Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c
summary
The gist
The Gauge Theory Bootstrap method is used to study asymptotically free gauge theories with a varying number of colors Nc by combining S-matrix/form factor bootstrap numerical techniques with UV…
In short
This study uses a Gauge Theory Bootstrap method to investigate how strongly coupled gauge theories change as their number of colors (Nc) varies from 3 to 12. By combining perturbative QCD inputs with low-energy constraints, the researchers computed properties of resonances like the sigma, rho, and f2 mesons. The results show that while some resonances scale predictably with Nc, others exhibit different behavior.
Key concepts
- Gauge Theory Bootstrap
- This is a numerical technique that connects high-energy (UV) physics to low-energy dynamics in strongly coupled gauge theories. It works by using constraints like unitarity and QCD sum rules to determine the properties of resonances by analyzing scattering amplitudes.
- Varying Color Parameter (Nc)
- Nc represents the number of colors in a gauge theory, which is a key parameter that dictates how strong the interactions are. The study systematically changes Nc within a range (3 to 12) to see how this microscopic parameter affects the low-energy physics and resonance properties.
- Low Energy Constants ($ar{l}_i$)
- These are parameters extracted from analyzing scattering amplitudes near low energies. They describe the behavior of resonances and scattering processes at small momentum transfers. The study examines how these constants change as Nc varies, comparing them to predictions from the large-Nc expansion of QCD.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c · Paper Radio
- Gauge Theory Bootstrap: Pion amplitudes and low energy parameters
- The Gauge Theory Bootstrap: Predicting pion dynamics from QCD
- The S-matrix Bootstrap II: Two Dimensional Amplitudes
- The S-matrix Bootstrap I: QFT in AdS
- The S-matrix Bootstrap III: Higher Dimensional Amplitudes
- Bootstrapping Massive Quantum Field Theories
- Discrete Basis Parameterization for the Gauge Theory Bootstrap
- Bootstrapping leading hadronic muon anomaly
- Lattice study of large N c QCD
- Large N c scaling of meson masses and decay constants
- A lattice study of pi pi scattering at large N c
- Lattice study of the chiral properties of large N c QCD
- Curve collapse for the isospin-2 pion scattering length from QCD with 3, 4, and 5 colors
- The pi pi scattering amplitude at large N c
- Non-perturbative determination of meson masses and low-energy constants in large- N QCD
- Nature of the f 0(600) from its N c dependence at two loops in unitarized Chiral Perturbation Theory
- Bootstrapping Pion Form Factors at Large N
- Bootstrapping QCD: the Lake, the Peninsula and the Kink
- Selection rules for the S-Matrix bootstrap
- Relative entropy in scattering and the S-matrix bootstrap
The paper
Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c · Read on arXiv
Rafael Cordoba, Yifei He, Martin Kruczenski, Derek Ping, Jignesh Mohanty, * Emil Alegria
Laboratoire de Physique de l’ Ecole Normale Supérieure, ENS, University of Paris Citພ, CNRS, Sorbonne University · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Purdue University
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The Gauge Theory Bootstrap method is used to study asymptotically free gauge theories with a varying number of colors Nc by combining S-matrix/form factor bootstrap numerical techniques with UV dynamical information from perturbative QCD and IR constraints from weakly coupled pions, allowing for the computation of strongly coupled resonances and low-energy constants Varying the Color Parameter The study examines gauge theories with varying number of colors Nc in the range 3 ≤ Nc ≤ 12 to see how their strong dynamics change The parameter Nc enters the computation through sum rules and asymptotic form factors, allowing for direct tuning of this microscopic parameter to examine low-energy strongly coupled dynamics The basic setup for Nc computation involves Nc entering explicitly as a free UV input in QCD sum rules and asymptotic form factor, while implicitly through the pion decay constant fπ which behaves as fπ ∼ √Nc at leading order in Nc Low Energy Parameters and Constants For 3 ≤ Nc ≤ 12, the authors extract scattering lengths, effective ranges, and low-energy constants ¯li to study their Nc dependence The results for low energy parameters and resonances match well with the Nc scaling predictions of the large-Nc expansion of QCD Specifically, the σ meson mass and width both increase with Nc, in agreement with a previous unitarized χPT analysis Resonance Properties The study obtains the σ, ρ, and f2 resonances for the same range of Nc The ρ and f2 masses depend only weakly on Nc, and their widths decrease as Nc increases, consistent with the 1/Nc scaling expected for conventional qq¯ mesons Conversely, the σ meson mass and width both increase with Nc The Gauge Theory Bootstrap framework provides a way to connect the low energy physics of asymptotically free gauge theories like QCD directly with their high energy (microscopic) descriptions and compute the strongly coupled dynamics in the intermediate energies The results compare well with alternative methods like unitarized χPT
60: and lattice gauge theory at finite and infinite Nc It also agrees with the expected asymptotic behavior following from the 1/Nc expansion of QCD The consistency of the results with previous calculations when available and with general scaling expectations from large-Nc provide further validation of the overall procedure A Low energy formulas The appendix collects additional formulas useful for analyzing the low energy region, such as expressions for scattering lengths aIl and effective range bIl derived from the expansion of the amplitude near the symmetric point in the unphysical region High energy 2-point functions The two-point functions of local operators are given by perturbative QCD expressions at leading order, which provide finite energy sum rules
2: These expressions are used to constrain the spectral density integrated in the strongly coupled region Numerical implementation The numerical implementation discretizes bootstrap variables using a discrete basis and imposes constraints from unitarity, QCD sum rules, asymptotic form factors, and low energy matching The procedure involves mapping kinematic variable ν to the unit disk through a specific transformation Strongly coupled region and resonances The strongly coupled energy region is characterized by resonances appearing as peaks in form factors or spectral densities at physical energies/momentum transfers The real and imaginary parts of the poles are related to the mass m and full-width Γ of the resonances as √spoles = m − iΓ/2 The leading resonances in the S0, P1, and D0 channels are respectively the σ, ρ, and f2 mesons The imaginary parts Im√spole – half-width decrease as 1/Nc for increasing Nc for the ρ and f2 resonances The σ or f0 resonance in the S0 channel has a slightly increasing Re√spole (mass) with increasing Nc, and it gets wider with increasing Nc Higher resonances The second resonances in the P1 and D0 channels can be physically interpreted as excited states of the ρ and f2 mesons with the same quantum numbers These excited states do not depend as smoothly on Nc as the leading σ, ρ, f2 mesons which is likely due to low numerical precisions at higher energies The masses and width of the second ρ and f2 poles follow the expected behavior of a qq¯ state, with relatively stable mass and decreasing width with increasing Nc Summary of low energy results (in mπ units) The summary provides the scattering lengths and effective range parameters as functions of Nc for various channels, including the coefficients of the expansion of the amplitude A(s, t, u) around symmetric points The low energy constants are related to the amplitude expansion and pion radii The Wilson coefficients in the limit of large Nc are found to be ¯lj,∞ = lim Nc→∞ ¯ljNc The pion decay constant fπ is related to λ and ¯lj through a fitting procedure The high energy behavior of the form factors is bounded by constraints like F00(s > s0) ≤ χ00 m4πs ln m2π (2.22a) The spectral densities in the region above s0 are constrained to agree with that of the perturbative QCD values The asymptotic form factor for the vector and tensor current takes the form F11(t) t→∞ ≃ −36πs2t C2(Nc) N2c (3.36a) The procedure has two main sources of errors: one due to high energy inputs, particularly asymptotic form factors in (2.22), and another systematic error depending on the implementation details The authors obtained a set of 35 solutions by varying the asymptotic form factors in the range (3.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're talking about this paper now, it's called "Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c". It's by Cordoba, He, Kruczenski, Ping, Mohanty and Alegria. The title itself tells you the main idea is using a specific method to study gauge theories where the number of colors, N c can change.
Mira: Right. What that means simply is they’re looking at how changing the number of colors in a theory—like how many "types" of particles interact—affects its strong dynamics. They're trying to see what happens when you vary that parameter from three up to twelve colors, N c equals three through twelve.
Lev: From my side, this is interesting because tuning N c directly into the sum rules and form factors means we can test how sensitive the low-energy physics is to that microscopic setting. But it also means we have to make sure the UV inputs are solid, you know, starting with perturbative QCD stuff for those form factors.
Kai: Exactly. The core idea is using this method to connect the high energy description of the theory, which comes from perturbative QCD and asymptotic form factors, with the low energy physics that pions dominate. It’s a bridge between those two worlds.
Mira: And it’s interesting because they aren't just looking at one fixed N c; they are systematically changing it to map out the landscape of strong coupling effects across different color numbers. It sets up a whole systematic study for the low energy constants and resonances.
Lev: If we think about running this on real hardware, varying N c means we have to re-evaluate how those UV constraints feed into the numerical setup for each new N c value, which adds some computational overhead.
The paper's summary: Kai: So what they actually did in this paper is use the Gauge Theory Bootstrap to compute a lot of stuff for that range of N c, from three up to twelve colors. They focused on extracting scattering lengths, effective ranges, and low energy constants called the bar-ell-i parameters.
Mira: The key takeaway here is how these low energy parameters change as N c varies. They found that for the sigma meson mass and width, they increase with N c, which aligns with what you see in previous unitarized chiral perturbation theory analyses of large N c expansions.
Lev: I’m looking at those scaling predictions now. If we look at the rho and f2 resonances, their masses actually depend only weakly on N c, but their widths decrease as N c increases, which is what you expect from the conventional quark-antiquark meson scaling.
Kai: So it’s a mixed bag—some things scale one way with N c, like the sigma resonance getting heavier and wider, while others scale differently, like the rho and f2 mesons settling down. It shows a complex interplay of dynamics across that color range.
Mira: That complexity is what makes this study important for understanding how confinement works in these theories. They are using the bootstrap to handle those strongly coupled regions where standard perturbation theory breaks down.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, getting these low energy constants right across a whole range of N c means our numerical implementation has to be very robust, because if we misplace a pole on the complex plane for one N c, it messes up the entire set of results for that color.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors also pointed out some ways they could improve this study. One big thing they suggest is using a discrete basis parameterization, which speeds up the numerical optimization and makes extracting those poles on the complex plane much easier.
Mira: That makes sense for computational efficiency. It helps you get those resonance properties—the masses and widths of the sigma, rho, and f2 mesons—out more reliably from the second sheet of analytic partial waves using Watson's theorem.
Lev: I see how that helps with the poles; if you can find them faster, you reduce the chance of getting stuck in numerical noise when trying to pin down those complex energy values. It’s about improving the precision of extracting those resonance properties.
Kai: And they also showed how to get better error estimates. Instead of just relying on one set of asymptotic form factors, they suggest exploring a range of coefficients for those form factors and testing different initial starting points for the Watsonian iteration procedure.
Mira: That’s good because it shows the sensitivity of the results to those high energy inputs. It highlights that the error in these low energy calculations is heavily dependent on how well we constrain that UV region, specifically through those asymptotic form factors.
Lev: From a real hardware standpoint, if we have to test different starting points or input parameters for every N c value, the computational cost multiplies quickly. So they are trying to balance that improved accuracy against the overhead of testing all those variations.
Conclusion: Kai: So putting it all together, this paper on "Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c" shows how systematically we can probe strong dynamics in asymptotically free gauge theories by tuning the number of colors N c between three and twelve.
Mira: The main implication is that we gain a much clearer picture of how low energy constants and resonances scale with color, especially seeing the sigma meson mass increase while other resonances like rho do not. This helps us verify scaling predictions from large N c expansions.
Lev: For us, it validates the Bootstrap framework as a viable tool to connect UV physics to IR dynamics, but we also see that running this on real hardware would require careful handling of those varying inputs and systematic error checking for every N c case.
Kai: So in short, they use the Gauge Theory Bootstrap method to study how these theories behave across different color numbers, and the results match what we expect from other methods like unitarized chiral perturbation theory.
Mira: It’s a solid piece of work because it successfully connects microscopic inputs to observable low energy parameters and resonance properties across a broad range of N c.
Lev: We see that this framework works, but the next step is building the actual numerical infrastructure that can handle all those systematic variations without losing precision at every stage.
Kai: That’s what we're looking at for now with this paper on "Gauge Theory Bootstrap with varying N c".
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds