Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval
summary
The gist
In this work, gauge theories in two dimensions are investigated nonperturbatively using a Hamiltonian truncation approach to explore strongly coupled systems without resorting to lattice field theory.
In short
This work investigates two-dimensional gauge theories nonperturbatively using a Hamiltonian truncation method instead of lattice field theory. By approximating the strong coupling using a finite set of basis states defined by an energy cutoff, the method successfully reproduces exact results for the Schwinger model and reveals signatures of color confinement in nonabelian SU(3) theories.
Key concepts
- Hamiltonian Truncation Method
- This is a nonperturbative technique that simplifies a complex quantum theory by using a finite matrix representation. The full Hamiltonian is split into a solvable part and an interaction part, and only states within an energy cutoff are kept, allowing for numerical diagonalization.
- Schwinger Model Analysis
- The study starts with the 1+1D QED model, the Schwinger model. The authors construct its classical Hamiltonian in axial gauge and define the interaction term based on the electric field operator squared, which is crucial for setting up the quantum mechanical problem.
- Nonabelian Gauge Theory Extension
- The framework is extended to SU(N) gauge theories with a single fermion. This generalization allows researchers to explore more complex phenomena like color confinement in these nonabelian systems, using the truncation method to handle the increased complexity.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval · Paper Radio
- A Cheap Alternative to the Lattice?
- Hamiltonian Truncation Study of the Phi 4 Theory in Two Dimensions
- A solution of 2D QCD at Finite N using a conformal basis
- Hamiltonian Truncation Study of the Phi 4 Theory in Two Dimensions II. The Z 2-Broken Phase and the Chang Duality
- Non-perturbative methodologies for low-dimensional strongly-correlated systems: From non-abelian bosonization to truncated spectrum methods
- Truncated Hilbert space approach to the 2d phi 4 theory
- RG Flow from phi 4 Theory to the 2D Ising Model
- Hamiltonian Truncation with Larger Dimensions
- Hamiltonian truncation tensor networks for quantum field theories
- Large Momentum EFT and Lightcone Quantization
- Nonperturbative dynamics of (2+1)d phi 4-theory from Hamiltonian truncation
- Towards a nonperturbative construction of the S-matrix
- Snowmass White Paper: Hamiltonian Truncation
- The renormalized Hamiltonian truncation method in the large E T expansion
- NLO Renormalization in the Hamiltonian Truncation
- Exploring Hamiltonian Truncation in
- Hamiltonian Truncation Effective Theory
- Effective Hamiltonians and Counterterms for Hamiltonian Truncation
- Hamiltonian Truncation Crafted for UV-divergent QFTs
- Testing the RG-flow M(3,10)+ phi 1,7 to M(3,8) with Hamiltonian Truncation
The paper
Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval · Read on arXiv
Rachel Houtza, James Ingoldbyb
University of Florida · Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology, Durham University
In this work, we investigate gauge theories in two dimensions nonperturbatively using the Hamiltonian truncation approach. Working on a spatial interval and adopting the axial gauge, we remove all gauge field degrees of freedom and express the interacting Hamiltonian in the eigenbasis of the free Dirac theory, truncated at a finite energy. As a benchmark we analyse the Schwinger model, where our numerical spectra agree closely with the exact results from bosonization across a wide range of couplings, validating the construction of the Hamiltonian. We then generalize the formulation to nonabelian gauge groups and apply it to SU(3) gauge theory with a single massless Dirac fermion. These results demonstrate that gauge theories can be explored nonperturbatively using a truncated Hamiltonian that generates evolutions in ordinary time, offering a complementary alternative to lattice field theory.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In this work, gauge theories in two dimensions are investigated nonperturbatively using a Hamiltonian truncation approach to explore strongly coupled systems without resorting to lattice field theory.
Kai: The method demonstrates that gauge theories can be explored nonperturbatively using a truncated Hamiltonian that generates evolutions in ordinary time, offering a complementary alternative to lattice field theory.
Mira: Hamiltonian Truncation Method Hamiltonian truncation is a nonperturbative method that approximates a stronglycoupled quantum theory using a finite-dimensional Hamiltonian matrix.
Kai: This approach involves splitting the Hamiltonian into two parts, H = H0 + V, where H0 is the Hamiltonian of some solved theory with a known energy eigenbasis and V encodes additional interactions that deform the theory away from H0.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, titled "Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval," and it's really focused on using a Hamiltonian truncation approach to study two-dimensional gauge theories without needing a lattice.
Mira: Right, and the authors are James Ingoldbyb and Rachel Houtza, who are tackling how you can get nonperturbative results for these strongly coupled systems.
Lev: I'm looking forward to seeing if this method actually translates to something runnable on real hardware without introducing too much overhead or approximation errors.
Kai: Well, the paper explains that this approach works by taking the infinite basis of states in the Hilbert space and just cutting it off at a finite energy cutoff, which gives you a finite-dimensional Hamiltonian matrix.
Mira: That's what I see—essentially turning an intractable problem into one you can diagonalize numerically because you’ve made the state space manageable.
Lev: And I'm curious how they handle that truncation; usually, those cuts introduce artifacts that make it hard to get accurate physics, and this is where I need to see if their cutoff choice is robust.
Kai: They use this idea as a benchmark first by analyzing the Schwinger model, which they find their numerical spectra agree closely with the exact results from bosonization across a wide range of couplings.
Mira: That's significant because it validates that the Hamiltonian construction they built actually captures the physics of the simpler abelian case when you tune it right.
Lev: Does that agreement hold up when we move away from the Schwinger model? Because moving to something more complex usually reveals where these approximations start to fail dramatically.
Kai: They then take this framework and generalize it to nonabelian gauge groups, specifically SU(three) gauge theory with a single massless Dirac fermion on a finite interval <ref:2509.17890#pg1,SU(3) gauge theory with a single massless Dirac fermion>.
Mira: That extension is key because it allows them to look at things like color confinement, which is a big topic in QCD-like theories.
Lev: Color confinement in these truncated models can be tricky; if the truncation isn't good, you might just get spurious states instead of seeing the real physics emerge.
Title and authors: Kai: The results they get for SU(three) theory show signatures of color confinement appearing in the low-energy spectrum when the gauge coupling is small, but those same states disappear as the coupling grows <ref:2509.17890#pg1>.
Mira: So it suggests that this truncation method can actually capture some features of infrared behavior even when you're dealing with a nonabelian group like SU(three) <ref:2509.17890#pg1>.
Lev: And I’m interested in their discussion about how the convergence rate behaves; they mention that excited energy gaps follow a power law scaling of one over the product of the energy cutoff and the interval length.
Kai: That scaling, one over Emax times L, is what tells us how fast we can expect to get closer to the true infinite system behavior by just increasing our cutoff or making the interval longer.
Mira: It sounds like a controlled way to see how much information you need in your finite description before you're done.
Lev: And that power law scaling is a nice piece of information for me because it gives us an explicit benchmark for error reduction when we try to push this onto actual computational systems.
Kai: The paper also points out some improvements they suggest for the framework itself, which they call systematic improvement schemes, and they show this has been demonstrated at next-to-leading order in two dimensional phi four theory, improving convergence from one over E max to one over E to the power of four.
Mira: That's a concrete improvement; it means that if you use their suggested corrections, you might see a much faster approach to the true answer than just using the basic truncation.
Lev: Faster is always better for us when we're trying to map these theories onto things that have to run on finite resources.
Kai: And they also discuss what this method does not do, which is important; they admit that by working on a finite interval in axial gauge, you lose translational invariance and momentum conservation, and the fermion boundary conditions break chiral symmetry.
Title and authors: Mira: That loss of symmetries is the trade-off for getting rid of all the gauge field degrees of freedom, which simplifies the Hamiltonian.
Lev: So what this really changes for someone looking at lattice field theory versus this truncation method? It's a different kind of compromise you’re making on spacetime structure.
Kai: Essentially, it gives you a way to explore strongly coupled systems that avoids the sign problem that plagues lattice gauge theory, but it forces you to accept these specific breaking of symmetries in exchange for numerical tractability.
Mira: And the paper's conclusion wraps this up by saying this Hamiltonian truncation framework is established and validated for both abelian and nonabelian theories in one plus one dimension on the interval.
Lev: It’s a solid foundation, but we still have to figure out how to properly manage that energy cutoff dependence when we try to apply it to more complicated models later.
Kai: Exactly, the paper calls this Hamiltonian truncation framework for gauge theories on the interval and it sets a benchmark for alternative computational approaches to strongly coupled gauge theories.
Mira: It suggests that you can use this formalism not just for one plus one dimension, but potentially for a wider range of problems, including those with different masses or theta parameters <ref:2509.17890#pg2>.
Lev: I'm just glad they’ve shown that the underlying mathematical machinery works well enough to be used as a starting point for more elaborate setups.
Kai: We have covered the title and authors, looked at how they structure this nonperturbative method using a finite Hamiltonian basis, and seen how it applies to the Schwinger model before moving into SU(three) theory <ref:2509.17890#pg1>.
Mira: Then we discussed the specific improvements they suggest for convergence rates, which are important for any real simulation you might try later.
Lev: We also talked about the necessary compromises they make with symmetries by working on a finite interval and what that means for comparison to lattice methods.
Kai: And finally, we summarized how this Hamiltonian truncation framework for gauge theories on the interval provides a solid, nonperturbative tool for studying strongly coupled systems in two dimensions.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to wrap up this part, they're saying that we can use this Hamiltonian truncation method to tackle gauge theories in two dimensions without needing a lattice simulation at all.
Mira: That's the main thing—they’ve built a way to explore strongly coupled systems by taking an infinite set of possibilities and just cutting it off at some energy limit, which gives you a finite mathematical system you can solve.
Lev: From where I sit, that means we don't have to worry about the sign problem that kills lattice theories when things get messy; we’re using this as a way to generate evolutions in ordinary time instead of trying to simulate it on a grid.
Kai: Exactly, and they validated this framework by showing it works for the simplest case, the Schwinger model, and their numerical results agree closely with what you get from bosonization across a wide range of coupling strengths.
Mira: That agreement is crucial because it means the mathematical machinery they built actually captures the physics of that simpler theory when you tune your parameters correctly.
Lev: But then they take it further, extending this framework to nonabelian groups, like SU three, and they see real signs of color confinement showing up in their low-energy spectrum when the coupling is small.
Kai: That’s interesting because we usually expect these types of truncations to break down quickly when you introduce nonabelian complexity; seeing confinement signatures there suggests the truncation is surprisingly robust for this specific setup.
Mira: It points to a deeper structural property of how these two-dimensional theories behave under this kind of approximation, showing that the interactions are organized in a way that respects some aspects of confinement even with our finite energy cutoff.
Lev: And they give us a scaling law for how the error drops, which is one over the product of your energy cutoff and the interval length; that tells you exactly how much more data you need to get better results.
Kai: That power law scaling is a practical piece of information because it gives us a clear roadmap for how we improve our simulations without just throwing more computer power at the problem blindly.
Mira: The paper also mentions some systematic improvements they found, which they show can take the convergence rate from one over your energy cutoff to one over the fourth power in the two dimensional phi four theory.
Lev: That’s a big deal for hardware because it means that if we want to run this on actual superconducting qubits or something similar, we have a much better idea of how fast we can reach accuracy.
Kai: So, what this really means is that this Hamiltonian truncation method gives us a controlled starting point for studying strongly coupled gauge theories in two dimensions without needing a spatial lattice.
Mira: It suggests you can use this formalism not just for the one plus one dimension case, but potentially for more complex setups involving different masses or theta parameters later on.
Lev: We still have to be careful about the symmetry trade-offs they mention; working on a finite interval in axial gauge means you lose translational invariance and chiral symmetry, which is what you're trading for the ability to actually diagonalize the Hamiltonian.
Kai: So this method is established and validated for both abelian and nonabelian theories on the interval, providing a benchmark for how we can compute strongly coupled physics without resorting to lattice field theory simulations.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, to look at what they suggest for improving their method, they’re talking about systematic improvement schemes that are designed to make things run faster on a computer.
Mira: They’re talking about ways to fix the truncation errors systematically so that you don't just rely on a random energy cutoff choice anymore; it makes the whole process more controlled.
Lev: That sounds like something we could actually implement in error correction, because usually, those systematic improvements are what get you from an approximation that’s okay to one that’s actually useful for real hardware.
Kai: They showed this improvement works at next-to-leading order in the two dimensional phi four theory, and they claim it helps organize the errors so the convergence rate improves from one over your energy cutoff to one over the fourth power.
Mira: That shift from one over E max to one over E to the fourth power is significant because it tells you how much precision you gain just by increasing your energy cutoff, which is a very practical metric for simulation design.
Lev: If that holds up when we apply it to something more complex like the SU three theory they studied, then we might have a solid plan for how to push this onto real quantum hardware without needing an infinite number of states.
Kai: The caveat here is that these systematic improvements are based on certain assumptions about the theory, so Mira has to pin those assumptions down before we trust the convergence rate improvement.
Mira: Exactly, and they’re basically saying that if you can get these error-reducing terms right, it gives you a much clearer path toward finding the true interacting theory's spectrum.
Lev: I wonder how much overhead this systematic improvement adds to the total time needed for diagonalization; we need to make sure that speedup in convergence isn't cancelled out by slow matrix multiplication steps.
Kai: The main implication for us is that this method provides a blueprint for building better numerical tools, not just a single result, and it gives us concrete targets on how to refine the approximations used in these types of studies.
Mira: It moves the discussion away from just getting *an* answer and toward understanding the underlying structure of why certain truncations work better than others.
Lev: So for someone building an error correction code, this means we have a more rigorous way to test how good our finite representation is before we try to scale it up.
Kai: It gives us a benchmark for alternative computational approaches that don't rely on the traditional lattice method when you’re dealing with these two dimensional gauge theories.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at "Hamiltonian Truncation Framework for Gauge Theories on the Interval," and it boils down to using a finite Hamiltonian matrix to study strongly coupled systems in two dimensions without needing a lattice simulation.
Mira: Right, they established that this method works well for both simple abelian theories like the Schwinger model and more complex nonabelian theories like SU three theory, showing results that actually match exact calculations from bosonization.
Lev: It’s a solid way to generate those evolutions in ordinary time, which is helpful because it means we don't have to worry about the sign problem that kills lattice approaches when things get complicated.
Kai: The method shows that even with the limitations of working on a finite interval and breaking symmetries like translational invariance, we can still see real physics emerging, like color confinement signatures in SU three.
Mira: That’s because the way the interactions are organized in this truncated Hamiltonian respects some underlying structure, even when we're cutting off the Hilbert space.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this method gives us a blueprint for how good our finite representation is before we try to scale it up to something more complex.
Kai: They also gave us clear numbers on convergence, showing that with systematic improvements, you can push that convergence rate from one over the energy cutoff to one over the fourth power.
Mira: That speedup in precision is what makes this approach useful for serious numerical work; it gives researchers a concrete target for how much more data they need to get better results.
Lev: If we can run these improvement schemes on actual quantum hardware, it changes how we think about the overhead required versus the quality of the physics we can extract.
Kai: So, this paper validates Hamiltonian truncation as a practical tool for nonperturbative studies in two dimensions and sets a benchmark for alternative computational approaches to strongly coupled gauge theories.
Mira: It suggests that you can use this formalism not just for one plus one dimension, but potentially for more complicated setups involving different masses or theta parameters later on.
Lev: We still have to be careful about the symmetry trade-offs they mention; working on a finite interval in axial gauge means you lose translational invariance and chiral symmetry, which is what you're trading for the ability to actually diagonalize the Hamiltonian.
Kai: So this method is established and validated for both abelian and nonabelian theories on the interval, providing a benchmark for how we can compute strongly coupled physics without resorting to lattice field theory simulations.
Mira: The main implication here is that it gives us a better handle on how gauge interactions vanish with energy, which is something we need to understand in high energy physics.
Lev: Moving forward, the real question is whether this convergence scaling holds up when we try to apply these systematic improvements to theories that are even more complicated than the ones they tested.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds