Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K 1(1270) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays
summary
The gist
Using K1(1270) → Kππ amplitude models constrained by the charmed-meson semileptonic decays D+(0) → K−π+π0(−)e+νe…
In short
The study estimates the up-down asymmetry in B+ → K+π++γ using K1(1270) amplitudes, constrained by charmed-meson decays. Model-dependent estimates show significant variation but generally fall below measured values when assuming a specific parameter ($\lambda\gamma=1$). The analysis explores how including excited states like K1(1400) can reduce this discrepancy with Standard Model predictions.
Key concepts
- Up-Down Asymmetry (Aud)
- This asymmetry measures the polarization of the photon emitted during B+ decays. Observing a non-zero value is a sensitive test for physics beyond the Standard Model, as it probes how quarks interact in these processes.
- Hadronic Factor (Hud)
- Hud is a complex factor needed to convert the measured up-down asymmetry into a quantity related to the internal structure of the K1(1270) particle. Determining Hud precisely requires detailed knowledge of its internal decay amplitudes and phases.
- K1(1400) Contribution
- The paper investigates whether contributions from excited kaon states, such as K1(1400), are necessary. Including these heavier states can significantly alter the calculated asymmetry, potentially resolving tensions between theoretical predictions and experimental measurements.
- Charmed-Meson Decays Constraint
- Using data from semileptonic decays of D+(0) mesons helps constrain the model for K1(1270). This external constraint improves the precision of the estimate for Hud, making it less dependent on purely theoretical assumptions about its internal structure.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K 1(1270) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays · Paper Radio
- Observation of photon polarization in the b to s gamma transition
- Mixing-induced CP Asymmetries in Radiative B Decays in and beyond the Standard Model
- Future prospects for the determination of the Wilson coefficient C 7 gamma
- Constraints on new physics from radiative B decays
- Novel method to reliably determine the photon helicity in b to s gamma
- Measuring the Photon Helicity in Radiative B Decays
- Photon polarization in radiative B decays
- Determining the photon polarization of the b --> s gamma using the B --> K1(1270) gamma --> (K pi pi) gamma decay
- The strong decays of K1 resonances
- Reexamining the photon polarization in B to K pi pi gamma
- Up-down Asymmetries and Angular Distributions in D to K 1(to K pi pi)+ nu
- Angular analysis of B -> J/psi K1: towards a model independent determination of the photon polarization with B-> K1 gamma
- First Measurement of the Decay Dynamics in the Semileptonic Transition of the D+(0) into the Axial-vector Meson K 1(1270)
- Covariant tensor formalism for partial wave analyses of psi decay to mesons
- Measurement of in B 0 to D(*) h 0 with D to K S 0 pi+ pi- decays by a combined time-dependent Dalitz plot analysis of BaBar and Belle data
- Study of the K+ pi+ pi- Final State in B+ -> J/psi K+ pi+ pi- and B+ -> psi-prime K+ pi+ pi-
The paper
Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K 1(1270) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays · Read on arXiv
Yijia Zeng, Hailong Ma
Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K 1(1270) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Using K1(1270) → Kππ amplitude models constrained by the charmed-meson semileptonic decays D+(0) → K−π+π0(−)e+νe, we present a model-dependent estimate of the up-down asymmetry observed in B+ → K+π++γ in the mass region MK+π++ ∈
1.1, 1.3: GeV/c2.
Kai: Estimates based on an isolated K1(1270) show significant model dependence, but systematically lie below the measured asymmetry H¯ud = (0.092 ± 0.023) when assuming λγ = 1.
Mira: Measurement Context and Challenges The observation of photon polarization in b → sγ transitions through the up-down asymmetry Aud is a sensitive test of the Standard Model and possible new physics.
Kai: A nonzero A¯ud = (0.069 ± 0.017) is observed in the mass region MK+π++ ∈
1.1, 1.3: GeV/c2 dominated by K1(1270).
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at the paper "Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K one(one thousand two hundred seventy) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays" <ref:2611.03035#pg1,Study of the up-down asymmetry in B>. This paper is really focused on how they measure a specific asymmetry in B plus to K plus pi plus pi minus gamma decays. They use the K one twelve hundred and seventy resonance as the main model for this measurement.
Mira: Exactly, and it's important because they link that measurement to something else, which is those charmed meson semileptonic decays, specifically D plus zero to kaon minus pi plus pi zero minus electron plus neutrino. They're trying to use that constraint from the D decay data to get a better handle on the model dependence of their estimate for the up-down asymmetry.
Lev: From my side, it’s interesting because this is where the real experimental challenge lies, figuring out how to isolate that photon polarization signal from all the other stuff happening in those decays. It sets up a very specific problem about what you need to know about the hadronic current.
Kai: Right, so it's not just a measurement of an asymmetry, it's trying to connect it robustly to known processes. The authors are essentially testing how well their model can predict the observed asymmetry when they use that constraint from the D decay data.
Mira: And what they find is that relying on just one isolated K one twelve hundred and seventy resonance makes a big difference in their results, showing significant model dependence. That's a key takeaway for understanding what we're seeing in B plus to K plus pi plus pi minus gamma decays.
Lev: If you were to try and run this on real hardware, you’d need a very precise knowledge of those intermediate amplitudes they mention, like the rho seven hundred seventy or the K star eight hundred ninety two. Those details are critical for error budgeting when you're actually trying to build an experiment that measures this effect.
Kai: So the main point here is that while they can estimate this asymmetry, it still depends a lot on how much they assume about those intermediate states, which is a bit worrying for precision. This leads us into what the paper actually does next.
The paper's summary: Mira: The summary of "Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K one(one thousand two hundred seventy) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays" boils down to this: they are estimating the up-down asymmetry observed in B plus to K plus pi plus pi minus gamma within a mass region of one point one GeV/c squared to one point three GeV/c squared <ref:2611.03035#pg1,Study of the up-down asymmetry in B>.
Kai: They use the K one twelve hundred and seventy resonance as their primary model, but they don't just use that; they constrain it using the charmed meson semileptonic decays from D plus zero to kaon minus pi plus pi zero minus electron plus neutrino. This constraint is meant to reduce the model dependence of their estimate for that asymmetry.
Lev: Essentially, the paper is saying, "We can calculate an estimate for the up-down asymmetry observed in B plus to K plus pi plus pi minus gamma in that mass region using K one twelve hundred and seventy amplitudes," but they immediately flag that this calculation is very dependent on their choices for those amplitudes.
Mira: They show that when they use just the isolated K one twelve hundred and seventy, their estimate systematically falls below what they actually measured for the up-down asymmetry, which is zero point nine two plus or minus zero point twenty three when assuming lambda gamma equals one.
Kai: That's a direct tension with the measurement. So what they explore next is how they can fix this issue, and that involves looking at other things interfering with the K one twelve hundred and seventy, specifically the K one fourteen hundred tail.
Lev: They introduce a revised hadronic current, which includes contributions from both the K one twelve hundred and seventy resonance and an interference term involving the K one fourteen hundred resonance. This is a direct attempt to model that missing part of what's going on in the decay process.
Mira: And they do a systematic scan over the relative phase of that interference term and how much weight they give to that K one fourteen hundred contribution, which is called the fit fraction FFK1 four hundred and forty zero zero. This is their way of figuring out if including that tail can significantly reduce the tension with what we know.
Kai: So, in short, this paper is about making that estimate more robust by incorporating constraints from D decays and by exploring excited K states like K one fourteen hundred to see if those extra pieces help close the gap.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests a couple of major improvements to address those issues with model dependence. First, they are using the constraint from the charmed meson semileptonic decays to make a more informed estimate of that hadronic factor Hud.
Mira: That’s crucial because Hud is hard to pin down phenomenologically on its own. They claim that by using the hadronic current constrained by those D plus zero to kaon minus pi plus pi zero minus electron plus neutrino decays, they can estimate it with higher precision than just using a purely phenomenological amplitude model.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that sounds like it would require a very tight constraint on the input parameters from those D decay data. If those constraints are loose, the resulting uncertainty in Hud won't be as small as they hope.
Kai: And second, they look at incorporating excited kaon states like K one fourteen hundred to reduce the tension between their calculated H bar ud and what they measure. They revise that hadronic current to include a term with the K one fourteen hundred resonance, which is proportional to its coupling and phase.
Mira: They perform a two dimensional scan over the relative phase of that contribution and how much of that K one fourteen hundred state they include, which is called the fit fraction FFK1 four hundred and forty zero zero. This lets them see if a sizable K one fourteen hundred tail can really help pull their estimate down towards the measured up-down asymmetry.
Lev: If you were to implement this on a real system, you’d need a way to measure that relative phase and the fit fraction with high fidelity, which is not trivial when dealing with these complex resonances like the K star eight hundred ninety two.
Kai: So, it’s a move toward robustness: using external data for constraint, and then systematically scanning over new physics components to see if they close the gap with reality.
Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up on "Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi+ pi-gamma using K one(one thousand two hundred seventy) amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays", they show that relying solely on the K one twelve hundred and seventy resonance leads to a model-dependent estimate for the up-down asymmetry <ref:2611.03035#pg1,Study of the up-down asymmetry in B>.
Lev: They show that this estimate is systematically below the measured value, which is zero point nine two plus or minus zero point twenty three when assuming lambda gamma equals one.
Kai: The improvements they propose involve using those semileptonic D decays to constrain the hadronic factor Hud and scanning over the phase and fit fraction of the K one fourteen hundred contribution to see if that reduces the tension with what they measure.
Mira: It gives us a better picture of the physics there, but it also shows that we still have some loose assumptions about these complex intermediate states that we need to nail down with even tighter constraints from other measurements.
Lev: For me, it's about the engineering challenge: getting a measurement that’s precise enough to even test if those K one fourteen hundred contributions are significant.
Kai: It’s definitely a step toward better photon polarization testing in these B plus decays, moving us past just having a single resonance model.
Mira: It’s a practical path forward, but we still need to ensure those experimental measurements of the phases are as accurate as possible before we can fully trust these new estimates.
Lev: Exactly, and that leads us right into how you actually measure those relative phases and fractions in the lab without introducing more systematic errors than you’re trying to eliminate.
More episodes
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2512.21290-Model-independent ZH production cross section at FCC-ee
- 2610.21982-First Observation of the Radiative Decay D 0 to gamma omega
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2512.08065-Searches for Light Dark Matter and Evidence of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering of Solar Neutrinos with the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Experiment
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2508.18022-Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider
- 2512.23992-Prospect for measurement of CP-violating parameters of B s 0 to phi gamma at the Tera Z factory