Unraveling heat transport and dissipation in suspended MoSe 2 crystals from bulk to monolayer
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Unraveling heat transport and dissipation in suspended MoSe 2 crystals from bulk to monolayer".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Understanding thermal transport in layered transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) crystals is crucial for a myriad of applications exploiting these materials.
Kai: This paper presents a combined experimental-theoretical study of the intrinsic lattice thermal conductivity of the representative TMD MoSe2, focusing on the effect of material thickness and the material’s environment.
Mira: Experimental Methodology The researchers employ Raman thermometry measurements on suspended crystals to identify and eliminate crucial artefacts.
Kai: They use continuous wave (CW) light with a wavelength of 532 nm to heat a local spot in the center of a suspended MoSe2 crystal, and subsequent cooling occurs by radial, diffusive flow of heat towards the edge.
Paper summary: Kai: So looking back at "Unraveling heat transport and dissipation in suspended MoSe two crystals from bulk to monolayer," the authors found that the inplane lattice thermal conductivity kappa doesn't change much as you go from bulk to monolayer, showing only a factor two variation <ref:2109.09225#pg1,Unraveling heat transport and dissipation in suspended>.
Mira: And they pointed out that the environment has a strong effect, especially for monolayer MoSe two because of this significant out-of-plane heat dissipation with that large heat transfer coefficient they measured up to thirty thousand watts per Kelvin <ref:2109.09225#pg1>.
Lev: What this means for us is that when we design thermal management systems for these materials, you can't ignore the surrounding environment; you need to account for that substantial cooling effect.
Kai: They also emphasized the importance of using gold-coated substrates with large holes to get those reliable intrinsic thermal conductivities because it leads to efficient heat sinking in their experiments.
Mira: The work provides a basis for understanding how this thermal transport behaves across different thicknesses, which is important guidance for investigating other TMD materials.
Lev: It suggests that the physics governing this transport is quite generalizable across the family of layered TMD materials, mainly differing by the atomic mass between tungsten, molybdenum, sulfur and selenium.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've seen how they studied heat transport in these suspended MoSe two crystals, going from thick bulk material down to just one layer and then looking at how the environment messes with it.
Mira: Yeah, that paper, "Unraveling heat transport and dissipation in suspended MoSe two crystals from bulk to monolayer," is basically mapping out exactly what's happening thermally inside this crystal structure.
Lev: I mean, they used Raman thermometry to measure things directly on these suspended samples, which is a solid experimental setup for getting intrinsic properties.
Kai: They confirmed that the inplane thermal conductivity doesn't change drastically between the bulk and the monolayer limit, showing only a factor two variation.
Mira: And that's interesting because it means we can really trust their measurements to represent the fundamental physics of these layered materials across different thicknesses.
Lev: The big thing they found is how much power is lost out of plane, especially for those monolayer crystals, which they quantified with a pretty large heat transfer coefficient.
Kai: So what this implies for us in the quantum hardware world is that thermal management in these devices depends heavily on the surrounding air or whatever medium you have near it.
Mira: Exactly. It shows that just knowing the material's intrinsic properties isn't enough; you have to consider how it interacts with its surroundings for real-world applications.
Lev: And they pointed out that this trend is generally true for other layered materials, not just MoSe two which gives us a broader framework to think about thermal engineering these 2D systems <ref:2109.09225#pg1>.
Kai: It really shows that we can use these experimental results to guide how we approach thermal transport in other TMDs as well.
D. Saleta Reig, S. Varghese, R. Farris, A. Block, J. D. Mehew, O. Hellman, P. Wožniak, Ü Sledzinska, ¡ El Sachat, E Chávez-Angel, S O Valenzuela, N F Van Hulst, P Ordej༹n, Z Zanolli, Ã M Sotomayor Torres, Ü M J Verstraete, Ÿ K J Tielrooij
Catalan Institute of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology (ICN2) · Linkཀྵping University · ICFO – Institut de Ci༾ncies Fotòniques · ICREA · Debye Institute for Nanomaterials Science, Utrecht University · Nanomat · Q-Mat · Е European Theoretical Spectroscopy Facility
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2021-09-19
Updated: 2021-09-19
Journal ref: Advanced Materials 34 2108352 (2022)
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 74/100
The gist: Understanding thermal transport in layered transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) crystals is crucial for a myriad of applications exploiting these materials.
Key concepts
- In-plane lattice thermal conductivity (κ)
- This measures how well heat travels within the crystal plane. It is calculated by observing how temperature changes when a local spot is heated and then cooling occurs, using specific Raman measurements on suspended crystals.
- Phonon modes
- These are quantized vibrations of the atoms within the material that carry heat. The study found that in thin MoSe2, low-energy flexural modes become very important, compensating for fewer high-frequency vibrational modes as thickness decreases.
- Out-of-plane heat dissipation
- This refers to heat escaping vertically from the crystal surface into the surrounding air. For monolayer MoSe2, this loss is significant (over 80% of thermal power), leading to a very large heat transfer coefficient, showing environment plays a major cooling role.
Terminology
Summary
Understanding thermal transport in layered transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) crystals is crucial for a myriad of applications exploiting these materials. p. 0 This paper presents a combined experimental-theoretical study of the intrinsic lattice thermal conductivity of the representative TMD MoSe2, focusing on the effect of material thickness and the material’s environment. p. 0
Experimental Methodology
The researchers employ Raman thermometry measurements on suspended crystals to identify and eliminate crucial artefacts. They use continuous wave (CW) light with a wavelength of 532 nm to heat a local spot in the center of a suspended MoSe2 crystal, and subsequent cooling occurs by radial, diffusive flow of heat towards the edge. p. 1 They vary the thickness from monolayer (1L) up to ∼70 layers (70L), corresponding to a range from 0. p. 17 nm up to ∼50 nm. The in-plane thermal conductivity κ is extracted using the equation κ = α · 1 / (2πd · ∂T /∂Pabs − 1 · ln R/r0). p. 2
Thickness Dependence and Phonon Contributions
The study finds that the main contribution to the in-plane thermal conductivity in few-layer MoSe2 comes from phonon modes centered around 1 THz. Towards the monolayer limit, this contribution decreases substantially due to fewer modes and decreasing phonon lifetimes. p. 1 This decrease is counteracted by the appearance of “surface” modes well below 1 THz with a long mean free path (MFP) of several micrometers, which significantly contribute to thermal transport. p. 1 The in-plane thermal conductivity is mostly constant up to a thickness of ∼10 layers with κ ∼20 Wm91K91 (∼25 Wm91K91) after which it increases towards ∼40 Wm91K91 for bulk. p. 1 Theoretical simulations show a weak effect of crystal thickness on the thermal conductivity, with results in good agreement with experiments. p. 5
Environmental Effects and Dissipation
Thermal transport is strongly affected by the material’s environment, particularly for monolayer crystals where >80% of the thermal power is lost through out-of-plane heat dissipation to surrounding molecules. The authors extract a remarkably large heat transfer coefficient hc up to 30,000 Wm92K91 for monolayer MoSe2. p. 1 This demonstrates that out-of-plane heat dissipation to air plays an important role in the cooling dynamics of suspended ultrathin materials. p. 7
Theoretical Insights into Phonons
Density functional theory simulations using the TemperatureDependent Effective Potential (TDEP) method compute the phonon dispersion and anharmonic terms to obtain the in-plane lattice thermal conductivity κ. For bulk MoSe2, both experimental and theoretical values give a κ of ∼40 Wm91K91, which is close to literature values. p. 5 The simulation results reveal that towards the monolayer limit, the decreasing contribution to κ from modes around 1 THz is compensated by the increasing contribution of modes with a much lower frequency, in particular a low-energy flexural mode. p. 7
Conclusion and Significance
The work establishes how the inplane lattice thermal conductivity κ depends on crystal thickness, showing a relatively weak effect within a factor two. The study also highlights the importance of using gold-coated substrates with relatively large holes to obtain reliable intrinsic thermal conductivities. p. 8 Finally, it demonstrates a very strong effect of the environment on thermal transport in monolayer MoSe2 due to out-of-plane heat dissipation with a surprisingly large heat transfer coefficient. p. 8 The results provide essential guidance for the thermal investigation of other TMD materials. p. 8
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The authors confirm the validity of both full Raman thermometry simulation and the simplified Raman thermometry equation (Eq. (1) in the main text), which confirms the validity of both approaches. p. 2 The comparison between experimental and theoretical results shows good agreement, with simulated values slightly higher than experimental results with ∼20 Wm91K91. p. 5
How the training signal is built
The Raman spectra were collected with a Horiba T64000 Raman spectrometer and a laser beam, with a wavelength of λ = 532 nm, focused to a 1/e spot size of ∼1 µm. The temperature increase is defined as ∆T = (νP − νP =0)/χT, with νP =0 the intercept from the linear fit of Raman shift with laser power. p. 9 The temperature coefficients χT change from 90. p. 2007 cm91/K for bulk to 90. p. 2015 cm91/K for monolayer MoSe2. p. 2
Where the gains come from
The authors conclude that it is crucial to use gold-coated substrates with relatively large holes, as this leads to efficient heat sinking, such that Eq. (1) is valid. p. 2 They attribute the discrepancy between experimental literature values and their systematic variation to the fact that not all measurements were performed under the same conditions nor with similar substrates. p. 4 The agreement between theoretical and experimental results suggests that the trend observed is representative of the broader family of layered TMD materials. p. 5
The authors note that phonons with a MFP 90% of the total thermal conductivity, confirming that the experimental hole size is not significantly affecting the extracted κ through edge scattering. The agreement with experiments is a further confirmation of the very clean and ideal nature of the experimental samples. p. 7
The study shows that out-of-plane boundary scattering does not play any role for the in-plane thermal conductivity of 2D van der Waals bonded TMDs. This is in large contrast with thin films of 3D bonded materials, where the thermal conductivity is typically thought to be limited by boundary scattering at the film surface. p. 7 The very long lifetimes of low energy modes in thin MoSe2 are made possible by the weakness of the van der Waals interlayer scattering, which is generic for all 2D materials. p. 7
The cumulative thermal conductivity in the monolayer case is carried by an increased fraction of low-frequency modes with a relatively long MFP. The most striking effect is the increasingly strong contribution of the flexural mode situated at ∼0. p. 71 THz for thin MoSe2. p. 7 This compensation results in an overall weak effect of material thickness on κ. p. 7
The relative power losses to air are much larger than in the case of graphene because the inplane thermal conductivity of monolayer MoSe2 is much smaller than that of graphene. The heat loss fraction ζ is found to be ∼20% for the lowest surface-to-volume ratio, which can be reproduced with a heat transfer coefficient hc of ∼5,000 Wm92K91. p. 7 The authors find that cooling is significantly more efficient for atomically thin crystals than for thicker crystals. p. 7
The simulation of the Raman thermometry experiment confirms the validity of both full Raman thermometry simulation and the simplified Raman thermometry equation (Eq. (1) in the main text). p. 1 p. 1 The comparison with experimental situation is achieved by extracting the part of the steady state heat profile that is being probed by the Raman laser. p. 2 p. 2
The authors note that many of these results represent essential guidance for the thermal investigation of other TMD materials. This work provides a basis to understand and engineer thermal transport properties of a broad class of materials with promising applications in thermal management, energy materials and (opto)electronic devices. p. 8 p. 8 p. 8
The results are representative for other TMDs as the obtained results focus on MoSe2 crystals but the findings are generalizable across the family of TMD materials. p. 1 The small difference in κ between different materials is mainly related to the difference in the atomic mass between W, Mo, S and Se. p. 3 p. 3
The agreement with literature values suggests that previous theoretical works may have been limited by different approaches and accuracy used. The extrapolation of κ by fitting the values obtained for different grids of q-points is done because a finite q-point grid usually underestimates the results. p. 9 p. 9 The small differences between theoretical and experimental results are attributed to the approximations used in both methods. p. 5
The simulation of Raman thermometry experiment confirms the validity of both full Raman thermometry simulation and the simplified Raman thermometry equation (Eq. (1) in the main text). The comparison with experimental situation is achieved by extracting the part of the steady state heat profile that is being probed by the Raman laser.
The authors note that many of these results represent essential guidance for the thermal investigation of other TMD materials. This work provides a basis to understand and engineer thermal transport properties of a broad class of materials with promising applications in thermal management, energy materials and (opto)electronic devices. The results are representative for other TMDs as the obtained results focus on MoSe2 crystals but the findings are generalizable across the family of TMD materials.
The authors note that many of these results represent essential guidance for the thermal investigation of other TMD materials. This work provides a basis to understand and engineer thermal transport properties of a broad class of materials with promising applications in thermal management, energy materials and (opto)electronic devices.
The results are representative for other TMDs as the obtained results focus on MoSe2 crystals but the findings are generalizable across the family of TMD materials. The small difference in κ between different materials is mainly related to the difference in the atomic mass between W, Mo, S and Se. The extrapolation of κ by fitting the values obtained for different grids of q-points is done because a finite q-point grid usually underestimates the results.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved material property prediction for 2D materials by incorporating thickness dependence into thermal conductivity models. The improved system can predict in-plane lattice thermal conductivity kappa as a function of crystal thickness, specifically showing
a relatively weak effect of crystal thickness on the lattice thermal conductivity kappa – within a factor two.
-
Enhanced experimental data interpretation for Raman thermometry by implementing rigorous checks for substrate-induced artefacts. The improved system can distinguish between intrinsic material properties and experimental noise by confirming that
gold-coated substrates with relatively large holes, with a radius of at least 5 µm, lead to an overestimation of kappa
when compared toartifact-free substrates.
-
Development of a comprehensive thermal management strategy for ultrathin devices by modeling out-of-plane heat dissipation. The improved system can calculate the
heat loss fraction zeta of ∼20% for the lowest surface-to-volume ratio
and predict that cooling issignificantly more efficient for atomically thin crystals than for thicker crystals.
-
Integration of first principles simulations with experimental observables to validate phonon transport mechanisms. The improved system can use Density Functional Theory in combination with the TemperatureDependent Effective Potential method to show
a weak effect of crystal thickness on the thermal conductivity,
specifically by identifying thatthe decreasing contribution to kappa from modes around 1 THz is compensated by the increasing contribution of modes with a much lower frequency.
-
Creation of an environment-aware thermal transport model for suspended materials. The improved system can predict that
athermal transport is strongly affected by the material’s environment,
specifically quantifying the effect of air versus vacuum, noting thatthe presence of air introduces an additional cooling channel
leading to amuch larger
effect on monolayer MoSe2 than on graphene.
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion