Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects

summary

The gist

The work constructs and studies a class of codimension-two conformal defects within Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) that possess spontaneously broken conformal symmetry…

In short

This work constructs and studies codimension-two conformal defects in Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) with broken conformal symmetry, generalizing known BPS defects like Gukov-Witten operators. It shows that these defects arise when a continuous internal symmetry is spontaneously broken on the moduli space. The results link defect operator spectra to the mass spectrum of particles in the symmetry-breaking vacuum, providing new exact results for supersymmetric examples and insights into non-conformal vacua.

Key concepts

Codimension-two conformal defects
These are specific types of topological excitations within a CFT that have a codimension of two. They are studied as analytic continuations of saddle point descriptions for large charge operators, interpolating between quantum and semiclassical regimes where local physics approaches the symmetry-breaking vacuum.
Moduli space
The moduli space describes the different possible vacua or configurations within a CFT. The paper investigates how conformal defects are intrinsically linked to this space, as their properties depend on continuous parameters that control operator expectation values and interpolate between regimes.
BPS defects
These are known, often supersymmetric, defects in theories like $\mathcal{N}=4$ SYM or ABJM theory. The study generalizes these concepts by constructing non-supersymmetric defects without relying on supersymmetry, allowing for a broader application to CFTs with broken conformal symmetry.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects · Read on arXiv

Gabriel Cuomo, Adar Sharonc

Sissa Institute of Science and Technology Trieste · INFN Sezione di Trieste · Mani L. Bhaumik Institute for Theoretical Physics Department of Physics and Astronomy University of California Los Angeles

We construct and study a class of codimension-two conformal defects in CFTs with spontaneously broken conformal symmetry, assuming that a continuous global symmetry is also broken on the moduli space. Our construction can be viewed as an analytic continuation of the saddle point describing large charge operators and generalizes known BPS defects in supersymmetric theories, such as Gukov-Witten surface operators in N=4 SYM and vortex loops in ABJM theory, but does not rely on supersymmetry. These defects are characterized by continuous, unbounded parameters controlling the expectation values of operators parametrizing the moduli space, and interpolate between a quantum regime and a semiclassical regime in which the local physics approaches that of the symmetry-breaking vacuum. This connection allows us to derive exact results from the effective description of the broken phase. In particular, our results for Gukov-Witten surface operators agree with localization, and we compute the g-function for a broad class of 1/2-BPS vortex loops in ABJM theory. Finally, we relate the spectrum of defect operators, in a suitable scaling limit, to the spectrum of massive particles in the symmetry-breaking vacuum.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The work constructs and studies a class of codimension-two conformal defects within Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) that possess spontaneously broken conformal symmetry, assuming a continuous global symmetry is also broken on the moduli space.

Kai: This construction is framed as an analytic continuation of the saddle point description for large charge operators and generalizes known BPS defects from supersymmetric theories, such as Gukov-Witten surface operators in N=4 SYM and vortex loops in ABJM theory, without relying on supersymmetry.

Mira: These defects are characterized by continuous, unbounded parameters that control the expectation values of operators parametrizing the moduli space, interpolating between a quantum regime and a semiclassical regime where local physics approaches the symmetry-breaking vacuum.

Kai: The central objective is to advance the understanding of CFTs with moduli spaces by examining this special class of conformal defects whose properties are intrinsically linked to the physics on the moduli space.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today titled "Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects" by Gabriel Cuomo and Adar Sharonc. It’s about how you can construct these codimension-two defects in conformal field theories that have spontaneously broken conformal symmetry, assuming a continuous global symmetry is also broken on the moduli space.

Mira: That sounds like it connects the geometry of the vacuum to something physical we measure in a CFT, which is interesting because usually finding those flat directions requires some kind of fine tuning or supersymmetry.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you're building hardware, you need to know if these defects are stable under real-world conditions or what kind of overhead error correction you'd need for them.

Kai: Exactly. The paper frames this construction as an analytic continuation from the saddle point description used for large charge operators and tries to generalize known BPS defects like Gukov-Witten surface operators or vortex loops in ABJM theory without relying on supersymmetry, which is a big deal.

Mira: It’s a generalization that doesn't need SUSY, so it opens up the study of non-supersymmetric theories with moduli spaces, which is where the real physics often lies.

Lev: But the construction involves continuous parameters controlling expectation values of operators parametrizing the moduli space, interpolating between a quantum regime and a semiclassical regime where local physics approaches that symmetry-breaking vacuum. How do we actually model that interpolation on hardware?

Kai: Well, they show that for codimension-two defects, local operators parametrizing the moduli space get an expectation value of a specific form involving lambda and the field z and z bar like lambda times O z raised to some power.

Mira: And they mention that this scaling lambda O h scales as h to the power of Delta, where h is related to some large parameter, and the monodromies alpha are generally dependent on h but approach a finite value as h goes really high.

Lev: If those monodromies depend on h, that means you can't just take a simple semiclassical limit; you have to deal with this h-dependence in your calculation for real hardware fidelity.

Kai: The central objective they state is to advance the understanding of CFTs with moduli spaces by looking at these defects whose properties are intrinsically tied to the physics on that moduli space.

Mira: They argue that such defects generically appear in CFTs with non-conformal vacua whenever a continuous internal symmetry is spontaneously broken in some region of the moduli space.

Lev: So they're saying this isn't just a mathematical exercise; it’s a way to find structure in theories that aren't perfectly conformal, which is relevant when we look at things like strongly coupled systems.

Title and authors: Kai: The results show that for codimension-two defects, the local operators parametrizing the moduli space acquire an expectation value of that form we just discussed involving lambda and z and bar z terms.

Mira: They also mention that they studied specific examples like Gukov-Witten surface operators in four dimensional supersymmetric Yang-Mills or vortex loops in ABJM theory.

Lev: If they can identify universal features of the defect operator spectrum at large h, that would give us a concrete target for what we should look for when we try to build these things.

Kai: They provide an effective field theory derivation for the partition function of Gukov-Witten surface operators and compute the g function for a broad class of one-half BPS vortex loops in ABJM theory, which is new work there.

Mira: And they link the spectrum of defect operators in a suitable scaling limit to the mass spectrum of particles in that symmetry-breaking vacuum, which is a very powerful connection.

Lev: That direct link between the defect spectrum and particle masses would be incredibly useful for setting up error correction codes or understanding how excitations propagate on a real system.

Kai: A key result they have is that for odd dimensions, there's a three-parameter family of one-half BPS defects labeled by lambda, its argument, and nu, which works for any flavor monodromy nu if lambda is large enough.

Mira: And when alpha equals the BPS value alpha BPS, the defect free energy becomes independent of both nu and that flavor monodromy parameter v.

Lev: Independence from parameters like that would make it much easier to predict stable configurations in a physical setup, because you wouldn't have to tune those extra variables perfectly just to keep the system working.

Kai: When alpha is BPS, the defect free energy becomes independent of both v and that flavor monodromy, yielding a result of one-twelfth pi plus some small correction term when you include a volume term in AdS space.

Mira: That result establishes the existence of a conformal manifold associated with that parameter v, which ties back to the geometry we're studying here.

Lev: So it’s not just about finding an energy value; it’s identifying the underlying geometric structure that supports that physical state, which is something we need to map onto real spacetime dynamics.

Kai: They also have some specific results connecting the asymptotic value in equation four point three six to the moduli-space effective field theory saddle point condition for the symmetric vortex, which reads two c alpha squared equals d minus two over two <ref:2611.13092#pg1>.

Mira: And near four dimensions, this leads to a prediction that alpha equals one minus eleven over forty eight epsilon plus higher order terms in epsilon.

Title and authors: Lev: Matching that to the mass limit of their microscopic calculation at large charge gives us a way to check if the EFT description is actually capturing the physics of large charge operators correctly.

Kai: The logarithmic term in equation four point three three also has an origin within that moduli-space effective field theory, and it's analogous to subleading corrections you see when dealing with large charge operator dimensions <ref:2611.13092#pg1>.

Mira: So the whole point is that the moduli space EFT acts as a tool to study data from those dual conformal field theories directly in the conformal vacuum.

Lev: That’s a big conceptual leap because we usually have to rely on approximations when we look at these limits, but this suggests the structure is actually encoded in what you see right there in the vacuum state.

Kai: To summarize for now, they've established connections between conformal defects and physics on the moduli space that extend beyond the EFT validity regime by using a macroscopic limit inspired by similar limits in CFTs at large scaling dimensions or large charge operators.

Mira: In this setting, the spectrum of defect operators is related to the mass spectrum in the corresponding vacuum on the moduli space.

Lev: That's a strong claim; it suggests we can use particle masses as a diagnostic for understanding these geometric defects, which would be very useful for any experimental setup.

Kai: They also have some specific results about how the onset of non-trivial saddle points occurs when the deformation becomes marginal, meaning its dimension coincides with the defect dimension.

Mira: That gives us a precise prediction that alpha equals one minus seven over twelve epsilon plus higher order terms in epsilon, which describes how that monodromy parameter evolves with the expansion parameter epsilon.

Lev: Knowing exactly how that parameter evolves helps us understand the stability of these defects as we move away from the idealized limit.

Kai: And they also have some specific results about quantum corrections, where they use equation three point one two seven to show that the constant term in their free energy is entirely determined by the one-loop effective field theory partition function <ref:2611.13092#pg2>.

Mira: This allows them to predict the logarithmic dependence of the defect free energy on m in even dimensions as being log g equals FN k minus FN minus M k, where m is some mass scale.

Lev: So that means we can predict how much quantum correction shows up in the free energy based on known one-loop calculations, which cuts down on the amount of new computation needed.

Kai: They also have a result about dimensional dependence, using equation four point two nine to determine that the onset of non-trivial saddle points happens when this deformation becomes marginal <ref:2611.13092#pg1>.

Title and authors: Mira: That gives us the precise prediction that alpha equals one minus seven over twelve epsilon plus higher order terms in epsilon, which describes how that monodromy parameter evolves with the expansion parameter epsilon.

Lev: And we need to be careful here because they also have a result about non-supersymmetric defect stability using equation four point six seven <ref:2611.13092#pg2>.

Kai: That equation shows that the eta zero mode satisfies the BF bound only for c greater than or equal to one for any value of d, which lets us predict when a vortex defect is perturbatively stable based on the Wilson coefficient c.

Mira: So we get a condition on how stable these objects are without needing supersymmetry, which is a big step for our general approach.

Lev: That stability prediction helps us narrow down the parameter space we need to explore experimentally before spending time building things that might not be viable.

Kai: So in conclusion, they’ve established connections between conformal defects and physics on the moduli space that extend beyond the EFT validity regime by introducing a macroscopic limit inspired by analogous limits in CFTs at large scaling dimensions or large charge operators.

Mira: This results in the spectrum of defect operators being related to the mass spectrum in the corresponding vacuum on the moduli space.

Lev: And they provide specific predictions about how quantum corrections appear, like log g equals FN k minus FN minus M k, which helps predict those divergences.

Kai: They also showed that for odd dimensions, a three-parameter family of one-half BPS defects can be obtained for arbitrary flavor monodromy nu with sufficiently large lambda.

Mira: And they showed that when alpha is BPS, the defect free energy becomes independent of both v and the flavor monodromy, yielding a result of one-twelfth pi plus some small correction term when you include a volume term in AdS space.

Lev: It’s interesting how that independence from those parameters simplifies things down to a fundamental geometric constant in the context of the AdS volume.

Kai: So to wrap up on "Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects", this paper shows how the moduli space EFT serves as a tool to study data from those dual conformal field theories directly in the conformal vacuum, connecting defect operators to particle masses.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that pushes the boundary of what we can study without assuming supersymmetry, opening up new avenues for understanding non-conformal vacua.

Lev: For our hardware guys, it gives us concrete stability criteria and predictions about quantum corrections that we can use to design better error correction schemes or to filter out unwanted noise.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, essentially, this paper is taking those complex conformal field theories that have broken symmetries and finding these specific defects—these codimension two things—that live right on the moduli space where everything is breaking down a bit.

Mira: Right, it’s about how those defects aren't just some abstract math problem anymore; they are tied directly to the shape of the vacuum itself.

Kai: They use this saddle point idea from looking at huge charge operators and stretch it out to describe these defects, generalizing things we already knew, like Gukov-Witten surface operators or vortex loops in ABJM theory, even without using supersymmetry.

Mira: The big picture they're hitting is that if you have a continuous symmetry breaking somewhere on the moduli space, you generically get these conformal defects showing up in the CFT.

Kai: And what they find is that these local operators parametrizing the moduli space don't just stay static; their expectation values follow this specific scaling pattern involving lambda and those z and bar z terms.

Mira: That scaling—the how fast it grows with that parameter h—is what links the quantum regime, where things are very fuzzy, to the semiclassical regime where local physics settles down near that symmetry-breaking vacuum.

Kai: The real meat for me is how they connect this defect spectrum to the mass spectrum of particles in that vacuum; it suggests you can use particle masses as a diagnostic tool for understanding these geometric defects.

Mira: And they get some pretty specific results, like finding a three-parameter family of one-half BPS defects that behave nicely even when you introduce arbitrary flavor monodromies.

Kai: That independence from the flavor monodromy when the defect is BPS is quite neat; it simplifies things by cutting out one of those messy variables.

Mira: It also gives us a way to calculate the free energy, and for certain conditions, it connects back to the volume of space in AdS, which grounds it in some kind of geometry.

Kai: So what this means for us is that we have a new framework to study data from dual theories directly in the conformal vacuum, using these defects as a bridge.

Mira: It’s pushing beyond just effective field theory regimes because they introduce this macroscopic limit inspired by how these things behave in other CFTs when you look at really large scaling dimensions or huge charges.

Kai: And for our hardware stuff, it means we have some concrete predictions about quantum corrections—like how the defect free energy depends on a mass scale m—which is useful for predicting what kind of noise or correction shows up.

Mira: It’s a lot of structure they’ve uncovered here, but they also show where the method stops; they flag that this whole setup relies on making certain approximations for those large limits to work out cleanly.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, this paper isn't just stopping there; they’ve actually pointed out some ways to make this construction better and more predictive.

Mira: Right, they’re suggesting improvements to the analysis based on what they found, focusing on how we can get more precise answers.

Kai: One big idea is using an equation called five point two seven to directly link the dimensions of the operators in that Regge trajectory to the mass spectrum of particles in the vacuum state.

Mira: That’s a huge step because it takes a relationship derived from bulk physics and makes it directly readable as particle masses, which is much more intuitive for us.

Kai: They also want to check for stability using an equation four point six seven; that shows the eta zero mode only satisfies the BF bound if the Wilson coefficient c is greater than or equal to one, regardless of the dimension d.

Mira: That’s practical because it gives us a way to predict when a vortex defect is stable just by looking at that Wilson coefficient, without needing full supersymmetry.

Kai: Then they use equation five point two zero to show that the leading large h one-point coefficients of scalar operators are fixed by their values in the corresponding vacuum on the moduli space.

Mira: That’s a nice way to connect data from dual theories—the DCFT data—to observables right in the conformal vacuum when you take that big limit, R, h approaching infinity.

Kai: They also use equation three point one two seven to figure out that the constant term in the defect free energy is entirely determined by the one loop effective field theory partition function.

Mira: That means they can predict how much quantum correction shows up in the free energy as a function of mass m, which is helpful for our calculations.

Kai: And finally, they use equation four point two nine to pinpoint exactly when the non-trivial saddle point actually kicks in by making that deformation marginal, where its dimension equals the defect dimension.

Mira: That gives us a precise prediction for how that monodromy parameter evolves with the expansion parameter epsilon, which tells us a lot about the behavior near those critical points.

Kai: So these improvements give us more concrete tools to analyze the data they’ve generated, moving from just finding a result to actually using it to predict and control the system.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've covered how they found these codimension two defects in CFTs with broken symmetries, and how they link their spectrum to particle masses in the vacuum state via that large h limit.

Mira: It really shows that the shape of a theory’s vacuum structure directly dictates the observable properties of its excitations, even without supersymmetry.

Lev: I just want to say that for any real hardware we build, knowing this relationship between defect operators and particle masses gives us a way to test our models with actual experimental data instead of just abstract math.

Kai: Exactly. And they provided some really specific stability criteria based on the Wilson coefficient c, which is useful for knowing when a vortex defect might actually survive in a physical setup.

Mira: That's valuable because it moves us from just theoretical existence to practical considerations about how these structures behave under perturbations.

Lev: Yeah, that stability prediction helps us narrow down the parameter space we need to explore before we start spending time building hardware that might not be viable.

Kai: And they have shown how the moduli space effective field theory can actually serve as a tool to study data from those dual theories right in the conformal vacuum.

Mira: That connection between bulk theory and vacuum observables is pretty powerful, especially since it works even in those large scaling dimension limits where things get really messy.

Lev: It means we don't have to rely solely on approximations when we look at these extreme regimes; the structure is actually encoded in what you see right there in the vacuum state.

Kai: So to wrap up, this paper, "Moduli spaces in CFT: vortex defects," gives us a much clearer picture of how these conformal defects relate to particle physics in broken symmetry vacua.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that pushes the boundary by showing how non-supersymmetric theories with moduli spaces can still yield very concrete, useful results.

Lev: For me, the implication is that we have more tools to design better error correction schemes and understand how quantum information might propagate in these kinds of strongly coupled systems.

Kai: It's definitely a topic worth following, especially since they laid out so many specific connections between the math and what we're measuring.

Mira: Next up, we’ll be looking at something completely different, like how triangular loop signals show up in cosmological collider models.

More episodes

← Home