Activity induced nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Activity induced nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Activity induced nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals shows that activity itself can give rise to nematic order and that this physics is already present in the dynamical equations of active nematic fluids The paper rigorously shows the development of activity induced nematic order in active nematics through a linear stability analysis, thus predicting the conditions that lead to this order Governing Equations The continuum model considers a suspension of active particles with nematic symmetry, where the nematic order is described by a symmetric, traceless, second rank tensor Q(x, t).
Kai: The active nematic equations of motion couple the evolution of the order parameter Q and the associated incompressible fluid velocity u.
Mira: The stress tensor is composed of three parts: viscous stress, passive stress, and active stress.
Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper, the authors are focusing on how activity drives nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals by using linear stability analysis to predict when it will happen <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: They've shown that ordering is favored when the particles are flow-aligning and strongest when the wavevector of that order perturbation isn't parallel or perpendicular to the director <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: For real hardware, this means we need to be careful about how activity couples with our existing elastic terms; if lambda zeta is positive, we predict an instability that could lead to structure formation <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Kai: It really frames activity not just as noise, but as a potential source of order under specific physical conditions <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: The paper connects the theory of active liquid crystals to fluid mechanical approaches for active matter, suggesting a deeper understanding of how these systems behave <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: It’s a solid theoretical prediction, but we still need to figure out the practical overhead for implementing such an effect in a physical device <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about how just making things move—activity—can actually create an ordered structure in liquid crystals even when everything looks completely random <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: It’s interesting because it suggests that activity isn't just noise; it’s a source of organization itself, which is something we usually think about in terms of external fields or temperature changes <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: If this holds up, it means the microscopic energy conversion mechanism, that active stress term, can drive the system toward a nematic state on its own <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Kai: So the authors used linear stability analysis to predict exactly when this ordering happens in an isotropic fluid setup <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: They showed that activity plays a destabilizing role proportional to the wave number, while the physical elastic terms provide a stabilizing effect that scales differently with that wave number <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: From my side, if we're building this on real hardware, we have to watch that competition between activity and rotational diffusion; it seems like rotation is the thing trying to keep things messy <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Kai: It points to a specific condition—a critical wave number where this exponential growth of order starts happening <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: And the authors found that when the director field fluctuations are at a specific angle, like pi over four, the growth rate actually hits zero <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: That’s a bit of a nice detail, but it doesn't solve how to scale that effect up from these lab simulations to something you could actually see in a device <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Kai: Exactly. It bridges the gap between the mathematical prediction and what we actually need to build and measure in our labs <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Mira: The implication is that understanding these active systems requires coupling fluid mechanics with liquid crystal theory in a way that accounts for this activity-induced order <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Lev: So we have a better map for what kind of instabilities to look out for when we design active materials, even if the practical implementation still has some major hurdles <ref:1912.05201#pg3>.
Sreejith Santhosh, Mehrana R. Nejad, Amin Doostmohammadi, Julia M. Yeomans, Sumesh P. Thampi
Indian Institute of Technology Madras Chennai · Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics Clarendon Laboratory Oxford · Niels Bohr Institute Copenhagen
cond-mat.soft, physics.flu-dyn
Submitted: 2019-12-11
Updated: 2019-12-11
Journal ref: J. Stat. Phys. 180, 699-709 (2020)
DOI: 10.1007/s10955-020-02497-0
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 78/100
The gist: Activity induced nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals shows that activity itself can give rise to nematic order and that this physics is already present in the dynamical equations of active…
Key concepts
- Nematic Order Parameter Q(x, t)
- This tensor describes the alignment of active particles. It is a mathematical tool used to quantify how the particles are organized—specifically, whether they exhibit orientational order like a liquid crystal, even when the system is initially isotropic (randomly oriented).
- Active Stress ($Ψactiveij = -βQ_{ij}$)
- This stress arises from the microscopic energy conversion mechanism of the active particles. Essentially, each active particle generates a local flow field that contributes to the overall stress of the fluid. This term is crucial because it drives the system away from equilibrium and promotes pattern formation.
- Linear Stability Analysis
- This mathematical technique is used to predict how small disturbances in a uniform (isotropic) state will evolve over time. By linearizing the governing equations, researchers found a dispersion relation that shows whether these disturbances will grow (instability) or decay, allowing them to pinpoint the exact conditions for nematic order development.
Terminology
Summary
Activity induced nematic order in isotropic liquid crystals shows that activity itself can give rise to nematic order and that this physics is already present in the dynamical equations of active nematic fluids The paper rigorously shows the development of activity induced nematic order in active nematics through a linear stability analysis, thus predicting the conditions that lead to this order
Governing Equations
The continuum model considers a suspension of active particles with nematic symmetry, where the nematic order is described by a symmetric, traceless, second rank tensor Q(x, t). The active nematic equations of motion couple the evolution of the order parameter Q and the associated incompressible fluid velocity u. p. 2 The stress tensor is composed of three parts: viscous stress, passive stress, and active stress. p. 2
-
The viscous stress is written as a Newtonian constitutive relation. p. 2
-
The passive contribution involves terms related to pressure P and the molecular field H. p. 3
-
The final contribution is the active stress generated by the microscopic energy conversion mechanism, given by Πactiveij = −ζQij. p. 3
Linear Stability Analysis
The linear stability analysis examines a static fluid of active particles in an isotropic configuration where S = 0. By linearizing the governing equations, the dispersion relation is obtained, which describes the evolution of the perturbed state through a nonlinear relation between wavenumber q and frequency ω. p. 4 The dispersion relation is given by ρω2 + q2(ωβ + 2λ cos2θ sin2θ(λκq2) - ζ) + Γ κq2η = 0. p. 4 This equation shows that activity ζ plays a destabilising role proportional to q in the evolution of the frequency ω, while the stabilising effect of orientational elasticity, κ, is proportional to q2. p. 4
Physical Mechanism
The physical mechanism involves each active particle creating a dipolar flow field. In an isotropic arrangement, these dipolar flows cancel on sufficiently large length scales resulting in no net flow everywhere in the system. p. 7 If a fluctuation generates a local nematic alignment of active particles, this results in the generation of locally shearing flow fields. p. 7 This leads to a bootstrap effect where stronger alignment generates stronger flows that generate stronger alignment. p. 7 The rotational diffusion tends to restore isotropic order and suppress the growth of the instability. p. 7
Numerical Simulations
Numerical simulations were performed using a method of lines for the evolution equation, employing a lattice Boltzmann method for Navier Stokes equations. Simulations confirm the predictions of linear stability analysis, showing that an imposed perturbation grows at the excited wavenumber q = 0. p. 912. Furthermore, simulations show that at later times, larger wavelengths (smaller wavenumbers q < 0. p. 912) are excited, which is consistent with the long wavelength instability predicted by the dispersion relation. p. 9 The growth rates obtained from simulations match well with the analytical results derived from linear stability analysis. p. 9
Discussion
The competition between activity and rotational diffusion results in a critical wave number below which exponential growth of nematic order is predicted. The bifurcation for the parameter combination λζ indicates that if λζ 0. p. 5 The angular dependence shows that when the wavevector describes fluctuations in the director field at an angle π/4 with the director field, then the growth rate is zero. p. 6 This instability associated with nematic order development precedes the bend-splay instability of an established nematically ordered state. p. 5 The work establishes a link between the theory of active liquid crystals and fluid mechanical approaches to active matter. p. 1
References
- T. Sanchez, D.T. Chen, S.J. DeCamp, M. Heymann, Z. Dogic, Nature 491(7424), 431
26 P de Gennes, J Prost, The Physics of Liquid Crystals. International series of monographs on physics (Clarendon Press, 1993)
3 A Beris, B Edwards, Thermodynamics of Flowing Systems: with Internal Microstructure. Oxford Engineering Science Series (Oxford University Press, 1994)
4 G Duclos, C Blanch-Mercader, V Yashunsky, G Salbreux, JF Joanny, J Prost, P Silberzan Nat. Phys. 14(7), 728 (2018)
5 T B Saw, A Doostmohammadi, V Nier, L Kocgozlu S Thampi Y Toyama P Marcq C T Lim J M Yeomans B Ladoux Nature 544(7649), 212 (2017)
6 R Di Leonardo L Angelani D DellArciprete G Ruocco V Iebba S Schippa M Conte F Mecarini F De Angelis E Di Fabrizio Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107(21), 9541 (2010)
7 S Ramaswamy Annu Rev Condens Matter Phys. 1(1), 323 (2010)
8 C Bechinger R Di Leonardo H Lowen C Reichhardt G Volpe G Volpe Rev Mod. Phys. 88(4), 045006 (2016)
9 P Illien R Golestanian A Sen Chem Soc Rev. 46(18), 5508 (2017)
10 M C Marchetti J F Joanny S Ramaswamy T B Liverpool J Prost M Rao R A Simha Rev Mod. Phys. 85(3), 1143 (2013)
12 S P Thampi R Golestanian J M Yeomans Phil Trans R Soc A 372(2029), 20130366 (2014)
14 E Tjhung D Marenduzzo M E Cates Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109(31), 12381 (2012)
27 A Beris B Edwards Thermodynamics of Flowing Systems: with Internal Microstructure Oxford Engineering Science Series (Oxford University Press, 1994)
30 S Edwards J Yeomans Europhys. Lett. 85(1), 18008 (2009)
37 D Marenduzzo E Orlandini M Cates J Yeomans Phys Rev E 76(3), 031921 (2007)
44 G Subramanian D L Koch J Fluid Mech. 632, 359 (2009)
45 D Saintillan M J Shelley Phys Rev Lett. 100(17), 178103 (2008)
46 D Saintillan M J Shelley Phys Fluids 20(12), 123304 (2008)
55 S P Thampi A Doostmohammadi R Golestanian J M Yeomans Europhys. Lett. 112(2), 28004 (2015)
66 P de Gennes J Prost The Physics of Liquid Crystals International series of monographs on physics (Clarendon Press, 1993)
77 A Beris B Edwards Thermodynamics of Flowing Systems: with Internal Microstructure Oxford Engineering Science Series (Oxford University Press, 1994)
88 R A Simha S Ramaswamy Phys Rev Lett. 89(5), 058101 (2002)
13 L Giomi M J Bowick X Ma M C Marchetti Phys Rev Lett. 110(22), 228101 (2013)
47 E Tjhung D Marenduzzo M E Cates Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109(31), 12381 (2012)
48 K T Wu J B Hishamunda D T Chen S J DeCamp Y W Chang A Fern´andezNieves S Fraden Z Dogic Science 355(6331), eaal1979 (2017)
49 F C Keber E Loiseau T Sanchez S J DeCamp L Giomi M J Bowick M C Marchetti Z Dogic A R Bausch Science 345(6201), 1135 (2014)
50 L Metselaar J M Yeomans A Doostmohammadi Phys Rev Lett. 123, 208001 (2019)
56 K Kawaguchi R Kageyama M Sano Nature 545, 327 (2017)
67 D Volfson S Cookson J Hasty L S Tsimring Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105, 15346 (2008)
68 D Nishiguchi K H Nagai H Chat´e M Sano Phys Rev E 95(2), 020601 (2017)
73 R A Simha S Ramaswamy Phys Rev Lett. 89(5), 058101 (2002)
74 R Voituriez J F Joanny J Prost Europhys. Lett. 70(3), 404 (2005)
76 P Chaikin T Lubensky Principles of Condensed Matter Physics Cambridge University Press (2000)
78 G Toth C Denniston J M Yeomans Phys Rev Lett. 88(10), 105504 (2002)
79 S Edwards J Yeomans Europhys. Lett. 85(1), 18008 (2009)
84 P D Olmsted P M Goldbart Phys Rev A 46(8), 4966 (1992)
75 E Lauga T R Powers Rep Prog. Phys. 72(9), 096601 (2009)
85 D Saintillan M J Shelley Phys Rev Lett.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Dynamic prediction of nematic order onset in isotropic active systems can be achieved by using a linear stability analysis to determine conditions for instability. This allows an AI system to predict when activity itself causes nematic order, contrasting with assuming it from a pre-defined free energy.
-
The improved system can model the evolution of the magnitude of the nematic order parameter S over time and space using numerical methods like lattice Boltzmann or method of lines. This enables simulation of how initial perturbations grow at specific wavenumbers, confirming predictions from linear stability analysis for a given activity level ζ.
-
The AI system can quantify the growth rate omega s by fitting the spatially averaged squared difference of the order parameter to an exponential function e2ωst to extract its value as a function of wavenumber q. This provides quantitative agreement between simulation results and analytical dispersion relations, such as equation (14).
-
The system can predict the critical wave number qc below which instability occurs, calculated using the formula qc = s λζ / 2κ (2ηΓ + λ2). This allows for the calculation of an active length scale p κ / ζ based on physical parameters like viscosity η and rotational diffusivity Γ.
-
The AI system can analyze the dependence of growth rate omega max and most unstable wavenumber qmax on the angle theta between the wavevector and director field. This reveals that
when theta approaches 0 or pi/2 both qmax and ωmax drop to zero indicating that there is no nematic order development along or perpendicular to the director.
Related papers
- Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles
- Three-body corrections to the Brownian viscosity of hard spheres without hydrodynamic interactions
- Thin active nematohydrodynamic layers: asymptotic theories and instabilities
- Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid
- Soft material mechanical property degradation at high strain rates
- Avalanche criticality emerges by thermal fluctuation in a quiescent glass