Defect Anomalies at a Distance
summary
The gist
Surface defects carry Weyl and gravitational anomalies that generalize the central charges of two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) and characterize the anomalous response of gapless…
In short
The paper investigates how surface defects carry Weyl and gravitational anomalies, which generalize 2D CFT central charges. It shows these anomalies are encoded in integrated bulk stress-tensor correlators at a distance. The authors derive sum rules for these anomalies and establish a lower bound on the boundary Weyl anomaly in three-dimensional CFTs.
Key concepts
- Weyl and Gravitational Anomalies
- These are physical effects that occur when surface defects interact with background geometry. They are generalizations of central charges from 2D conformal field theories, describing how gapless surface modes respond anomalously to the environment.
- Integrated Bulk Stress-Tensor Correlators
- The paper uses correlators of the bulk stress tensor to encode the anomalies of surface defects. These correlators are scheme-independent and allow researchers to detect anomalies that appear as contact terms in boundary theories, effectively linking bulk physics to boundary properties.
- Sum Rules for Anomalies
- The authors derive specific mathematical relationships (sum rules) involving defect operator data and bulk stress tensor correlators. These rules provide a way to calculate or constrain the anomaly values based on measurable correlation functions away from the defect.
- Lower Bound on Boundary Weyl Anomaly
- For three-dimensional CFTs, the paper establishes a lower limit for the boundary Weyl anomaly (denoted as 'b'). This bound is derived using exact identities involving bulk data and provides a constraint on how large this anomaly can be.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Defect Anomalies at a Distance · Paper Radio
- Geometric and Renormalized Entropy in Conformal Field Theory
- Entanglement Entropy and Quantum Field Theory
- The Theory of Boundary Critical Phenomena
- CFT in AdS and boundary RG flows
- Boundary criticality of the O(N) model in d = 3 critically revisited
- The extraordinary boundary transition in the 3d O(N) model via conformal bootstrap
- Boundary Criticality of the 3D O(N) Model: From Normal to Extraordinary
- A plane defect in the 3d O (N) model
- Surface defects in the O(N) model
- Notes on a Surface Defect in the O(N) Model
- Phases of Surface Defects in Scalar Field Theories
- Spontaneous symmetry breaking on surface defects
- Surprises in the Ordinary: O(N) Invariant Surface Defect in the epsilon-expansion
- Factorizing Defects from Generalized Pinning Fields
- Fermions in AdS and Gross-Neveu BCFT
- Fermions in Boundary Conformal Field Theory: Crossing Symmetry and epsilon-Expansion
- Boundary criticality for the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa models
- Boundary critical behavior of the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa model
- Extraordinary Surface Criticalities for Interacting Fermions
- A Constraint on Defect and Boundary Renormalization Group Flows
The paper
Defect Anomalies at a Distance · Read on arXiv
Center for Cosmology and Particle Physics, New York University · Institute for Advanced Study · Joseph Henry Laboratories, Princeton University
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Defect Anomalies at a Distance".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Surface defects carry Weyl and gravitational anomalies that generalize the central charges of two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) and characterize the anomalous response of gapless surface modes to background geometry <ref:2611.08476#pg2> The authors explain how these anomalies are encoded at a distance, in scheme-independent integrated bulk stress-tensor correlators <ref:2611.08476#pg4> They derive sum rules for them in terms of defect operator data, establish a lower bound on the boundary Weyl anomaly in threedimensional CFTs, and illustrate their results with explicit examples <ref:2611.08476#pg6>.
Kai: Encoding Anomalies via Correlators The paper connects the Weyl and gravitational anomalies of conformal surface defects to correlators of the bulk stress tensor <ref:2611.08476#pg3> The trace of T is a contact term that detects the Weyl anomaly <ref:2611.08476#pg4> The coefficients cD and h are tied to the trace anomaly through the scale dependence of the renormalized action W
g: <ref:2611.08476#pg4> The coefficient b in (I.2), normalized to b = 1 for a free boson on Σ, is not captured this way <ref:2611.08476#pg4> Transporting Anomalies to Bulk Observables The task is to transport the anomaly, a contact term on Σ, to correlators of T away from Σ <ref:2611.08476#pg4> They combine the two into a deformation δg = Lξg + 2φg with three properties <ref:2611.08476#pg4> The Ward identities (II.2) then determine the linear response of this δg by the Weyl anomaly, up to the Lie transport of ⟨T⟩ <ref:2611.08476#pg4> Deriving Sum Rules for Anomalies The main results here are, B = 12πV rd RV Z d/dx' log r r' × ⟨Tzz(x)Tz¯z¯(x′) + (x ↔ x′)⟩, κ = 24πV rd RV Z d/dx' log r r' × ⟨Tz¯z¯(x)Tzz(x′) − (x ↔ x′)⟩ for any x away from Σ <ref:2611.08476#pg4> The structures of these identities become more transparent after a Weyl map to H3×S d−3 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Applications and Bounds For d = 3, the Weyl tensor vanishes and ⟨T⟩ = 0, so B = b <ref:2611.08476#pg6> This identity gives b and κ exactly in terms of correlation function data, and it bounds b from below by cD <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The inequality is strict because every block vanishes at v = 0, while α(0) = 2/3CT > 0 with CT the norm of the bulk stress tensor <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Monodromy Defects in Four Dimensions For a Weyl fermion with α < 1/2 has no scalar operator of dimension 2, so there is no contact term, and Bfermion(α) = α 2/2, κfermion = α <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The same propagators at coincident points give h <ref:2611.08476#pg4> With no curved background, scalar: b = 1/2 τ(α) squared, d squared = 3/2 τ(α) squared <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The Dirac: b = 2α squared − α 4, d squared = 3α 2(1 − α 2) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Boundary Anomalies in Three Dimensions Table I collects the values that follow from (VI.3) and (VI.9) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> All satisfy the bound b/d1 > −1 of (VI.1) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The normal O(N) boundary comes close to saturating it <ref:2611.08476#pg6>.
Mira: Monodromy Defects in Four Dimensions For the scalar, the integral in (V.5) is therefore −τ (α), and the contact term from Φ†Φ, of dimension d − 2 = 2, gives A2 = τ(α) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> In sum for a free scalar monodromy defect, Bscalar(α) = κscalar(α) = 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The Weyl fermion with α < 1/2 has no scalar operator of dimension 2, so there is no contact term, and Bfermion(α) = α 2/2, κfermion = α <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The same propagators at coincident points give h <ref:2611.08476#pg4> Since d squared = 36π/2h by (I.3) and b = B + 12π/2h by (I.6), we obtain, with no curved background, scalar: b = 1/2 τ(α) squared, d squared = 3/2 τ(α) squared <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Dirac: b = 2α squared − α 4, d squared = 3α 2(1 − α 4) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Boundary Anomalies in Three Dimensions The scalar: Neumann 1/16 3/32 0 2/3 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The Dirac: γ 3ψ = ±ψ 0 3/16 ±1/2 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> O(N): ordinary 0 3π/2N/512 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> O(N): normal −N/2 27π/2N/512 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> B1⟩: −N/4 9π/2N/256 −N/2 −64π/9π<ref:2611.08476#pg6> Monodromy Defects in Four Dimensions scalar: b = 1/2 τ(α) squared, d squared = 3/2 τ(α) squared <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Dirac: b = 2α 4 − α 8, d squared = 3α 4(1 − α 4) <ref:2611.08476#pg6> Boundary Anomalies in Three Dimensions The scalar: Neumann 1/16 3/32 0 2/3 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> The Dirac: γ 3ψ = ±ψ 0 3/16 ±1/2 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> O(N): ordinary 0 3π/2N/512 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> O(N): normal −N/2 27π/2N/512 0 <ref:2611.08476#pg6> B1⟩: −N/4 9π/2N/256 −N/2 −64π/9π<ref:2611.08476#pg6> The scalar: α = α(0)(1 + v 6) ± CT v(1 - v 2) squared, Dirac: α = cD 2(1 + v 6), α˜ = 3v 2(1 + v 2) 3/32π/ (VI.5> The paper is 2611.084765.
Kai: Page 1 --- Surface defects carry Weyl and gravitational anomalies that generalize the central charges of two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) and characterize the anomalous response of gapless surface modes to background geometry <ref:2611.08476#pg4> The authors explain how these anomalies are encoded at a distance, in scheme-independent integrated bulk stress-tensor correlators <ref:2611.08476#pg4> They derive sum rules for them in terms of defect operator data, establish a lower bound on the boundary Weyl anomaly in threedimensional CFTs, and illustrate their results with explicit examples <ref:2611.08476#pg6>.
Paper summary: Kai: To recap what we've seen so far, the paper "Defect Anomalies at a Distance" argues that surface defects carry Weyl and gravitational anomalies, which are essentially generalized central charges from two-dimensional conformal field theories.
Mira: The core claim is that these anomalies are encoded in scheme independent integrated bulk stress tensor correlators, rather than just being local contact terms on the defect itself.
Lev: They use this to derive sum rules for these anomalies using data from defect operators, and they even establish a lower bound on the boundary Weyl anomaly specifically for three dimensional CFTs.
Kai: They illustrate all of this by giving explicit examples, which shows how it works in practice.
Mira: The method involves connecting the anomaly to correlators of the bulk stress tensor T, and they use Ward identities to link these two things together via a deformation of the metric delta g.
Lev: It seems like they are trying to build a bridge between surface physics and bulk measurements, which is always an interesting challenge when you're building error correction systems.
Kai: They do this by showing how the trace of the stress tensor, which detects the Weyl anomaly, relates to these separated point correlators in a simple manner.
Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up "Defect Anomalies at a Distance," it seems like the main contribution is deriving those sum rules for anomalies using defect operator data and setting that lower bound on the boundary Weyl anomaly in three dimensional CFTs.
Kai: The title itself suggests a distance relationship, but what they really achieve is showing how anomalies are encoded in bulk correlators, which is a big conceptual step.
Lev: For someone building real hardware, this means we can look at bulk measurements and use those to infer properties about the surface defects without having to measure everything right on that defect.
Kai: It’s about using the structure of the stress tensor correlators to constrain what we know about the underlying field theory at a boundary.
Mira: They move beyond just looking at local contact terms and give us a way to relate them to integrated bulk information, which is very useful for understanding how these systems behave under different geometries.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds