Can sunlight replace LEDs in vertical farms? A critical assessment of optical-fiber daylighting strategies

summary

The gist

Vertical farming is a promising approach for increasing food production in controlled environments while reducing land use, water consumption, and dependence on external climatic conditions.

In short

The study assessed optical-fiber daylighting systems for vertical farms using lettuce as a reference crop. While these systems can deliver natural light, their high costs and uncertainties in light distribution make them economically unfeasible currently. Hybrid strategies offered trade-offs between energy savings and productivity, but overall, current optical fiber technology is not a mature or cost-effective solution.

Key concepts

Optical Fiber System
This system uses optical fibers to deliver natural sunlight into vertical farming structures. It aims to distribute daylight across all growing layers. Its efficiency depends on the specific type of fiber used and how the light is concentrated.
Light-Pipe Configuration
This is an alternative solar strategy compared to optical fibers. It has higher optical efficiency but offers less flexibility in integrating it within a vertical farm setup. It serves as a benchmark for comparison.
SEEC (Specific Energy Consumption)
This metric measures the energy used per kilogram of crop produced, accounting for both lighting and growing needs. Lower SEEC indicates better energy efficiency in the system.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Can sunlight replace LEDs in vertical farms? A critical assessment of optical-fiber daylighting strategies · Read on arXiv

Department of Energy, Systems, Territory and Construction Engineering University of Pisa

Vertical farming is a promising approach for increasing food production in controlled environments while reducing land use, water consumption, and dependence on external climatic conditions. However, its large electricity demand, mainly driven by artificial lighting, still limits its energetic and economic sustainability. This study evaluates the techno-economic potential of an optical-fiber daylighting system designed to transport concentrated sunlight directly to the crop growing zones of a vertical farm. A validated transient vertical farm model was coupled with Tonatiuh ray-tracing simulations to assess a single-axis solar-tracked Fresnel concentration system. Five optical fiber typologies and three daylighting strategies were compared in terms of crop production, specific electrical energy consumption, and light cost, and benchmarked against light-pipe and rooftop photovoltaic solutions. The optical-fiber system achieved an annual useful-PAR delivery efficiency of 19-27%, depending on fiber typology. By distributing daylight across all rack shelves and limiting heat gains through a UV-IR filter, it reduced electricity consumption by 35-89%, compared with 12% for the light-pipe configuration. The daylight-only strategy achieved the lowest SEEC, equal to 1.81 kWh kg-1, but caused a 52% crop productivity reduction. Hybrid LED-optical-fiber strategies avoided this penalty and achieved electricity savings of about 50%, with a minimum SEEC of 3.16 kWh kg-1. However, current optical fiber costs make the system economically unattractive, requiring an estimated capital cost reduction of about 90% to become competitive. Rooftop photovoltaics covered 22% of annual electricity demand and achieved an 11-12-year payback, making PV the most economically viable rooftop solar option under current market conditions.

DOI: 10.1016/j.enconman.2026.122349

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Can sunlight replace LEDs in vertical farms? A critical assessment of optical-fiber daylighting strategies".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Vertical farming is a promising approach for increasing food production in controlled environments while reducing land use, water consumption, and dependence on external climatic conditions.

Rosa: The optical-fiber system achieved an annual useful-PAR delivery efficiency of 19–27%, depending on fiber typology.

Dev: By distributing daylight across all rack shelves and limiting heat gains through a UV-IR filter, it reduced electricity consumption by 35–89%, compared with 12% for the light-pipe configuration.

Rosa: Hybrid LED–optical-fiber strategies avoided this penalty and achieved electricity savings of about 50%, with a minimum SEEC of 3.16 kWh kg-1.

Paper summary: Rosa: So to wrap up this assessment of "Can sunlight replace LEDs in vertical farms? A critical assessment of optical-fiber daylighting strategies," the main point is that while the technology shows significant potential for reducing electricity use in controlled environments, it's not ready for widespread use yet.

Dev: Right. The authors are really emphasizing that there's a gap between the energy savings they achieve with optical fiber and what’s required to make it economically practical right now. They suggest that high investment costs and uncertainties about how light actually distributes inside the farm still outweigh the benefits of those electricity savings.

Taro: From an autonomy standpoint, I think their concern about uncertainty in light distribution is key. If you can't predict exactly how much PAR you're getting across all your layers, that makes it hard to design a reliable real-time loop for the system.

Rosa: Exactly. And they also point out that the technology isn't fully mature yet. So, while we see great results in simulations and trials, there are still things missing in terms of how this system performs when you throw it out into the real world with all its unpredictable variables.

Dev: So the future development for this area, based on these findings from this paper, seems to be heavily focused on reducing those optical fiber costs first. That’s where they think the next big step needs to happen before we see widespread adoption of these systems.

Conclusion: Rosa: So we've looked at how optical fiber systems can bring sunlight inside vertical farms, and this paper is taking a really hard look at whether that actually works in the real world yet.

Dev: Yeah, it’s titled "Can sunlight replace LEDs in vertical farms? A critical assessment of optical-fiber daylighting strategies," and the authors are really zeroing in on the practical side of this whole idea.

Taro: It seems like they aren't just showing pretty diagrams; they’re digging into why it might fail when you take these systems out of a perfect lab setting.

Rosa: Right, because the big picture is that while we see some good energy savings in simulations, the paper makes it clear that high investment costs and uncertainty about how light actually gets spread around the farm are still major roadblocks.

Dev: Exactly, they’re saying you need to cut those fiber costs by about ninety percent just to make this economically sensible under normal operating conditions.

Taro: So it sounds like the current reality is that optical fiber daylighting isn't a mature or affordable solution for vertical farms right now, despite the potential energy gains.

Rosa: That’s the core message, and it highlights that we still have a lot of work to do before this kind of technology becomes a standard in controlled environments.

More episodes

← Home