Revisiting Connes' Finite Spectral Distance on Non-commutative Spaces: Moyal Plane and Fuzzy Sphere

summary

The gist

The paper revises an algorithm to compute the finite Connes’ distance between normal states on non-commutative spaces like the Moyal plane and fuzzy sphere…

In short

The paper revises an algorithm for computing Connes' finite spectral distance between normal states on non-commutative spaces like the Moyal plane and fuzzy sphere. It shows that a corrected formula involving transverse components yields the exact distance under generic conditions, improving upon previous lower-bound only results.

Key concepts

Connes' Distance
This is a measure of how far apart two states are on a non-commutative space. The paper seeks to compute this finite distance between normal states using Hilbert-Schmidt operatorial formulations, moving beyond simple lower bounds to find the exact value.
Moyal Plane
A specific non-commutative space studied in the paper. Its geometry is analyzed by looking at its Dirac operator and eigen-spinor bases. The distance computation here relates to coherent states and their behavior in this setting.
Fuzzy Sphere
Another non-commutative space, modeled using finite $n$-representations of SU(2). Unlike the Moyal plane, a conventional geodesic distance is not defined for all representations. The paper analyzes how the finite distance relates to the commutative sphere's geodesic distance.
Transverse Component ($\Delta\rho_\perp$)
This refers to a component of an algebra element that is orthogonal to the 'longitudinal' component ($\Delta\rho$). Finding which transverse component minimizes an expression is key, but under generic conditions, the distance simplifies and becomes proportional to the trace norm of the difference in density matrices.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Revisiting Connes' Finite Spectral Distance on Non-commutative Spaces: Moyal Plane and Fuzzy Sphere · Read on arXiv

Yendrembam Chaoba Devi, Alpesh Patil, Aritra N Bose, Kaushlendra Kumar, Biswajit Chakraborty, Frederik G Scholtz

S.N.Bose National Centre For Basic Sciences Salt Lake Kolkata India · Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Pune India · Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Kolkata Nadia India · National Institute for Theoretical Physics Stellenbosch South Africa

DOI: 10.1142/S0219887818502043

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Revisiting Connes' Finite Spectral Distance on Non-commutative Spaces".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper revises an algorithm to compute the finite Connes’ distance between normal states on non-commutative spaces like the Moyal plane and fuzzy sphere, showing that while a formula in a previous work only provided a lower bound, a corrected expression involving transverse components yields the exact distance under generic conditions Algorithmic Revision and Correction The original formula in

1: contains an error and actually only provides a lower bound The correct expression involves the computation of the infimum of an expression which involves the “transverse” component of the algebra element in addition to the “longitudinal” component of

1: This renders the formula less user-friendly, as the determination of the exact transverse component for which the infimum is reached remains a non-trivial task, but under rather generic conditions it turns out that the Connes’ distance is proportional to the trace norm of the difference in the density matrices, leading to considerable simplification In addition, we can determine an upper bound of the distance by emulating and adapting the approach of

2: in our Hilbert-Schmidt operatorial formulation Moyal Plane Analysis For the Moyal plane, we can find one optimal element for which the upper bound is reached through a sequence obtained by finite dimensional projections of the representative of an element belonging to a multiplier algebra onto the subspaces of the total Hilbert space occurring in the spectral triple and spanned by the eigen-spinors of the respective Dirac operator In contrast with the fuzzy sphere, where this upper bound is never reached for any finite n-representation of SU(2) For maximal non-commutativity (n = 1/2), the finite distance is shown to coincide exactly with the above mentioned lower bound, with the transverse component playing no role Fuzzy Sphere Geometry For the fuzzy sphere, where one can not define a geodesic in the conventional sense for any finite n-representation of SU(2) The distance turns out to be much smaller than the geodesic distance of S2, which coincides with the above-mentioned upper bound For maximal non-commutativity i.e.

Kai: for n = 1/2, even the finite distance is shown to coincide exactly with the lower bound with transverse component playing no role and any pair of pure states is shown to be interpolated by a one-parameter family of mixed states, lying in the interior of S2 Distance Computation Strategies The computation of (finite) distances on the Moyal plane is done in the coherent and the “harmonic oscillator” basis in sections 4 and 5 For the fuzzy sphere, we adopt a different algorithm using Dirac eigen-spinors and study the n = 1/2 and n = 1 representations of the fuzzy sphere algebra The distance between finitely separated states are additive and they saturate the triangle inequality for the fuzzy sphere, much like in the case of the Moyal plane Results and Comparison The distance between coherent states on the Moyal plane is proportional to the trace norm, which is simply the Euclidean distance, infinitesimally and for finite distances The upper bound of the Connes’ distance on the fuzzy sphere is actually the geodesic distance on the commutative sphere d(ωz, ω0) = rθ This implies that for any finite n representation, the distance between two points on the fuzzy sphere is less than the geodesic distance for a commutative sphere The finite distance for n = 1 and that of n = 1/2 have almost the same functional form except for an overall scaling by a factor of √2 and a minuscule deformation at small ‘θ’ and that too only from the sixth decimal onwards The results show that the transverse component plays a role in improving estimates for finite distances, though it does not contribute to the exact distance when it is saturated Acknowledgements We thank Prof.

Mira: A.P Balachandran for his valuable suggestions AP thanks the INSPIRE and KK thanks SNBNCBS for the financial support to carry out their project works Both of them thank SNBNCBS for the hospitality during their stay when parts of this work were completed Appendix The Dirac operator in Moyal plane, its response to ISO(2) symmetry and a useful identity is presented in Appendix A.1 The Dirac operator transforms as D → D(z) = U(z, z¯)DU† (z, z¯) = r 2 θ 0 b † − z¯ˆ b − z 0 This structure allows us to make it also act directly from the left on Ψ = ψ1iψ2i ∈ Hc ⊗ C2 The Dirac operator for the fuzzy sphere is D ≡ 1/rn J ⊗ σ = 1/rn Jˆ3 Jˆ−Jˆ+ −Jˆ3 For a hermitian algebra element a = a† ∈ A, k

D, π(a): k2op = k

D, π(a): †

D, π(a): kop = 1/r2

J+, a: †

J+, a: +

J3, a: †

[J−, a: ,

J3, a: ] −

[J+, a: ,

J3, a: ]

J−, a: †

D- J3, 0 The ball condition for the fuzzy sphere reduces to k[D, π(a): kop ≤ r The lower bound for the infinitesimal distance is d(ωz+dz, ωz) ≥ tr(dρ2) k

D, π(dρ): kop = r dθr 2n 6n + 1 The finite distance for the discrete basis is given by dn(ωm3, ωn3) = X k i=1 p rn n(n + 1) − (p + i)(p + i − 1) The distance between north and south poles is d(N, S) = √2 r1 which matches exactly with the result of (135) for the distance between discrete states 1ih1 and-1ih−1 The upper bound of the Connes distance on the fuzzy sphere is actually the geodesic distance on the commutative sphere d(ωz, ω0) ≤ 2r tan−1z = rθ The lower bound for infinitesimally separated coherent states is d(ωz, ω0) ≤ √2θz The exact distance for the Moyal plane is d(ρ0, ρdz) = √2θ dz The distance between discrete "harmonic oscillator" states in the Moyal plane is d(ωm, ωn) = rθ2 mX−n i=1 1/√n + i- 1

b, a: n + ii The distance between north and south poles for the fuzzy sphere is d3/2(N, S) = 1.6547 r3/2 The upper bound of the spectral distance on the fuzzy sphere is actually the geodesic distance on the commutative sphere d(ωz, ω0) ≤ 2r tan−1z = rθ The lower bound for infinitesimally separated coherent states is d(ωz, ω0) ≤ √2θz The distance between north and south poles for the fuzzy sphere is d(N, S) = √2 r1 which matches exactly with the result of (135) for the distance between discrete states 1ih1 and-1ih−1 The lower bound for n = 1/2 fuzzy sphere is d(N, S) = r 1/2 dθ References

1: Scholtz F G and Chakraborty B 2013 J Phys A Math Theor 46 085204

2: Martinetti P and Tomassini L 2013 Commun Math Phys 323 107-141

3: Doplicher S, Fredenhagen K, and Roberts J E 1995 Commun Math Phys 172 187

4: Yendrembam C D, Prajapat S, Mukhopadhyay A K, Chakraborty B and Scholtz F G 2015 J Math Phys 56 041707

5: Connes A Non-Commutative Geometry New York Academic

6: Van den Dungen K and van Suijlekom W D Rev Math Phys 24 1230004

7: Cagnache E, D’Andrea F, Martinetti P and Wallet J-C 2011 J Geom Phys 61 1881

8: Martinetti P, Mercati F and Tomassini L 2012 Rev Math Phys 24 1250010

9: Latremoliere F Quantum locally compact metric spaces arXiv:1208.2398 math-ph

10: A M Perelomov Generalized coherent states and some of their applications Sov Phys Usp 20 9 (1977)

11: H Grosse P Preˇsnajder The construction of Non-commutative manifolds using coherent states Lett in Math Phys 28 239-250,1993

12: D’Andrea F Lizzi F, and Varilly J C 2013 Lett Math Phys 103 183

13: Scholtz F G, Chakraborty B, Govaerts J and Vaidya S 2007 J Phys A Math Theor 40 14581

14: Scholtz F G, Gouba L, Hafver A and Rohwer C M 2009 J Phys A Math Theor 42 175303

15: Galluccio S, Lizzi F and Vitale P 2008 Phys Rev D 78 085007; Balachandran A P and Martone M 2009 Mod Phys Lett A 24 1721; Balachandran A P, Ibort A, Marmo G and Martone M 2010 Phys Rev D 81 085017

16: Provost J P and Vallee G 1980 Commun Math Phys 76 289

17: Ashtekar A and Schilling T A 1997 Geometrical formulation of quantum mechanics arXiv:9706069 gr-qc

18: D’Andrea F Pythagoras Theorem in Noncommutative Geometry arXiv: 1507.08773 math-ph

19: Basu P, Chakraborty B and Scholtz F G 2011 J Phys A Math Theor 44 285204

20: Connes A 1995 J Math Phys 36 6194

21: Bratelli O and Robinson D W 1987 Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics vol 1 2nd edn Berlin Springer p 76

22: Iochum B, Krajewski T and Martinetti P 2001 J Geom Phys 37 100-125

23: Conway J B A Course in Functional Analysis 90 New York Springer p 32

24: Rohwer C M and Scholtz F G Additional degrees of freedom associated with position measurements in non-commutative quantum mechanics arXiv:1206.1242 hep-th

33: Connes A 1995 J Math Phys 36 6194 The finite spectral distance for the Moyal plane is proportional to the trace norm, which is simply the Euclidean distance, infinitesimally and for finite distances For the fuzzy sphere, although an analogous upper bound can be constructed for any finite n-representation of su(2), there simply does not exist an optimal element as saturating the inequality In contrast, on the fuzzy sphere, except for the extremal points, the interpolating “points” correspond to mixed states The distance between north and south poles is d(N, S) = √2 r1 which matches exactly with the result of (135) for the distance between discrete states 1ih1 and-1ih−1 Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The formula quoted in

1: actually corresponds to the lower bound However, as far as the computation of infinitesimal distances is concerned, this formula is quite adequate because it can reproduce the local infinitesimal distance up to an overall numerical factor as shown in

1, 4: Knowledge of infinitesimal distances may not be adequate to capture the geometry of a generic non-commutative space because such spaces may not allow a geodesic to be defined in the conventional sense How the training signal is built The lower bound for the spectral distance is found by considering an optimal element as s.t.

Paper summary: Kai: Okay, so to recap this paper Revisiting Connes' Finite Spectral Distance on Non-commutative Spaces: Moyal Plane and Fuzzy Sphere. The main thesis is that they took an old algorithm and made it better for computing the finite distance between normal states on non-commutative spaces like the Moyal plane and fuzzy sphere.

Mira: What they claim is that the original formula only provided a lower bound, but this revised expression computes an infimum involving both longitudinal and transverse components of the algebra element.

Lev: So they are trying to get closer to the true distance by looking at those extra parts of the algebra element that weren't in the first version.

Kai: And under generic conditions, they find that this distance turns out to be proportional to the trace norm of the difference in density matrices, which simplifies things a lot.

Mira: They also provide an upper bound by adapting an approach from another study using their Hilbert-Schmidt operatorial formulation, which is good because it avoids ambiguities from star products.

Lev: So they are doing two things: improving the lower bound and setting up a reliable upper bound using a different mathematical tool.

Kai: And the result is that for the Moyal plane, this approach yields the correct distance in the harmonic oscillator basis and gives you a flat metric in the coherent state, up to an overall scaling factor.

Mira: But for the fuzzy sphere, they find that their upper bound is never reached by any finite n representation of SU two. That's a key difference in how these two spaces are behaving geometrically.

Lev: So when you're trying to apply this to actual hardware, knowing that you can always get an upper bound from the commutative geometry case is helpful for setting expectations on accuracy.

Kai: And they also look at distance computation strategies specifically for the fuzzy sphere using Dirac eigen-spinors and study n equal to one point five and n equal to one representations of the fuzzy sphere algebra.

Mira: It seems like they're using those specific representations to probe the structure of the fuzzy sphere in a way that gives them better insights into its distance properties.

Lev: I just hope these specific checks lead somewhere useful when we try to build actual error correction protocols on these spaces.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've gone through the Revisiting Connes' Finite Spectral Distance on Non-commutative Spaces: Moyal Plane and Fuzzy Sphere paper. The authors are Yendrembam Chaoba Devi, Alpesh Patil, Aritra N Bose, Kaushlendra Kumar, Biswajit Chakraborty, and Frederik G Scholtz.

Mira: The implication is that for these non-commutative spaces—the Moyal plane and the fuzzy sphere—we have a more robust way to calculate distances than what was available before.

Lev: It means that when we try to model quantum systems on these geometries, we can rely on this method giving us an estimate of how far apart states are.

Kai: It's about moving from just knowing a lower bound to having a better estimate that actually works under generic conditions without needing the exact transverse component for the infimum.

Mira: And it highlights that for these spaces, the geometric behavior is quite distinct, especially when comparing the Moyal plane to the fuzzy sphere.

Lev: So when we look at real hardware, this means we can better predict how errors propagate or how quickly states diverge in a physical system.

More episodes

← Home