An ode to instantons

summary

The gist

We present a formalism for semiclassical time evolution in quantum mechanics, building on a century of work <ref:2603.06575#pg2> We identify complex saddle points in real time…

In short

The work develops a semiclassical formalism for time evolution in quantum mechanics by identifying complex saddle points across real and complex time domains. This method successfully reproduces known solutions for classic problems like the harmonic oscillator and under-barrier transmission. It provides a framework to compute decay rates in quantum field theory with non-trivial time dependence by analyzing analogies in quantum mechanics.

Key concepts

Semiclassical Formalism
This method approximates the path integral in the limit where Planck's constant ($\hbar$) approaches zero. It achieves this by finding specific points, called complex saddle points, in different time spaces (real and complex) that dominate the path integral's contribution to the quantum wave function.
Complex Saddle Points
These are crucial mathematical structures identified in the semiclassical method. They are not just simple peaks but can exist in real time, complex time, or both. They serve as the primary contributors to approximating the quantum evolution, linking quantum mechanics to classical solutions.
Decay of Metastable States
This involves studying how a system trapped in a false vacuum eventually decays. The formalism reveals that decay is governed by contributions from 'bouncing solutions' occurring across various complex time contours, which collectively determine the exponential decay probability over late times.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

An ode to instantons · Read on arXiv

Laboratory for Theoretical Fundamental Physics, EPFL · Institute for Theoretical Physics, KU Leuven · Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Universita di Roma · INFN Sezione di Roma

We review a formalism for semiclassical time evolution in quantum mechanics, identifying complex saddle points in real time, real saddle points in complex time, and complex saddle points in complex time that reproduce known answers to classic problems. For the decay of a metastable state, we find finite-time and finite-energy analogs of the "bounce" which have no zero or negative modes. The one-loop phase of the wave function and the multiplicity of bounce solutions at late times are discussed. The motivation for this work is to learn how to compute decay rates in quantum field theory in situations with interesting time dependence, by first taking a humble step back to the fascinating world of quantum mechanics.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "An ode to instantons".

Title and authors: Kai: The title itself, "An ode to instantons," suggests a focus on these specific configurations that are central to semiclassical approximations in quantum mechanics >

Mira: It sounds poetic, but it really points to the mathematical structures they are using—the instantons—which are basically solutions to equations of motion that describe tunneling or transition processes >

Lev: For us, instantons are just a way of visualizing the dominant paths in the path integral, and this paper is showing how those paths can exist in different time regimes >

Kai: It's about using these instantons—the complex saddle points they mentioned—to give answers to standard problems like under-barrier transmission or over-barrier reflection >

Mira: They are taking a known technique from one area and applying it to make headway in another, which is what makes this work so interesting for us as theorists >

Lev: I wonder if the authors have found a way to make these instanton contributions more reliable when you move from simple systems like the harmonic oscillator to field theories with more fields >

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what they actually do is present this formalism for semiclassical time evolution using the method of steepest descent by finding these complex saddle points >

Mira: They express the wave function as a collection of contributions from these saddles, and the prefactor involves the determinant of a fluctuation operator which they compute using the Gelfand–Yaglom method >

Lev: That sounds like a lot of machinery. From an engineering perspective, computing that determinant is often where you run into numerical instabilities if you don't handle it right >

Kai: But they say this calculation connects back to known results in one-dimensional quantum mechanics, like the harmonic oscillator and under-barrier transmission >

Mira: And they show how coherent state evolution of the harmonic oscillator can be reproduced by solving differential equations in the complex plane, which is a neat link between these ideas >

Lev: So they're showing that this path integral approach isn't just abstract; it actually maps onto solvable problems we already know how to handle >

The paper's improvements: Kai: One area they focus on is the decay of metastable states, where they decompose the initial state into resonant energy levels and sum up contributions from various complex time contours >

Mira: This summation reveals that the probability inside the false vacuum decays exponentially at late times because of a combinatorial factor counting bounce multiplicity >

Lev: That combinatorial factor is what makes it complicated for us on hardware. If you have many bouncing solutions, you have to account for all of them, which is computationally heavy >

Kai: But they show that for times of order t equals one over gamma n, the collective contribution from all bouncing solutions with a bounce number l equal to one competes with the non-bouncing part >

Mira: And they compare this method against other ways of computing the wave function outside the false vacuum, like WKB or numerical Schrödinger equation solutions >

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, they've compared four methods for finding the wave function outside the false vacuum—WKB, indirect semiclassical path integral, numerical solutions—and they show that those first two methods only become good approximations after a time of order one over omega >

Mira: The main result is that if you find every relevant saddle point, all the path integral calculations match known WKB results for all examples >

Lev: That's solid. It means we can trust this formalism to reproduce established results in these cases, provided we can actually find those saddle points properly >

Kai: The big implication is that the path integral approach gives us a way to compute decay rates in quantum field theory with time dependence by studying these simpler quantum mechanics analogs >

Mira: And they leave the general problem of which complex saddle points contribute to the time-evolved state open for future work, speculating on whether the normalization constant for subleading saddle points is one or one over two times >

Lev: I just hope that NP equals one for all contributing saddle points, because if it’s half for solutions with bounces, that adds a layer of complexity we'd have to deal with when trying to implement this on real hardware >

More episodes

← Home