Brans-Dicke Theory with lambda > 0: Black Holes and Large Scale Structures

arXiv:1505.02375 · gr-qc · Submitted 2015-05-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Brans-Dicke Theory with lambda > 0".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A step-by-step approach is followed to study cosmic structures in the context of Brans-Dicke theory with positive cosmological constant Λ and parameter ω Thus, to describe a star one has to assume that there is no such stationary horizon in the faraway asymptotic region.

Kai: Black Hole Constraints Regular stationary black-hole solutions not only have constant Brans-Dicke field φ, but can exist only for ω = ∞, which forces the theory to coincide with the General Relativity.

Mira: Generalizations of the theory in order to evade this black-hole no-hair theorem are presented.

Kai: It is also shown that in the absence of a stationary cosmological event horizon in the asymptotic region, a stationary black hole horizon can support a non-trivial Brans-Dicke hair.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're starting with the title and authors of this paper, Brans-Dicke Theory with lambda > zero: Black Holes and Large Scale Structures <ref:1505.02375#pg1>. It’s a study on how the scalar field interacts with gravity under these specific conditions.

Mira: They are led by Sourav Bhattacharya, Konstantinos Dialektopoulos, Antonio Enea Romano, and Theodore N. Tomaras. These authors bring expertise across the fields of general relativity and scalar-tensor theories.

Lev: From what I know about this paper’s focus, it looks like it’s trying to bridge the gap between black hole solutions in these theories and how those relate to large scale cosmic structures.

Kai: Exactly, that's the core idea. They are looking at how the scalar field phi and the cosmological constant lambda influence both localized objects like black holes and things on a cosmic scale like stars.

Mira: They tackle a couple of different angles here: first, examining regular stationary solutions for black holes and second, investigating what those solutions imply for structures in an expanding universe with positive Lambda.

Lev: I'm thinking the authors are trying to test if these scalar-tensor theories can accommodate realistic astrophysical scenarios without immediately collapsing into the standard Einstein gravity we already know.

Kai: Right, that’s it. They are exploring the modifications introduced by adding a positive cosmological constant and the Brans-Dicke parameter omega to see what kind of new physics emerges.

The paper's summary: Mira: So, let's look at their summary of this paper, which basically follows this step-by-step approach to study cosmic structures in the context of Brans-Dicke theory with positive cosmological constant Lambda and parameter omega.

Kai: They begin by showing that for a star solution to exist, they have to assume there is no stationary horizon in the faraway asymptotic region.

Mira: Then they show that this assumption leads them to study generic spherical cosmic structures perturbatively, and the result is that only certain values of omega work with observations.

Lev: And then there's the part where they look at no hair theorems, especially for finite omega, showing that phi diverges on the horizons when beta equals zero.

Kai: That divergence implies omega goes to infinity and phi becomes constant if you want the integral over the two horizons to vanish.

Mira: This is a key result because it essentially shows that without that horizon, you can have non-trivial hair for black holes.

Lev: So what this means for us is that they are demonstrating how the theory can evade those standard no-hair theorems under certain conditions, which is important because we already know about those theorems in General Relativity.

Kai: They also introduce a way to generalize the scalar equation when omega is a function of phi and show that if the second derivative of U with respect to psi is non-negative, then the no-hair theorem holds for that setup.

Mira: So they're adding more flexibility to the theory, but they are carefully defining exactly when those standard theorems still apply.

Lev: It sounds like they are providing a framework where we can explore how much freedom we have in these theories before things break down or force the solution into GR.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now, regarding the improvements suggested by the authors of this paper, they suggest looking at ways to evade those no-hair theorems in Einstein gravity.

Mira: They propose that by complexifying the scalar field, you can still keep the desired symmetries for both the energy-momentum tensor and spacetime while allowing for non-trivial hairy solutions.

Lev: That’s interesting because it suggests that if we allow complex fields, we might find solutions in GR that look different from what standard real field theories predict.

Kai: It means they are looking at extensions of the no-hair theorems, not just sticking to the standard setup where everything is real.

Mira: They also focus on the need for a specific condition on omega to ensure consistency with astrophysical data when comparing predicted maximum sizes to actual observations.

Lev: So what this means for us is that they are pushing for a specific value of omega, like greater than zero or minus five, which is dictated by cosmic structure size limits.

Kai: They are suggesting that the theory only makes sense when you avoid that stationary cosmological event horizon entirely.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up this discussion on Brans-Dicke Theory with lambda > zero: Black Holes and Large Scale Structures, they summarize their implications for black holes and cosmic structures <ref:1505.02375#pg1>.

Kai: The big picture is that for finite omega, you can't have regular solutions unless there's no stationary cosmological event horizon.

Mira: And this absence of that event horizon means the theory needs to deviate from de Sitter or Einstein’s gravity at very large length scales for it to be viable in nature.

Lev: For black holes, they found we not only get phi equals constant but also omega equals infinity, which forces the whole theory into General Relativity.

Kai: The most striking result is that a regular star solution simply cannot exist in the presence of a stationary cosmological event horizon.

Mira: So if we want this Brans-Dicke theory with positive Lambda to describe reality, we have to assume there isn't that stationary horizon out there in the far away region.

Lev: I just want to add that for black holes, they also found that this absence of a cosmological event horizon means the spacetime at very large scales has to deviate from de Sitter or Einstein’s gravity if we want it to work.

University of Crete

gr-qc

Submitted: 2015-05-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: v4, 14pp; information regarding affiliation of A. E. Romano corrected and updated; the title now matches with that of the journal; rest remains the same

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 181104 (2015)

DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.181104

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: A step-by-step approach is followed to study cosmic structures in the context of Brans-Dicke theory with positive cosmological constant Λ and parameter ω Thus…

Key concepts

No-Hair Theorem in Brans-Dicke Theory
This theorem generally suggests that black holes should only have constant scalar fields ($\phi$) and no other 'hair' (like complex structures). The paper shows that for finite $\omega$, the scalar field diverges on horizons, forcing $\omega \to \infty$ and $\phi$ to be constant, effectively reducing the theory to General Relativity.
Stationary Cosmological Event Horizon
This is a horizon in spacetime that does not move or change over time. The paper finds that if such a horizon exists in the far region of space, it prevents any regular stationary solution from existing for describing stars. This absence of the horizon is a necessary condition for star solutions.
Astrophysical Constraints on $\omega$
Observations of galaxies and galaxy clusters constrain the theory. The predicted maximum sizes of spherical cosmic structures are only consistent with real-world data if the Brans-Dicke parameter $\omega$ is either greater than zero ($\omega > 0$) or equal to negative five ($\omega = -5$). This links theoretical predictions directly to observable cosmic scales.

Terminology

Summary

A step-by-step approach is followed to study cosmic structures in the context of Brans-Dicke theory with positive cosmological constant Λ and parameter ω Thus, to describe a star one has to assume that there is no such stationary horizon in the faraway asymptotic region. p. 0

Black Hole Constraints

Regular stationary black-hole solutions not only have constant Brans-Dicke field φ, but can exist only for ω = ∞, which forces the theory to coincide with the General Relativity. Generalizations of the theory in order to evade this black-hole no-hair theorem are presented. p. 0 It is also shown that in the absence of a stationary cosmological event horizon in the asymptotic region, a stationary black hole horizon can support a non-trivial Brans-Dicke hair. p. 0 Even more importantly, it is shown next, that the presence of a stationary cosmological event horizon rules out any regular stationary solution, appropriate for the description of a star. p. 0

Star Solution Requirements

To describe a star one has to assume that there is no such stationary horizon in the faraway asymptotic region. Under this implicit assumption generic spherical cosmic structures are studied perturbatively and is shown that only for ω > 0 or ω. p. 0−5 their predicted maximum sizes are consistent with observations. p. 0

No Hair in Λ > 0

For finite ω, the scalar field φ necessarily diverges on the horizons (β2 = 0). This result is obtained by evaluating an integral over the spatial hypersurface orthogonal to χa between the two horizons, where β = 0 on ∂Σ. p. 4 The vanishing of this integral implies ω → ∞ and φ=constant. p. 5

Generalization to ω(φ)

For general ω = ω(φ) the scalar equation (2) becomes (2ω(φ) + 3) φ + (∂φω(φ)) (∇φ) 2 + (4Λ − T) = 0. Following [2, 8], the equation in the Einstein frame becomes Gψ = U′(ψ) === -4Λ − T/φ squared p 2ω(φ) + V′(ψ). p. 6 If U'' (ψ) ≥ 0 holds, then the no-hair theorem is valid.

Astrophysical Constraints

The consistency with the astrophysical data for galaxies and galaxy clusters requires that Rta,max is necessarily larger than or about equal to 0.9 (3M/Λ)1/3. This implies that either ω > 0 or ω. p. 9−5. Thus, the Brans-Dicke theory with a positive Λ can describe physics only when a stationary cosmological event horizon is absent. p. 8

Outlook on Theory

For black holes, we not only have φ = const. (i.e., the usual statement of no hair theorems [7, 8]), but also ω = ∞, forcing the whole theory to General Relativity. p. 0 Most strikingly, we have seen that there can be no regular star solution in the Brans-Dicke theory in the presence of a stationary cosmological event horizon. p. 0 Thus the Brans-Dicke theory with a positive Λ can describe physics only when a stationary cosmological event horizon is absent. p. 8 The absence of a cosmological event horizon means that for this theory to exist in nature, at very large length scales the spacetime has to deviate from de Sitter, or Einstein’s gravity. p. 2

References

[1] C. Brans and R. p. 0 H. Dicke, Phys. p. 0 Rev. 124, 925 (1961)

[2] T. Clifton, P. G. Ferreira, A Padilla and C Skordis, Phys Rep 513, 1 (2012)

[3] A Avilez and C Skordis, Phys Rev Lett 113, 011101 (2014)

[4] J D Bekenstein gr-qc/9808028

[5] J D Bekenstein Phys Rev D 5, 1239 (1972)

[6] C A R Herdeiro E Radu arXiv:1504.08209

[7] S W Hawking Commun Math Phys 25, 167 (1972)

[8] T P Sotiriou and V Faraoni Phys Rev Lett 108, 081103 (2012)

[9] L Hui and A Nicolis Phys Rev Lett 110, no. 24, 241104 (2013)

[10] A A H Graham and R Jha Phys Rev D 89, no. 8, 084056 (2014)

[11] E Babichev C Charmousis M Hassaine arXiv:1503.02545

[12] T P Sotiriou S-Y Zhou PhysRevLett 112 (2014) 251102

[13] H Maeda and G Giribet JHEP 1111, 015 (2017)

[14] G W Gibbons and S W Hawking Phys Rev D 15, 2738 (1977)

[15] D Kastor and J H Traschen Phys Rev D 47, 5370 (1993)

[16] W Boucher G W Gibbons and G T Horowitz Phys Rev D 30, 2447 (1984)

[17] R M Wald Phys Rev D 28, 2118 (1983)

[18] C M Chambers and I G Moss Phys Rev Lett 73, 617 (1994)

[19] S Bhattacharya and A Lahiri Phys Rev Lett 99, 201101 (2007)

[20] R M Wald General Relativity Chicago Univ Pr. (1984)

[21] S Bhattacharya Phys Rev D 88, 044053 (2013)

[22] A similar result in a different context can be found in D V Galtsov M Yu Morozov Phys Lett A132 N 89 (1988) 387390

[23] For other options for φ as well as f(r) and h(r) below, see S Bhattacharya K Dialektopoulos A E Romano C Skordis and T N Tomaras in preparation

[24] V Pavlidou T N Tomaras JCAP 1409, 020 (2014)

[25] V Pavlidou N Tetradis and T N Tomaras JCAP 1405, 017 (2014)

[26] D Tanoglidis V Pavlidou and T N Tomaras arXiv:1412.6671

[27] E Babichev C Deffayet Class Quant Grav 30, 184001 (2013)

[28] Clearly the same conclusion holds in the presence of more than one black-hole horizons

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The surface integral is evaluated on the two horizons, where β vanishes, and n a is the spacelike unit normal to the horizons. The left hand side of (8) vanishes [28]. p. 5 For 2ω + 3 > 0, we take ε = −1 in Eq. p. 5 (8). Given that Daφ is spacelike, the inner product (Daφ)(Daφ) is positive definite, T ≤ 0 and Λ > 0, the integrand is the sum of two negative-definite terms. p. 5 Thus, the vanishing of the integral over Σ implies ω → ∞ and φ=constant. p. 5

How the training signal is built

We show next that its behavior is φ ∼ ln β there. Substituting this into (5) and using (11) shows R ∼ (β ln β) −2 on the Killing horizons. p. 6 However, since Γ(x) is finite, expanding it in positive powers of β, it is easy to see that the first term on the right hand side of (13) vanishes on the horizon as ∼ β2. p. 6 Thus we can make φ (and hence R) bounded on the horizon by simply setting C1 = 0. p. 6

Where the gains come from

We conclude that in order to describe, for instance, a star in the context of (1) with finite ω, one has to search for solutions in the absence of a stationary cosmological event horizon. This will be the implicit assumption we use next. p. 9 This is analogous to the so called Vainshtein mechanism [27]. The study of specific realizations of the necessary assumption of absence of the stationary cosmological event horizon, and the subsequent complete analysis of the predictions of the theory about the maximum size of cosmic structures and their comparison to the data, are worth further study. p. 0

[1] C. Brans and R H Dicke Phys Rev 124 925 (1961)

[2] T Clifton P G Ferreira A Padilla and C Skordis Phys Rep 513 1 (2012)

[3] A Avilez C Skordis Phys Rev Lett 113 011101 (2014)

[4] J D Bekenstein gr-qc/9808028

[5] J D Bekenstein Phys Rev D 5, 1239 (1972)

[6] C A R Herdeiro E Radu arXiv:1504.08209

[7] S W Hawking Commun Math Phys 25, 167 (1972)

[8] T P Sotiriou and V Faraoni Phys Rev Lett 108, 081103 (2012)

[9] L Hui and A Nicolis Phys Rev Lett 110, no. 24, 241104 (2013)

[10] A A H Graham and R Jha Phys Rev D 89, no. 8, 084056 (2014)

[11] E Babichev C Charmousis M Hassaine arXiv:1503.02545

[12] T P Sotiriou S-Y Zhou PhysRevLett 112 (2014) 251102

[13] H Maeda and G Giribet JHEP 1117, 045 (2017)

[14] G W Gibbons and S W Hawking Phys Rev D 35, 2738 (1977)

[15] D Kastor and J H Traschen Phys Rev D 47, 5370 (1993)

[16] W Boucher G W Gibbons and G T Horowitz Phys Rev D 30, 2447 (1984)

[17] R M Wald Phys Rev D 28, 2118 (1983)

[18] C M Chambers and I G Moss Phys Rev Lett 73, 617 (1994)

[19] S Bhattacharya and A Lahiri Phys Rev Lett 99, 201101 (2007)

[20] R M Wald General Relativity Chicago Univ Pr. (1984)

[21] S Bhattacharya Phys Rev D 88, 044053 (2013)

[22] A similar result in a different context can be found in D V Galtsov M Yu Morozov Phys Lett A132 N 89 (1988) 387390

[23] For other options for φ as well as f(r) and h(r) below, see S Bhattacharya K Dialektopoulos A E Romano C Skordis and T N Tomaras in preparation

[24] V Pavlidou T N Tomaras JCAP 1409, 020 (2014)

[25] V Pavlidou N Tetradis and T N Tomaras JCAP 1405, 017 (2014)

[26] D Tanoglidis V Pavlidou and T N Tomaras arXiv:1412.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform non-perturbative analysis of Brans-Dicke theory with positive cosmological constant to determine if a regular star solution can exist in a stationary cosmological event horizon by integrating equation (7) on the spacelike two surface S0 between the star and the horizon.

  2. Improved AI can constrain the Brans-Dicke parameter omega based on comparison with observational data by studying how predicted maximum sizes of spherical cosmic structures compare to observations when assuming no stationary cosmological event horizon is present.

  3. Improved AI can analyze potential violations of scalar no hair theorems in Einstein gravity by considering complexified scalar fields to retain desired symmetries while allowing for non-trivial hairy solutions.

Sources

Related papers