Thermality from a Rindler quench

arXiv:1807.04584 · gr-qc, cond-mat.quant-gas, hep-th · Submitted 2018-07-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Thermality from a Rindler quench".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ultracold fermionic atoms in an optical lattice with a sudden position-dependent change in the effective dispersion relation have been proposed as an analogue spacetime test of the Unruh effect The quench is energetically mild, and late time static observers see thermality at a temperature equal to the Unruh temperature for asymptotic Rindler domains These results strengthen the motivation to realize the experimental proposal.

Kai: Analogue System Setup The system analyzed consists of fermionic atoms held in an optical lattice with a dispersion relation that can depend on both space and time The spacetime metric is engineered to undergo a sudden change, a quench, from the (2 + 1)-dimensional Minkowski metric to a metric given by the (1 + 1)-dimensional part ds2 = −χ2/dη2 + dχ2 (1.1) plus one flat spatial dimension The field’s behaviour at constant χ, sufficiently far from χ = 0 in terms of the lattice scale, has thermal characteristics in a position-dependent temperature that approximates 1/(2πχ) This thermality is interpreted as an analogue of the Unruh effect because the regions χ > 0 and χ < 0 of (1.1) each cover one Rindler wedge of Minkowski spacetime, the worldlines of constant χ ≠ 0 have proper acceleration 1/χ, and the usual Unruh effect states that an observer in a Rindler wedge at constant χ experiences the Minkowski vacuum as thermal at the Unruh temperature 1/(2πχ) Challenges and Simplifications The optical lattice quench and the usual Unruh effect setup have three qualitative differences that could potentially limit the ability of the lattice to simulate the Unruh effect First, in the usual setup, the field is prepared in its Minkowski vacuum, implying that by contrast, a sudden quench can be expected to inject energy into the field Second, the degeneracy of (1.1) at χ = 0 gets regularised in

34, 35: , and the results are found to be relatively insensitive to this regulator when it is small Third, the latticeregularised metric does not have a counterpart of the Minkowski spacetime future and past quadrants that join the two Rindler wedges in the usual setup.

Mira: Post-Quench Field Dynamics The analysis proceeds by quantizing a massless scalar field on the quench spacetime, separating it into pre-quench and post-quench regions In the pre-quench region, standard Fock quantisation adapted to the Killing vector ∂t is employed with mode functions uω,ǫ = 1/√4πω exp

-iω(η − ǫx): In the post-quench region, standard Fock quantisation adapted to the Killing vector ∂η is used with mode functions Uomega,ǫ = 1/√4πomega exp

-iomega(η − ǫy): The Bogoliubov transformation relates these modes at t = 0, yielding coefficients αomegaω and βomegaω Thermal Response Analysis The post-quench Wightman function W(x, x') is evaluated using the pre-quench Minkowski vacuum state 0M i>, leading to a closed form expression for W(x, x') The asymptotic late time form of W(x, x') is given by (4.11) When the detector operates such that the transition rate takes the Planckian form F˙(E) = E e E/Tχ - 1, it is found to be thermal in temperature Tχ This response is approximately Planckian at approximately the usual Unruh temperature 1/(2πχ) at proper times much larger and much smaller than χ ln(2χ/b) when χ ≠ 0 and b ≪ χ The regularised quench produces a well-defined stress-energy tensor everywhere to the future of the quench The 'total energy' at constant η, Eη, is finite for all η and increases monotonically from 0 to 1/(16πb) as η increases from 0 to infinity These results strengthen the motivation to realize the experimental proposal of

34, 35: The Wightman function could be used to study spatial entanglement by harvesting techniques

42, 1807.04584> However, a pair of Unruh-DeWitt detectors coupled linearly to the proper time derivative avoids infrared ambiguity and shows that the regularised quench makes the detector respond identically to the Unruh effect The short distance properties of the twice differentiated Wightman function require detectors to be smeared in time and space, suggesting a need for a numerical approach. [Kai: Acknowledgments This work originated at a June 2018 Unruh effect workshop organised at the University of Nottingham by Silke Weinfurtner The authors thank the workshop participants, particularly Alessio Celi, for stimulating discussions This work was supported in part by Science and Technology Facilities Council (Theory Consolidated Grant ST/P000703/1).

Title and authors: Kai: So let's start with the title and who wrote this paper, "Thermality from a Rindler quench." The authors are Rodríguez-Laguna et al.

Mira: They are linking ultracold fermionic atoms in an optical lattice to testing the Unruh effect by using a sudden change or quench in the system's effective dispersion relation.

Lev: I wonder if this is just a theoretical exercise, or if they have actually built something that you can cool down and measure? What’s on the hardware side?

Kai: The authors are proposing this as an analogue spacetime test because they are analyzing a massless scalar field on a one plus one dimensional continuum spacetime with a similar quench.

Mira: They describe this as joining an early time Minkowski region at some constant time surface to a late time static region where the left and right asymptotic Rindler domains are connected by something that’s smooth negative curvature.

Lev: That's the geometry they are using, right? I wonder how much of this geometry they can actually control in their lab setup.

Kai: They are saying that this setup lets them study thermality in a temperature matching the Unruh temperature for observers in those asymptotic Rindler domains.

Mira: It’s important to note that they acknowledge there are three major qualitative differences between this lattice quench setup and the usual Unruh effect.

Lev: I'm interested in those differences. What do you think limits their ability to truly simulate the real thing?

Kai: First, in the standard setup, the field starts in its Minkowski vacuum state, which means its stress energy tensor has a zero expectation value. But here, a sudden quench can inject energy into the field, potentially quite a lot of it.

Mira: And second is this part where they mention that the degeneracy at kappa equals zero gets regularized by something related to the spatial lattice. They found their results are actually pretty insensitive to that regularization when it’s small.

Lev: That sounds like a good thing for experimentalists, because if it doesn't depend too much on how you regularize those points, it makes the simulation more robust.

The paper's summary: Kai: So to summarize this paper "Thermality from a Rindler quench," they are analyzing a massless scalar field on this (one + one) -dimensional continuum spacetime with a similar quench to the one in their physical system <ref:1807.04584#pg1,1 + 1)$-dimensional continuum spacetime with a similar quench>.

Mira: The key finding is that the late time static observers, when modeled as a derivative-coupling Unruh-DeWitt detector, see thermality at exactly the Unruh temperature for those asymptotic Rindler domains.

Lev: So they are confirming that under this specific quench scenario, you get thermal behavior even though you started with a non-vacuum state. That's a strong result if true.

Kai: It is significant because it shows that the analogue system works well for capturing the Unruh effect's temperature in this context.

Mira: They are also looking at how they do this by separating the field into pre-quench and post-quench regions, using different mode functions for each part.

Lev: I see them using Bogoliubov transformations to relate those modes across the quench point, which is standard practice in these types of calculations.

Kai: That matching process leads to a closed form expression for the Wightman function after the quench, and they find it has this specific late time asymptotic form.

Mira: This late time asymptotic form means that when you use a detector with a transition rate that follows Planckian statistics, the response is thermal at temperature T kappa.

The paper's improvements: Lev: Now let’s talk about what they suggest as improvements or new ideas in this work. They point out some qualitative differences between their setup and the standard Unruh effect simulation.

Kai: They highlight that the field is prepared in a Minkowski vacuum in the usual setup, but here, a sudden quench can inject energy into the field, potentially lots of it.

Mira: And they raise this as a point for discussion: does the post-quench stress-energy tensor stay small in some controllable sense? That’s their first big question.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that’s huge. If we can control the energy injection and keep the stress energy tensor manageable, that makes it much more realistic for hardware simulations.

Kai: They also discuss how the degeneracy at kappa equals zero gets regularized by a lattice structure, and they note their results are relatively insensitive to this regularization when it's small.

Mira: That insensitivity is important because it means the physics of the Unruh effect isn't being washed out by how you define the geometry at that specific point.

Lev: So, if they can show that this doesn't change their core temperature result much, that’s a big win for applying this to real hardware constraints.

Kai: And finally, they mention the metric doesn't have those standard Minkowski future and past quadrants joining the Rindler wedges as neatly as in the usual setup.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up "Thermality from a Rindler quench," they show that their regularized quench produces a well-defined stress energy tensor everywhere into the future of the quench.

Kai: They also find that the total energy at constant kappa, which they call E kappa, stays finite for all time and it increases monotonically from zero to one over sixteen pi times b as time goes to infinity <ref:1807.04584#pg1>.

Lev: That monotonic increase is interesting. It suggests that this system evolves in a controlled way without runaway energy or infinite buildup, which is good for stability checks.

Mira: This work strengthens the motivation for building these experimental proposals because it shows the results are robust even with the energy injection from the quench and after accounting for regularization.

Lev: I’m just saying that if you use a linear Unruh-DeWitt detector coupled to the proper time derivative of this field, it avoids some infrared ambiguity that can pop up in other calculations.

Kai: That detector response shows it behaves identically to the Unruh effect for fixed non-zero acceleration, which is exactly what they hoped for.

Mira: The final point is that because of the short distance properties of the twice differentiated Wightman function, they suggest detectors need to be smeared in both time and space, which points toward needing a numerical approach.

Lev: So it’s a solid piece of work showing the concept is viable even with these caveats about how we actually implement it in hardware.

University of Nottingham

gr-qc, cond-mat.quant-gas, hep-th

Submitted: 2018-07-12

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 16 pages. v4: typo eta -> t in (3.2) corrected

Journal ref: Class. Quant. Grav. 35, 205006 (2018)

DOI: 10.1088/1361-6382/aadb34

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: Ultracold fermionic atoms in an optical lattice with a sudden position-dependent change in the effective dispersion relation have been proposed as an analogue spacetime test of the Unruh effect The…

Key concepts

Analogue System Setup
The system uses fermionic atoms in an optical lattice where the dispersion relation changes suddenly (a quench). This engineered metric mimics a spacetime transition from Minkowski space to a different geometry, allowing researchers to study thermal effects in this controllable physical system.
Unruh Effect Analogue
The setup is analogous to the Unruh effect, where an observer accelerating in spacetime perceives the vacuum as thermal radiation. Here, regions of the lattice correspond to Rindler wedges, and observers experience a temperature proportional to 1/(2π|χ|), which is precisely the Unruh temperature for that acceleration.
Post-Quench Field Dynamics
The analysis quantizes a massless scalar field by splitting it into pre-quench and post-quench parts. This allows for calculating how the field modes change after the sudden quench, using Bogoliubov transformations to relate the initial and final states.

Terminology

Summary

Ultracold fermionic atoms in an optical lattice with a sudden position-dependent change in the effective dispersion relation have been proposed as an analogue spacetime test of the Unruh effect The quench is energetically mild, and late time static observers see thermality at a temperature equal to the Unruh temperature for asymptotic Rindler domains These results strengthen the motivation to realize the experimental proposal. p. 0

Analogue System Setup

The system analyzed consists of fermionic atoms held in an optical lattice with a dispersion relation that can depend on both space and time The spacetime metric is engineered to undergo a sudden change, a quench, from the (2 + 1)-dimensional Minkowski metric to a metric given by the (1 + 1)-dimensional part ds2 = −χ2/dη2 + dχ2 (1.1) plus one flat spatial dimension The field’s behaviour at constant χ, sufficiently far from χ = 0 in terms of the lattice scale, has thermal characteristics in a position-dependent temperature that approximates 1/(2πχ) This thermality is interpreted as an analogue of the Unruh effect because the regions χ > 0 and χ < 0 of (1. p. 11) each cover one Rindler wedge of Minkowski spacetime, the worldlines of constant χ ≠ 0 have proper acceleration 1/χ, and the usual Unruh effect states that an observer in a Rindler wedge at constant χ experiences the Minkowski vacuum as thermal at the Unruh temperature 1/(2πχ)

Challenges and Simplifications

The optical lattice quench and the usual Unruh effect setup have three qualitative differences that could potentially limit the ability of the lattice to simulate the Unruh effect First, in the usual setup, the field is prepared in its Minkowski vacuum, implying that by contrast, a sudden quench can be expected to inject energy into the field Second, the degeneracy of (1.1) at χ = 0 gets regularised in [34, 35], and the results are found to be relatively insensitive to this regulator when it is small Third, the latticeregularised metric does not have a counterpart of the Minkowski spacetime future and past quadrants that join the two Rindler wedges in the usual setup. p. 2

Post-Quench Field Dynamics

The analysis proceeds by quantizing a massless scalar field on the quench spacetime, separating it into pre-quench and post-quench regions In the pre-quench region, standard Fock quantisation adapted to the Killing vector ∂t is employed with mode functions uω,ǫ = 1/√4πω exp[-iω(η − ǫx)] In the post-quench region, standard Fock quantisation adapted to the Killing vector ∂η is used with mode functions Uomega,ǫ = 1/√4πomega exp[-iomega(η − ǫy)] The Bogoliubov transformation relates these modes at t = 0, yielding coefficients αomegaω and βomegaω

Thermal Response Analysis

The post-quench Wightman function W(x, x') is evaluated using the pre-quench Minkowski vacuum state 0M i>, leading to a closed form expression for W(x, x') The asymptotic late time form of W(x, x') is given by (4.11) When the detector operates such that the transition rate takes the Planckian form F˙(E) = E e E/Tχ - 1, it is found to be thermal in temperature Tχ This response is approximately Planckian at approximately the usual Unruh temperature 1/(2πχ) at proper times much larger and much smaller than χ ln(2χ/b) when χ ≠ 0 and b ≪ χ

Conclusion and Outlook

The regularised quench produces a well-defined stress-energy tensor everywhere to the future of the quench The 'total energy' at constant η, Eη, is finite for all η and increases monotonically from 0 to 1/(16πb) as η increases from 0 to infinity These results strengthen the motivation to realize the experimental proposal of [34, 35] The Wightman function could be used to study spatial entanglement by harvesting techniques [42, 1807.04584> However, a pair of Unruh-DeWitt detectors coupled linearly to the proper time derivative avoids infrared ambiguity and shows that the regularised quench makes the detector respond identically to the Unruh effect The short distance properties of the twice differentiated Wightman function require detectors to be smeared in time and space, suggesting a need for a numerical approach. p. 9

Acknowledgments

This work originated at a June 2018 Unruh effect workshop organised at the University of Nottingham by Silke Weinfurtner The authors thank the workshop participants, particularly Alessio Celi, for stimulating discussions This work was supported in part by Science and Technology Facilities Council (Theory Consolidated Grant ST/P000703/1).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved simulation of analogue spacetime tests can analyze massless scalar fields on (1 + 1)-dimensional continuum spacetimes with quenches, specifically joining an early time Minkowski region to a late time static region connected by a smooth negative curvature bridge. This allows for studying thermality in temperature that equals the Unruh temperature for observers in the asymptotic Rindler domains.

  2. Enhanced ability to model laboratory analogues of the Unruh effect by incorporating features like energetic and causal properties that differ from usual settings, such as sudden quenches and lattice regularization effects. The system can probe whether the quench is energetically mild even when energy is injected into the field, despite the absence of a late time Killing horizon.

  3. Capability to perform quantum field quantization in regions with different effective metrics, specifically quantizing a massless scalar field separately in the pre-quench region and the post-quench region. This enables the calculation of post-quench Wightman functions by matching pre-quench and post-quench mode functions using Bogoliubov transformation formalism.

  4. Analytical determination of the post-quench stress energy tensor using Hadamard renormalization, yielding well defined and finite results everywhere in the post-quench region. This allows for the analysis of how the initial negative pressure evolves at late times into a finite and static positive total energy.

  5. Assessment of thermality using a pointlike Unruh-DeWitt detector coupled linearly to the field's proper time derivative, which avoids infrared ambiguity in the Wightman function. This method shows that for fixed non-zero acceleration, the detector’s transition rate is approximately Planckian at approximately the usual Unruh temperature 1/(2pichi).

Sources

Related papers