A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory
summary
The gist
A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory provides an overview of the interconnection between generalized symmetries and cohomology…
In short
The course connects generalized symmetries in quantum field theory to cobordism and K-theory in string theory using differential forms. It shows that global symmetries relate to zero cobordism classes, while gauged symmetries relate to non-zero classes. This framework helps understand the topological transitions between D-branes and fluxes.
Key concepts
- Generalized Symmetries
- These are transformations in quantum field theory defined by a current, often a $(D-p)$-form $\ast J_{p+1}$. They generalize standard symmetries and are crucial for describing physical systems like Dp-branes in string theory.
- Cobordism Group $\Omega_G^q$
- This group classifies different types of manifolds that can be smoothly deformed into each other. In this context, it organizes the equivalence classes of cycles, allowing physicists to distinguish between physically distinct configurations like stable Dp-branes and fluxes.
- K-theory Isomorphism
- There is a mathematical link proving that the oriented cobordism group of certain manifolds is isomorphic to the cohomology of spaces called Thom Spaces. This bridge connects geometric properties (cobordism) with topological invariants used in quantum field theory.
- Topological Transition
- This describes how a Dp-brane can change its nature, for example, transforming into fluxes. Mathematically, this is identified by analyzing when the symmetry current becomes exact under specific differential maps like $d3$, leading to a zero class in the relevant cobordism group.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory · Paper Radio
- Symmetries and Strings in Field Theory and Gravity
- Generalized Global Symmetries
- Lectures on Generalized Symmetries
- ICTP Lectures on (Non-)Invertible Generalized Symmetries
- Generalized Symmetries For Generalized Gravitons
- Lecture Notes on Generalized Symmetries and Applications
- Aspects of Categorical Symmetries from Branes: SymTFTs and Generalized Charges
- Introduction to Generalized Global Symmetries in QFT and Particle Physics
- Generalized Charges, Part II: Non-Invertible Symmetries and the Symmetry TFT
- An Introduction to Higher-Form Symmetries
- Generalized symmetries and Noether's theorem in QFT
- Notes on generalized global symmetries in QFT
- Dimensional Reduction of Cobordism and K-theory
- Dynamical Cobordism of a Domain Wall and its Companion Defect 7-brane
- Looking for structure in the cobordism conjecture
- Open-Closed Correspondence of K-theory and Cobordism
- On the Swampland Cobordism Conjecture and Non-Abelian Duality Groups
- Cobordism Conjecture, Anomalies, and the String Lamppost Principle
- Generalized Charges, Part I: Invertible Symmetries and Higher Representations
- Snowmass White Paper: Generalized Symmetries in Quantum Field Theory and Beyond
The paper
A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory · Read on arXiv
Oscar Loaiza-Brito, Víctor M. López-Ramos
Departamento de Fijsica, Universidad de Guanajuato
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory provides an overview of the interconnection between generalized symmetries and cohomology, describing a method for connecting them with cobordisms and K-theory within string theory These lectures constitute an expanded version of the mini-course presented at the XI School on Topological and Algebraic Methods in Quantum Field Theory, held in Villa de Leyva, Colombia In these lectures, we offer a general perspective on one of the most interesting topics in theoretical physics over the last decade: the study of generalized symmetries The initial part of the notes is dedicated to covering the construction of generalized symmetries from a physical perspective, utilizing well-defined mathematical objects such as differential forms An important aspect of this discussion is the identification of broken and gauged symmetries with zero cobordism classes Symmetries in Quantum Field Theory The review of symmetries in classical and quantum field theory starts by considering a continuous global transformation U ∈ G where G is taken to be a compact continuous group, for the sake of simplicity, we are going to consider this group to be the abelian Lie group U(1) A symmetry implies that the variation of the Lagrangian density is of the form L′ ≈ L + δL with δL(ϕ, ∂µϕ) = ∂µKµ This implies also a variation on the action of the form δS = Z dD+1 ∂µJ µ = Z dDx ω µj µ Symmetries and Cohomology The study of symmetries and conserved charges from the point of view of cohomology involves expressing symmetries in terms of differential forms A continuous global symmetry is a transformation Uˆ acting on the quantum fields ϕ ∈ H, where H is the Hilbert space, generated by elements of a continuous compact Lie group (think here as U(1)) such that if LD+1 defines a class in HD+1(WD+1; Z), the transformed Lagrangian L′ = L(ϕ′, dϕ′) still belongs to the same equivalence class
LD+1: ∈ H D+1(WD+1; Z) This defines the closed D-form Noether current ∗J1 as ∗J1 = ∗L1 − ∗K1 The current class
∗J1: can be the zero or a non-zero element in HD(WD+1; Z) and this is reflected in the number associated to this class through the isomorphism A.17 from which the conserved charge is defined as Qi = Z ΣD i ∗J1 Generalized Symmetries and Cobordisms Generalized symmetries have captured the attention of a considerable part of the theoretical physics community over the last few years A current given by a (D − p)-form ∗Jp+1 ∈ C D−p(WD+1), which can be closed or not, defines a p-form symmetry, as a generalization of the QFT symmetries we review in the last section A global charged Q (p)i related to a p-form symmetry is defined as Q (p)i = Z ΣD−p i ∗Jp+1 Topological Transitions and Cobordism Two cycles must be related to each other by an equivalence relation even if they posses more general structures, as being a base manifold with orientability, and spin or spinc structures This allows to define a cobordant equivalence class by
Σq i: = The set of space slide used to measure the charge Q q f at some time tf > ti This set of equivalence classes establish a q-graded group, called the qth-Cobordism group omega G where G denotes all the required structure on the cobordant spaces Σq Implications to Quantum Gravity The presence of global conserved charges, associated with non-zero cobordism classes, does not appear to play a significant role in the theory, particularly once we incorporate gauge fields and their extensions in string theory It is conjectured that a theory consistent with quantum gravity must be described by null classes in a cobordism theory Cobordism and K-theory Relation The existence of an isomorphism between the oriented cobordism group of (D−p)-dimensional manifolds ΣD−p and cohomology of groups of certain spaces called Thom Spaces T(E) associated to the oriented vector bundle E over ΣD−p, where the Thom space is the total space of E modulo its zero section This theorem provides a bridge between cobordism and cohomological invariants associated with vector bundles such as the global charge Generalized p-form Symmetries The p-dimensional objects carrying a global charge Q (p)i can be identified with Dp-branes in string theory We can generalize the corresponding Lagrangian in the case of an abelian gauged psymmetry as L = Fp+2 ∧ ∗Fp+2 + Ap+1 ∧ ∗Jp+1 Fluxes and Branes Interaction The total charge at time ti is given by Q (p)i,T = Z ΣD−p (∗Jp+1 + Hq ∧ ∗Fp−q) This in turn defines a Lagrangian of the form L = Fp+2 ∧ ∗Fp+2 − Cp+1 ∧ ∗Jp+1 − Hq ∧ Fp−q Quantization of Charges Dirac’s quantization leads us to consider the abelian free part of cohomology to be Z This implies that we have a topologically nontrivial U(1)-bundle, regarding the charge operators (or quantum fields) to be sections of a line bundle Gauged Symmetries and Broken Higher Symmetries Breaking the 3-symmetry means that
d3 ∗ Fp+4: ∈ H D−p+3(WD+1; Z) but not in E p 2(WD+1; Z) This implies that d3: H D−p H D−p+3 0 0 ∈ E Cobordism Conjecture It is conjectured that a theory consistent with quantum gravity must be described by null classes in a cobordism theory, where the mathematical structures on the spacetime are yet to be fully determined This conjecture suggests that continuous global symmetries in quantum gravity appear to be untenable De Rham Cohomology Basics The pth de Rham cohomology group is defined by H p dR(WD+1) = Z p(WD+1)/Bp(WD+1) The zero element in Hp dR(WD+1) consists on all exact p-forms Hodge Dual Map Let us now define the Hodge dual map, denoted ∗ by ∗: Hp(WD+1; Z) → HD+1−p(WD+1; Z) Notice that for any p-form and for any p, d(ωp∧∗ωp) = 0 for which ωp ∧ ∗ωp defines an equivalence class in HD+1(WD+1; Z) Homology Definition Define the pth homology group as Hp(WD+1; Z) = Σ p ∈ Cp ∂Σ p = 0 / Σ p ∈ Cp Σp = ∂Πp+1 Hence the pth homology group consists on equivalence classes of cycles where the null element are chains which are the boundary of other Poincaré Dual Map Define the Poincar´e Dual map PD: Hp(WD+1; Z) ←→ H D+1−p(WD+1; Z) such that PD(ωp) has compact support on a transversal cycle to Σp Notice that in this case PD(Σp) is identified with a localized bump form (usually expressed in physics literature as a Dirac’s delta) supported on PD(ωp) with PD(ωp) PD(Σp) = 1 De Rham Theorem's For
ωp: ∈ H p dR(WD+1; Z) and Σp ∈ Cp (WD+1) with Σp = ∂Πp+1, Z Σp ωp = Z Πp+1 dωp = 0 The paper explores the connection between generalized symmetries and cohomology through differential forms, establishing a framework for relating these concepts to cobordisms and K-theory in string theory It details how global symmetries are related to zero cobordism classes, while gauged symmetries are related to non-zero classes in certain cobordism groups The discussion extends to p-form symmetries and the topological transition between Dp-branes and fluxes, connecting these concepts via the Atiyah-Hirzebruch Spectral Sequence and K-theory Finally, it concludes that continuous global symmetries are untenable in quantum gravity due to constraints imposed by black hole thermodynamics The paper provides a mathematical structure for understanding the conservation of gauged charges through null cobordism classes The presence of global conserved charges, associated with non-zero cobordism classes, does not appear to play a significant role in the theory, particularly once we incorporate gauge fields and their extensions in string theory It is conjectured that a theory consistent with quantum gravity must be described by null classes in a cobordism theory The paper provides a mathematical structure for understanding the conservation of gauged charges through null cobordism classes Topological Transition Summary A stable Dp-brane that could transform into fluxes defines a zero-class in E D−p 2(WD+1) A stable Dp-brane that does not transform into fluxes and does not decay into the vacuum defines a zero class in E D−p 2(WD+1) The paper shows that breaking the 3-symmetry means that
d3 ∗ Fp+4: ∈ H D−p+3(WD+1; Z) but not in E p 2(WD+1; Z) This implies that d3: H D−p H D−p+3 0 0 ∈ E Supergravity Context The construction of a supergravity theory seems to be in agreement with associating the spaces over which we compute global symmetries to belong to a zero cobordism class This is known in string theory as the tadpole condition The tadpole condition is compatible with a D-brane current in a zero class in omegaeG D−p, and it is followed by a zero class in omegaG D−p−1 Final Summary of Symmetries The paper explores the connection between generalized symmetries and cohomology through differential forms, establishing a framework for relating these concepts to cobordisms and K-theory in string theory It details how global symmetries are related to zero cobordism classes, while gauged symmetries are related to non-zero classes in certain cobordism groups The discussion extends to p-form symmetries and the topological transition between Dp-branes and fluxes, connecting these concepts via the Atiyah-Hirzebruch Spectral Sequence and K-theory Finally, it concludes that continuous global symmetries are untenable in quantum gravity due to constraints imposed by black hole thermodynamics The paper provides a mathematical structure for understanding the conservation of gauged charges through null cobordism classes The paper is 2404.03599.
Kai: Page 1 --- A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory Oscar Loaiza-Brito and V´ıctor M.
Mira: L´opez-Ramos Departamento de F´ısica, Universidad de Guanajuato, Loma del Bosque No.
Kai: 103 Col.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into the title of "A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory" today. It sets up a big picture connecting generalized symmetries with cobordisms and K-theory.
Mira: It sounds like the authors are setting out to show how these concepts aren't separate ideas, but actually deeply interconnected tools that work together in string theory.
Lev: When you see those terms thrown around, it’s a sign they're trying to build a mathematical machinery that handles complex interactions where standard QFT tools might fall short.
Kai: Exactly. They are using differential forms as the language to bridge the gap between symmetries and cohomology, which is a common starting point for many of us.
Mira: And then they use cobordisms and K-theory to formalize that relationship, giving it a topological grounding within string theory.
Lev: It’s interesting because this isn't just a review; they are actually trying to propose a method for connecting these concepts, which is more constructive than just saying they exist.
Kai: Right. The paper explicitly states its goal is to describe that method, providing an overview for students who already have the basic knowledge of QFT and differential forms.
Mira: And it’s designed not to give a formal mathematical construction from scratch, but rather a physically motivated approach focused on interconnecting these ideas.
Lev: I like that restraint because trying to build the full mathematical construction from zero is usually where things get bogged down quickly in these kinds of papers.
Kai: So they are focusing on the physical intuition first, assuming you have some foundational knowledge already. They're using physics arguments to guide the math they present.
Mira: And that guidance is what makes it accessible to people outside of pure mathematics, which is a key thing for getting these ideas into broader physics discussions.
Lev: It’s a nice way to introduce the concepts without immediately drowning the listener in heavy machinery from the start.
Kai: So we're setting the stage by explaining what they are trying to achieve: connecting generalized symmetries with cobordisms and K-theory through a physical lens.
The paper's summary: Mira: Now let’s look at the actual summary of "A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory." It outlines how they connect symmetries to cohomology.
Kai: They start by reviewing symmetries in QFT, looking at continuous global transformations like U(one), where a symmetry implies the variation of the Lagrangian density is of the form L' about L + delta L with delta L(phi, d mu phi) = d mu K mu <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Mira: This variation leads directly to a transformation on the action, delta S = Z dD D+one d mu J mu, which is what they call the Noether current class J one in H D+one(W D+one; Z) <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Lev: They then define the conserved charge as Q i = Z sum i *J one which can be zero or non-zero depending on whether that current class is exact or not <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Kai: This is where they introduce generalized symmetries, moving to a (D minus p)-form current, *J p+one which generalizes the QFT symmetries we just discussed <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Mira: A global charged Q(p)i is defined as Q(p) i = Z sum from-p to i *J p+one and this generalized symmetry is defined by that specific p-form current <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Lev: So it’s a generalization of the standard charges, but now you've got multiple forms involved, which suggests more complex dynamics.
Kai: And they immediately connect these generalized symmetries to cobordism by saying two cycles must be related by an equivalence relation even if they have more general structures.
Mira: This lets them define a cobordant equivalence class sigma q as the set of space slides used to measure the charge Q q f at time t f from some initial time t i.
Lev: That’s how they establish that q-graded group, omega G q, which is defined by all the required structure on those cobordant spaces sigma q.
Kai: And then they link this to K-theory through that isomorphism between oriented cobordism groups and the cohomology of Thom Spaces T(E) associated with a vector bundle E over sigma D-p.
Mira: That isomorphism is the key piece that links the geometric objects—the manifolds—to the algebraic invariants like K-theory.
Lev: It’s showing that these topological invariants are not just abstract math; they correspond to physical charges derived from spacetime geometry.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Moving into what the paper suggests as its improvements, it hints at how we can use this framework for classification of physical states.
Mira: One major improvement is suggesting that we can perform topological classification of physical states by mapping them to cobordism classes in the qth-Cobordism group omega G q.
Lev: That would mean we could distinguish between stable Dp-branes that decay into fluxes and those that don't, based on whether their associated current class is zero or non-zero in the relevant cohomology groups.
Kai: And they suggest another improvement is calculating the fate of physical systems under symmetry breaking by looking at relative intersection numbers, defined as IR(sigma D t, gamma one) = I(sigma D f, gamma one) - I(sigma D t, gamma one) <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Mira: That would allow us to describe how global charges evolve or vanish over time by tracking those intersection numbers across different time slices.
Lev: From my side, that’s where the real overhead lands; running those relative intersection number calculations on real hardware would be computationally demanding.
Kai: They also talk about calculating quantized electric and magnetic charges using the Chern character of principal U(one)-bundles and the linking number between boundaries and worldlines <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Mira: This means we can precisely determine gauge charges q(e) i and magnetic charges q(m) i based on topological invariants like I S squared F squared = q m <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Lev: That’s a very concrete calculation, but you have to make sure the underlying bundle structure is stable enough for those calculations to hold.
Kai: Finally, they identify topological transitions between D-branes and fluxes by analyzing conditions where the current is exact under specific differential maps like d three which leads to a zero class in E p squared <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Mira: This helps determine exactly when a Dp-brane transforms into fluxes, which they represent as that zero class in E D-p squared <ref:2404.03599#pg2>.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up the discussion on "A mini-course on Generalized Symmetries and a relation to Cobordisms and K-theory," it boils down to these major implications for the field.
Mira: The main implication is that continuous global symmetries in quantum gravity seem untenable because we need null classes in a cobordism theory, which is supported by black hole thermodynamics.
Lev: I think for experimentalists, this means we have to be very cautious about what kind of conserved charges we expect to see when building theories.
Kai: For theorists, it gives us a concrete mathematical structure—the framework connecting generalized symmetries to cobordism and K-theory—to study these charges systematically.
Mira: It connects the conserved charges from QFT directly to the geometric properties of spacetime, which is vital for string theory compactifications.
Lev: The paper provides a mathematical structure for understanding the conservation of gauged charges through null cobordism classes, which is really what we need to know about those interactions.
Kai: It’s a very structured approach that takes abstract symmetries and grounds them in concrete topological invariants.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds