World average charged-current inclusive neutrino cross section from 6 to 200 GeV

summary

The gist

The paper presents a world average inclusive charged-current neutrino cross section energy-dependence slope for neutrinos and anti-neutrinos across a broad energy range…

In short

The study determined world average inclusive charged-current neutrino cross section energy dependence slope ($\sigma/E$) across a broad energy range (6 to 200 GeV). By synthesizing high-energy and low-energy experimental data, the results show a slight deviation from a constant value for both neutrinos and anti-neutrinos. This precision data helps tune neutrino event generators and constrains fundamental neutrino properties.

Key concepts

Inclusive Charged-Current Cross Section Slope ($\sigma/E$)
This term describes how the probability of a charged-current interaction changes as the energy of the incoming neutrino increases. It is a key observable used to constrain structure functions and electroweak parameters in particle physics, helping scientists understand how neutrinos interact with matter at different energies.
High Energy World Average Determination
This involves applying Particle Data Group methods to establish a consistent average slope for the cross section at higher neutrino energies (30-200 GeV). These high-energy values serve as an anchor, and the low-energy data is often anchored to these high values for consistency checks.
Low Energy Extension
This process extends the measurement of $\sigma/E$ down to lower energy ranges (6-30 GeV) using specific low-energy techniques. This extension provides crucial constraints on the behavior of the cross section at lower energies, revealing potential deviations from a simple constant trend.
Model Tuning and Future Constraints
The precise $\sigma/E$ data is used to fine-tune models used in neutrino event generators, showing that these generators' inclusive DIS slope becomes nearly constant at high energy. This analysis also suggests a possible downward trend for the anti-neutrino cross section as energy decreases.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

World average charged-current inclusive neutrino cross section from 6 to 200 GeV · Read on arXiv

Richard Gran

University of Minnesota Duluth

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "World average charged-current inclusive neutrino cross section from 6 to 200 GeV".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a world average inclusive charged-current neutrino cross section energy-dependence slope for neutrinos and anti-neutrinos across a broad energy range, which is crucial for constraining foundational neutrino quantities like structure functions and electroweak parameters High Energy World Average Determination The methods of the Particle Data Group are applied to produce a world average inclusive, charged-current, muon neutrino cross section energy-dependence slope sigma/E The values obtained for the range 30 < Eν < 200 GeV are (0.677 ± 0.013) and (0.335 ± 0.007) ×10−38 cm2/GeV for neutrino and anti-neutrino, respectively These values are practically identical to those in common use The second world average is obtained for 6 < E < 30 GeV primarily from three experiments that rely on the high energy value as the anchor for the low-E technique Experimental Data Synthesis and Consistency Checks The synthesis of low energy data is new, incorporating additional experimental values and treating correlated beamline uncertainties explicitly The final high energy fits yield (0.677 ± 0.012) cm2/GeV for the neutrino case and (0.335 ± 0.008) cm2/GeV for anti-neutrino Consistency is evaluated by showing that seven of the eighteen measurements are beyond one standard deviation, and a second metric of consistency shows a chi-squared of 67.8 for the neutrino case Low Energy Extension and Model Interpretation The low energy extension is obtained for 6 < E < 30 GeV using the low-E method, resulting in values of (0.698 ± 0.018) and (0.316 ± 0.012) ×10−38 cm2/GeV An interpretation is provided in the context of the Bodek Yang 2000 model and two configurations of the GENIE neutrino event generators The low-E data suggests a small deviation from the high energy constant sigma/E Model Tuning and Future Constraints The precision data for sigma/E is used to design and tune models used in neutrino event generators, illustrating that the generator’s inclusive DIS sigma/E becomes nearly constant at high energy The GENIE v2 case was tuned so that the high energy cross section would match the neutrino world average The anti-neutrino cross section may not increase as fast as the energy decreases or could even decrease, suggesting a real downward trend in the cross section Low Energy World Average Results The method has been extended to improve the flux constraints of lower energy, wide-band beams when the energy spectrum sufficiently overlaps the higher energy results used in the world average The final neutrino result is sigma/E = (0.698 ± 0.016) ×10−38 cm2/GeV using data in the range 6 to 30 GeV that was not already used in the high energy world average The results are 3% higher than the high energy result, demonstrating that sigma/E likely deviates from a constant in the neutrino case, though close enough that sigma/E remaining constant would not be ruled out by even a 2σ standard The final combination of low-E experiments results in (0.698 ± 0.016)×10−38 cm2/GeV using data in the range 6 to 30 GeV that was not already used in the high energy world average The value for the inclusive CC cross section slope sigma/E is known all the way down to 10 GeV to better than 3% (4%) and consistent with a deviation high (low) for neutrino (anti-neutrino) cases The results are also consistent with the null hypothesis that a single constant is adequate all the way to 10 GeV The compatibility of these results leads to a higher precision than the individual measurements and there is no apparent tension among the experiments Acknowledgements The author thanks Stephen Dolan, Anežka Klustová, Jorge Morfin, Laura Munteanu, Donna Naples, Julia Tena Vidal, Clarence Wret, Sam Zeller, and the CERN Archives and Library staff The author was supported by a Fermilab URA visiting scholar fellowship and a National Science Foundation grant number 2310154 References

8: G.

Kai: Zweig, An SU(3) model for strong interaction symmetry and its breaking.

Mira: Version 2, in Developments in the quark theory of hadrons.

Kai: Vol.

Paper summary: Mira: So looking at the whole paper, "World average charged-current inclusive neutrino cross section from six to two hundred GeV," it’s about establishing a definitive world average for that slope, sigma over E nu, across a wide energy band <ref:2611.01435#pg1,World average charged-current inclusive neutrino cross section from 6 to 200>. The authors show how their combination of high and low energy data leads to two different results depending on whether you look at neutrinos or anti-neutrinos.

Kai: And the main point is that while the neutrino result shows some deviation from a constant slope, it’s not so big that we rule out the idea of a single constant value at two sigma level. The anti-neutrino result suggests something else—a downward trend.

Lev: From an engineering view, this paper confirms that tuning our event generators using these precise measurements is necessary to get accurate predictions for neutrino experiments, especially when we look at lower energies where the cross section starts showing those trends.

Kai: The authors are doing a lot of work here in combining their experiments and treating uncertainties explicitly. They provide a comprehensive literature review of all these measurements and how they apply to things like nucleon structure functions and electroweak parameters such as sin two theta W.

Mira: That’s the big picture, right? It shows how these cross section measurements have multiple uses, not just for neutrino physics itself, but also for constraining other areas of particle physics. They are using sigma over E nu to pin down other quantities like the Bjorken scaling variable x bj and inelasticity y or the square of four momentum transfer Q squared.

Lev: The authors also flag that their method has limitations, specifically that when beam experiments don't have good in-situ absolute flux constraints, they need an external normalization value from experiments with a sigma over E nu to get those structure function measurements. That’s a practical constraint for any future experiment design.

Kai: So the paper confirms that down to ten gigaelectron volts, the cross section slope is known better than three percent or four percent and it’s consistent with either a high or low deviation for both neutrino and anti-neutrino cases. It shows compatibility with the idea that a single constant is sufficient all the way to ten gigaelectron volts.

Mira: Ultimately, this work shows that even when we look at the lower energy range of six to thirty gigaelectron volts, we get results that are higher for neutrinos and lower for anti-neutrinos. This confirms there might be a real downward trend in the cross section as energy decreases, though it’s not strong enough to rule out a constant slope.

Lev: So what this means for the future is that our models need to incorporate those subtle trends we see across different energy scales when we design detectors and plan next generation experiments. They need to account for that evolution in the interaction strength.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we’ve been looking at how the authors figured out this world average charged-current neutrino cross section slope across a huge energy range, from six gigaelectron volts all the way up to two hundred gigaelectron volts.

Mira: And what they actually did was synthesize data from different experiments, trying to make sure the low energy measurements fit with the high energy ones.

Lev: The authors used their own method for combining those low energy results, and they found these specific numbers for both neutrinos and anti-neutrinos.

Kai: They ended up with a neutrino slope of about zero point six nine eight times ten to negative thirty eight squared per gigaelectron volt, which is three percent higher than the high energy value they found earlier.

Mira: That slight difference is what they call a deviation from a constant, so it means the cross section isn't perfectly flat across all those energies.

Lev: From an error correction point of view, that small deviation is important because if we assume it’s perfectly flat, our predictions for lower energy experiments will be off by exactly that three percent.

Kai: It means they also found a similar but slightly different slope for anti-neutrinos, around zero point three one six times ten to negative thirty eight squared per gigaelectron volt.

Mira: The authors suggest this isn't necessarily a big problem because the deviation is only two sigma away from assuming a flat constant across the whole range.

Lev: But it does mean that when you design your detectors, you can't just use one number for everything; you have to account for that energy-dependent behavior.

Kai: So, in short, this paper tells us the slope isn't perfectly constant, and we need to use these combined results when we build our next generation of neutrino experiments.

More episodes

← Home