SymTFT in Superspace

summary

The gist

We propose a manifestly supersymmetric formulation of the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SuSymTFT) for theories with supersymmetry The SuSymTFT is a framework that helps organizing symmetries and…

In short

The paper proposes a manifestly supersymmetric formulation of Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SuSymTFT) by constructing it as a topological field theory on a supermanifold. It generalizes BF theory to include supersymmetry, allowing for the systematic study of symmetries and anomalies in supersymmetric quantum field theories, including examples like compact and chiral super-bosons.

Key concepts

Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT)
A framework that organizes symmetries and anomalies in Quantum Field Theory (QFT) by associating them with topological defects. It unifies the treatment of charged and charge operators, serving as a tool to handle their anomalies.
SuSymTFT
The supersymmetric version of SymTFT, constructed on a supermanifold. It provides a geometric way to organize symmetries according to their fermionic grading, using the structure of superspace to define the theory's bulk and boundary.
Super-BF Action
The general action for this topological theory written on a supermanifold. It involves promoting ordinary forms into pseudoforms that saturate both even and odd dimensions, ensuring manifest supersymmetry in the construction.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

SymTFT in Superspace · Read on arXiv

Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics · Dipartimento di Fisica, Università degli Studi di Milano–Bicocca and INFN, Sezione di Milano–Bicocca · Università del Piemonte Orientale · INFN, Sez. Torino

DOI: 10.1103/cv6g-twbs

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "SymTFT in Superspace".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We propose a manifestly supersymmetric formulation of the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SuSymTFT) for theories with supersymmetry The SuSymTFT is a framework that helps organizing symmetries and anomalies of a QFT Here, we consider the most prominent example of theories exhibiting fermionic symmetries, that is supersymmetric models We provide the general construction of the SuSymTFT as a super-BF theory living in a (nm)-dimensional supermanifold and check our proposal in two particular examples, the compact and the chiral super-bosons in two dimensions The modern notion of symmetry in Quantum Field Theory (QFT) goes well beyond ordinary unitary group-like operators acting on local operators <ref:2604.15424#pg2> The seminal paper

1: has led to a true revolution in our understanding of symmetries: Symmetries of QFTs have been naturally associated to topological defects, allowing for a vast generalization of their notion, including higher-form symmetries, non-invertible symmetries and, more generally, categorical (non-group-like) structures <ref:2604.15424#pg2> A particularly efficient way of packaging these data is through the symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT)

8–17: <ref:2604.15424#pg2> The advantage of the SymTFT is that it provides a unified framework to treat charged and charge operators on the same footing, while also serving as an organizing tool to handle their anomalies <ref:2604.15424#pg2> General Construction in Superspace In superspace, supersymmetry acts geometrically along the odd directions, and bosonic and fermionic currents are assembled into supermultiplets <ref:2604.15424#pg2> Reformulating SymTFT directly in superspace is therefore not only aesthetically natural, but also conceptually useful <ref:2604.15424#pg2> Given a supersymmetric theory living on a supermanifold SM(dm), we construct a supersymmetric SymTFT, or SuSymTFT, defined on a bulk supermanifold SM(d+1n) whose boundary contains the physical superspace <ref:2604.15424#pg2> The odd bulk dimension n is determined by the bulk supersymmetry and by the amount preserved at the boundary; in the standard half-BPS situation one expects n = 2m <ref:2604.15424#pg2> BF Theory on Supermanifolds The symmetry sector of a QFT defined on a d-dimensional smooth manifold M(d) can be encoded in a topological theory in one dimension higher: its Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) <ref:2604.15424#pg3> If the physical theory on M(d) has a symmetry group G (this may be internal or even spacetime), then its SymTFT is a theory of flat connection for the G group on M(d+1) <ref:2604.15424#pg3> The topological BF theory is described by the following general action SBF = Z M(d+1) b (d−p) ∧ da(p) (1)<ref:2604.15424#pg3> Supersymmetric BF Action In order to write a BF action in the SM(d+1m) supermanifold, it is sufficient to promote ordinary forms in the action (1) to pseudoforms, such that their product saturates both the even and the odd dimensions <ref:2604.15424#pg3> The most general expression for a super-BF action is then SsBF = Z SM(d+1m) b (d−pm−q) ∧ da(pq) (5)<ref:2604.15424#pg3> SuSymTFT Construction Having introduced the topological BF theory on supermanfolds, we can use it to construct the Supersymmetric version of the SymTFT (SuSymTFT) for supersymmetric theories defined in superspace <ref:2604.15424#pg3> Generalizing the construction reviewed above for bosonic theories, in the supersymmetric setup the SuSymTFT for a theory living in a supermanifold SM(dm) is a topological field theory on the supermanifold SM(d+1n) such that ∂SM(d+1n) = SM(dm) <ref:2604.15424#pg3> Scalar Supermultiplet Example As a first simple example, we consider the free theory for a N = (1, 1) super-compact boson living in a flat supermanifold SM(22) <ref:2604.15424#pg4> The physical degrees of freedom - one compact scalar plus two Majorana-Weyl fermions - are governed by the following action S = 1/4π Z SM(22) dΦ ∧ ⋆dΦ (19)<ref:2604.15424#pg4> Global Symmetries and Charges The system possesses two (on-shell) closed quantities, a (10)-superform J = dΦ and its dual (12)-integral form Je = ⋆dΦ, which lead to two conserved U(1) currents <ref:2604.15424#pg5> The topological charges implementing the action of these symmetries on local operators are Ug(Γ(10)) = exp ig 2πR Z Γ(10) dΦ = exp ig 2πR Z SM(22) dΦ ∧ Y (12) Γ(10) Vh(Σ(12)) = exp ihR Z Σ(10) ⋆dΦ = exp ihR Z SM(22) ⋆dΦ ∧ Y (10) Σ(12) (24)<ref:2604.15424#pg5> Spacetime Symmetries Supersymmetry currents with lower picture can be obtained by applying the Z, Z PCOs defined in appendix A <ref:2604.15424#pg6> To determine the topological generators of super-translations, it is convenient to use the (12)-picture of the S current, see eq.

Kai: (29) <ref:2604.15424#pg6> Mixed Anomaly for Compact Boson The gauged action is manifestly invariant under local shifts Φ → Φ + ω, B → B + dω (40)<ref:2604.15424#pg7> Moreover, as detailed in appendix C, applying gauge transformations of gravitational and Be backgrounds of the form χ → χ + dΛ, Be → B˜ + dωe − Σ(Λ, B) (41) with Σ(Λ, B) determined in appendix C (see eqs.

Mira: (85,86)), the action is invariant up to the following ’t Hooft anomaly δS

B, B, χ e: = 1/4π Z SM(22) ωe ∧ dB (42)<ref:2604.15424#pg7> Supersymmetry with Boundary In supergeometry, an infinitesimal supersymmetry transformation is captured by the Lie derivative with respect to the vector field ϵ = ϵ αQα, where Qα are the real supercharges of the theory <ref:2604.15424#pg8> Instead, if the supermanifold has a boundary the last term in (90) survives as a boundary term Z ∂SM ιϵω (91)<ref:2604.15424#pg8> Chiral Supermultiplet Dynamics The chirality constraint implies that the degrees of freedom reduce to a single holomorphic boson and a single holomorphic fermion <ref:2604.15424#pg5> The results found above for the chiral sector of the compact boson can be easily adapted to the present model <ref:2604.15424#pg6> Self-Duality in Supermanifolds In a supermanifold, the (anti-)self-duality condition (51) is promoted to an analogue condition for the superform Φ

51: The chirality - or equivalently the self-duality - constraint implies that the expansion of the (10)-supercurrent J is shortened to J = V ∂Φ + ψDΦ (55)<ref:2604.15424#pg7> Mixed and Gravitational Anomalies We then conclude that in the chiral model there is no mixed gauge-supersymmetry anomaly <ref:2604.15424#pg7> In order to take it into account, we linearly couple the supersymmetry current S (11) to a gravitational background field H(11) <ref:2604.15424#pg8> Supersymmetric SuSymTFT in 3D The continuous global symmetry sector is encoded into a SuSymTFT consisting of a bulk abelian N = 2 supersymmetric BF theory, whose action in the SM(34) supermanifold reads SsBF = 1/4π Z SM(34) A1 ∧ dA2 (44)<ref:2604.15424#pg8> Supersymmetric Boundary Conditions To make the SuSymTFT of the super-compact boson, we have to fix appropriate physical and topological boundary conditions <ref:2604.15424#pg8> We take SM(34) to be a supermanifold of the form SM(34) = I (12) × SM(22) phys ∪ SM(22) top <ref:2604.15424#pg8> In this paper we have proposed an intrinsically supersymmetric formulation of the SymTFT – the SuSymTFT <ref:2604.15424#pg2> We have advanced a formal construction of the SymTFT in a supersymmetric environment, but more work is required to embed our construction within the most general systematic study of spacetime and superconformal symmetries

26: <ref:2604.15424#pg2> This work leaves many open interesting direction for future investigations <ref:2604.15424#pg2> A Picture Changing Operators Primer Here we depict a few ingredients regarding PCOs, which we use in the main text <ref:2604.15424#pg2> Lowering PCOs, denoted as Z (0-q), instead remove q delta’s <ref:2604.15424#pg3> Given Z (0-1) in (69) we have the freedom to add exact terms without modifying the cohomology class <ref:2604.15424#pg2> SM(22) Supermanifold Parametrization We parametrize the SM(22) minkowskian superspace by two bosonic light-cone real coordinates (x++, x−−) ≡ (z, z) and one Majorana spinor θα = (θ+, θ−) ≡ (θ, θ) with real entries <ref:2604.15424#pg3> The corresponding differential 1-forms are (dz, dz, dθ, dθ) and the flat super-vielbeins read V = dz + θdθ, V = dz + θdθ, ψ = dθ, ψ = dθ (71)<ref:2604.15424#pg3> Chiral Supermultiplet Self-Duality Upon choosing the following PCO 7 Y (02) = δ(ψ) − V V δ′(ψ)δ′(ψ) (54) and expanding dΦ and ⋆dΦ as in (21), constraint (52) enforces and is enforced by the usual (anti)-self-duality condition DΦ = 0 <ref:2604.15424#pg4> Gravitational Anomaly Compensation The action in (61) is manifestly invariant under gauge transformations (60) thanks to the closure of S(11) <ref:2604.15424#pg5> It is then straightforward to see that this variation can be canceled by modifying the gauge transformation of Be as Be → Be + dωe − Σ(Λ, B) (88)<ref:2604.15424#pg5> Supersymmetry with Boundary Details The integral of a top form ω on a manifold without boundary is automatically supersymmetric, as Z SM Lϵω ≡ Z SM ιϵ(dω) + d(ιϵω) = 0 (90)<ref:2604.15424#pg6> Instead, if the supermanifold has a boundary the last term in (90) survives as a boundary term Z ∂SM ιϵω (91)<ref:2604.15424#pg6> Boundary Conditions for N=2 Theory We can easily check that with such boundary conditions the expression LsBF(A∂, A˜∂) is identically vanishing, therefore the symTFT is manifestly supersymmetric in SM(34) <ref:2604.15424#pg6> The PCO Y (02) necessarily introduced in (47) for matching the form picture, localizes the expression on two out of four fermionic directions <ref:2604.15424#pg6> Final Result for SuSymTFT The most general expansions of (10) and (12) forms on the basis of super-vielbeins (92) read A1 = A˜ aV a+ A˜α i,abV aV b ι i α+ A˜(αβ) (ij) V 3 ι i α ι j β δ 4 (ψ) and A2 = AaV a + A i αψ αi (98)<ref:2604.15424#pg6> Inserting these expansions in the bulk action (44), it is easy to work out that SsBF has the following form SsBF = 1/4π Z SM(34) LsBF(A, A˜) V 3 δ 4 (ψ), with LsBF(A, A ˜) = ϵ abc A˜ aFbc − A˜i abγcWi <ref:2604.15424#pg6> This expression is obtained by the supergeometry setting in D=4 N = 1 framework and it shows a phenomena discussed in

34: leading to the chiral and antichiral splitting of supersymmetric actions (a complete discussion is found also in

45: ) <ref:2604.15424#pg6> References

1: D.

Kai: Gaiotto, A.

Title and authors: Mira: So we’ve looked at what this paper is about—the "SymTFT in Superspace"—and the authors are tackling the fermionic case of symmetry topological field theory directly, using supermanifolds to organize things by grading. This moves beyond just bosonic symmetries because they can handle higher-form symmetries and categorical structures as well.

Kai: It’s interesting how they frame it, saying that this approach allows for a manifest organization of the symmetries according to their fermionic grading, which is conceptually useful when dealing with supersymmetry. I wonder if that structure simplifies the anomaly handling they mentioned in the introduction.

Lev: Manifest organization sounds nice on paper, but as an engineer building error correction codes, I immediately start wondering about how much overhead this topological structure adds to what we already know about gauge anomalies. Does this construction simplify the error checking process or just make it harder to debug?

Mira: Well, the paper explains that one major advantage of this SymTFT is that it provides a unified framework to treat charged and charge operators on the same footing, while also serving as an organizing tool to handle their anomalies. It lets you manage those things in one place.

Kai: That’s key because usually, when you have both charged matter and topological features, they get treated separately until you try to calculate the anomaly. This paper seems to bridge that gap by giving them a single language for both aspects of the theory.

Lev: A unified language is good, but I need to know if this unification means we can actually compute things faster or if it just introduces new layers of mathematical complexity that slow down the actual simulation on real systems.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, summarizing the main point of "SymTFT in Superspace," they propose a general construction for the SuSymTFT as a topological field theory on a supermanifold SM(d+1n) that sits over the physical superspace SM(dm) <ref:2604.15424#pg1>. This is the core idea.

Mira: It’s important to know that they define this bulk theory using a supersymmetric BF action, SsBF, which is formulated by promoting ordinary forms into pseudoforms so they saturate both the even and odd dimensions of the supermanifold.

Lev: Promoting forms to pseudoforms is a common trick in these contexts, but I need to know what constraints that puts on the actual physical fields we are interested in. Are we just looking at a simplified model here?

Kai: They test this construction on specific examples, like the free theory for an N = (one one) super-compact boson living on a flat supermanifold SM(twenty-two) <ref:2604.15424#pg1>. This gives us concrete math to look at.

Mira: In that example, they define the physical degrees of freedom—one compact scalar and two Majorana-Weyl fermions—and the action is given by something like one over four pi times the volume form integrated with its dual.

Lev: Okay, so we have a specific theory setup defined on this supermanifold, and now we have this topological description of it. I’m trying to visualize how that topological description relates back to the actual dynamics of those two fermions and that scalar field on a computer chip.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now, let's talk about what the authors suggest as improvements or deeper insights they found in this construction. They focus heavily on how global symmetries and charges are implemented within this framework using specific topological charges.

Mira: They introduce two conserved quantities, a superform J and its dual integral form Je, which lead to two U(one) currents <ref:2604.15424#pg1>. The way they define the topological charges implementing these symmetries on local operators is what’s really interesting here for understanding how the symmetries act.

Lev: Those topological charges sound abstract. How do those translate into anything tangible? Does this mean we can calculate conserved quantities more easily, or are we just defining new mathematical objects that don't help us with real computation?

Kai: They also look at spacetime symmetries, like super-translations, and they suggest using a specific picture changing operator, denoted as the Z PCOs defined in appendix A. This lets them determine the topological generators of super-translations by using a specific picture for the S current.

Mira: And then they tackle mixed anomalies—the mixed gauge-supersymmetry anomaly—showing how it arises in gauged actions and then identifying inflow actions that compensate for it, which is a standard tool in this field.

Lev: So they are showing that there’s a way to systematically calculate these anomalies by relating them to bulk dynamics, which is useful because we can't just guess the compensation term; it has to be derived from the theory itself.

Conclusion: Kai: Wrapping up, this paper on "SymTFT in Superspace" really gives us a formal way to construct supersymmetric SymTFTs using supermanifolds, and they’ve shown it works for simple models like the super-compact boson. It’s a solid foundation for tackling more complex theories.

Mira: The key implication is that this framework allows you to organize symmetries according to their fermionic grading, which helps manage those tricky anomalies by relating them directly to the bulk topological theory structure. It’s a powerful organizing tool for QFT symmetries in general.

Lev: I still think we need more work on how this translates into actual computational overhead. Right now, the complexity seems tied up in defining these supergeometric expansions and picture changing operators, which might be hard to implement efficiently on existing architectures.

Kai: That’s a fair point, Lev; the paper does suggest more work is needed to embed this construction within the most general systematic study of spacetime and superconformal symmetries. But it opens up interesting directions for future investigations.

Mira: Exactly, so while the construction is formal and mathematically sound on these examples, embedding it systematically into a broader context of spacetime symmetries is the next big challenge for this field. It points toward where we need to go next in understanding these theories.

Lev: Yeah, so if we take this paper as a starting point for how to structure the bulk theory on a supermanifold, then the next step is figuring out how to make that concrete enough for error correction or any real physical realization.

Kai: That’s the path forward. We’ll keep an eye on how this formal machinery helps us tackle those more complicated supersymmetric models we are aiming for.

More episodes

← Home