Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity

summary

The gist

Spinning states and unitarity in 3D gravity revisits proposals to cure negative density of states in the threedimensional gravitational path integral by adding spinning states whose spin scales with…

In short

The paper explores adding specific spinning states to 3D gravity to fix known problems (negativities) in the density of states calculation for black hole physics. It finds that sub-extremal and extremal states below the black hole threshold, plus certain overspinning states above it, can cancel these negativities, suggesting a path toward a positive density of states.

Key concepts

Spectral Negativity
This refers to known problems where the density of quantum states in gravity calculations becomes negative. The authors investigate how adding specific spinning states helps cancel these negative contributions in the partition function, aiming to make the total state count positive.
Spinning States Classification
The paper categorizes spinning states into three types based on their relationship to the BTZ black hole threshold: sub-extremal defects below it, extremal states exactly at the threshold, and overspinning states above it. These categories help determine which specific states are needed to resolve spectral negativity.
MWK Partition Function
This is the specific mathematical function used in three-dimensional anti-de Sitter spacetime gravity calculations. Its density of states is computed using sums over modular crossing kernels and Kloosterman sums, which decompose the result into different spin sectors.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity · Read on arXiv

Ziyi Li

University of California at Davis

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spinning states and unitarity in 3D gravity revisits proposals to cure negative density of states in the threedimensional gravitational path integral by adding spinning states whose spin scales with the central charge, showing that sub-extremal and extremal spinning states below the black hole threshold, together with certain overspinning states above it, can cancel known negativities in the spectrum Addressing Spectral Negativity The paper investigates how adding specific spinning states can resolve the known negativities in the density of states of the Maloney–Witten–Keller (MWK) partition function The authors show that sub-extremal and extremal spinning states below the black hole threshold, as well as certain massive overspinning states above it, can cancel known negativities in the semiclassical regimes analyzed here The positivity proof for the scalar sector is exact for these sub-extremal and extremal families Characterizing Spinning States The paper classifies the spinning states into three categories based on their relation to the BTZ black hole threshold: 1.

Kai: Sub-extremal spinning states below the black hole threshold, which are interpreted as bulk spinning defects 2.

Mira: Extremal spinning states at the black hole threshold 3.

Kai: Overspinning states above the BTZ threshold, interpreted as maximal, fixed-point-free BTZ quotients Analyzing Positivity and Bounds The authors analyze the positivity of the total density of states by adding sub-extremal and extremal seeds to cancel large-spin negativities For the overspinning states, a bound on degeneracy is established, summarized in Table 1 The scalar positivity result for sub-extremal and extremal states places no upper bound on the degeneracy d of the added states Bulk Geometries and Completions The paper distinguishes between two bulk interpretations for the spinning seeds: a spinning-defect completion below threshold, which is adopted as conventional, and a maximal overspinning BTZ quotient above it The former is supported by a stress-energy tensor localized at the defect The latter is studied as a smooth Lorentzian vacuum quotient with a pathological second boundary Equivalence of Constructions The paper demonstrates that the image expression for the overspinning background is proposed by a quotient-motivated image expression suggested by the quotient and geodesic result This image expression agrees exactly with the positive-frequency mode sum derived from first principles The two constructions agree branch by branch as Lorentzian Wightman boundary values The paper concludes that each spinning family contains states that can cure existing negativities without introducing new ones in the semiclassical regimes analyzed The choice between the spinning-defect and maximal-quotient completions remains open, as both are candidate interpretations of the added CFT seeds rather than established Euclidean saddles The difficulty lies in matching the dual characters exactly, which requires a nontrivial cancellation involving matter degrees of freedom for some completions Review of MWK Partition Function The appendix reviews the basic assumptions and computations underlying the Euclidean gravitational path integral in three-dimensional anti-de Sitter spacetime The partition function is related to the Virasoro character of a primary state of weight H The density of states is computed as a P SL(2,Z) sum of modular crossing kernels The resulting density involves sums over Kloosterman sums to decompose into spin sectors Extremal Defect Correlator The extremal negative-mass geometry is described by an elliptic–parabolic quotient, with one elliptic and one parabolic chiral holonomy The scalar wave equation in these coordinates reduces to the Whittaker equation The quantization condition for the modes is derived from regularity at the defect location z = ∞ Image Expression Equivalence The image expression reproduces the positive-frequency mode sum exactly when taking the limit of a regulated image expression as epsilon approaches zero The Fourier-transform condition pkl > 0 is the same as the Whittaker branch condition ωkl + l > 0 The opposite boundary value gives G−(t, ϕ) = G+(−t, −ϕ) and agrees with the Q < 0 branch Finite-ξ Numerical Check The finite-ξ numerical check confirms positivity at leading semiclassical order and shows that the convergent remainder Rj(t) is positive throughout the tested range The numerical calculation suggests that for d = 2, the convergent remainder Rj(t) is positive throughout the tested range Euclidean Continuation and Bulk Interpretation The Euclidean interpretation of these geometries depends on how the Lorentzian spacetime is completed, and it is important to specify which cycle of the boundary torus becomes contractible The bulk geometries should therefore be regarded as candidate interpretations of the added CFT seeds rather than established Euclidean saddles The Euclidean filling, contour, and boundary conditions remain open questions regarding the gravitational integration contour Uniqueness of Spinning States The search for overspinning states is guided by the requirement that they should not introduce new negativities in the scalar density when ξt ≲ O(1) while at the same time avoiding overly restrictive conditions on ξ The choice of spin leads to different quantization conditions on ξ, and a bottom-up analysis does not uniquely determine which states should be added A top-down embedding might ultimately determine the admissibility of these candidate saddles Euclidean Continuation of Spinning Geometries The Euclidean interpretation of these geometries depends on how the Lorentzian spacetime is completed, and it is important to specify which cycle of the boundary torus becomes contractible and require its holonomy to lie in the center The conventional spinning-defect completion is adopted because it introduces a source by construction The extremal identification is constructed separately, as discussed above The Euclidean interpretation of the overspinning geometry has mixed elliptic–hyperbolic holonomy, which suggests a two-boundary amplitude Bulk Interpretation Summary The spectral construction does not by itself determine which of these bulk completions belongs to the gravitational integration contour The locally AdS3 quotient structure leads to analytically continued or quotient-motivated image expressions The Euclidean filling, contour, and boundary conditions remain open questions regarding the gravitational integration contour Acknowledgments The authors thank David Berenstein, Steve Carlip, and Jacqueline Caminiti for helpful discussions They also acknowledge Claude and ChatGPT for assistance with numerical computations, TikZ figure preparation, and language/format editing A Review of the MWK Partition Function The appendix reviews the basic assumptions and computations underlying the Euclidean gravitational path integral in three-dimensional anti-de Sitter spacetime The classical action of Euclidean AdS3 is readily evaluated using (A.1) The semiclassical partition function of Euclidean AdS3 can be written as Z(β, θ) = Trh e−βH+iθJ i = Trh q L0− c 24 q¯ L¯0− c 24 i The full contribution to the partition function is given by Z(τ, τ¯) = X γ∈Γ∞ SL(2,Z) ZEAdS3 (γ · τ, γ · τ¯) Density of States Calculation The density of states for the MWK partition function is given by a sum over modular crossing kernels The decomposition into spin sectors yields the expression for ρ MWK j involving Kloosterman sums The remaining terms can be computed similarly after decomposing the result into spin sectors Extremal Defect Correlator Details The scalar correlator for the extremal negative-mass geometry is studied by performing a coordinate transformation to z = β 2+ r 2+ The wave equation in these coordinates reduces to the Whittaker equation The quantization condition for the modes is derived from regularity at the defect location z = ∞ Image Expression Equivalence Details The image expression reproduces the positive-frequency mode sum when taking epsilon to zero, and this agrees exactly with the positive-frequency mode sum The Fourier-transform condition pkl > 0 is determined by the integral representation of Ikl The resulting Wightman function is recovered at the end by taking epsilon to zero Positive Frequency Mode Sum The positive-frequency mode sum is given by G+img(t, ϕ) = X∞ k=0 Xl∈Z pkl>0 (2β+) ∆ p∆−1k Γ(∆ + k) Γ(∆)2Γ(k + 1) e−iωklt+ilϕ This agrees exactly with the positive-frequency mode sum (3.39), including its normalization The Fourier-transform condition pkl > 0 is therefore the same as the Whittaker branch condition ωkl + l > 0 Opposite Boundary Value The opposite boundary value gives G−(t, ϕ) = G+(−t, −ϕ) and agrees with the Q < 0 branch The two expressions agree as Wightman boundary values The opposite boundary value gives G−(t, ϕ) = G+(−t, −ϕ) and agrees with the Q < 0 branch Finite-ξ Numerical Check Details The numerical calculation shows that the convergent remainder Rj(t) is positive throughout the tested range The smallest value was R(120) 1(0) = 984.938 at the overspinning point (ξ, J) = (3/2, 1) The numerical calculation shows that for small ξ, the bound initially dips before stabilizing around d ∼ 3.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Spinning States and Unitarity in three dee Gravity" <ref:2604.14492#pg1,Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity>. It tackles a big problem with the density of states in the three-dimensional gravitational path integral.

Mira: Right, it's about how adding specific spinning states can fix that known negativity issue. The authors show that sub-extremal and extremal spinning states below the black hole threshold, plus certain overspinning states above it, can cancel out those negativities in the spectrum.

Lev: That means they are trying to restore unitarity in this model of gravity by tuning what kind of gravitational excitations you include in your calculation.

Kai: They classify these spinning states into three groups based on their relation to the BTZ black hole threshold: sub-extremal states below it, extremal states right at the threshold, and overspinning states above it.

Mira: The paper interprets the sub-extremal ones as bulk spinning defects, which is a conventional way to think about those kinds of objects in gravity.

Lev: And they look at the overspinning states differently; they interpret them as maximal, fixed-point-free BTZ quotients instead of just classical spinning strings.

Kai: What's interesting is that these overspinning geometries show causal pathologies when you try to continue them into Lorentzian spacetime.

Mira: Exactly. They arise from mixed elliptic and hyperbolic identifications and have one formally real chiral temperature, which points toward a more complex structure there.

Lev: So, while the negative density of states in the Maloney–Witten–Keller partition function is a known feature, these new states are proposed to cancel those terms out in the semiclassical regimes they are analyzing.

Kai: The authors also established some bounds on degeneracy for those overspinning states, summarizing them in Table one <ref:2604.14492#pg2>. They also found that for the sub-extremal and extremal scalar sector results, there's no upper bound on how many of those added states you can have.

Mira: That lack of an upper bound is something to watch because it suggests a lot of freedom in how you can construct these states to achieve positivity.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means the overhead for implementing this correction would depend heavily on the specific spin you choose for those added states, which leads to different quantization conditions on your parameters.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we have these three categories of spinning states below and above the black hole threshold that they are using to repair the spectrum.

Mira: The core idea is that by carefully selecting these seeds, you can resolve known negativities in the spectrum without introducing new ones in the semiclassical regimes they are studying.

Lev: But there's still a big open question about which of those bulk completions—the spinning defect or the maximal quotient—actually belongs on your gravitational integration contour.

Kai: That choice is crucial because it dictates how you interpret the geometry when you move from these Euclidean calculations to the physical, Lorentzian spacetime.

Mira: It sounds like the paper is setting up a framework where the dual CFT might be unitary in certain limits, provided you include these specific gravitational excitations.

Lev: And that leads us into the conclusion of "Spinning States and Unitarity in three dee Gravity" <ref:2604.14492#pg1,Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity>. The authors argue that each spinning family they introduced contains states capable of curing existing negativities without introducing new ones in the semiclassical regimes analyzed.

Kai: So, the main thrust is this specific construction manages to keep things positive where they used to be negative.

Mira: And the real sticking point, as the paper points out, is that choosing between the spinning-defect and maximal-quotient completions remains open because both are candidate interpretations of those added CFT seeds rather than established Euclidean saddles.

Lev: So, for someone building actual hardware or running simulations on this theory, you still have to figure out which completion makes sense physically.

Kai: It sounds like the paper is less about delivering one final answer and more about providing a set of candidates for how to fix the known problems in the density of states.

Mira: And it highlights that matching those dual characters exactly might require a non-trivial cancellation involving matter degrees of freedom for some of those completions.

Lev: That's a big hurdle, because if you need extra stuff like matter degrees of freedom to match things up, that adds complexity to the entire system.

Kai: The whole paper is built around revisiting how you cure the negative density of states in the threedimensional gravitational path integral by adding these spinning states whose spin scales with the central charge.

Paper summary: Mira: It's a necessary step because before this, the spectrum was continuous rather than discrete, which challenged how we usually interpret pure three-dimensional gravity as dual to a single CFT two.

Lev: The paper also spends time reviewing the Maloney–Witten–Keller partition function itself, showing how the density of states calculation involves sums over modular crossing kernels and Kloosterman sums to decompose into spin sectors.

Kai: And when they get to the extremal negative-mass geometry, they study its scalar correlator by transforming coordinates to z equals beta squared plus r squared, reducing the wave equation there to a Whittaker equation.

Mira: That reduction is interesting because it links the gravity problem down to a known solvable mathematical equation in that specific coordinate system.

Lev: And when they look at the image expression for the overspinning background, they find it agrees exactly with the positive-frequency mode sum when you take the limit of a regulated image expression as epsilon approaches zero.

Kai: That agreement is pretty strong, showing that their quotient-motivated image expression reproduces the positive-frequency mode sum exactly when you look at the right limit.

Mira: But they also found that for small values of xi, the bound on degeneracy initially dips before stabilizing around d equals three.

Lev: So, while they show positivity at leading semiclassical order and a convergent remainder is positive throughout the tested range for some cases, there are still limits to how far those results hold.

Kai: The paper's conclusion is that each spinning family contains states that can cure existing negativities without introducing new ones in the semiclassical regimes analyzed.

Mira: But they have to acknowledge that the choice between the spinning-defect and maximal-quotient completions remains open, as both are candidate interpretations of those added CFT seeds rather than established Euclidean saddles.

Lev: That ambiguity means the actual physical interpretation depends on how you complete that Lorentzian spacetime, which is still an open question regarding the gravitational integration contour.

Kai: So, to sum up this paper called "Spinning States and Unitarity in three dee Gravity", it suggests a way to cancel known spectral problems using specific spinning states, but the final physical picture depends on which bulk completion you pick <ref:2604.14492#pg1,Spinning States and Unitarity in 3D Gravity>.

Mira: It's a step forward because it provides concrete candidates for fixing the spectrum, even if it leaves some deep structural questions about how gravity should be completed in that framework.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at these spinning states in three dimensional gravity, and this paper is called "Spinning States and Unitarity in three dee Gravity."

Mira: Right, it boils down to using these specific spinning states to fix a known problem with the density of states calculation.

Lev: That calculation involves sums over modular crossing kernels, which leads to negative numbers in some regimes that shouldn't be there for a unitary theory.

Kai: The authors show that by adding sub-extremal and extremal spinning states below the black hole threshold, plus some overspinning states above it, those known negativities actually get canceled out.

Mira: That means they’re proposing a way to make the density of states positive again in those semiclassical limits they looked at.

Lev: The caveat is that this depends entirely on which bulk geometry you choose to interpret those added seeds as—is it a spinning defect or some maximal quotient?

Kai: Exactly. That choice really matters for how we move from these Euclidean calculations to the physical Lorentzian spacetime we might actually be interested in.

Mira: It suggests that the dual conformal field theory might look unitary under these conditions, but only if you include this specific set of gravitational excitations.

Lev: And there's still a hurdle because matching those dual characters exactly might require some matter degrees of freedom to line everything up perfectly.

Kai: So, they provide candidates for curing the negativity, but the final physical picture hinges on that completion choice before we can really say what this means for fundamental gravity.

More episodes

← Home