Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model
summary
The gist
The gravitational dynamics of 3+1 dimensional covariant quantum spacetime in the IKKT or IIB matrix model lead to interesting modifications of gravity at long distances…
In short
The study investigates gravity in 3+1 dimensional covariant quantum spacetime using IKKT or IIB matrix models at one loop. This leads to modified Einstein equations featuring an extra geometrical tensor called 'mirage matter.' This modification introduces non-Ricci flat geometric modes with a non-standard dispersion relation, suggesting dark matter-like behavior at long distances.
Key concepts
- Mirage Matter (Tµν[C])
- This is an extra geometrical tensor that appears on the right side of the modified Einstein equations. It arises from rewriting the Yang-Mills action in a non-local way, acting like a halo-like effective energy-momentum tensor induced around localized matter. It influences gravity at large scales.
- Quantum Spacetime Structure
- The underlying Hilbert space is finite, meaning quantum spacetime has only finitely many degrees of freedom per volume. This results in a discrete set of higher-spin modes rather than a continuous spectrum, leading to a well-defined matrix model action even at one loop.
- Effective Geometry (Gµν)
- In the semi-classical regime, the kinetic term is governed by an effective metric Gµν. Near generic backgrounds, this simplifies to Gµν = sinh(τ) ηµν, describing a k=-1 FLRW geometry with a Big Bounce at τ=0.
- IR Modification
- At long distances (IR limit), the mirage matter causes screening behavior where deltaTµν[C](k) approaches -Tµν(k). This modification is distinct from standard GR modifications and resembles massive gravity in the quasi-static regime.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model · Paper Radio
- A Large-N Reduced Model as Superstring
- Progress in the numerical studies of the type IIB matrix model
- Monte Carlo studies of quantum cosmology by the generalized Lefschetz thimble method
- Inequivalence between the Euclidean and Lorentzian versions of the type IIB matrix model from Lefschetz thimble calculations
- Defining the type IIB matrix model without breaking Lorentz symmetry
- General Relativity in IIB Matrix Model
- Describing Curved Spaces by Matrices
- One-loop effective action of the IKKT model for cosmological backgrounds
- Covariant cosmological quantum space-time, higher-spin and gravity in the IKKT matrix model
- Emergent Geometry and Gravity from Matrix Models: an Introduction
- One-loop effective action and emergent gravity on quantum spaces in the IKKT matrix model
- Gravity as a Quantum Effect on Quantum Space-Time
- Modified Einstein equations from the 1-loop effective action of the IKKT model
- Spatially flat FLRW spacetimes with a Big Bang from matrix geometry
- Higher-spin kinematics & no ghosts on quantum space-time in Yang-Mills matrix models
- Einstein gravity from a matrix integral -- Part I
- The Polarised IKKT Matrix Model
- A supergravity dual for IKKT holography
- Minimal covariant quantum space-time
- Deformed Twistors and Higher Spin Conformal (Super-)Algebras in Four Dimensions
The paper
Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model · Read on arXiv
University of Vienna
The gravitational dynamics of 3+1 dimensional covariant quantum spacetime in the IKKT or IIB matrix model is studied at one loop, combining the Yang-Mills-type matrix action with the induced Einstein-Hilbert action. This combined action leads to interesting modifications of the gravitational dynamics at long distances, governed by modified Einstein equations including an extra geometrical tensor interpreted as ''mirage matter''. In particular we find extra non-Ricci flat geometric modes with a non-standard dispersion relation, with features reminiscent of dark matter and/or dark energy.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The gravitational dynamics of 3+1 dimensional covariant quantum spacetime in the IKKT or IIB matrix model lead to interesting modifications of gravity at long distances, governed by modified Einstein equations including an extra geometrical tensor interpreted as ”mirage matter” Modified Gravity and Mirage Matter The study investigates the gravitational dynamics of 3+1 dimensional covariant quantum spacetime in the IKKT or IIB matrix model at one loop, combining the Yang-Mills-type matrix action with the induced Einstein-Hilbert action This combined action results in interesting modifications of the gravitational dynamics at long distances, governed by modified Einstein equations including an extra geometrical tensor interpreted as ”mirage matter” In particular, the research finds extra non—Ricci flat geometric modes with a non-standard dispersion relation, with features reminiscent of dark matter This modification of GR arises from an ”anharmonicity tensor”, which appears as a non-local ”mirage” of actual matter, but can acquire its own dynamics These modifications of gravity in the IR arise from extra gravitational modes which are not Ricci-flat, and satisfy a non-relativistic dispersion relations Quantum Spacetime Structure The underlying Hilbert space H ∼= L2(R 3) is much smaller
6: , leading to a discrete set of normalizable higher-spin (hs)-valued modes rather than a continuous set of non-normalizable hs modes The resulting quantum spacetime carries only finitely many dof per volume and leads to a well-defined matrix model action for the fluctuation modes without regularization, even at one loop Covariant quantum spaces are considered, where the global SO(3, 1) symmetry of the matrix model is equivalent to a gauge transformation The algebraic structure End(H0) can be interpreted as quantized algebra of functions on a 6-dimensional symplectic space B, viewed as S squared bundle over cosmological spacetime M3,1 Effective Geometry and Scales In the semi-classical regime, the kinetic term in the action for all fluctuations of the matrices around some (generic) background Tα˙ in the matrix model is governed by an effective metric Gµν, which arises from a frame eαµ˙ = Tα˙, xµ = eαµ˙(x) Locally, all hs components can be eliminated The effective metric near ξ is obtained as Gµν = sinh(τ) ηµν, γµν ≈ sinh 2(τ) ηµν This describes a k = −1 FLRW geometry with Big Bounce at τ = 0 and spacelike SO(3, 1) isometry acting on the background via (2.5) The uncertainty scale (2.32) LNC = rαeτ / 2 corresponds to an effective length scale (LNC,G) squared = ∆yµ∆yνGµν = r 2α 2e t Modified Einstein Equations and IR Behavior The modified Einstein equations are derived by combining the (semi-)classical action with the Einstein-Hilbert action induced at one loop The resulting modification of gravity is discussed below, noting that Tµν
C: is a purely geometric object here, rather than an energy-momentum tensor of some actual (dark) matter For longer distances ≫ m−1, a screening behavior due to mirage matter is found, with δTµν
C: (k) → −Tµν(k) in the IR limit k → 0 This modification is distinct from conventional modifications of GR such as f(R), but it is similar to massive gravity in the quasi-static regime, where □˜ ∼ 1/3α 2e t□G (A.46) Mode Expansion and Stability The physical on-shell modes of the YM action are found to be 6 physical modes with positive norm The common factor □ implies that the transversal and longitudinal gravitational waves remain massless The extra propagating modes have a non-relativistic dispersion relation with group velocity less than c (except at cosmic scales), assuming the above extra terms These extra modes seem to be tachyonic in the IR for ⃗k squared < m squared, as can be seen in the plot of the kinetic term A(-k 2 0 + ⃗k 2)(k 2 0 - k 2/5 + 0.1)A in figure 3 This instability can be cured by taking into account the hs components at the quadratic order Discussion and Conclusion The crucial new ingredient is a ”mirage” or anharmonicity tensor Tµν
C: on the rhs of the Einstein equations, which arises by rewriting the Yang-Mills-type action in terms of a non-local expression for the frame It describes new physics at large scales beyond Lcross, which separates the length scales governed by GR and the Yang-Mills action, respectively Mirage matter Tµν
C: manifests itself as a halo-like effective energy-momentum tensor which is induced around localized matter It also has implications at cosmic scales reminiscent of some sort of dark energy The appearance of higher-spin modes on covariant quantum spacetime may seem an undesirable complication, but it might hold the key to resolve the singularity problem at the center of black holes In any case, it is clear that the resulting gravity theory shares basic properties of GR, but goes beyond it in many ways Acknowledgement This paper grew out of a collaboration with Pei-Ming Ho and Hikaru Kawai, to whom I would like to express my gratitude for extensive discussions and valuable input I would also like to thank Chong-Sun Chu, Alessandro Manta and Kaushlendra Kumar for dicsussions and related collaborations This work is supported by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) grant P36479 A Appendix A.1 Local normal coordinates We summarize some results in section 10.2.5 of
20: , which establish the crucial fact that any given hs-valued matrix background defines locally some ordinary 3+1 dimensional geometry The basic observation is that the frame eµ˙α = Tα˙, xµ and all derived objects (such as metric and torsion) are tensors, considering the frame indices ˙α as fixed This means that they transform as hs-valued tensors under coordinate redefinitions y˜µ = ϕµ(x), i.e.
Kai: e˜µα˙ = Tα˙, y˜µ = ∂ϕµ∂xνe˙(A.2) assuming that ϕµ(x) depends only on xµ We can take advantage of this freedom to cast any hs-valued frame locally into standard form in terms of suitably adapted hs-valued coordinates on spacetime y˜µ = ϕµσ(u) yσ + ϕµαβ˙(u)yαyβ˙(A.5) Then the dependence of the frame on u can always be eliminated locally, in analogy to Riemann normal coordinates in GR A.2 Gauge transformations and volume-preserving hs diffeos On the 6-dimensional symplectic bundle B over spacetime M3,1, gauge transformations can be interpreted as Hamiltonian vector fields ϕ → ϕ + to ϕ + (A.10) This is a subset of volume-preserving vector fields on B, which provides enough degrees of freedom to describe all volume-preserving diffeomorphisms on 3+1-dimensional spacetime Indeed for classical functions ϕ = ϕ(y), the above transformation acts as ϕ → ϕ + (A.11) which is a (hs-deformed) diffeomorphism along the vector field Vµ = to yµ = (A.12) A.3 hs- deformed diffeos and Lorentz transformations Local reconstruction of divergence-free vector fields It is shown in
20: that all volume-preserving vector fields V on M1,3 can be generated as V = to ϕ → (A.16) by some uniquely determined Λ = Aσ(y)uσ For vector fields Aσ(y) with wavelengths ≪ LIR, the second term dominates, and using the bracket relations (2.29) we find to y i ≈ L 2NC∂A lu iul = L 2NC∂0A lu jul Projecting to the spin 0 sector using (2.28), one finds
V 0: 0 = -1/3LIR∂iA i
V k: 0 ≈ 1/3LIR∂0A k(A.18) A.4 Dilaton contributions We need ρ squared = ρM det eαµ˙ = ¯ρ squared detδµν + ¯e˙αµ δeαµ˙ (A.26) We use the expansions det(1 + B)-1 = 1 - tr(B) + 1/2(tr B) squared + trB squared + O(B 3) (A.27) A.5 Non-derivative contributions from the YM term Keeping the non-derivative terms, the Yang-Mills term (4.32) acquires an extra contribution: Fα˙ β˙ = α(- to Tα˙, Aβµ˙uµ + to Tβ˙, Aαµ˙uµ) − to Aν uν, Aβµ˙uµ ≈ αr cubed sinh(τ) (-Aβµdotθαν̇ + Aαmudotθβν̇)ημν + O(∂A) + O(A 2) (A.32) This leads to extra terms Fα˙ β˙Fα˙ β˙ ⊃ - to Aβµdotuνξα̇ηµνAβρdotuσξα̇ηρσ = -2α 2r 2AβµdotuµAβρdotuρ
F alpha dot beta dot F alpha dot beta dot: 0 ⊃ -2α 23r 2Aβi˙ Aβj˙δij (A.34) A.6 Cosmic scale function Consider the effective metric (2.40) Gµν = α 2e tηµν =: 1/A(τ) ηµν, A = α-2e-t (A.35) in Cartesian coordinates We can cast this into k = −1 FLRW form as follows ds 2G = Gµνdxµdxν = -r 2A-1sinh 2τ dτ 2 + r 2A-1cosh 2τ dΣ squared, (A.36) where dΣ squared = dχ squared + sinh squared χ(dθ2 + sin2θdφ2) (A.37) is the invariant length element on the spacelike hyperboloids H3 We can bring the metric (A.36) to the standard FLRW form ds 2G = -dt squared + a(t) squared dΣ squared via dt squared = r 2A-1sinh 2τ dτ 2, (A.39) a(t) squared = r 2A-1cosh 2τ ∼ r 3αe(3t/4) Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The common factor □ implies that the transversal and longitudinal gravitational waves remain massless Here m squared = 32πGN α 2r-4 (4.45) recovers the IR scale (3.26) setting the boundary between the YM regime governing the cosmological evolution, and the Einstein-Hilbert regime with GR-like dynamics The second (YM) term dominates in the IR regime ⃗k squared < m squared, which is the cosmic regime Higher-loop contributions are expected to be UV finite as well, with effective UV cutoff given by ΛNC or the highest KK (SUSY breaking) scale, which is related to the Planck scale The analysis in this paper and in particular the equations (3.32) are simplified for the sake of transparency The results should apply quite generally to non-commutative backgrounds in the matrix model, as long as the action is well-defined Mirage matter Tµν
C: manifests itself as a halo-like effective energy-momentum tensor which is induced around localized matter It also has implications at cosmic scales reminiscent of some sort of dark energy The appearance of higher-spin modes on covariant quantum spacetime may seem an undesirable complication, but it might hold the key to resolve the singularity problem at the center of black holes In any case, it is clear that the resulting gravity theory shares basic properties of GR, but goes beyond it in many ways Where the gains come from The paper derives modified Einstein equations (3.32) governing the effective metric in the IKKT matrix model on covariant quantum spacetime, obtained by combining the (semi-)classical action with the Einstein-Hilbert action induced at one loop The crucial new ingredient is a ”mirage” or anharmonicity tensor Tµν
C: on the rhs of the Einstein equations, which arises by rewriting the Yang-Mills-type action in terms of a non-local expression for the frame This leads to IR modifications of GR as illustrated below Mirage matter Tµν
C: manifests itself as a halo-like effective energy-momentum tensor which is induced around localized matter It also has implications at cosmic scales reminiscent of some sort of dark energy The analysis in this paper and in particular the equations (3.32) are simplified for the sake of transparency How the training signal is built The authors derive a system of coupled tensorial equations governing emergent gravity on spacetime M1,3 via the Einstein tensor Gµν, the energy-momentum tensor Tµν of matter, and the anharmonicity tensor Tµν
C: interpreted as ”mirage matter” The latter leads to IR modifications of GR as illustrated below The common factor □ implies that the transversal and longitudinal gravitational waves remain massless Here m squared = 32πGN α 2r-4 (4.45) recovers the IR scale (3.26) setting the boundary between the YM regime governing the cosmological evolution, and the Einstein-Hilbert regime with GR-like dynamics The second (YM) term dominates in the IR regime ⃗k squared < m squared, which is the cosmic regime Higher-loop contributions are expected to be UV finite as well, with effective UV cutoff given by ΛNC or the highest KK (SUSY breaking) scale, which is related to the Planck scale The analysis in this paper and in particular the equations (3.32) are simplified for the sake of transparency Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The common factor □ implies that the transversal and longitudinal gravitational waves remain massless Here m squared = 32πGN α 2r-4 (4.45) recovers the IR scale (3.26) setting the boundary between the YM regime governing the cosmological evolution, and the Einstein-Hilbert regime with GR-like dynamics The second (YM) term dominates in the IR regime ⃗k squared < m squared, which is the cosmic regime Higher-loop contributions are expected to be UV finite as well, with effective UV cutoff given by ΛNC or the highest KK (SUSY breaking) scale, which is related to the Planck scale The analysis in this paper and in particular the equations (3.
Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper called "Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model". It combines the Yang-Mills type matrix action with the induced Einstein-Hilbert action.
Mira: Essentially, they're studying how gravity behaves in three plus one dimensions when you look at it through the lens of these quantum spacetime models at one loop. The main claim is that this combination leads to modifications of gravity at long distances, governed by modified Einstein equations and an extra geometrical tensor they call "mirage matter".
Lev: So, what they're suggesting is that these modifications aren't just some simple correction; they introduce extra non-Ricci flat geometric modes with a non-standard dispersion relation that looks like dark matter.
Kai: Right, so this isn't just tweaking the existing gravity equations; it seems to be creating new types of gravitational modes that have different behaviors at large scales.
Mira: Exactly. The paper says this modification comes from something called an "anharmonicity tensor" which they describe as a non-local "mirage" of actual matter, but that thing itself can have its own dynamics.
Lev: And the key is that these modifications show up in the infrared, or IR limit, when you look at very long distances, where they behave like extra gravitational modes with non-relativistic dispersion relations.
Kai: That sounds interesting because it suggests these extra modes might be a real physical feature of this quantum spacetime setup rather than just artifacts of the calculation.
Mira: It's definitely that way. And the paper also points out that the underlying Hilbert space, which they say is L2 of R three, is much smaller, and this leads to a discrete set of normalizable higher spin valued modes instead of a continuous set.
Lev: That discreteness is important for us on hardware. If we tried to run this on real quantum systems, you'd have these finitely many degrees of freedom per volume which simplifies things because it avoids needing regularization at the one loop level.
Kai: So, moving beyond the abstract idea of mirage matter, what are they saying about the structure of this emergent spacetime itself?
Mira: They interpret the algebraic structure as something that could be viewed as a quantized algebra of functions on a six dimensional symplectic space, which is like an S two bundle over cosmological spacetime.
Lev: That connection between the matrix model's algebraic structure and a geometric object is where it gets deep. It suggests the underlying math isn't just abstract; it maps to some kind of geometry we can think about.
Paper summary: Kai: So, if you consider this effective geometry in the semi-classical regime, what does that look like for the actual spacetime we observe?
Mira: In that semi-classical picture, they find an effective metric G mu nu which arises from a frame definition related to some background T alpha dot, and locally near a point ξ it describes a k negative one flat riemann flat world with a big bounce at tau equals zero.
Lev: A big bounce is interesting because it suggests the spacetime isn't just smoothly expanding or contracting everywhere, but has some kind of turnaround in its evolution at that specific time parameter.
Kai: And they give us an uncertainty scale, LNC, which corresponds to a length scale squared that depends on the measurement record and some other parameters.
Mira: That length scale squared is LNC squared equals r alpha squared e t, which relates to how fast the uncertainty grows as time progresses in this model.
Lev: So it connects the quantum structure of spacetime directly to a measurable physical length scale that evolves with time.
Kai: Now, let's talk about those modified Einstein equations they derived from combining the action at one loop with the Einstein-Hilbert action. What are they claiming there?
Mira: They derive modified Einstein equations where T mu nu C is this purely geometrical object interpreted as mirage matter, rather than a traditional energy momentum tensor of some dark matter.
Lev: That distinction is important because it means this isn't just adding a new fluid to the universe; it's fundamentally altering the gravitational dynamics through geometry itself.
Kai: And for long distances, specifically beyond a scale related to one over m, they find a screening behavior due to this mirage matter that pushes the effective energy-momentum tensor toward zero in the infrared limit when k approaches zero.
Mira: That screening behavior is distinct from what you see in conventional modifications of general relativity, like f R theories, but it shares similarities with massive gravity in its quasi static regime where something resembles a square root of the Laplacian acting on G mu nu.
Lev: So it's proposing a specific way that gravity modifies itself at large scales, and they are linking this to known effective field theories in different regimes.
Kai: What about the physical modes? They looked at the physical modes of the Yang-Mills action, and what did they find regarding gravitational waves?
Paper summary: Mira: They found six physical modes of the Yang-Mills action with positive norm, and interestingly, because there's a common factor in their kinetic term, it means that both transversal and longitudinal gravitational waves remain massless.
Lev: Massless gravitational waves are expected in standard general relativity because gravity itself is mediated by massless spin two particles.
Kai: But these extra propagating modes they found have a non-relativistic dispersion relation with group velocity less than the speed of light, except for very large cosmic scales.
Mira: And there's a problem there; these extra modes seem to be tachyonic in the infrared for wave numbers smaller than some mass squared value, which they call m squared.
Lev: Tachyonic behavior suggests instability, which is something we always worry about when designing physical systems or theories that describe real physics.
Kai: They suggest this instability might actually be cured by taking into account those higher spin valued modes at the quadratic order of their action expansion.
Mira: So they're saying the way to fix this potential instability lies in including all those higher spin components when you look at the full quadratic term of the action.
Lev: That shifts the burden from just looking at the lowest order terms to understanding how all those modes couple together dynamically.
Kai: This brings us to what this means for us, for people who just listen to this show. What's the big picture here?
Mira: In simple terms, it suggests that gravity isn't entirely as straightforward as we think when you look at it in these quantum spacetime settings. It introduces a new long-distance physics characterized by this mirage matter halo effect.
Lev: For someone building hardware, the finding about the discrete modes being normalizable is pretty helpful because it means we don't have to worry about infinities popping up when calculating fluctuations at one loop.
Kai: And for cosmology, they hint that these extra modes could be relevant at cosmic scales, potentially acting somewhat like a form of dark energy.
Mira: It also suggests that the way we think about spacetime at very small scales might need to incorporate higher spin physics to resolve issues like the singularity problem in black holes.
Lev: Ultimately, it’s about showing how the structure of quantum gravity models, even those starting with matrix theory, can generate modifications of gravity that look very similar to things we see in observational cosmology.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been diving into how these quantum spacetime models affect gravity at big scales in this paper called "Modified gravity at large scales on quantum spacetime in the IKKT model."
Mira: Yeah, basically, they're looking at combining the matrix action with Einstein's equations and seeing what new physics pops out.
Lev: From my side, it’s about figuring out if these modifications are something that could actually run on real quantum hardware or if they just stay in the math.
Kai: And what I’m digging into is how this whole setup works, whether you're talking about superconducting qubits or just trying to keep a system cold enough to measure anything at all.
Mira: The authors point out that the core idea here is this "mirage matter" term appearing on the right side of Einstein's equations, which they see as a purely geometric object.
Lev: So, it’s not just adding some new fluid into space; it’s altering the geometry itself through this tensor.
Kai: And they find that for long distances, beyond one over m, this mirage matter causes a screening effect that pushes the dynamics toward standard general relativity in the infrared limit.
Mira: That screening behavior is different from other gravity modifications we see, like f R theories.
Lev: It’s similar to massive gravity in its quasi static regime, but the way they get there is through this quantum spacetime framework.
Kai: The paper also mentions some tricky stuff with higher spin modes and how that might be connected to solving problems at black hole centers later on.
Mira: It's definitely interesting because it suggests that these higher spin modes in covariant quantum spacetime might hold a key to resolving singularities.
Lev: That’s the big picture, isn't it? The authors are proposing a new way gravity behaves on large scales using this matrix model framework.
Kai: So while the math is deep, what does this actually mean for our understanding of gravity itself?
Mira: It means that the structure of quantum spacetime introduces physics at very large scales that goes beyond classical general relativity.
Lev: It suggests that even in these highly quantized backgrounds, we can still get behaviors reminiscent of dark energy or something similar.
Kai: So next time, we'll talk about how they actually set up this effective geometry and what those length scales mean for measurement.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds