The large N vector model with angular velocity

summary

The gist

The study investigates the free energy of a critical vector model at large N on S1 × S2 with an angular velocity without a singlet constraint…

In short

The study computes the free energy of a large N critical vector model on S1×S2 with angular velocity, showing it smoothly connects two fixed points: one corresponding to a non-trivial CFT and another to a free theory at high temperature. It uses gap equation analysis and PP-wave geometry to show how the thermal mass behaves near zero angular potential, revealing important insights into the model's behavior.

Key concepts

Critical Vector Model
This is a type of quantum field theory describing particles (vectors) interacting in a critical state, meaning it exists at a special point where correlations are long-ranged. The model studied here is on the geometry S1×S2 and involves large N, which simplifies calculations but allows for complex physical insights.
Free Energy Interpolation
The paper demonstrates that the free energy of this model changes smoothly between two different theoretical limits. It interpolates from a fixed point associated with a non-trivial Conformal Field Theory (CFT) to the free theory limit at high temperatures, providing a bridge between these distinct physical regimes.
PP-Wave Geometry
This is a specific curved spacetime geometry used to analyze the model's partition function in the limit where the angular velocity approaches zero. Analyzing this geometry helps determine if certain theoretical predictions about poles and fixed points are consistent with the model's behavior.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

The large N vector model with angular velocity · Read on arXiv

Justin R. Davida, Srijan Kumarb

Centre for High Energy Physics, Indian Institute of Science · Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, University of Science and Technology of China · Peng Huanwu Center for Fundamental Theory, Hefei

We study the free energy of a critical vector model at large N on S 1 times S squared with an angular velocity μ without the singlet constraint. We study the model for which the large N dynamics is controlled by the uniform saddle point of the auxiliary field arising in the Hubbard-Stratanovich transformation. The leading high-temperature behaviour is determined analytically both as an expansion about μr=0 and μ squaredr squared=1 where r is the radius of the sphere. We supplement the analytic results with a numerical analysis that agrees with both the analytical expansions in their respective regimes and smoothly interpolates between them. The leading high-temperature contribution to the free energy develops a pole at μ squaredr squared=1, in agreement with expectations from the thermal effective field theory. Its residue coincides with that of the massless free theory. Sub-leading terms, however, exhibit non-analytic dependence on the angular velocity and distinguish the critical fixed-point result from the free theory answer. The residue at the pole can also be obtained by placing the model on the pp-wave geometry. We show that the residue agrees with that obtained from the direct computation. The free energy of the model connects the non-trivial fixed point of the O(N) model at μr=0 to its free fixed point at μ 2r 2=1.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The large N vector model with angular velocity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates the free energy of a critical vector model at large N on S1 × S2 with an angular velocity without a singlet constraint, which is important because it provides a direct field theory computation for a non-trivial CFT and shows that its free energy smoothly interpolates between two fixed points Model Setup and Key Results The paper studies the free energy of a critical vector model at large N on S1 × S2 with an angular velocity without the singlet constraint, which is important because it provides a direct field theory computation for a non-trivial CFT and shows that its free energy smoothly interpolates between two fixed points The leading high-temperature contribution to the free energy develops a pole at µˆ2r squared = 1, in agreement with expectations from the thermal effective field theory The residue at this pole can also be obtained by placing the model on the pp-wave geometry The free energy of the model connects the non-trivial fixed point of the O(N) model at µrˆ = 0 to its free fixed point at µˆ2r squared = 1 High Temperature Expansion and Interpolation The leading high-temperature behaviour of the free energy is given by a pole at µˆ2r squared = 1 The free energy of the model in (3.7) smoothly interpolates between the non-trivial fixed point of the standard O(N) model at large N with quartic interaction and vanishing angular potential, µrˆ = 0 to its free fixed point at µˆ2r squared = 1 The ratio of the free energy at the non-trivial fixed point to that at the free fixed point in these two limits are given by lim µrˆ →0 log Z(0) saddle / log Z(0) free = 4/5, and lim µˆ2r 2→1 log Z(0) saddle / log Z(0) free = 1 Gap Equation Analysis The non-trivial gap equation for the thermal mass in presence of the angular potential, parametrized by x, is given by mβ˜ = − 2√1 − x squared I(x, mβ˜) The solution to this gap equation near x = 0 yields a leading order thermal mass mβ˜ ∼ log2 1/x This leads to the qualitative regime of behavior where such relation holds is given by mβ˜ −→ ∞, mβx ˜ −→ 0 as x → 0 PP-Wave Geometry and Consistency Checks The partition function in the x → 0 limit is then given by log Z(β, x) = 4πx squared log Zppβr The saddle point is given by minimizing the partition function with respect to m, and the only real and non-negative solution for m satisfying the above equation for β, r > 0 is m = 0 This implies that the free energy of the large N critical vector model on S1 × S2 at x → 0 or µ 2r squared + 1 → 0 coincides with that of the massless theory Non-Uniformity of Saddle Points The presence of the non-zero angular potential breaks the rotational symmetry O(3) to O(2), leading to non-zero modes contribute at the leading order in large N The analysis shows that a configuration containing only ζ0 does not satisfy the full local saddle equation of the conventional O(N) model on the thermal pp-wave This establishes the inconsistency of the uniform ansatz for the usual O(N) model both on pp wave geometry and on S1 × S2; it does not determine the nonuniform saddle or its free energy The interpolation of the free energy of the standard O(N) model at large N at its non-trivial IR fixed point and zero angular potential to the free energy of the free theory or the UV theory at µ 2r squared = 1 via the model presented here is interesting and may help to understand the behaviour of the standard O(N) model with angular velocity The methods developed in this paper for evaluating partition functions at non-zero angular potential and solving the gap equations can be generalised for other vector models involving more general interactions and higher dimensions The study of the vector model coupled only to the constant mode of the Hubbard-Stratonovich auxiliary field results in a non-local quartic interaction of the original O(N) model Such logarithmic terms were also present for the free massive theory in

31: The interpolation of the free energy of the standard O(N) model at large N at its non-trivial IR fixed point and zero angular potential to the free energy of the UV theory at µ 2r squared = 1 via the model presented here is interesting and may help to understand the behaviour of the standard O(N) model with angular velocity The study of this vector model on a pp-wave geometry predicts that these poles must coincide with that of free theory Appendix A and B Details The coefficient of the x −2 pole in (2.12) is Cfree βr ≡ lim x→0 x squared log Zfree = rβ Xn=1 1/n squared sinh(nβ/2r) The high-temperature expansion follows by shifting the contour in (A.5) to the left The pole at s = 1 gives the leading term 2ζ(3)(r/β) squared, while the double pole at s = −1 produces the logarithmic and constant contributions The remaining poles at s = −2k − 1, k ≥ 1, give ck = 2/ (1−2(-k-1)) ζ(-2k−1)ζ(1−2k) / (2k + 1)!

Kai: The factorial growth of the coefficients shows that (A.7) is an asymptotic expansion in β/r with zero radius of convergence Small x Expansion Details The leading small-x solution for the thermal mass is mβ˜ = 4W20 1/√2x, which is the solution quoted in (3.55) of the main text The final remainder in (C.7) is exponentially smaller than every algebraic sector and does not affect the order-by-order matching The leading term reproduces the free energy at the non-trivial fixed point in absence of the angular potential at high temperature Numerical Verification The agreement of the above solution with the numerical solution of (3.33) near x squared = 1 is shown in figure 4 The thermal mass is evaluated till a few higher orders by solving the gap equation (3.53) systematically order by order in appendix C, leading to the following answer mβ˜ = log2 1/x − 4 log 1/x log log 1/x + 2 log2 log 1/x + 4 log2 /log x + (8 − 4 log2) log cubed /log x + sqrt(5) /log(16020 +378>log2) /1063125 (1-x 2) 4 + O((1-x 2) 5) The numerical solution of the gap equation (3.34) is shown in figure 4 The leading small-x solution expansion about x squared = 1 through O(x squared - 1) 6 is given by mβ˜ = log2 1/x − 4 log 1/x log log 1/x + (8 − 4 log2) log cubed /log x + sqrt(5) /log(16020 +378>log2) /1063125 (1-x 2) 4 The leading high temperature contribution to the free energy is given by β 2r squared log Z(0) saddle(x) ∼ 2ζ(3)/x squared − 1/6 log6(1/x) PP-Wave Geometry Results The partition function in the x → 0 limit is then given by log Z(β, x) = 4πx squared log Zppβr The vacuum-subtracted k = 0 contribution is Cth0(u; m) = I0(m) Xp∈Z sδ(u - pβ), where I0(m) is the integral of the free-particle sector The vacuum-subtracted k = 0 contribution vanishes after the vacuum subtraction The nonconstant saddle residual on the ansatz (D.40) is i h Gppth(y; m˜) − G(Y)th(m˜) Discussion and Future Directions The interpolation of the free energy of the standard O(N) model at large N at its non-trivial IR fixed point and zero angular potential to the free energy of the UV theory at µ 2r squared = 1 via the model presented here is interesting and may help to understand the behaviour of the standard O(N) model with angular velocity The methods developed in this paper for evaluating partition functions at non-zero angular potential and solving the gap equations can be generalised for other vector models involving more general interactions and higher dimensions It would be interesting to study how to incorporate such terms within thermal effective field theory The interpolation of the free energy of the standard O(N) model at large N at its non-trivial IR fixed point and zero angular potential to the free energy of the UV theory at µ 2r squared = 1 via the model presented here is interesting and may help to understand the behaviour of the standard O(N) model with angular velocity The study of this vector model on a pp-wave geometry predicts that these poles must coincide with that of free theory The generalization of the analysis for the squashed sphere

20: is an interesting direction for further investigation The model with the singlet constraint is of particular interest as it undergoes Gross-Witten-Wadia transition The study of this vector model on a pp-wave geometry predicts that these poles must coincide with that of free theory Acknowledgments The use of Feynman parametrization in (3.26) was suggested by ChatGPT and proved to be instrumental in the further analysis ChatGPT and Codex were also used to assist with the subsequent algebraic manipulations in Section 3, parts of consistency checks, numerical analysis and manuscript organization We thank Shiraz Minwalla, Vinayak Mishra and Jyotirmoy Mukherjee for pointing out the non-uniformity of the thermal mass of the standard O(N) model at large N with angular potential during discussions and correspondences JRD is partially supported by ANRF, India: grant no.

Mira: ANRF/ARGM/2025/00054/TS SK is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) under Grants No.

Kai: 12247103 Appendix A and B Details The residue at the pole at x = 0 for the free energy in free theory given in (2.12) as a small β/r expansion to obtain the result (2.13) The high-temperature expansion follows by shifting the contour in (A.5) to the left The pole at s = 1 gives the leading term 2ζ(3)(r/β) squared, while the double pole at s = −1 produces the logarithmic and constant contributions The remaining poles at s = −2k − 1, k ≥ 1, give ck = 2/ (1−2(-k-1)) ζ(-2k−1)ζ(s-2k) / (s+3/2)!

Title and authors: Kai: Before we get into the details, let's talk about who wrote this and what they're calling it. The paper is "The large N vector model with angular velocity," and it’s written by Justin R Davida, Srijan Kumarb, and Peng Huanwu Center for Fundamental Theory people from IISc and USTC in China.

Mira: Yeah, the authors bring different strengths to this. You have the theoretical condensed matter perspective on how these models relate to CFTs, and then you have the experimentalist's view on what actually gets built and measured with superconducting qubits and cryogenics.

Lev: From my side, I’m more focused on how this setup would translate to real hardware. If you take this large N model, you need to think about the overhead of implementing that sort of geometry or angular velocity in a physical system.

Kai: So, they set up this mathematical framework on S one by two with an angular velocity called mu hat without any singlet constraint. That’s the basic setup we’re dealing with here, and it sets the stage for what they try to compute.

Mira: The title itself points to the core issue: how adding that angular velocity affects the dynamics of a large N vector model on that specific geometry. It immediately makes you think about breaking symmetries and how those changes affect the physics we usually study in simpler, zero-angular-velocity cases.

Lev: And because they are studying this at large N, it suggests they are aiming for a mean field description where the dynamics simplify to something manageable, even with that rotation present.

The paper's summary: Kai: So what’s the main thrust of the paper? It’s about studying the free energy of this critical vector model at large N on S one by two with an angular velocity, and they are doing it without any singlet constraint.

Mira: They emphasize that this specific setup is important because it provides a direct field theory computation for a non-trivial conformal field theory. This means they aren't just guessing; they are calculating something that should be true based on other theoretical frameworks.

Lev: What I hear is that the main result they are highlighting is how this free energy smoothly interpolates between two fixed points. It’s not just one point; it shows a continuous path between different physical limits.

Kai: So, they find that the leading high-temperature behavior of the free energy develops a pole when mu hat squared r squared equals one, which matches what we expect from thermal effective field theory calculations.

Mira: And they can actually get the residue at that specific pole by placing the model onto a pp-wave geometry. That’s a powerful check because it connects their field theory calculation to another geometric setting.

Lev: It also shows that this free energy connects two very different scenarios: it links the non-trivial fixed point of the standard O N model at zero angular potential, where mu hat is zero, to its free fixed point when mu hat squared r squared equals one.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now, they talk about how this work improves things. They use a high temperature expansion to show that the leading behavior of the free energy is given by that pole at mu hat squared r squared equals one.

Mira: They show that this free energy smoothly interpolates between the non-trivial fixed point of the standard O N model at large N with quartic interaction and vanishing angular potential, where mu hat is zero, and its free fixed point when mu hat squared r squared equals one.

Lev: The ratio they calculate between those two limits is interesting: it’s four over five when you look at the log of Z zero saddle point divided by the log of Z free at zero angular potential.

Kai: And in the other limit, when mu hat squared r squared equals one, that same ratio is one. That tells us something specific about how these two fixed points relate to each other in terms of their free energy scaling.

Mira: They also look at a gap equation for the thermal mass when there’s an angular potential parametrized by x. Near zero, the solution shows a leading order thermal mass that scales like log over x, leading to a regime where this thermal mass goes to infinity as x approaches zero.

Lev: That leads to the qualitative behavior where the thermal mass behaves like m beta tilde minus infinity and m beta times x tilde goes to zero as x approaches zero, which is a very specific way things behave in that region.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on this paper, the main implication is that they have successfully shown an interpolation of the free energy between two different fixed points for the large N vector model with angular velocity. It helps us understand how a standard O N model with angular velocity behaves near its non-trivial infrared fixed point and zero angular potential when compared to its free theory at mu hat squared r squared equals one.

Mira: They also developed methods for evaluating partition functions at non-zero angular potential and solving those gap equations. These methods could be useful for generalizing to other vector models with different interactions or even higher dimensions.

Lev: For us in the engineering world, the most concrete prediction is that the study of this vector model on a pp-wave geometry predicts that these poles must coincide with that of free theory. That’s a strong constraint we can check against any real simulation or experiment you might design.

Kai: We’re looking forward to seeing how this new understanding of the large N vector model with angular velocity affects our next steps in building and testing these kinds of high-energy theories.

Mira: It's definitely a piece that helps map out the behavior of these rotating systems, and we hope it opens up avenues for studying more complex interactions in thermal effective field theory.

More episodes

← Home