When higher-order interactions enhance synchronization: the case of the Kuramoto model
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nonlinear Sciences. The day in nonlinear science: chaos, patterns, networks and adaptation.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "When higher-order interactions enhance synchronization".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Synchronization dynamics in coupled oscillators can be enhanced by higher-order interactions in non-pairwise systems, and this effect is non-monotonic with respect to coupling strength.
Kai: Effect of Higher-Order Interactions on Synchronization The effect of higher-order interactions on synchronization in the Kuramoto model is non-monotonic, as the degree of synchronization reached is maximized at a small but nonzero higherorder coupling strength.
Mira: This observation holds for both random hypergraphs and globally coupled systems.
Kai: Furthermore, under a constrained budget for interactions, a mixture of pairwise and higher-order couplings achieves higher synchronization than either interaction type alone.
Paper summary: Kai: So, what does the paper actually claim about these higher-order interactions in this Kuramoto model? It's not just that they exist; it's how they behave when you change their strength. Mira They show that adding weak higher-order interactions to a system with pairwise links actually helps boost the synchronization level. But if you crank up the strength of those higher-order couplings too much, things start getting worse for the synchronization. Lev That’s interesting because we see literature suggesting that higher-order interactions can sometimes make it harder to achieve a synchronized state, like shrinking the attraction basin of that synchronous state or making twisted states harder to disrupt >
Kai: The paper investigates this on random hypergraphs and globally coupled systems, showing this non-monotonic behavior holds across different setups. Mira And they also look at a scenario where you have a limited budget for interactions, and they find that mixing pairwise and higher-order couplings is generally better than using just one type alone. Lev That means if you're trying to get the best synchronization with limited resources, you probably need both types of connections >
Kai: What this means for us right now is that we can't just assume more connections always mean better results; the way those extra connections are structured matters a lot. Mira It suggests that higher-order interactions aren't universally detrimental; they have a specific window where they help, and beyond that, they become counterproductive >
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you're building hardware for these systems, you need to be careful how you allocate those interaction budgets because mixing them seems to be the optimal strategy for getting the highest synchronization levels >
Conclusion: Kai: So looking at this paper, "When higher-order interactions enhance synchronization: the case of the Kuramoto model," what's left to unpack about why this matters for how we think about these systems? Mira The core idea is that the relationship between coupling strength and synchronization isn't a simple straight line; it has a peak where adding weak higher-order interactions helps, and then it drops off when they get strong. Lev It’s important because it tells us that when we model real-world systems with complex connections, we can't just treat all connections the same way >
Kai: The authors also point out that this behavior isn't just a quirk of the size of the system; it holds up for both smaller random hypergraphs and much larger globally coupled systems, like ten thousand oscillators > <ref:2508.10992#pg1>
Mira: And they confirm that even when initial phases are very messy, those triangles or higher-order interactions still have a beneficial effect on synchronization, even if it's less effective in those specific incoherent cases >
Lev: The main implication for us is that we need to look at how these different interaction topologies work together rather than just focusing on the individual types of coupling >
Kai: So, the paper shows that combining links and triangles usually leads to better synchronization than using either one by itself, even when you adjust the individual strengths independently >
Riccardo Muolo, Hiroya Nakao, Marco Coraggio
RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Sciences · Department of Systems and Control Engineering, Institute of Science Tokyo · Research Center for Autonomous Systems Materialogy · Scuola Superiore Meridionale
nlin.AO, cond-mat.stat-mech, math.OC, nlin.PS
Submitted: 2025-08-14
Updated: 2026-09-11
DOI: 10.1063/5.0354134
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: Synchronization dynamics in coupled oscillators can be enhanced by higher-order interactions in non-pairwise systems, and this effect is non-monotonic with respect to coupling strength.
Key concepts
- Higher-Order Interactions
- These are coupling mechanisms beyond simple pairwise connections, such as interactions between three or more oscillators simultaneously (e.g., triangles in a network). The paper explores how these complex connections influence the overall synchronization behavior of the system, showing they can have a beneficial effect under certain conditions.
- Non-Monotonic Dependence
- This means that as you increase the strength of higher-order coupling, the synchronization level doesn't just keep increasing or decreasing steadily. Instead, it reaches a peak at a small, specific coupling strength and then starts to decrease. This behavior is robust across different system sizes.
- Optimal Resource Allocation
- When limited resources are available for setting up connections (links vs. triangles), the best way to maximize synchronization is not to use only one type of connection. The study found that a balanced mix of both pairwise and higher-order couplings yields superior synchronization compared to focusing entirely on one type.
- Global Coupling Systems
- This refers to systems where every oscillator is connected to every other oscillator, regardless of its position in the network. The paper specifically analyzed large globally coupled systems, confirming that the non-monotonic behavior observed with higher-order coupling persists even in these large settings.
Terminology
Summary
Synchronization dynamics in coupled oscillators can be enhanced by higher-order interactions in non-pairwise systems, and this effect is non-monotonic with respect to coupling strength. p. 9 We found that the effect of higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic: weak higherorder interactions enhance it when added to pairwise ones,
whereas strong ones hamper it, in line with the reduced basins
and richer dynamics (cluster synchronization, slow switching,
multistability) reported previously41,44,50,56,58
. We covered two complementary regimes: random hypergraphs of 10 and 100 nodes—a range relevant to realworld applications, such as small subnetworks of interacting
brain regions61, inverters in islanded microgrids62, and small
groups of individuals coordinating their movements63—and
globally coupled systems of N0 = 10000 oscillators.Where the paper says it
Effect of Higher-Order Interactions on Synchronization
The effect of higher-order interactions on synchronization in the Kuramoto model is non-monotonic, as the degree of synchronization reached is maximized at a small but nonzero higherorder coupling strength. This observation holds for both random hypergraphs and globally coupled systems. p. 0 Here we show that the effect of such
higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic. Through a numerical study of higher-order Kuramoto
models on random hypergraphs and on globally coupled systems, we find that the degree of synchronization reached
from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength: weak higherorder interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it, in line
with earlier reports of reduced basins and of cluster states. We observe this in both random
hypergraphs and globally coupled systems, indicating the
effect is neither a finite-size artifact nor specific to a particular topology. We further find that, under a constrained
budget for interactions, a mixture of pairwise and higherorder couplings achieves higher synchronization than either interaction type alone, which points to a design principle for engineered oscillator networks.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Quantifying the Enhancement Mechanism
The study investigated how the strength of higher-order interactions affects the level of synchronization reached on general hypergraphs. The results showed that weak higher-order interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it. p. 0 Here we show that the effect of such
higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic. Through a numerical study of higher-order Kuramoto
models on random hypergraphs and on globally coupled systems, we find that the degree of synchronization reached
from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength: weak higherorder interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it, in line
with earlier reports of reduced basins and of cluster states. Here we show that the effect of such
higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic. Through a numerical study of higher-order Kuramoto
models on random hypergraphs and on globally coupled systems, we find that the degree of synchronization reached
from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength: weak higherorder interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it, in line
with earlier reports of reduced basins and of cluster states.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Optimal Resource Allocation Strategy
When a limited budget for interactions is considered, the optimal configuration for synchronization generally involves a combination of both pairwise and higher-order interactions. Specifically:
-
The optimal link allocation fraction b1 is rarely exactly 0 or 1, as dedicating all resources exclusively to either links or triangles is almost never optimal. p. 7
Where the paper says it
Combining links and triangles is optimal A key finding from this analysis is that the optimal link allocation fraction b1 is rarely exactly 0 or 1, i. , dedicating all resources exclusively to either links or triangles is almost never optimal.
-
The optimal value of b1 strongly depends on the relative coupling strengths K1 and K2, with more resources typically allocated to the interaction type associated with the stronger coupling. p. 7
Where the paper says it
Across all panels, the optimal configuration consistently favors a combination of both interaction types. Notably, the optimal value of b1 strongly depends on the relative coupling strengths K1, K2, with more resources typically allocated to the interaction type associated with the stronger coupling.
Robustness Across System Scales
The non-monotonic dependence on the higher-order coupling strength is not a finite-size artifact but a robust feature of the higher-order Kuramoto dynamics across different system sizes. This was confirmed for random hypergraphs of 10 and 100 nodes, as well as globally coupled systems of N0 = 10000 oscillators. p. 9 We found that the effect of higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic: weak higherorder interactions enhance it when added to pairwise ones,
whereas strong ones hamper it, in line with the reduced basins
and richer dynamics (cluster synchronization, slow switching,
multistability) reported previously41,44,50,56,58
. We covered two complementary regimes: random hypergraphs of 10 and 100 nodes—a range relevant to realworld applications, such as small subnetworks of interacting
brain regions61, inverters in islanded microgrids62, and small
groups of individuals coordinating their movements63—and
globally coupled systems of N0 = 10000 oscillators.Where the paper says it
Complementary Results for Different Topologies
The beneficial effect of triangles persists even when the initial phases are highly incoherent, although they are less effective at enhancing synchronization in that scenario. This suggests that higher-order interactions complement pairwise couplings and can enhance synchronization. p. 9 This is reflected
by the black optimal-allocation curves bending slightly left as
c2 increases. These findings indicate that higher-order interactions complement pairwise couplings and can enhance synchronization. That convergent evidence, obtained for different topologies
and different target states, indicates the effect is generic rather
than specific to the setting considered here. Since our results on random hypergraphs are obtained by
averaging over hundreds of topology realizations, they hold
on average; specific hypergraph structures may behave differently, as reflected in the order parameter distributions in
Figure 4.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Analysis of Large Systems
For large, globally coupled systems, both order parameters R and R2 have a maximum for low (but non-zero) values of K2, beyond which R decreases monotonically with K2. This confirms the non-monotonic behavior persists for large, globally coupled systems. p. 6 Beyond that maximum,
R decreases monotonically with K2. The non-monotonic behavior therefore persists for large, globally coupled systems,
and is neither a finite-size effect nor specific to random hypergraphs. The non-monotonic behavior therefore persists for large, globally coupled systems,
and is neither a finite-size effect nor specific to random hypergraphs. Additionally, for large K2, R falls below 0. Additionally, for large K2, R falls below 0. 2, while R2 stays
near 0. 2, while R2 stays
near 0. 9, a signature of two-cluster organization41,44,49,50. By contrast, the numerical results show that larger K2 promotes competing two-cluster states, as indicated in Figure 5
by R2 remaining high while R decreases. The competition between local phase compression at weak K2 and cluster formation at stronger K2 provides a qualitative explanation for the
non-monotonic dependence of R on K2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Interaction Mixing
The optimal link allocation fraction b1 is rarely exactly 0 or 1, consistently favoring a combination of both interaction types. This finding indicates that combining links and triangles generally yields higher synchronization than using either alone, even when K1 and K2 are tuned independently. p. 8 See Appendix B for further details. We observe that combining links and triangles generally yields higher synchronization than using either alone. To
this end, we studied Kuramoto oscillators coupled through 2-
and 3-body interactions and conducted a numerical study on
random hypergraphs of 10 and 100 nodes, a regime relevant
for real-world applications61–63. Our analysis confirms that
higher-order interactions generally enhance synchronization
when the initial conditions are close to the synchronous state;
however, incoherent initial states reveal a non-monotonic dependence on the higher-order coupling strength. 57, showing that the critical coupling
for synchronization increases, facilitating desynchronization,
and in Refs. 58 and 59, where it was demonstrated that, once
achieved, synchronization and twisted states become harder
to disrupt due to higher-order interactions. This is reflected
by the black optimal-allocation curves bending slightly left as
c2 increases. These findings indicate that higher-order interactions complement pairwise couplings and can enhance synchronization. Spanning three orders of magnitude in system size (10,
100, 10000) and finding the same non-monotonic dependence
throughout indicates that the effect is not a finite-size artifact
but a robust feature of the higher-order Kuramoto dynamics. The non-monotonic dependence on the higher-order coupling strength described here was first reported in the preprint
version of this work106. This is related to our
mixed-allocation result of Section IV, but concerns mixing
within the coupling function rather than in the structural allocation of a fixed resource budget, as we do here (Section IV). That convergent evidence, obtained for different topologies
and different target states, indicates the effect is generic rather
than specific to the setting considered here.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Remarks on Future Work
Whether the non-monotonic effect reported here survives for such interactions, for four-body and higher couplings, or for combinations of them, remains an open question and a natural direction for future work. A further promising avenue would be to identify which higher-order topologies most effectively enhance synchronization by extending the numerical network analysis in Ref. p. 9 Whether the non-monotonic effect reported here survives for
such interactions, for four-body and higher couplings, or for
combinations of them, remains an open question and a natural
direction for future work, alongside an in-depth exploration of
different higher-order topologies, and considering the effects
of noise112. A further promising avenue would be to identify
which higher-order topologies most effectively enhance synchronization, by extending the numerical network analysis in
Ref. These recent findings motivate our first research goal,
which is to quantify the effects of higher-order interactions
on the synchronous state for more general hypergraph topologies. As in previous works, our framework considers the addition of higher-order interactions to the pairwise setting. A mean-field self-consistency analysis shows that a
fully locked, single-cluster solution of the pairwise model at
K2 = 0 becomes more coherent when continued to infinitesimal positive 3-body coupling: namely, dR/dK2|K2=0 > 0. This increase results from a compression of the frequencyinduced phase lags, and provides a local mechanism for the
initial increase in R once the fully locked branch has been
reached. 5 (results omitted here for brevity), confirming the same trend. Appendix D reports the same analysis for normally distributed
frequencies, for larger hypergraphs, and for the KuramotoDaido order parameter R2; the non-monotonic dependence on
K2 is confirmed in all cases. A mean-field self-consistency analysis shows that a
fully locked, single-cluster solution of the pairwise model at
K2 = 0 becomes more coherent when continued to infinitesimal positive 3-body coupling: namely, dR/dK2|K2=0 > 0. This increase results from a compression of the frequencyinduced phase lags, and provides a local mechanism for the
initial increase in R once the fully locked branch has been
reached.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix Details
The paper includes detailed appendices for computationally efficient simulation methods and descriptions of numerical setups for coupling strength analysis and hyperedge allocation analysis. Appendix B describes the description of the numerical methods used in the work. p. 0 Here we show that the effect of such
higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic. Through a numerical study of higher-order Kuramoto
models on random hypergraphs and on globally coupled systems, we find that the degree of synchronization reached
from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength: weak higherorder interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it, in line
with earlier reports of reduced basins and of cluster states. To further validate this, we repeated the analysis for Gaussian
rather than uniform frequency distributions, for larger hypergraphs of N0 = 100 nodes, and for the Kuramoto-Daido order
parameter R2. In all cases, the results consistently confirm that
a combination of links and triangles is more effective for synchronization than relying on a single interaction type. The globally coupled system considered here also lends itself to an analytical explanation for the initial increase in R at
small K2. A mean-field self-consistency analysis shows that a
fully locked, single-cluster solution of the pairwise model at
K2 = 0 becomes more coherent when continued to infinitesimal positive 3-body coupling: namely, dR/dK2|K2=0 > 0. The paper is structured as follows: in the next Section, we
introduce the framework of higher-order interactions and the
higher-order Kuramoto model. In Section III, we present our
first results, i.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Non-monotonic coupling strength optimization for synchronization: The AI system can determine that
the degree of synchronization reached from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength
when adding higher-order interactions to pairwise ones, and conversely, thatstrong ones work against it.
-
Optimal resource allocation for network design: The system can employ a cost-constrained allocation analysis to find that
a mixture of pairwise and higher-order couplings consistently achieves higher synchronization than relying on either type alone
when resources are limited. -
Adaptive network topology selection: The AI can guide the design of oscillator networks by using the finding that
the optimal link allocation fraction b1 is rarely exactly 0 or 1, i.e., dedicating all resources exclusively to either links or triangles is almost never optimal.
-
Robust synchronization prediction across scales: The system can predict that
the non-monotonic dependence on the higher-order coupling strength described here was first reported in the preprint version of this work
and that this effectis not a finite-size artifact but a robust feature of the higher-order Kuramoto dynamics
across system sizes ranging from N0 = 10 to N0 = 10000. -
Distinguishing synchronization regimes: The AI can differentiate between synchronization and two-cluster organization by analyzing the Kuramoto order parameter R and the Kuramoto-Daido order parameter R2, noting that
for large K2, R falls below 0.2, while R2 stays near 0.9.
Abstract
Synchronization is a fundamental phenomenon in complex systems, observed across a wide range of natural and engineered contexts. The Kuramoto model provides a foundational framework for understanding synchronization among coupled oscillators, traditionally assuming pairwise interactions. However, many real-world systems exhibit group and many-body interactions, which can be effectively modeled through hypergraphs. Here we show that the effect of such higher-order interactions on synchronization is non-monotonic. Through a numerical study of higher-order Kuramoto models on random hypergraphs and on globally coupled systems, we find that the degree of synchronization reached from incoherent initial conditions is maximized at a small but nonzero higher-order coupling strength: weak higher-order interactions enhance synchronization when added to pairwise ones, whereas strong ones work against it, in line with earlier reports of reduced basins and of cluster states. We further show, through a cost-constrained allocation analysis, that under a constrained budget for interactions a mixed allocation of pairwise and higher-order couplings consistently achieves higher synchronization than relying on either type alone. These findings clarify the role of higher-order interactions in shaping collective dynamics and point to design principles for optimizing synchronization in complex systems.
Sources
- Collective dynamics of higher-order Vicsek model emerging from local conformity interactions
- Mixed higher-order coupling stabilizes new states
- Symmetry-based selection rules for higher-order interactions in coupled oscillators
Related papers
- Scale-Dependent Collective Adaptation in Self-Amending LLM Societies: A Cross-Family Study of Emergent Governance
- Paths to synchronization in the Kuramoto model with inertia
- Oscillations in two-stage contagion on networks: contagion structure, turnover and connectivity
- Phase Locking in Oscillator Networks with Uncertain and State-Dependent Couplings
- Cooperation Dynamics with Environmental Feedback: Steady States and Transitions
- Waveform proportionality and Taylor's law in networks of Lorenz systems