The Phenomenology of the Dark Dimension and Non-Supersymmetric Strings

summary

The gist

Swampland principles, combined with the smallness of dark energy Λ, lead to the dark dimension scenario, with one extra dimension of micron size The predictions of the scenario tie together…

In short

The dark dimension scenario uses Swampland principles to unify dark matter, dark energy, and scale hierarchies within a single framework. It posits one extra micron-sized dimension arising from field space duality, naturally explaining the Kaluza-Klein tower for dark matter and providing a mechanism for an evolving dark sector that fits cosmological data.

Key concepts

Dark Dimension Scenario
This scenario suggests one extra spatial dimension of micron size arises from the Distance/Duality Conjecture when moving far in field space. This extra dimension is crucial because it naturally generates a tower of light states, which serves as a candidate for dark matter.
Kaluza-Klein (KK) Tower
The KK tower refers to the set of massive excitations arising from compactifying a higher-dimensional space. In this context, the KK excitations of gravitons in the dark dimension are proposed as a natural and light candidate for dark matter.
Evolving Dark Sector (FDS)
Motivated by Swampland conjectures, this model suggests that dark energy is not a constant but evolves. The evolution of the dark sector's diameter correlates with the variation in its mass, providing a fit to cosmological data while avoiding problematic phantom crossing behavior.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

The Phenomenology of the Dark Dimension and Non-Supersymmetric Strings · Read on arXiv

Cumrun Vafa

Jefferson Physical Laboratory · Harvard University

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The Phenomenology of the Dark Dimension and Non-Supersymmetric Strings".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Swampland principles, combined with the smallness of dark energy Λ, lead to the dark dimension scenario, with one extra dimension of micron size The predictions of the scenario tie together, in a single framework, the puzzles listed above: the Kaluza–Klein (KK) tower of gravitons in the dark dimension provides the dark matter a bulk B−L gauge symmetry naturally requires three righthanded neutrinos propagating in the bulk and explains mν ∼ Λ1/4 Higgsing the bulk B−L gauge symmetry by a bulk scalar at the Higgs scale results in a massive gauge field with mB−L ≳ 100 GeV, gB−L ∼ 10−10 The dark dimension also provides a concrete realization of an evolving dark sector: the evolution of its diameter correlates the variation of dark energy with that of the dark matter mass, fitting the recent DESI DR2 (+CMB+supernovae) data while avoiding the phantom crossing that the w0waCDM parametrization would suggest The fits to the data have a further lesson: the effective logarithmic slope of the dark energy potential predicted as well as fitting to order one in Planck units is smaller than 2 This suggests that the field controlling dark energy sits in the interior of moduli space, perhaps close to an unstable critical point The Dark Dimension Scenario and its Predictions The starting point is the Distance/Duality Conjecture as one moves a large distance in field space, a tower of states becomes exponentially light leading to a dual description Applying this to the observed dark energy (1), and using the general expectation 1 d ≤ α ≤ 1/2 for the exponent together with experimental constraints, fixes the exponent One is led to mKK ∼ λ-1 Λ/4, 10-4 ≲ λ ≲ 1, i.e., a KK tower in the 10-1 – 10 meV range, corresponding to one extra dimension of size l5 ∼ λΛ-1/4 ∼ 0.1 – 10 µm The associated five-dimensional Planck scale is M5 ∼ m KK M 2/3 pl ∼ Λ1/12 ∼ 10 9 – 10 10 GeV, which will play the role of a fundamental UV scale in what follows Dark Matter and Scale Hierarchies The dark dimension comes with a natural dark matter candidate The distance conjecture predicts that there should be a light weakly coupled tower, which in our case is the tower of KK excitations of the graviton Cosmology provides the answer: the SM brane is in thermal equilibrium, but the bulk tower is not The production is dominated by the highest temperatures, and requiring the resulting abundance to match the observed dark matter density fixes the maximal (“initial”) temperature of the radiation era to be Ti ∼ 1 GeV Higgs sector is controlled by the moduli fixing the Standard Model brane, one is led parametrically to mweak ∼ Λ1/6 in Planck units The mass of the modulus is naturally related both to the size of the SM brane as well as the mass scale on the brane, namely, the weak scale Evolving Dark Sector and Cosmological Fits The Swampland de Sitter conjecture

19: and the TCC

20: suggest that dark energy is not a cosmological constant Motivated by these ideas and the fact that dark matter mass also naturally has logarithmic derivative with respect to moduli of O(1) in Planck units led to the cosmological model of fading dark sector

21: given by two parameters of O(1) in Planck units (c, c′) The preferred FDS region has c ≃ −1, c′ ≃ 0.05, stable across dataset combinations Non-Supersymmetric Vacua and Critical Points The main difficulty is the absence of the usual supersymmetric protection: generic loop corrections displace candidate critical points The strategy that has proven effective is to use symmetries, and in particular unbroken duality symmetries: isolated points in field space fixed by a symmetry are automatically critical points of any invariant potential, to all orders In particular it is found that V > 0, ∇V = 0: (unstable) de Sitter critical points Hierarchies of Scales as Powers of Λ The dark dimension suggests an updated version of the answer: the mysterious scales of our universe organize themselves as simple rational powers of the dark energy, in Planck units The last line is the GUT relation (14) of Section 6 Swampland principles lead to a unique corner of the quantum gravity landscape—the dark dimension—which beautifully fits the various experimental bounds and leads to new predictions, which so far match the data remarkably well Meeting this challenge requires developing string theory away from its supersymmetric comfort zone The symmetry-based strategy reviewed in the second part of this paper—isolated critical points protected by unbroken duality groups, realized both in non-geometric flux vacua and in Scherk–Schwarz compactifications of M-theory, together with the emerging duality web for non-supersymmetric strings—suggests that this challenge is beginning to be met Appendix A KK tower of ϕ as Dark Matter and FDS with a stabilized Dark Dimension The evolving dark sector of

23: therefore predicts, with nothing added, a second light tower in the dark sector!

Kai: The zero mode’s four-dimensional kinetic term is untouched, so ϕ0 rolls as in Section 7 The dark matter is then a sterile spin-zero tower at the GeV scale, with no decay signal, whose one cosmological coupling is to the rolling ϕ0 through its masses The FDS equations, the apparent phantom behavior and the dark fifth force 2c′ squared are the same either way References

1: C.

Mira: Vafa, “The String landscape and the swampland,” arXiv:hep-th/0509212

3: H.

Kai: Ooguri and C.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper, The Phenomenology of the Dark Dimension and Non-Supersymmetric Strings. It sets out that Swampland principles, when paired with the fact that dark energy is small, leads directly to this dark dimension scenario with one extra micron size.

Mira: The thesis is that this scenario provides a single framework to address several deep puzzles we have in physics: what dark matter and dark energy actually are.

Lev: It claims that within this setup, the Kaluza-Klein tower of gravitons naturally serves as a candidate for dark matter, and it also links neutrino masses to the dark energy scale via a bulk B minus L gauge symmetry.

Kai: And it connects the QCD axion decay constant to the five dimensional Planck scale at around ten to ten billion giga-electron volts.

Mira: Furthermore, the dark dimension scenario gives us an evolving dark sector, where its size changing correlates with how dark energy and dark matter mass are varying.

Lev: This evolution is important because it allows them to fit recent data from DESI DR2 plus CMB plus supernovae observations without running into that phantom crossing issue that standard models suggest.

Kai: They also found that the fits suggest the dark energy field itself resides in the interior of moduli space, not just being a simple cosmological constant.

Mira: So why does this matter for us? Because this scenario creates a very specific set of predictions—the small extra dimension size, the mass scales, and how everything evolves together.

Lev: It means if we are looking for physics beyond the Standard Model that can explain these observations simultaneously, this dark dimension scenario is a very strong candidate to explore.

Conclusion: Kai: The authors are essentially showing that Swampland rules carve out this specific corner of the quantum gravity landscape where a micron-sized extra dimension is required.

Mira: It matters because it shows that even when you step away from supersymmetry, using duality symmetries can still fix stable points in field space, which is crucial for building consistent string theory models.

Lev: For us on the experimental side, this means any dark sector physics we design needs to respect these geometric constraints imposed by the extra dimension size and scale relationships.

Kai: So it's about showing that these abstract principles can actually yield concrete predictions about particle masses and cosmological evolution when we look at non-supersymmetric vacua.

Mira: In simple terms, it’s about finding a consistent way to describe dark matter, dark energy, and neutrino masses all stemming from this unique geometric structure.

Lev: It really forces us to think hard about how the scales of our universe organize themselves as powers of the dark energy scale in Planck units.

More episodes

← Home