Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions
summary
The gist
Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions study how holographic phase transitions imprint their scaling laws on the local Kasner geometry inside Einstein-scalar black…
In short
The study investigates how critical scaling near a black hole phase transition affects local Kasner geometries inside Einstein-scalar black holes. It finds an analytic link between boundary critical behavior and multiple interior Kasner epochs. Numerical results confirm these predictions for ordinary and tricritical cases, revealing how different coupling strengths modify the scaling laws.
Key concepts
- Kasner Epochs
- The black hole interior is not a single geometry but passes through several local Kasner epochs separated by scalar-field bounces. Each epoch has its own set of Kasner exponents, which describe the local spacetime structure at that specific point in time and space.
- Critical Scaling
- This refers to how physical quantities near a phase transition behave when tuned close to the critical point. The paper shows that this boundary scaling dictates the temperature dependence of Kasner exponents inside the black hole, linking far-field physics to interior geometry.
- Irrelevant Exponent ($\delta_{IR}$)
- This exponent governs how quickly a system approaches its infrared fixed point (low-temperature behavior). The paper shows that this exponent determines the low-temperature scaling of Kasner exponents, and it changes significantly depending on the specific holographic model used.
- Screened Kasner Solution
- This is a specific numerical finding where an exterior hairy black hole possesses an interior that behaves like a single Schwarzschild-like Kasner epoch. This suggests that the influence of the exterior order parameter on the first interior Kasner exponent is suppressed or 'screened'.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions · Paper Radio
- The Black Hole Singularity in AdS/CFT
- Excursions beyond the horizon: Black hole singularities in Yang-Mills theories (I)
- Black Hole Singularity from OPE
- Holographic flows from CFT to the Kasner universe
- Black hole singularities across phase transitions
- Multi-Trace Operators, Boundary Conditions, And AdS/CFT Correspondence
- Holographic quantum criticality from multi-trace deformations
- Observing the origin of superconductivity in quantum critical metals
- AdS Black Holes with a Bouncing Interior
- Analytical studies on 3D hairy rotating black hole interiors
- AdS/CFT Correspondence and Symmetry Breaking
- Multi-Trace Deformations in AdS/CFT: Exploring the Vacuum Structure of the Deformed CFT
- Multitrace deformations, Gamow states, and Stability of AdS/CFT
- An Analytic Holographic Superconductor
- A Simple Holographic Insulator
- Interior geometry of black holes as a probe of first-order phase transition
- Trans-IR Flows to Black Hole Singularities
- Imprints of phase transitions on Kasner singularities
- Linear Growth of Holographic Time-like Entanglement Entropy and Kasner exponents
- Interior of helical black holes
The paper
Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions · Read on arXiv
Ling-Long Gao, Yan Liu, Hong-Da Lyub
Department of Space Science · Key Laboratory of Particle Physics and Particle Irradiation (MOE) · Institute of Frontier and Interdisciplinary Science
We study how holographic phase transitions imprint their scaling laws on the local Kasner geometry inside Einstein-scalar black holes. At fixed double-trace coupling, we derive the near-critical scaling of the deviation of the first-epoch Kasner exponent from the Schwarzschild value: p t(1)+ 1 over 3 proportional to O squared proportional to (T c-T) 1/r, where O denotes the boundary condensate and r labels ordinary criticality (r=1), tricriticality (r=2), and higher multicriticality (r at least3). A super-exponential scalar potential generates a sequence of Kasner epochs separated by scalar-field bounces. We further find that any later epoch that can be tracked continuously across the transition inherits the same temperature exponent, while its coefficient depends on the epoch. Numerical solutions confirm these predictions for the ordinary and tricritical cases. Finally, we show analytically that the leading irrelevant exponent of the infrared fixed point governs the low-temperature Kasner scaling, and verify the resulting scaling numerically for the first Kasner exponent.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions study how holographic phase transitions imprint their scaling laws on the local Kasner geometry inside Einstein-scalar black holes At fixed double-trace coupling, near-critical scaling of the deviation of the first-epoch Kasner exponent from the Schwarzschild value is given by a power law The paper derives an analytic connection between boundary critical behavior and multiple local Kasner epochs of the black-hole interior Numerical solutions confirm these predictions for ordinary and tricritical cases Holographic Setup and Interior Geometry The study considers four-dimensional Einstein-scalar gravity with a scalar potential consisting of polynomial and super-exponential terms The super-exponential term generates a sequence of Kasner epochs separated by scalar-field bounces, meaning the interior does not settle into a single asymptotic Kasner regime but passes through local epochs Each epoch is characterized by its own set of Kasner exponents p(n)t, p(n)x, and p(n)ϕ The analysis uses a perturbation method to relate the boundary condensate to the first local Kasner epoch and tracks this scaling across later epochs that remain continuously identifiable Analytical Perturbative Analysis The paper develops a unified perturbative description of how phase structure is encoded in critical scaling near the Schwarzschild bifurcation point The expansion around the critical point determines ordinary criticality, tricriticality, and fourth-order multicriticality by tuning quartic and sextic couplings The leading irrelevant exponent of the infrared fixed point governs the low-temperature Kasner scaling The scaling of temperature with respect to the coupling is determined by quantities like τ2 and zh2, which depend on potential couplings like λ4 Numerical Analysis and Scaling Relations Numerical studies verify the analytic predictions for ordinary and tricritical transitions The scaling relations for the first Kasner exponent are found to be p(1)t - pScht ∝ O2 at the ordinary critical point, proportional to (Tc − T)1/r at multicritical points r=2 and r≥3 For a fixed later epoch, its temperature exponent is inherited from the first epoch while its coefficient depends on the epoch The low-temperature scaling of Kasner exponents is governed by the leading irrelevant exponent of the IR fixed point, which leads to p(n)t - pScht ∝ T2δIR for a fixed epoch n Low-Temperature and First-Order Transitions The analysis extends to extremely low temperatures where the scaling is controlled by the irrelevant exponent of the zero-temperature IR fixed point The scaling of Kasner exponents at extremely low temperature is shown to be p(1)t - pScht ∝ T2δIR for both super-exponential and polynomial models For a first-order phase transition, the discontinuity in the Kasner exponent at the coexistence temperature T1 is not a discontinuity of the bulk solution but arises from thermodynamic branch selection The scaling at extremely low temperature for first-order transitions also follows p(1)t - pScht ∝ T3 for both models The main result is that the critical and multicritical scaling of the boundary order parameter is encoded in local Kasner epochs behind the horizon The condensate scaling fixes the interior temperature scaling, showing that p(1)t - pScht is linear in Tc - T at ordinary criticality, proportional to (Tc - T)1/2 at tricriticality, and proportional to ((Tc - T)1/3) at a fourth-order multicritical point The scaling exponent is label-independent for the interior Kasner epochs, but their coefficients are epoch-dependent Several open questions remain regarding the connection to experimentally accessible systems and chaotic BKL dynamics in general gravitational systems Thermodynamics of Black Holes The renormalized free energy density can be written in terms of boundary data as F ≡ F V2 = T SE on-shell V2 = mT − κa2 / 2 This reproduces the thermodynamic identity E - Ts = F The analysis shows that for continuous transitions, the scaling of free energy with respect to epsilon is completely determined by that of the temperature For first-order transitions, a finite-condensate free-energy crossing among physical solutions is the criterion that establishes the first-order transition The analysis also shows that for a special hairy black hole with a Schwarzschild-like interior, the scalar velocity in the interior is screened by its exterior profile Numerical Procedure to Obtain Solution The numerical procedure involves constructing a representative solution in horizon units and then applying a scaling transformation to obtain the solution with κ = −1 The physical observables are then extracted from this representative solution using the planar rescaling The scalar velocity is invariant under the planar rescaling, allowing for the identification of kinetic-dominated plateaus before or after imposing κ = −1 A Special Hairy Black Hole with Schwarzschild-like Interior In a special numerical solution, even with exterior scalar hair, the first interior plateau satisfies v1 ≃ 0 and p(1)t + 1/3 ≃ 0, meaning the whole interior is described by a single Schwarzschild-like Kasner epoch This behavior suggests that the map from exterior order parameter to interior Kasner data depends on the full radial evolution of the scalar field between the boundary, horizon, and interior Kasner epoch References
1: L.
Kai: Fidkowski, V.
Mira: Hubeny, M.
Kai: Kleban and S.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today, "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions." It's about how those phase transitions happening on the boundary of a black hole affect the local geometry deep inside.
Mira: Exactly. The authors are using holographic setups to see if you can map the critical behavior of something outside, like temperature changes, onto the actual spacetime geometry near a singularity inside a black hole.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I'm curious about what they actually built to model this. Is this happening in some specific quantum system or just theoretical gravity?
Kai: It’s done in four-dimensional Einstein-scalar gravity with a scalar potential that has polynomial and super-exponential terms. They are modeling a black hole interior where the super-exponential term creates a sequence of local Kasner epochs separated by scalar field bounces.
Mira: That sequence of epochs is key because it means the interior doesn't settle into just one simple Kasner regime; it passes through these distinct local ones, and they characterize the geometry with their own set of Kasner exponents.
Lev: So, if we think about running this on real hardware, how does that sequence of epochs translate into something computationally tractable? What’s the overhead there?
Kai: The paper uses a perturbation method to connect the boundary condensate to that very first local Kasner epoch and tracks that scaling across later epochs that they can continuously identify.
Mira: They derive an analytic connection between what happens at the boundary during a critical transition and all those multiple local Kasner epochs inside the black hole.
Lev: That sounds like a lot of work to connect things smoothly, especially when you have these bounces happening in the field. What's the main scaling relation they find?
Kai: At fixed double-trace coupling, near that critical point, they find a power law for how much the first epoch’s Kasner exponent deviates from the Schwarzschild value.
Mira: Specifically, it says this deviation scales like a power of (Tc - T) where r labels ordinary criticality as one, tricriticality as two, and higher multicriticality is three or greater.
Lev: That dependence on r suggests a very structured way the geometry responds to the boundary conditions. Is that what they found numerically?
Title and authors: Kai: Yes, numerical solutions confirm those analytic predictions for both ordinary and tricritical cases, and they actually show that the fitted powers reproduce mean-field values when checking against results like p t plus one three proportional to O2 proportional to (Tc minus T) over r at ordinary criticality.
Mira: That's interesting because it links the microscopic boundary order parameter directly to the macroscopic geometric structure of the interior in a very precise way.
Lev: I see that, but what about those later epochs? The paper mentions something about them inheriting scaling behavior from earlier ones. What does that mean for stability when you have multiple epochs?
Kai: The paper suggests that for any later epoch that can be tracked continuously across the transition, it inherits the same temperature exponent from the first epoch, even though its specific coefficient will depend on that particular epoch.
Mira: So, even if there are many distinct geometric regions inside, they all follow a common rule regarding temperature scaling near criticality.
Lev: If we consider a scenario where you're trying to implement error correction on this system, does that inheritance mean the complexity stays manageable? Or does it just mean you have more parameters to track?
Kai: The low-temperature scaling of those Kasner exponents is governed by the leading irrelevant exponent of the infrared fixed point.
Mira: They found that for extremely low temperatures, this scaling is controlled by the irrelevant exponent of the zero-temperature infrared fixed point, and it shows that for both super-exponential and polynomial models, it scales like p t plus one three proportional to T squared delta IR.
Lev: So when you push to absolute zero temperature, the geometry settles into a specific low-energy scaling dictated by that fixed point exponent. That helps with understanding the thermal stability of the state.
Kai: And for first-order phase transitions, they found that the discontinuity in the Kasner exponent at the coexistence temperature T one is not actually a discontinuity of any bulk solution at all; instead, it arises from which thermodynamic branch you pick when you move through solutions.
Mira: That’s a crucial distinction because it means the geometry itself isn't fundamentally discontinuous in a way that breaks causality, but rather we are selecting different paths through the solution space based on our temperature.
Title and authors: Lev: So, for designing error correction protocols, that implies we don't need to worry about fundamental singularities causing immediate breakdown of the physics; it’s more about selecting which branch of solutions to look at.
Kai: The main result is that this critical and multicritical scaling of the boundary order parameter actually fixes the interior temperature scaling for you.
Mira: So, p t plus one three is linear in Tc minus T at ordinary criticality, proportional to (Tc minus T) over two at tricriticality, and proportional to ((Tc minus T) over three) at a fourth-order multicritical point.
Lev: That linear dependence on the temperature difference for the first case makes sense for thermal systems, but what about implementing those specific power laws in a real quantum simulation? Does that require incredibly fine tuning of your coupling constants?
Kai: The scaling exponent is label independent for those interior Kasner epochs, but their coefficients do depend on which specific epoch you are looking at.
Mira: It's a lot to track, but the structure itself seems robust across different types of potentials they tested. The paper also showed that for a special hairy black hole with a Schwarzschild-like interior, the scalar velocity in the interior is screened by its exterior profile.
Lev: A screened Kasner solution sounds like it might be more physically relevant for certain models because it suggests the complexity of the exterior doesn't fully dictate every single internal dynamic.
Kai: We also have some improvements suggested, which is interesting because they look at how to make this analysis even richer. They suggest that by tuning quartic and sextic couplings, you can predict whether a phase transition will be continuous or first-order by looking at the sign of coefficients in the Landau effective theory.
Mira: So if you find that for lambda four less than lambda t four, one instead finds t two less than zero, that leads to a first-order transition. That gives us a concrete way to predict the nature of the transition from just observing boundary data.
Lev: If we can predict the order of the transition by looking at those couplings in a simple effective theory, that could simplify the whole process of modeling complex systems where you don't know which regime you are in beforehand.
Title and authors: Kai: We also see an improvement in how we model those low-temperature behaviors, specifically by showing that for super-exponential models, the irrelevant exponent drops from two point seven nine six one to two point seven five two four five.
Mira: That change is significant because it means the IR fixed point behavior is more sensitive to the specific form of the super-exponential potential than we thought before. It tells us a lot about how that term drives the low-energy physics.
Lev: So, for real hardware, that means when you try to simulate these very cold states, your error correction needs to be tuned based on this new exponent value rather than a generic one.
Kai: And we also have a numerical procedure they used where they construct a representative solution in horizon units and then apply a scaling transformation to get the solution with kappa equal minus one. This allows them to extract physical observables using the planar rescaling.
Mira: That procedure is smart because it lets them identify kinetic-dominated plateaus before or after imposing that kappa equal minus one condition, which gives us insight into how the system behaves near that boundary where things start to get complex.
Lev: It’s good they can pinpoint those kinetic plateaus; for error correction, identifying where the dynamics become purely kinetic versus dissipative is vital for setting up your syndrome extraction algorithms.
Kai: Overall, this paper, "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions," shows how the critical behavior on a boundary translates into structured geometric features deep inside black holes.
Mira: It gives us a map connecting the order of a phase transition to the specific scaling exponents of different internal regions behind the horizon.
Lev: The implications are that we have a way to probe these interior geometries using boundary data, which could be useful if we ever develop experiments sensitive enough to see those gravitational signatures.
Kai: So, this work lays down the groundwork for how we can connect quantum criticality on a surface to the geometry of spacetime near singularities.
Mira: It’s a reminder that even in highly complex gravity setups with multiple epochs, there is often an underlying universal structure controlling the scaling.
Lev: We’ll keep watching how these theoretical results translate into actual experimental constraints on error correction and thermal physics for black hole systems.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we’ve talked about how the boundary behavior of these holographic systems actually dictates the geometry deep inside black holes in this paper, "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling."
Mira: Right. Basically, they are showing that when you have a phase transition happening on the edge of a black hole—a critical point—that information gets imprinted right onto those local regions called Kasner epochs inside.
Lev: So what does that mean for us, practically? Does this give us a better way to calculate things inside?
Kai: It gives us a direct link between how the temperature changes on the boundary and the geometry of spacetime near the singularity. They found that for ordinary criticality, like at one critical point, the deviation of that first Kasner exponent from its usual Schwarzschild value scales linearly with how much you move away from that critical temperature.
Mira: That linear scaling is pretty clean for a continuous transition. But they also looked at more complex scenarios, like tricritical points and higher multicritical points, where the scaling changes to a power law based on the order of the transition.
Lev: A power law means different degrees of complexity lead to different geometric responses, which is interesting because it tells us how sensitive the interior dynamics are to how messy the phase transition is on the outside.
Kai: They also looked at extremely low temperatures, where everything gets controlled by a specific fixed point in the infrared—that's called a zero-temperature infrared fixed point.
Mira: And they found that for those low temperatures, the scaling follows an exponent related to that fixed point, and it’s different depending on whether you are using a super-exponential potential or just polynomial terms.
Lev: That means when you simulate these very cold states in hardware, the way the geometry scales down is determined by this specific fixed point behavior rather than just a generic low-energy guess.
Kai: And for first-order transitions, they found that even though there’s a jump in the Kasner exponent at the coexistence temperature, it isn't a jump in the bulk solution itself; it’s just you picking a different thermodynamic branch.
Mira: So the geometry stays smooth, but our choice of which mathematical path we follow through solutions dictates whether we see a continuous or first-order transition.
Lev: That helps us think about error correction because if the transition isn't fundamentally discontinuous in space, it means the dynamics are more about selecting a path than encountering a hard wall.
Kai: The main point is that this boundary scaling fixes the interior temperature scaling for you, showing that p t plus one three scales linearly for ordinary criticality and then changes to one over two or one over three at tricritical and fourth-order points respectively.
Mira: It’s a direct mapping of critical exponents from the boundary onto the local geometry behind the horizon.
Lev: This suggests we can use boundary data to predict structural features deep inside, which is useful if we ever get instruments that can probe these gravitational signatures directly.
Kai: We also saw an improvement in how they model those low-temperature behaviors by showing that for super-exponential models, the relevant exponent drops from two point seven nine six one down to two point seven five two four five.
Mira: That shift means the low-energy physics is more sensitive to that super-exponential potential than we initially thought, which tells us a lot about how that term drives the low-energy behavior.
Lev: If you're building hardware for these cold states, you need to know this new exponent value to tune your error correction algorithms correctly.
Kai: So yeah, it connects the math of critical scaling right to the geometry of spacetime near singularities in a way we hadn't fully mapped out before.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we’ve talked about how the boundary behavior of these holographic systems actually dictates the geometry deep inside black holes in this paper, "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling." Now we’re going to look at some suggestions for making that analysis even stronger.
Kai: The authors are suggesting ways to make the connection between boundary physics and interior geometry more precise. They want to improve how they predict the scaling of those Kasner exponents in subsequent interior epochs based on what happens on the boundary.
Mira: Exactly, because right now they can track some later epochs continuously across a transition, but they want a way to analytically predict that any later epoch that you can track will inherit the same temperature exponent as the first one.
Lev: That would be huge for error correction because it means we don't have to re-derive the scaling rules every time we look at a new interior region; it’s standardized.
Kai: They also improved their numerical verification of ordinary and tricritical cases, showing that their fitted powers reproduce mean-field values when checking against results like p t plus one three proportional to O2 proportional to Tc minus T over r at ordinary criticality.
Mira: That means they've tightened the constraints on the fitting, making sure those numerical fits are actually consistent with what we expect from simpler theories.
Lev: If you’re running simulations for real hardware, that consistency is everything; it shows that the math holds up when we move away from the idealized limits.
Kai: They also looked at how different holographic models compare, specifically by showing how a super-exponential interaction modifies the infrared fixed point by increasing that irrelevant exponent from two point seven five two four five to two point seven nine six one for the first Kasner exponent at low temperature.
Mira: That change in the exponent is significant because it shows that the specific form of that super-exponential potential really drives how the geometry scales when you’re looking at very cold physics.
Lev: So, for those simulations running at extremely low temperatures, you need to use that new exponent value instead of a generic one to get an accurate result.
Kai: And they introduced a concept called a "screened Kasner solution," which is an exterior hairy black hole with a Schwarzschild-like interior where the leading imprint on the first interior Kasner exponent is screened.
Mira: That's interesting because it suggests that even when you have complex hair outside, the geometry inside can be simplified or screened in certain ways, which simplifies our theoretical assumptions.
Lev: If we can isolate a shielded solution, it might be easier to map the dynamics to something we can actually simulate on real hardware with less complexity overhead.
Kai: Finally, they suggested using Landau effective theory to predict the order of the transition itself by looking at the sign of coefficients like lambda four and lambda t four.
Mira: So if you find that for lambda four less than lambda t four, you get a negative value for two point two, that predicts a first-order transition instead of continuous.
Lev: That gives us a way to predict the type of phase transition just by looking at the coupling constants in a simple effective theory before we even run the full simulation.
Kai: It’s about connecting the Landau theory directly to the geometry scaling, which is a nice piece of puzzle for our work on quantum criticality.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions" shows that we can map the critical behavior on a boundary directly onto local geometric features deep inside black holes.
Mira: It confirms that the order of a phase transition dictates the specific power law governing how those internal Kasner exponents scale with temperature near criticality.
Lev: So for error correction, this means we have more structure to work with when modeling the interior dynamics, even in these complicated multi-epoch scenarios.
Kai: The main implication is that you can use boundary data to fix the temperature scaling of the interior geometry, which is pretty powerful for testing our models.
Mira: It really shows how universal structures control the scaling, even as we introduce more complex features like super-exponential potentials or different orders of critical points.
Lev: If we can predict this structural relationship from boundary measurements, it simplifies the overhead calculation needed to simulate those interior regions on real hardware.
Kai: This work gives us a clearer framework for understanding how quantum criticality on a surface translates into the actual spacetime geometry near singularities in black holes.
Mira: It’s a strong reminder that even when things get complicated with multiple epochs, there is an underlying structure controlling the scaling behavior.
Lev: We still have to figure out how to get this kind of precise geometric information out of a real simulation, but this paper gives us the map we need to aim for.
Kai: So yeah, "Critical and multicritical Kasner scaling in holographic phase transitions" connects boundary physics to interior geometry in a way that’s genuinely interesting for us.
Mira: It sets the stage for how we can probe these interior geometries using data from the boundary, which opens up some new avenues for theory and experiment.
Lev: We’ll keep looking at how these theoretical results translate into actual experimental constraints on error correction and thermal physics for black hole systems.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds