Energy of test objects on black hole spacetimes: A brief review
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Energy of test objects on black hole spacetimes".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In this paper, the authors review and revisit various notions of energy for test particles on stationary spacetimes to show how a gravitational potential energy can be consistently defined and how this relates to black hole energetics The notion of horizon energy as defined by the isolated horizons formalism provides a satisfactory notion of energy compatible with the particle’s total conserved energy, leading to a global conservation of energy.
Kai: Defining Conserved Quantities The concept of energy in general relativity is subtle because there is no “absolute” background on which the theory is defined, making the notion of a gravitational energy density ill defined.
Mira: The existence of a time-like isometry allows for the notion of total conserved energy to be well defined, which can then be used to consistently define a gravitational potential energy.
Kai: For test particles with four-velocity u a, the quantity E = −m ξa u a is conserved if the particle follows a geodesic.
Title and authors: Kai: So today we're talking about "Energy of test objects on black hole spacetimes: A brief review," which is just a look at how we define energy for particles moving in stationary spacetimes, and how that leads to defining a gravitational potential energy term.
Mira: It’s essentially taking all the different ways people have defined energy for particles and showing that you can consistently define a gravitational potential energy term based on the total conserved energy.
Lev: They use examples like an asymptotically flat black hole and the de Sitter case with a positive cosmological constant to illustrate this definition of generalized kinetic energy, or GKE.
Kai: They take that conserved quantity E and break it down into kinetic and potential parts in a way that respects the spacetime geometry.
Mira: Right, so the big implication here is establishing this preferred notion of horizon energy through the isolated horizons formalism, which they claim is compatible with the total conserved energy at infinity.
Lev: That compatibility ensures that there's a global conservation of energy across the whole spacetime, which is what makes the isolated horizon approach so strong for this problem.
Kai: It sounds like they are proving that if you stick to this formalism, you get a consistent picture of energy balance everywhere.
The paper's summary: Mira: Now, the authors suggest some improvements to the existing ideas in their review, specifically looking at how we can define energy near a black hole using an observer at rest outside it.
Lev: They propose considering an observer at rest just outside the black hole and modifying the first law by introducing a modified surface gravity kappa bar which is kappa divided by V.
Kai: That choice allows for a local sense of conservation, but they admit that it loses contact with the canonical definition of total energy at infinity, meaning you lose that 'global' conservation we were talking about.
Mira: But then they argue that this conserved energy quantity in equation thirty-one is actually very closely related to a quantity defined by Komar, and compatibility with the total notion of energy will select the quantity E over others.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means we have to carefully decide which energy definition is actually runnable on real hardware when we try to build something that needs global stability.
Kai: It seems like the paper is guiding us toward using the total conserved energy E as the standard because it’s what connects everything together in a physically sensible way.
The paper's improvements: Mira: So to wrap up, they show that a direct generalization of energy measured by an observer isn't enough on its own because it doesn't give you the gravitational contribution.
Lev: But in stationary spacetimes, there is this conserved quantity that can be interpreted as the total energy of the particle, including that gravitational potential energy term.
Kai: And then they show that the formalism of isolated horizons provides a preferred notion of horizon energy that matches the requirements for energy balance at infinity.
Mira: The conclusion is that you have to choose the total energy E because it’s what's consistent with the standard definition of horizon energy for the black hole if you want global conservation of energy.
Lev: Yeah, so ultimately, this paper on "Energy of test objects on black hole spacetimes: A brief review" confirms that E is the quantity we need to have for consistency when defining the standard horizon energy for a black hole.
Kai: That makes sense. It’s about choosing the right definition of energy so that it works across all these different regions of spacetime.
Mira: Yeah, it’s a solid foundation for how we should think about black hole energetics moving forward.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper, "Energy of test objects on black hole spacetimes: A brief review," shows how we can consistently define the total energy for a test particle by using the isolated horizons formalism.
Mira: Exactly. It establishes that there is this preferred notion of horizon energy that works with the total conserved energy at infinity, which ensures we have global conservation of energy across the spacetime.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means if you want to build a stable system that involves a black hole, you have to stick to this definition of total energy E because it’s what’s compatible with the physics at the boundary.
Kai: Right. And they show how we can break down that total energy into kinetic and potential parts using a Killing vector field, giving us a way to talk about negative gravitational potential energy when the Killing vector norm is less than one.
Mira: That’s a big conceptual step because it gives us that physically motivated definition of the potential energy term, which they call Ures equals m times V minus one.
Lev: But remember, that relies on the assumption that you have a stationary spacetime where you can define this time-like Killing vector field in the first place.
Kai: Yeah, and they also looked at alternative proposals for black hole energy, like using an observer outside the horizon, which they found didn't provide that global conservation we need.
Mira: That’s what I was thinking. The paper is really pushing us toward the isolated horizon approach because it’s where you get that consistency with energy balance at infinity.
Lev: So for me, the main thing is that this formal tool provides a way to connect the particle's motion to the black hole's mass change through something like delta M equals E.
Kai: It’s a solid foundation for thinking about how matter interacts with gravity in these spacetimes, and it sets up the next step for more detailed analysis of black hole thermodynamics.
Mira: Definitely. And once we have this total energy E, we can start looking at how that relates to other thermodynamic quantities in these spacetimes.
Lev: Yeah, and I’m keen to see if this framework holds up when you try to run it on real error correction codes for things like the Kerr geometry.
Alejandro Corichi
Centro de Ciencias Matemáticas, Universidad Nacional Aut༹noma de México · Center for Fundamental Theory, Institute for Gravitation and the Cosmos, Pennsylvania State University
gr-qc
Submitted: 2012-07-04
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 17 pages, no figures. Discussion expanded and typos corrected, de Sitter BH case included. Matches published version
Journal ref: Int Jour Mod Phys D24, No. 14 (2015) 1550103
DOI: 10.1142/S0218271815501035
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 74/100
The gist: In this paper, the authors review and revisit various notions of energy for test particles on stationary spacetimes to show how a gravitational potential energy can be consistently defined and how…
Key concepts
- Total Conserved Energy (E)
- This is a quantity conserved for a test particle following a geodesic in stationary spacetimes. It contains information about the gravitational field and can be interpreted as the total energy of the particle, including its gravitational potential energy.
- Generalized Kinetic Energy (GKE)
- In asymptotically flat spacetimes with a time-like Killing vector, E is related to the GKE. In this context, it helps define a generalized potential energy U = E(V - 1), which describes the particle's energy in relation to its velocity.
- Isolated Horizons Formalism
- This formalism defines horizon energy in a way that is compatible with the particle's total conserved energy. It provides a preferred notion of black hole mass change ($\delta M_h = E$), which is consistent with the standard definition of ADM mass at infinity, ensuring global energy conservation.
Terminology
Summary
In this paper, the authors review and revisit various notions of energy for test particles on stationary spacetimes to show how a gravitational potential energy can be consistently defined and how this relates to black hole energetics The notion of horizon energy as defined by the isolated horizons formalism provides a satisfactory notion of energy compatible with the particle’s total conserved energy, leading to a global conservation of energy. p. 0
Defining Conserved Quantities
The concept of energy in general relativity is subtle because there is no “absolute” background on which the theory is defined, making the notion of a gravitational energy density ill defined. The existence of a time-like isometry allows for the notion of total conserved energy to be well defined, which can then be used to consistently define a gravitational potential energy. p. 0 For test particles with four-velocity u a, the quantity E = −m ξa u a is conserved if the particle follows a geodesic. p. 2 This conserved quantity E can be interpreted as a total energy, and it should contain information about the gravitational field. p. 3
Energy in Asymptotically Flat Spacetimes
In asymptotically flat spacetimes with a time-like Killing vector field (KVF) ξ a such that ξ aξ a = −1, the conserved quantity E is related to the generalized kinetic energy (GKE) of the particle. The quantity E can be interpreted as a total energy, and in the small velocity regime, it is given by m + 1/2 mv squared. p. 2 The generalized potential energy U can be defined by setting E:= E + U, yielding U = E(V − 1) or U = E(1 − 1/V). p. 4 For a particle at rest with respect to the observer following the orbits of ξ a, the potential energy becomes Ures = m(V − 1). p. 4
Energetics Near Black Holes
In the vicinity of a black hole, for an asymptotically flat case like Schwarzschild, the GKE E as measured by an observer at rest with respect to the BH at a ‘distance’ r is given by E = E / (1 − 2M r ξ aξ a). The speed of the particle with total energy E, as measured by the observer at rest at a ‘distance’ r, is v = 1 − m/E squared / (1 − 2M r ξ aξ a). p. 5 The total energy of the particle E is conserved along the geodesic, and for a particle held at rest just outside the black hole horizon, its total energy approaches zero at the horizon due to negative gravitational potential energy Ures approaching −m. p. 6
Black Hole Energy Formalism
The notion of horizon energy as defined by the isolated horizons formalism provides a satisfactory notion of energy compatible with the particle’s total conserved energy, which ensures a global conservation of energy. The change in horizon mass is given by δM h = E, meaning the change in BH mass is equal to the total energy of the test object. p. 5 This choice of surface gravity leading to an equality between horizon and ADM masses for electro-vac spacetimes is fully justified because the change in mass of the horizon has to be equal to the total energy E of the in-falling object.
Alternative Energy Proposals
An alternative proposal involves considering an observer at rest outside the black hole and modifying the 1st law, leading to a modified surface gravity κ bar = κ/V. This choice allows for a local sense of conservation but loses contact with the canonical definition of total energy at infinity, implying a loss of ‘global’ conservation of energy. p. 0 The conserved energy (31) is closely related to the quantity defined by Komar, and compatibility with the total notion of energy will select the quantity E. p. 0
Discussion on Consistency
There is an important difference between the two main notions of energy, as a direct generalization to general relativity of the energy as measured by an observer does not provide information about the gravitational contribution to the energy. When the spacetime is stationary, there is a conserved quantity that can be interpreted as the total energy of the particle, including the gravitational (potential energy) contribution. p. 1 The formalism of isolated horizons provides a preferred notion of horizon energy consistent with energy balance at infinity. p. 0 p. 0 A test matter field's conserved current is distinct from the SR notion of energy flux, and compatibility with the total notion of energy selects E. The paper concludes that the choice of total energy E is consistent with the standard definition of horizon energy for the black hole in order to have (global) conservation of energy. p. 0
Acknowledgments
This work was in part supported by DGAPA-UNAM IN103610 grant, by CONACyT 0177840 and 0232902 grants, by the PASPA-DGAPA program, by NSF PHY-1403943 and PHY1205388 grants, and by the Eberly Research Funds of Penn State.
References
[1] R. M. Wald, “General Relativity,” Chicago, USA: Univ. p. 1 p. 1 Pr. (1984) 491p
[2] N. M. J. Woodhouse,“General relativity,” London, UK: Springer (2007) 219 p
[3] A. Corichi and A. p. 0 p. 0 Gomberoff, “Black holes in de Sitter space: Masses, energies and entropy bounds,” Phys. p. 1 p. 1 Rev. D 69, 064016 (2004) [hep-th/0311030]
[4] A. Ashtekar, S. Fairhurst and B. Krishnan, “Isolated horizons: Hamiltonian evolution and the first law,” Phys. p. 0 p. 0 Rev. D 62, 104025 (2000) [gr-qc/0005083]; A. Ashtekar, A. Corichi and D. p. 0 p. 0 Sudarsky, “Hairy black holes, horizon mass and solitons,” Class. p. 1 p. 1 Quant. Grav. 18, 919 (2001) [gr-qc/0011081]
[5] A. Ghosh and A. Perez, “Black hole entropy and isolated horizons thermodynamics,” Phys. p. 0 p. 0 Rev. Lett. 107, 241301 (2011) [Erratum-ibid. 108, 169901 (2012)] [arXiv:1207. p. 0 p. 00887v3]
[6] E. Frodden, A. Ghosh and A. Perez, “A local first law for black hole thermodynamics,” Phys. p. 1 p. 1 Rev. D 87, no. 12, 121503 (2013). arXiv:1110. p. 0 p. 04055 [gr-qc]
[7] A recent proposal is to consider instead an observer that is at a small distance, of the order of the Planck length, outside the horizon [5]
[8] The mass M of the black hole refers to the horizon mass Mh as defined by the isolated horizon formalism [4]
[9] It has been shown that for asymptotically flat stationary electro-vac spacetimes the horizon mass and the ADM mass coincide [4]
[10] Here we are assuming that the presence of the test object does not modify the horizon mass M, so our approximation is valid
[11] Note also that in the proposal of [5] and in subsequent papers, it is argued that the ‘mass’ M˜ of the black hole is proportional to its area
Conclusion
The paper demonstrates that while a direct generalization to general relativity of energy as measured by an observer does not provide information about the gravitational contribution, there is a conserved quantity in stationary spacetimes that can be interpreted as the total energy of the particle, including the gravitational (potential energy) contribution. The formalism of isolated horizons provides a preferred notion of horizon energy consistent with energy balance at infinity. The paper concludes that the notion of total energy E for a test particle is consistent with the standard definition of horizon energy for the black hole in order to have (global) conservation of energy. p. 0
[1] R. M. Wald, “General Relativity,” Chicago, USA: Univ. Pr. (1984) 491p
[2] N. M. J. Woodhouse,“General relativity,” London, UK: Springer (2007) 219 p
[3] A. Corichi and A. Gomberoff, “Black holes in de Sitter space: Masses, energies and entropy bounds,” Phys. Rev. D 69, 064016 (2004) [hep-th/0311030]
[4] A. Ashtekar, S. Fairhurst and B. Krishnan, “Isolated horizons: Hamiltonian evolution and the first law,” Phys. Rev. D 62, 104025 (2000) [gr-qc/0005083]; A. Ashtekar, A. Corichi and D. Sudarsky, “Hairy black holes, horizon mass and solitons,” Class. Quant. Grav. 18, 919 (2001) [gr-qc/0011081]
[5] A Ghosh and A. Perez, “Black hole entropy and isolated horizons thermodynamics,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 241301 (2011) [Erratum-ibid. 108, 169901 (2012)] [arXiv:1207.0887v3]
[6] E. Frodden, A. Ghosh and A. Perez, “A local first law for black hole thermodynamics,” Phys. Rev. D 87, no. 12, 121503 (2013). arXiv:1110.4055 [gr-qc]
[7] A recent proposal is to consider instead an observer that is at a small distance, of the order of the Planck length, outside the horizon [5]
[8] The mass M of the black hole refers to the horizon mass Mh as defined by the isolated horizon formalism [4]
[9] It has been shown that for asymptotically flat stationary electro-vac spacetimes the horizon mass and the ADM mass coincide [4]
[10] Here we are assuming that the presence of the test object does not modify the horizon mass M, so our approximation is valid
[11] Note also that in the proposal of [5] and in subsequent papers, it is argued that the ‘mass’ M˜ of the black hole is proportional to its area
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can consistently apply the isolated horizons formalism to define horizon energy compatible with total conserved energy for both asymptotically flat and de Sitter black hole spacetimes, ensuring a global conservation of energy.
-
Improved AI can derive a modified notion of black hole energy from an observer at rest outside the black hole, which approaches asymptotically the horizon area for large black holes but retains nontrivial dependence in general.
-
Improved AI can analyze test particle motion near a Schwarzschild black hole by relating the generalized kinetic energy to a gravitational potential energy term U = E (V - 1), allowing for a physically motivated definition of negative gravitational potential energy when the norm of the Killing vector is less than one.
-
Improved AI can calculate the speed of a particle with total energy E as measured by an observer at rest at distance r, using Eq. (11) and compare this result to the Newtonian expression, highlighting where GR differs, such as in the coincidence where escape velocity equals one when r equals 2M.
-
Improved AI can determine the maximum radial distance a particle with total energy less than its rest mass m can attain before falling back into a Schwarzschild black hole using Eq. (12) and compare it to the corresponding Newtonian quantity r max given by Eq. (12).
-
Improved AI can identify that for an object at rest outside the black hole, its total energy E is strictly positive in the region where it can be defined, and derive a potential energy Ures = m [1 - 2M/r(1/2) - 1] which satisfies properties i), ii), and iii) for r >> 2M.
-
Improved AI can analyze circular motion by relating the potential V(r) to the conserved quantities L and E, showing that the top speed of a test particle on a circular orbit is precisely fifty percent of the speed of light when the orbit is at its last stable circular orbit.
-
Improved AI can evaluate a new proposal for black hole energy based on an observer at rest outside the horizon by deriving an effective surface gravity kappa bar = kappa / V, which yields a modified first law for the black hole mass delta M˜ = kappa 8 pi V delta A.
Sources
- Black hole entropy and isolated horizons thermodynamics
- A local first law for black hole thermodynamics
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals