A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder
summary
The gist
A quantum mechanical model involving interacting fermions without disorder that has the same low energy physics as the supersymmetric SYK model is considered…
In short
This study investigates a quantum mechanical model of interacting fermions that shares low-energy physics with supersymmetric SYK models. It focuses on 'melon diagrams' which dominate the theory, providing an explicit description of BPS states in certain limits. The analysis reveals a dramatic simplification when angular momentum is near its maximum, reducing the theory to a simple 1+1 dimensional CFT.
Key concepts
- Melonic Approximation
- This approximation applies when the number of fermions is large. It means that only 'melon diagrams' (a specific type of diagram) are important for describing the low-energy physics, as other non-melonic diagrams are suppressed by a logarithmic factor relative to melonic ones.
- BPS States
- These are special states in the model that have protected properties. The paper shows that BPS states concentrate at small values of an R charge and that there is an exponentially large number of these states with |R| = 1/6 when the angular momentum is large.
- Effective CFT2
- In the limit where SU(2) charge is very large, the model simplifies to an effective 1+1 dimensional Conformal Field Theory (CFT2). This simplification occurs because the theory becomes equivalent to a system with two decoupled sectors, which has a known spectrum described by specific mathematical formulas.
- SU(2) Charge Limit
- When the angular momentum approaches its maximum value ($J_3 o j^2/2$), the entire theory simplifies significantly. In this limit, it becomes equivalent to a 1+1 dimensional CFT with two decoupled sectors, allowing for an explicit description of all states.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder · Paper Radio
- Supersymmetric SYK models
- An SYK-Like Model Without Disorder
- Uncolored Random Tensors, Melon Diagrams, and the SYK Models
- Remarks on a melonic field theory with cubic interaction
- Holographic covering and the fortuity of black holes · Paper Radio
- Towards quantum black hole microstates
- Finite N black hole cohomologies
- Fortuity in SYK Models
- BPS Chaos
- Fortuity with a single matrix
- Classical 6j-symbols and the tetrahedron
- Asymptotics of classical spin networks
- Phases of N=2 Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models
- Correlators in the N=2 Supersymmetric SYK Model
- Supersymmetric SYK Model: Bi-local Collective Superfield/Supermatrix Formulation
- N=2 SYK model in the superspace formalism
- Fermionic Localization of the Schwarzian Theory
- Comments on the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model
- Comments on magnetic black holes
- Applied Conformal Field Theory
The paper
A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder · Read on arXiv
Anna Biggs, Loki L. Lin, Juan Maldacena
Jadwin Hall, Princeton University · Leinweber Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Michigan · Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton University
We consider a quantum mechanical model involving interacting fermions without disorder that has the same low energy physics as the supersymmetric SYK model. The model is SU(2) invariant, and the supercharge involves the SU(2) 3j symbol. We analyze various solvable corners, conceptually explain why it has a melonic expansion, and perform an exact diagonalization for small values of N. Expanded around the states with maximal angular momentum, the model is approximated by a two dimensional CFT. The BPS states have a simple description in that regime.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A quantum mechanical model involving interacting fermions without disorder that has the same low energy physics as the supersymmetric SYK model is considered, and this study analyzes various solvable corners and regimes of this model Model Definition and Symmetries The model involves N = 2j + 1 complex fermions in a single spin j representation of SU(2) with an SU(2) invariant interaction constructed from the Wigner 3j symbol.
Kai: The simplest version of the model has N = 2 supersymmetry with supercharges of the schematic form Q ∼ (3j symbol)ψ and Q† ∼ (3j symbol)(ψ†).
Mira: In the melonic approximation, and for SU(2) singlet observables, the theory becomes the same as the N = 2 supersymmetric SYK model studied in
1: <ref:2601.08908#pg4> Melonic Approximation and Low Energy Physics The model has a melonic approximation when the number of fermions is large, and it also possesses a nearly conformal region in the infrared The simplest melonic diagram gives the same result as one would have obtained in SYK after averaging over couplings <ref:2601.08908#pg8> Furthermore, if we restrict to melon diagrams we get the same expressions as for the N = 2 supersymmetric SYK model in
1: <ref:2601.08908#pg8> However, non-melonic diagrams are suppressed by a factor of (log j)/j relative to the melonic diagrams.
Kai: BPS States and Large SU(2) Charge Limit The BPS states come with various values of the SU(2) charges, and when the angular momentum is near the maximal value, of order J3 ∼ j 2/2, the whole theory simplifies and becomes equivalent to a 1+1 dimensional CFT with two decoupled sectors <ref:2601.08908#pg6> In this limit, for large SU(2) charge, the model becomes an effective CFT2 <ref:2601.08908#pg8> The two states with maximal angular momentum (60) have R charges R = ±1/6 and J3 = j(j + 1)/2 <ref:2601.08908#pg6> Exact Diagonalization and CFT Description Exact diagonalization for small values of j suggests that the BPS states are concentrated at small values of the R charge, and the number of BPS states with R = 1/6 is exponentially large in j <ref:2601.08908#pg8> In the limit of large SU(2) charge, we find an explicit description of all states, including the BPS states, in this limit <ref:2601.08908#pg8> The spectrum in the CFT approximation is given by (71), and each of those states can be tensored with any state of the H± Hilbert space, all of which will have the same energy <ref:2601.08908#pg27> Large U(1)R Charge and Emergent CFT2 In this section, we discuss some features of the large R charge states, which are relatively simple since there is a small number of states for extreme values of the R charge <ref:2601.08908#pg17> The two states with maximal angular momentum (60) correspond to the vacuum for the ϕ±-bosons and the zero energy states of the ϕz boson, which have no ϕz-oscillators excited and have no other excitations <ref:2601.08908#pg21> Counting Degrees of Freedom The presence of this extra degree of freedom can be understood by considering the solution of the constraint equations depicted in figure 17 <ref:2601.08908#pg42> This redundancy leads to a rotational degree of freedom in the solution space of possible arrow configurations, accounting for the √j enhancement discussed in section 3.1 <ref:2601.08908#pg41> Energy Spectrum Analysis The energy of the state with maximal angular momentum for a given R charge is E(R)/J = 2j + 1/3 - (n + 1) = 18R - 2j - 1/6, for n ≤ (j − 1)/2 or j 6 ≤ R The energy gap between the states approaches the Schwarzian prediction as j increases, but the convergence is not as good as in N = 2 SYK <ref:2601.08908#pg28> The model has a global SU(2) symmetry, and we expect some low action degrees of freedom from this SU(2) symmetry <ref:2601.08908#pg16> One simple generalization would be a model with different types of fermions, each with a different angular momentum <ref:2601.08908#pg32> Another simple generalization would be to change the group from SU(2) to SU(N)> Exact Diagonalization Details We performed an exact diagonalization up to j = 11, and we found a small amount of additional degeneracy in the energy spectrum at fixed R, occurring at the energies and R-charges in (58) <ref:2601.08908#pg25> The numerical results display some features that we have not explained <ref:2601.08908#pg31> Discussion on Sporadic States We have checked that these sporadic states do not violate the index calculated in section 2.2 <ref:2601.08908#pg37> One would therefore like to understand whether this feature persists for larger values of j > The authors consider a quantum mechanical model with interacting fermions without disorder that has the same low energy physics as the supersymmetric SYK model, and they find that melon diagrams dominate and provide an explicit description of BPS states in certain limits The study reveals a dramatic simplification in the corner where angular momentum is near its maximum, reducing the theory to a simple 1+1 dimensional CFT <ref:2601.08908#pg8> Possible Generalizations One simple generalization would be a model with different types of fermions, each with a different angular momentum <ref:2601.08908#pg32> Another simple generalization would be to change the group from SU(2) to SU(N)> The paper also suggests that nonsupersymmetric models where the Hamiltonian is given by H = J X m O†j3mOj3m, Oj3m = j1 j2 j3 m1 m2 m ψj1m1ψj2m2 <ref:2601.08908#pg9> are expected to give rise to melonic diagrams <ref:2601.08908#pg10> The authors also expect that the effective action is not simply the SU(2) Casimir <ref:2601.08908#pg31> Acknowledgments We would like to thank K.
Paper summary: Kai: So, we’re looking at this paper called "A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder" and the authors are trying to build a quantum mechanical model with interacting fermions that has the same low energy physics as the supersymmetric SYK model Kai. They are focusing on an SU(two) invariant interaction built from the three-j symbol Kai <ref:2601.08908#pg1>.
Mira: Their main thesis is that by using a melonic approximation and looking at certain solvable corners, they can explain why this model expands in a melonic way even without disorder Mira. It’s motivated because this new mechanism for getting melonic dominance is different from tensor models they studied before Mira.
Lev: What matters is that the paper suggests this approach might be better for exact numerical diagonalization than those tensor models, which would be good for testing the theory on real hardware or at least in simulation Lev. They are specifically looking at how the supercharge involves the three-j symbol Lev.
Kai: And they find that when you expand around states with maximal angular momentum, this model is approximated by a two dimensional conformal field theory Kai. This means that in that specific regime, the complexity drops down to something much simpler, which is a CFT Kai.
Mira: The paper also discusses BPS states and how they have a simple description in that large SU(two) charge limit where it becomes an effective CFT two dimensions Mira <ref:2601.08908#pg1,have a simple description in that>. They mention specific states with maximal angular momentum around j six zero having R charges of plus one over six and three-j symbols of j plus one over two times j equals the values they are looking at Mira.
Lev: And they do perform exact diagonalization for small numbers of fermions, like up to N equals eleven, and they found a small amount of additional degeneracy in the energy spectrum at fixed R charges Lev. This is where things get interesting because it shows some features that were not fully explained by their previous work Lev.
Kai: So, in short, this paper introduces a model that shares physics with SYK but uses different tools—melonic diagrams—to find solvable limits and exact descriptions of its states in certain regimes Kai. It’s about finding structure in a complicated quantum system Kai.
Conclusion: Mira: So, looking at "A melonic quantum mechanical model without disorder," the core idea is that they found a way to use specific mathematical tools—the three-j symbol interactions—to map a complex interacting fermion system onto the well-studied supersymmetric SYK model Mira.
Kai: The implication for us is that this suggests there might be other ways to find solvable limits in these types of quantum models, especially when you’re looking at things like BPS states and large spin values Kai. It opens up new avenues for finding structure where we previously only saw a connection to disorder Kai.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, the fact that they suggest this model is more amenable to exact numerical diagonalization is a practical point because it means we might be able to test these ideas on real hardware much sooner than with other models Lev. It lowers the barrier for testing these theoretical predictions Lev.
Kai: Overall, what this paper does is show that even without disorder, you can have rich low energy physics by focusing on specific diagrammatic expansions, and it gives us a concrete picture of how the theory behaves in highly symmetric limits like large SU(two) charge Kai <ref:2601.08908#pg1>. It’s about finding structure in complexity Kai.
Mira: Exactly. The authors are showing that the melonic expansion is not just an approximation, but a genuine feature of this model, which means we should keep looking at these specific diagrammatic structures when trying to solve these kinds of quantum problems Mira.
More episodes
- 2606.30117-Gravitational Duals from Equations of State II: Large Hierarchies and False Vacua
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2603.06575-An ode to instantons
- 2607.09594-Massless fermionic current of Schwinger pairs in 3D de Sitter spacetime
- 2508.13283-Algebraic traversable wormholes
- 2509.07838-Multi-Centered Black Hole Index from a Superconformal Quiver Index
- 2512.16596-Trace anomaly for a conformal 2D vector field model
- 2605.03155-Flat Space Physics from AdS Actions
- 2606.02707-Gravitational index, black hole saddle degeneracy, and one-form symmetry
- 2606.24008-General Lagrangian formulations for mixed-antisymmetric tensor fields on flat backgrounds