHEE: A case study from Bangladesh. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Employing the fuzzy logic inference technique to account for data uncertainties of the analyzed indicators. Presenting a case study to demonstrate the applicability of the introduced resilience estimation methodology.

[34] Tesfamariam, S., R. Sadiq, and H. Najjaran, Decision making under uncertainty—An example for seismic risk management. p. 6

Where the paper says it

3 Background of Fuzzy Logic Zadeh [32] introduced the concept of fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic to address the subjectivity of human judgment in the use of linguistic terms in the decision-making process [33-35]. The purpose of fuzzy logic is to solve high degree uncertainty problems and to represent vague, ambiguous, and chaotic information [36, 37].

[35] De Iuliis, M., et al., Downtime estimation of building structures using fuzzy logic. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process. This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience.

[36] Quelch, J. and I.T. Cameron, Uncertainty representation and propagation in quantified risk assessment using fuzzy sets. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience. Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process.

[37] Bonvicini, S., P. Leonelli, and G. Spadoni, Risk analysis of hazardous materials transportation: evaluating uncertainty by means of fuzzy logic. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[38] Tesfamariam, S. and M. Saatcioglu, Seismic vulnerability assessment of reinforced concrete buildings using hierarchical fuzzy rule base modeling. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Fuzzy Inference System (FIS) 4 Methodology to estimate community resilience The methodology proposed in this work enhances the previous work introduced by [19] by incorporating fuzzy logic in the computation process. The methodology can be divided into the following (see Figure 2): • Resilience modeling and indicator grouping: a hierarchical rule base model is built based on the structure of the PEOPLES framework.

[39] Colangelo, F., Probabilistic characterisation of an analytical fuzzy-random model for seismic fragility computation. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[40] Karimi, I. and K. Meskouris, Risk management of natural disasters: a fuzzy-probabilistic methodology and its application to seismic hazard. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[41] Tesfamariam, S. and M. Saatcioglu, Risk-based seismic evaluation of reinforced concrete buildings. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[42] UNISDR, How to make cities more resilient: A handbook for local government leaders: A contribution to the global campaign 2010-2015: Making cities resilient - My city is getting ready! p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Past global disaster events have shown an upward trend over the years, suggesting that modern communities are often not resilient enough to natural and man-made disasters. Therefore, research on disaster resilience has gained increased attention.

2012.

[43] Norris, F.H., et al., Community resilience as a metaphor, theory, set of capacities, and strategy for disaster readiness. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Over the years, Fuzzy Logic has become a key factor in many fields due to its effectiveness and reliability. In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40].

[44] George, K. and Y. Bo, Fuzzy sets and fuzzy logic, theory and applications. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In the existing literature, fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic have been applied in Machine Intelligence Quotient (MIQ) to simulate human ability, in earthquake engineering for seismic damage evaluation [35, 38], in fragility curve analysis [39], and natural disaster risk management [40]. Fuzzy logic assigns different membership grades (µ) ranging between 0 and 1 to a variable x to indicate the membership of the variable to several classes (fuzzy sets).

[45] Cimellaro, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24, Torino, Italy (Corresponding author), Email: gianpaolo. cimellaro@polito.

P., et al., Rapid building damage assessment system using mobile phone technology.

[46] US Census Bureau, Selected housing characteristics, 2007‐2011 American Community Survey 5‐year estimates. p. 4

Where the paper says it

2 PEOPLES Framework PEOPLES is a multi-layered framework developed at the Multidisciplinary Center of Earthquake Engineering Research (MCEER) that aims to identify different resilience characteristics of a community at different scales (spatial and temporal) and assess possible responses of a community by taking into account the interdependence between community levels [5]. The PEOPLES framework consists of seven dimensions of a community divided into a set of components, each of which is in turn subdivided into several indicators.

[47] Magdalena, L., On the role of context in hierarchical fuzzy controllers. p. 3

Where the paper says it

the main concern is its application in case of epistemic uncertainties and the computational effort in determining conditional probabilities [28]. The primary goal of this paper is to cover the previously mentioned shortcomings of existing scientific literature by introducing a Fuzzy Logic-based method within the context of the PEOPLES framework.

--- Page 1 ---

Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach Melissa De Iuliisa, Omar Kammouhb, Gian Paolo Cimellaroc a PhD. Candidate, Dept. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Measuring and improving community resilience: a Fuzzy Logic approach Melissa De Iuliisa , Omar Kammouhb , Gian Paolo Cimellaroc a PhD. Candidate, Dept.

of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Candidate, Dept. of Structural, Geotechnical and Building Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24, Torino, Italy, Email: melissa.

Abstract Due to the increasing frequency of natural and man-made disasters worldwide the scientific community has paid considerable attention to the concept of resilience engineering in recent years. p. 0

Where the paper says it

cimellaro@polito. it Abstract Due to the increasing frequency of natural and man-made disasters worldwide, the scientific community has paid considerable attention to the concept of resilience engineering in recent years.

Authorities and decisionmakers, on the other hand, have been focusing their efforts to develop strategies that can help increase community resilience to different types of extreme events. p. 0
Where the paper says it

it Abstract Due to the increasing frequency of natural and man-made disasters worldwide, the scientific community has paid considerable attention to the concept of resilience engineering in recent years. Authorities and decisionmakers, on the other hand, have been focusing their efforts to develop strategies that can help increase community resilience to different types of extreme events.

Since it is often impossible to prevent every risk the focus is on adapting and managing risks in ways that minimize impacts to communities (e. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Authorities and decisionmakers, on the other hand, have been focusing their efforts to develop strategies that can help increase community resilience to different types of extreme events. Since it is often impossible to prevent every risk, the focus is on adapting and managing risks in ways that minimize impacts to communities (e.

g., humans and other systems). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since it is often impossible to prevent every risk, the focus is on adapting and managing risks in ways that minimize impacts to communities (e. , humans and other systems).

Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, humans and other systems). Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience.

Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience. Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process.

This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process. This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience.

The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community. A fuzzy-based approach is implemented to quantify the PEOPLES indicators using descriptive knowledge instead of hard data accounting also for the uncertainties involved in the analysis. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community. A fuzzy-based approach is implemented to quantify the PEOPLES indicators using descriptive knowledge instead of hard data, accounting also for the uncertainties involved in the analysis.

To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A fuzzy-based approach is implemented to quantify the PEOPLES indicators using descriptive knowledge instead of hard data, accounting also for the uncertainties involved in the analysis. To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework.

The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators. Hence it serves as a decision-support tool to help decision-makers and stakeholders assess and improve the resilience of their communities. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators. Hence, it serves as a decision-support tool to help decision-makers and stakeholders assess and improve the resilience of their communities.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Fuzzy Logic integration for uncertainty handling in resilience modeling: The AI system can quantify community resilience using a fuzzy logic inference system to account for data-related uncertainties, as the methodology utilizes the resilience indicators presented in [19] to come up with an extensive resilience model that accounts for all aspects of a community.

  2. Importance factor determination via interdependency analysis: The AI can assign weighting factors to PEOPLES variables by performing an interdependency analysis where importance is related to the number of other variables in the same group that depends on it, thus ensuring indicators are ranked according to their importance.

  3. Hierarchical rule-based aggregation for complex systems: The AI system can combine indicators through a Mamdani fuzzy inference system using a decomposition technique, allowing aggregation at each level of the hierarchical scheme, resulting in a maximum of 33 = 27 rules per subgroup.

  4. Crisp output generation via center of gravity method: The final resilience index calculation can be performed by applying the center of gravity method to obtain a crisp number from the output fuzzy set, as described by Equation (5) and demonstrated with a result of R = 0.73 for San Francisco's physical infrastructure dimension.

  5. Scenario-based decision support tool: The improved AI system can serve as a decision-support tool that allows users to (i) learn about the state of their communities in the face of a particular event and (ii) prioritize planning and management strategies to improve the resilience of their communities to future hazardous events.

Abstract

Due to the increasing frequency of natural and man-made disasters worldwide, the scientific community has paid considerable attention to the concept of resilience engineering in recent years. Authorities and decision-makers, on the other hand, have been focusing their efforts to develop strategies that can help increase community resilience to different types of extreme events. Since it is often impossible to prevent every risk, the focus is on adapting and managing risks in ways that minimize impacts to communities (e.g., humans and other systems). Several resilience strategies have been proposed in the literature to reduce disaster risk and improve community resilience. Generally, resilience assessment is challenging due to uncertainty and unavailability of data necessary for the estimation process. This paper proposes a Fuzzy Logic method for quantifying community resilience. The methodology is based on the PEOPLES framework, an indicator-based hierarchical framework that defines all aspects of the community. A fuzzy-based approach is implemented to quantify the PEOPLES indicators using descriptive knowledge instead of hard data, accounting also for the uncertainties involved in the analysis. To demonstrate the applicability of the methodology, data regarding the functionality of the city San Francisco before and after the Loma Prieta earthquake are used to obtain a resilience index of the Physical Infrastructure dimension of the PEOPLES framework. The results show that the methodology can provide good estimates of community resilience despite the uncertainty of the indicators. Hence, it serves as a decision-support tool to help decision-makers and stakeholders assess and improve the resilience of their communities.

Related papers