Eikonal, nonlocality and regular black holes

summary

The gist

We investigate the leading gravitational eikonal in nonlocal D dimensional theories of gravity to reconstruct singularity-free…

In short

The study uses gravitational eikonal phases from nonlocal D-dimensional theories of gravity to reconstruct singularity-free black hole deformations, specifically those with a de Sitter core. By analyzing scattering amplitudes in the Regge limit, the authors extract classical observables like deflection angles and time delays. The resulting nonlinear metric describes an asymptotically flat object characterized by a horizonless compact core.

Key concepts

Gravitational Eikonal Phase
This is a mathematical tool derived from high-energy scattering amplitudes in gravity. It allows researchers to reliably extract classical scattering observables, such as deflection angles or time delays, by analyzing the saddle point of the amplitude expansion.
Nonlocal D-dimensional Theories
These are modifications of general relativity where gravitational interactions depend on the spacetime structure over a region rather than just at a single point. The paper investigates how these nonlocality effects influence particle scattering and black hole geometry in higher dimensions.
Probe Limit
This scenario involves scattering where one particle is much heavier than the other. In this limit, the eikonal phase accurately reflects the geodesic motion of the lighter 'probe' particle moving through a background field generated by the heavy particle.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Eikonal, nonlocality and regular black holes · Read on arXiv

Mariano Cadoni, Lorenzo Herres, Leonardo Modesto, Lorenzo Orlando, Mirko Pitzalis

Dipartimento di Fisica, University of Cagliari, Cittadella Universitaria, 09042 Monserrato, Italy · Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Sezione di Cagliari, Cittadella Universitaria, 09042 Monserrato, Italy

We investigate the leading gravitational eikonal in nonlocal D dimensional theories of gravity. We analyze the simplest cases of 2 to2 massless and massive scalar scattering at tree level, studying the effects of nonlocal form factors in the gravitational sector. We give an interpretation of our results in terms of geodesic motion in effective generalized Aichelburg-Sexl geometries for the massless case, and in smeared linearized Schwarzschild metrics for the massive case in the probe limit. Combining our results for the geometries at linearized level with general requirements about the behaviour of the solutions in the core, we propose a nonlinear completion of the geometries. The resulting spacetimes describe singularity-free, asymptotically flat deformations of the Schwarzschild solution with a de Sitter core. We also analyze the main geometric and thermodynamic features of these solutions.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Eikonal, nonlocality and regular black holes".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate the leading gravitational eikonal in nonlocal D dimensional theories of gravity to reconstruct singularity-free, asymptotically flat deformations of the Schwarzschild solution with a de Sitter core Leading Eikonal Extraction The primary tool at our disposal will be the gravitational eikonal phase.

Kai: The main idea is that at high energies and fixed momentum transfer — the Regge limit — the S-matrix for a scattering process is well approximated by an infinite sum to all orders in the loop expansion of leading terms in ladder and crossed ladder diagrams.

Mira: This has two important effects: it unitarizes the elastic process, otherwise inconsistent with partial wave unitarity, and justifies a saddle point analysis from which observables like the classical impulse, deflection angles or time delays may be reliably extracted <ref:2604.18004#pg2> Massless Scattering Analysis For massless scalar scattering in ordinary GR, the leading eikonal phase is intimately connected to the phase shift of one of the two scatterers in the background of the emergent Aichelburg-Sexl shockwave produced by the other <ref:2604.18004#pg2> The leading eikonal for massless particles in a D-dimensional spacetime is given by an expression involving Gamma functions and impact parameter b The absence of an imaginary part in the string theory result is related to the production of heavy closed string states in the s channel, clearly something absent in this model.

Kai: Massive Scattering and Probe Limit In the probe limit of massive scalar scattering, where one body is much heavier than the other, the eikonal faithfully reproduces the physics of geodesic motion of the probe in a background produced by the heavy particle <ref:2604.18004#pg12> The leading PM deflection angle for this case reads Nonlinear Metric Reconstruction The full nonlinear form of the spacetime geometry is reconstructed from results at the linearized level by imposing eikonal compatibility.

Title and authors: Mira: So, let's talk about the title and the authors of this paper, "Eikonal, nonlocality and regular black holes." It’s by Cadoni, Herres, Modesto, Orlando, and Pitzalis.

Kai: The title itself tells you exactly what we are looking at: the eikonal phase in nonlocal theories of gravity. It’s connecting scattering methods to the shape of spacetime.

Mira: And the authors bring different strengths to this; they have a mix of expertise from different areas, which is important when you're trying to bridge quantum gravity ideas with classical general relativity structures.

Lev: From my side, I focus on what it would take to actually run this kind of reconstruction on real hardware. It's about the computational overhead and whether these nonlocal corrections are manageable for error correction schemes.

Kai: I’m working with superconducting qubits and cryogenics, so when they talk about the underlying theory, I want to know if they're talking about something that could be physically realized or at least simulated faithfully.

Mira: What this paper suggests is that by incorporating nonlocal form factors into the gravitational sector, we can tame the problematic UV behavior of Einstein gravity and potentially recover familiar local field theories in a specific limit.

Lev: That recovery in the alpha to zero limit is what gives me pause; it means that if you build a real device based on this theory, you’re essentially relying on that nonlocal physics being well-behaved enough to approximate standard gravity at low energy.

Kai: The authors are treating these form factors as tunable input data, which makes the theory more flexible than theories where everything is fixed by a specific fundamental constant like the Planck scale.

Mira: Exactly, it’s about decoupling the nonlocal scale from the Planck scale so that its effects can survive into our observable gravitational infrared regime.

Lev: If we could isolate those effects cleanly, maybe we wouldn't need such complex error correction overhead just to manage the nonlocality of spacetime itself.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what’s the actual summary of this paper? They are investigating the leading gravitational eikonal in nonlocal D dimensional theories of gravity.

Mira: They analyze the simplest cases: two-to-two massless and massive scalar scattering at tree level, specifically studying how nonlocal form factors modify those interactions in the gravitational sector.

Lev: The core idea is using these eikonal phases to interpret results in terms of geodesic motion in effective Aichelburg-Sexl geometries for the massless case and smeared linearized Schwarzschild metrics for the massive probe limit.

Kai: This allows them to combine their linearized geometric results with general requirements about how solutions must behave in the core, which leads them to propose a nonlinear completion of these geometries.

Mira: They’re trying to reconstruct a spacetime that is asymptotically flat but has a de Sitter core, and this result describes something they find called an horizonless compact object.

Lev: I see that reconstruction step as the most ambitious part; moving from the linearized description to something fully nonlinear requires imposing those eikonal compatibility conditions.

Kai: And they also look beyond just analyticity by considering strong infrared form factors, which might describe cosmic acceleration or dynamical dark energy.

Mira: They suggest a second infrared form factor could lead to a deflection angle that recovers Einstein's general relativity result when that scale approaches zero.

Lev: That’s interesting because it connects the scattering analysis directly to large-scale cosmological phenomena, which is where I usually get stuck when trying to model real universe dynamics.

Kai: So, the summary boils down to using eikonal methods in nonlocal gravity to build a regular black hole solution with a de Sitter core and explore how these nonlocality scales manifest in observable gravitational effects.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Now let’s talk about the improvements they suggest for this work. They are moving beyond just the basic setup by looking at stronger infrared form factors as a way to model cosmic acceleration or dynamical dark energy.

Kai: They also suggest that a second infrared form factor leads to a one-percent deflection angle that recovers Einstein's general relativity result when the scale goes to zero, which is a specific numerical result they found.

Lev: That recovery in the limit of the scale going to zero is important for me because it suggests that even with nonlocality, you can still get back to standard gravity if you tune those parameters correctly.

Mira: They also propose a proposal for reconstructing the full form of the nonlinear metric generated by a delta source by analyzing higher percent orders with explicit computation of subleading terms in higher loop amplitudes.

Kai: That means moving from just the leading order analysis to including more complex quantum corrections to get a better picture of the geometry.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that’s where things get really hairy; calculating those subleading terms in higher loop amplitudes will drastically increase the complexity of what we'd need to simulate on hardware.

Mira: They also show how they can classify black hole horizons based on a mass parameter mu, allowing them to distinguish between dirty gravastar configurations, extremal black holes, and horizonless compact objects.

Kai: That classification based on the mass parameter mu is something I can actually map onto different types of excitations in my qubit experiments; different regimes correspond to different physical states.

Lev: That sounds like a roadmap for what kind of observables we should be looking for if we were trying to build a real sensor sensitive to these gravitational configurations.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper on "Eikonal, nonlocality and regular black holes," the main implication is that we have a method to reconstruct singularity-free, asymptotically flat deformations of the Schwarzschild solution with a de Sitter core using these nonlocal gravitational theories.

Mira: It’s important because it provides a concrete framework for seeing how nonlocality influences gravitational interactions at intermediate impact parameters and how those effects might relate to dark energy or cosmic acceleration.

Lev: For me, the most practical implication is the roadmap they give for reconstructing the full nonlinear metric from linearized results, which shows us what kind of structure we'd need to aim for in a real simulation.

Kai: I think it’s a powerful tool because it links scattering amplitudes directly to spacetime geometry in a way that’s hard to achieve otherwise.

Mira: It opens up the door to analyzing black hole horizon structures based on parameters like mu, which is vital for understanding what happens near the event horizon in these new geometries.

Lev: I think we should keep watching how they refine those higher order calculations; that’s where the real test of whether this framework can describe actual physics will be.

More episodes

← Home