Inside-Out Planet Formation. VII. Astrochemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks and Implications for Planetary Compositions

arXiv:2202.02483 · astro-ph.EP · Submitted 2022-02-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Inside-Out Planet Formation. VII. Astrochemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks and Implications for Planetary Compositions".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF) proposes that the abundant systems of close-in Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes form in situ at the pressure maximum associated with the Dead Zone Inner Boundary (DZIB) <ref:2202.02483#pg2> This model predicts that planetary cores formed by pebble accretion in IOPF are expected to be volatile poor <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Disk Physical and Chemical Modeling The study presents a model of the physical and chemical evolution of protoplanetary disk midplanes following gas advection, radial drift of pebbles, and gas-grain chemistry <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The model employs an alpha-disk framework to specify disk midplane conditions based on accretion rate, stellar mass, luminosity, and viscosity parameter <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Key physical properties include radial temperature profiles described by equations (7) and (8), which account for active accretion heating in the inner regions and passive heating in outer regions <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The model evolves for a fiducial duration of 105 years, considering a secular decline in the global accretion rate via equation (13) <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Transport Mechanisms and Dust Evolution Radial drift of icy pebbles is influential, with gas-phase abundances of volatiles enhanced up to two orders of magnitude at ice-lines while the outer disk becomes depleted of dust <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The study investigates six cases (a) through (f) to examine the effects of transport mechanisms, including no transport, gas advection, and pebble drift <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Cases (d) through (f) show that decoupling pebbles from the gas provokes a general depletion of the dust component in the outer disk <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The dust-to-gas mass ratio (D/G) stabilizes at about 10−6 in the very outer disk at 300 au for Case (d) <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Chemical Evolution of Volatile Species The chemical evolution is computed using a time-dependent gas-grain astrochemical network developed by Walsh et al.

Vera: (2015) <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The results show that the radial evolution of the main C-bearing species is dominated by CO and its transition from the ice phase in the outer disk to the gas phase in warmer inner regions <ref:2202.02483#pg2> In cases with radial drift, gas-phase volatiles at their icelines are greatly enhanced, with gas-phase H2O peaking at an abundance of ∼ 10−2 with respect to H nuclei at 1 au <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Implications for Planetary Compositions The results imply that planets forming near the DZIB inside about 1 au would be volatile-poor, including water-poor, but could accrete a primordial water-rich atmosphere <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The gas-phase C/O ratio at the water iceline reaches values of.

Jocelyn: 0.1 in models with radial drift <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Furthermore, the total element ratios reveal an enhancement of gas-phase volatiles at the icelines and the depletion of ices due to transport <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Caveats and Future Work The authors note several caveats, including the use of only one cosmic ray ionization rate (CRIR) in their main model series <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The choice of timescale over which to consider the evolution, 105 yr, is motivated by the desire to follow the chemistry to the point of first planet formation within the IOPF scenario <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Future work is needed to explore two and three-dimensional models and effects of chemical model uncertainties <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The authors conclude that pebble drift enriches the inner disk with solids, while depleting the outer disk <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Gas-grain reactions of gas-phase CO continuously supplies the protoplanetary disk with H2O ice, which then drift towards its iceline where it sublimates and enhances water vapor abundance by more than two orders of magnitude <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The resulting composition of the disk is affected by its previous history, i.e., evolving from a state with a greater accretion rate <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The final results suggest that accreted planetary atmospheres in the inner disk, relevant for IOPF, should also have this low value of C/O <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The paper represents the first predictions for chemical compositions of planets forming in the Inside-Out Planet Formation scenario <ref:2202.02483#pg2> References The authors thank an anonymous referee for comments that helped to improve the paper <ref:2202.02483#pg2> They also thank Christian Eistrup for helpful discussions <ref:2202.02483#pg2> This work is based on that submitted in partial requirements for Mr.

Vera: Arturo Cevallos Soto’s Masters thesis in Physics at Chalmers University of Technology, supervised by Prof.

Title and authors: Vera: Now let's talk about what they actually found in this paper, "Inside-Out Planet Formation. VII. Astrochemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks and Implications for Planetary Compositions." They look at how cosmic-ray induced chemistry and gas-grain reactions were important for the dominance of water ice and carbon dioxide ice in the outer disk, at the expense of CO ice and methane gas.

Jocelyn: So they found that cosmic rays actually play a role in setting up those initial chemical conditions, but then they show how physical processes like gas advection and pebble drift change that composition over time.

Subrahmanyan: The crucial finding here is that outer disk pebbles will influence the composition of the inner regions by transporting ices of volatile species inwards as they migrate, which is a key mechanism for planet formation.

Vera: They tested six different cases, from no transport to gas advection and pebble drift, and found that decoupling pebbles from the gas provokes a general depletion of the dust component in the outer disk.

Jocelyn: And for those cases with radial drift, they found that gas-phase volatiles at their icelines are greatly enhanced, with gas-phase water peaking at an abundance of about ten to the power of negative two with respect to H nuclei at one au <ref:2202.02483#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That enhancement is significant because it shows how the disk's chemistry gets boosted right where planets might form, which is right?

Vera: It really does. The paper also shows that the gas-phase C/O ratio at the water iceline reaches values of zero point one in models with radial drift and gas advection over one hundred five years <ref:2202.02483#pg3>.

Jocelyn: That low value for C/O is important because it suggests that any accreted planetary atmospheres in the inner disk, relevant for Inside-Out Planet Formation, should also have this low value.

Subrahmanyan: If those planets form near the DZIB inside about one au, these results imply they would be volatile-poor and water-poor, but they could still accrete a primordial water-rich atmosphere <ref:2202.02483#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Vera: To summarize what the paper is saying about its results, it’s that pebble drift enriches the inner disk with solids while simultaneously depleting the outer disk. This happens because gas-grain reactions involving gas-phase CO continuously supply the protoplanetary disk with water ice.

Jocelyn: And this water ice then drifts towards its iceline where it sublimates, which enhances the abundance of water vapor by more than two orders of magnitude, right?

Subrahmanyan: It’s a feedback loop: transport brings ices inward, sublimation at the ice-line boosts gas phase volatiles, and this whole process is affected by the disk's previous history because it evolves from a state with a greater accretion rate.

Vera: They show that the resulting composition of the disk is sensitive to its previous history in terms of accretion rate.

Jocelyn: It’s not just about what’s there now, but how it got there through time evolution within this model.

Subrahmanyan: I think that sensitivity to history is important because it connects the local environment to the global structure of the disk and eventually how planets end up with their final compositions.

The paper's improvements: Vera: One major improvement they point out in this work is coupling chemical evolution in a disk midplane with the disk evolution due to gas advection, which was neglected in some earlier studies.

Jocelyn: And that coupling is what lets them model how pebble drift influences the resulting composition of planets, showing that it’s not just a simple chemical network anymore.

Subrahmanyan: They are also using a more detailed gas-grain astrochemical network, developed by Walsh et al., to compute the chemical evolution over time, which is a step up from simpler models.

Vera: They've also made specific choices about initial abundances that they found have an impact on the chemical makeup of the disk even after one Myr, including overall C/O ratios in gas and ice species <ref:2202.02483#pg2,have an impact on the chemical makeup of the disk even after>.

Jocelyn: And they explicitly compare their results for cases with different accretion rates to show how that history matters in the final outcome.

Subrahmanyan: They also acknowledge some limitations, like using only one cosmic ray ionization rate in their main model series, which is something they need to address later.

Conclusion: Vera: So wrapping up this paper, the main implication is that planets forming near the DZIB inside about one au would be volatile-poor and water-poor <ref:2202.02483#pg1>. They could still accrete a primordial water-rich atmosphere, which they predict based on their models.

Jocelyn: And they highlight that pebble drift enriches the inner disk with solids while depleting the outer disk, and gas-grain reactions supply water ice to enhance vapor abundance at the ice-lines by over two orders of magnitude.

Subrahmanyan: For me, this work is important because it provides the first predictions for chemical compositions of planets forming in this specific Inside-Out Planet Formation scenario.

Vera: It gives us a starting point for predicting atmospheric compositions based on these evolved disk conditions.

Jocelyn: And they’ve shown how transport mechanisms can be a crucial factor in determining the final composition, moving beyond just looking at static disk snapshots.

Subrahmanyan: So, this paper "Inside-Out Planet Formation. VII. Astrochemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks and Implications for Planetary Compositions" gives us predictions about what these planets might look like based on how the disk evolves through time and transport effects.

Arturo Cevallos Soto, Jonathan C. Tan, Xiao Hu, Chia-Jung Hsu, Catherine Walsh

Department of Space, Earth and Environment, Chalmers University of Technology · Department of Astronomy, University of Virginia Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Leeds

astro-ph.EP

Submitted: 2022-02-05

Updated: 2022-09-13

Comments: Submitted to MNRAS; comments welcome; for summary of Inside-Out Planet Formation papers see http://www.cosmicorigins.space/iopf

DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stac2650

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF) proposes that the abundant systems of close-in Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes form in situ at the pressure maximum associated with the Dead Zone Inner Boundary…

Key concepts

Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF)
This model suggests that close-in Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes form in situ at the pressure maximum of the Dead Zone Inner Boundary. It implies a specific formation pathway where planetary cores are built up from pebbles within this region, influencing their final composition.
Radial Drift of Icy Pebbles
As gas moves through the disk, icy pebbles drift radially. This process significantly alters volatile distribution: it enhances gas-phase volatiles near ice lines while causing a general depletion of dust in the outer disk, which is crucial for determining where water vapor will concentrate.
Chemical Evolution Network
This network tracks how chemical species change over time using gas-grain reactions. It shows that molecular carbon (CO) transitions from an ice phase in cold outer regions to a gas phase in warmer inner regions, directly impacting the availability of water and other volatiles for planet formation.

Terminology

Summary

Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF) proposes that the abundant systems of close-in Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes form in situ at the pressure maximum associated with the Dead Zone Inner Boundary (DZIB) <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> This model predicts that planetary cores formed by pebble accretion in IOPF are expected to be volatile poor <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2>

Disk Physical and Chemical Modeling

The study presents a model of the physical and chemical evolution of protoplanetary disk midplanes following gas advection, radial drift of pebbles, and gas-grain chemistry <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The model employs an alpha-disk framework to specify disk midplane conditions based on accretion rate, stellar mass, luminosity, and viscosity parameter <ref:2202. p. 102483#pg2> Key physical properties include radial temperature profiles described by equations (7) and (8), which account for active accretion heating in the inner regions and passive heating in outer regions <ref:2202. p. 102483#pg2> The model evolves for a fiducial duration of 105 years, considering a secular decline in the global accretion rate via equation (13) <ref:2202. p. 102483#pg2>

Transport Mechanisms and Dust Evolution

Radial drift of icy pebbles is influential, with gas-phase abundances of volatiles enhanced up to two orders of magnitude at ice-lines while the outer disk becomes depleted of dust <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The study investigates six cases (a) through (f) to examine the effects of transport mechanisms, including no transport, gas advection, and pebble drift <ref:2202. p. 602483#pg2> Cases (d) through (f) show that decoupling pebbles from the gas provokes a general depletion of the dust component in the outer disk <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> The dust-to-gas mass ratio (D/G) stabilizes at about 10−6 in the very outer disk at 300 au for Case (d) <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2>

Chemical Evolution of Volatile Species

The chemical evolution is computed using a time-dependent gas-grain astrochemical network developed by Walsh et al. (2015) <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> The results show that the radial evolution of the main C-bearing species is dominated by CO and its transition from the ice phase in the outer disk to the gas phase in warmer inner regions <ref:2202. p. 602483#pg2> In cases with radial drift, gas-phase volatiles at their icelines are greatly enhanced, with gas-phase H2O peaking at an abundance of ∼ 10−2 with respect to H nuclei at 1 au <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2>

Implications for Planetary Compositions

The results imply that planets forming near the DZIB inside about 1 au would be volatile-poor, including water-poor, but could accrete a primordial water-rich atmosphere <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The gas-phase C/O ratio at the water iceline reaches values of. p. 7 0.1 in models with radial drift <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> Furthermore, the total element ratios reveal an enhancement of gas-phase volatiles at the icelines and the depletion of ices due to transport <ref:2202.02483#pg2>

Caveats and Future Work

The authors note several caveats, including the use of only one cosmic ray ionization rate (CRIR) in their main model series <ref:2202.02483#pg2> The choice of timescale over which to consider the evolution, 105 yr, is motivated by the desire to follow the chemistry to the point of first planet formation within the IOPF scenario <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> Future work is needed to explore two and three-dimensional models and effects of chemical model uncertainties <ref:2202.02483#pg2>

Conclusions

The authors conclude that pebble drift enriches the inner disk with solids, while depleting the outer disk <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Gas-grain reactions of gas-phase CO continuously supplies the protoplanetary disk with H2O ice, which then drift towards its iceline where it sublimates and enhances water vapor abundance by more than two orders of magnitude <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> The resulting composition of the disk is affected by its previous history, i. p. 0e., evolving from a state with a greater accretion rate <ref:2202. p. 102483#pg2> The final results suggest that accreted planetary atmospheres in the inner disk, relevant for IOPF, should also have this low value of C/O <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> The paper represents the first predictions for chemical compositions of planets forming in the Inside-Out Planet Formation scenario <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2>

References

The authors thank an anonymous referee for comments that helped to improve the paper <ref:2202.02483#pg2> They also thank Christian Eistrup for helpful discussions <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> This work is based on that submitted in partial requirements for Mr. p. 1 Arturo Cevallos Soto’s Masters thesis in Physics at Chalmers University of Technology, supervised by Prof. p. 0 Jonathan C. p. 0 Tan <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> The data from the computed models is available upon request to the authors <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> The paper has been typeset from a TEX/LATEX file prepared by the author <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2>

Figure Captions

Figure 1 shows the radial profiles of disk properties, showing an evolutionary sequence for an exponentially decaying accretion rate from m¤ = 10−8 M yr−1 to m¤ = 10−9 M yr−1 in 105 years <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Figure 3 shows the radial drift velocities obtained using equation 16 of various pebble sizes for the physical conditions of our model <ref:2202. p. 302483#pg2> Figure 4 shows the values of the dust-to-gas mass ratio (D/G) after 105 years of evolution <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure 5 shows the final abundances of C and O-bearing species with respect to H nuclei after 105 years of evolution of the disk for cases (a) to (f) <ref:2202. p. 802483#pg2> Figure 6 shows the final abundances for N-bearing species <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure 7 shows three cases evidencing the varying location of icelines and chemistry for different accretion rates <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Figure 8 shows the final total C/H, O/H and N/H ratios after 105 years <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure 9 shows the final C/O ratio after 105 years for Cases (a) to (f) <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure 10 compares the final C/O ratio after 105 years for atomic and molecular variations of Case (f) with the fiducial pre-aged result <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure A1 shows the enclosed gas mass profiles for the models with 10−8 (blue line) and 10−9 M yr−1 (red line) accretion rates <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> Figure A3 compares the chemical abundances of Case (f) and Case (g) <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure A4 shows the final C/O ratios of Case (f) (blue) and Case (g) <ref:2202. p. 202483#pg2> Figure B1 shows the effect of initial chemical abundances and cosmic ray ionization rate <ref:2202. p. 1 p. 102483#pg2> Figure B5 shows the final abundances of C and O-bearing species with respect to H nuclei after 105 years of evolution for cases (a) to (f) <ref:2202. p. 802483#pg2> Figure B6 shows the final abundances for N-bearing species <ref:2202. p. 502483#pg2> Figure A4 shows the final C/O ratios (gas phase - dotted lines; ice phase - solid lines) of Case (f) (blue) and Case (g) <ref:2202. p. 802483#pg2> Figure B1 shows the effect of initial chemical abundances and cosmic ray ionization rate <ref:2202.02483#pg2> Figure A3 shows the left column: Final abundances for Case (f) (i. p. 2e., evolved for 105 years; same as shown in Figs. p. 7 5 and 6) <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> Figure A3 shows the right column:: Final abundances for Case (g) (i. p. 2e., evolved for 1 Myr) <ref:2202. p. 002483#pg2> Figure B1 shows the top three rows of Figures B1 and B5 show the chemical evolution after 105 years of the same species as Figure 5 plus CH3OH for the Molecular initial condition <ref:2202.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved modeling of planet formation scenarios will allow AI systems to predict volatile-poor compositions for close-in Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes by accurately simulating Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF).

  2. AI systems can simulate the radial drift of pebbles, enabling them to predict how volatile species are transported from the outer disk inward, which is crucial for understanding planetary core composition.

  3. AI systems can model chemical evolution coupled with physical transport mechanisms to predict changes in gas and ice phase abundances over time, allowing for predictions of atmospheric compositions based on where icelines move.

  4. The improved models allow AI to calculate the total element ratios (C/H, O/H, N/H) across eight distinct regions within a protoplanetary disk based on the location of various icelines.

  5. AI systems can predict that gas-phase C/O ratios at the water iceline reach values of 0.1 in models with radial drift and gas advection over 105 years, which is relevant for predicting atmospheric compositions of planets forming in situ via IOPF.

Sources

Related papers