Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L 0 pi+
summary
The gist
The paper presents the first amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement of D+ → K0SK0Lπ+ decay using BESIII data…
In short
This study performed an amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement for D+ → K0SK0Lπ+ decay using BESIII data. The key finding is a ratio RϕKK of 0.611±0.023, which suggests significant isospin symmetry breaking in phi meson couplings compared to theoretical expectations, highlighting a tension with previous world averages.
Key concepts
- RϕKK
- This ratio compares the decay rates of the phi meson into different kaon pairs: B(ϕ → K0SK0L) divided by B(ϕ → K+K-). A value of unity would indicate perfect isospin symmetry, but the measured value suggests a deviation, pointing to isospin symmetry breaking in how phi mesons couple to neutral versus charged kaon pairs.
- Amplitude Analysis
- The researchers used an isobar model with covariant tensors to describe the total decay amplitude. They fit this model using maximum-likelihood methods, including various resonances like ϕπ+, K0LK*(892)+, and K0SK*(892)+, to determine the underlying physics of the decay process.
- Isospin Symmetry Breaking
- Isospin symmetry is a theoretical concept suggesting that particles with similar quark content should have nearly identical properties. The paper investigates how this symmetry breaks in phi meson couplings by comparing measurements to predictions. The measured RϕKK value challenges simple theoretical expectations under this symmetry.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L 0 pi+ · Paper Radio
- Amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement of the decay D 0 to K 0 S pi 0 pi 0
The paper
Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L 0 pi+ · Read on arXiv
M. Ablikim, M. N. Achasov, P. Adlarson, X. C. Ai, C. S. Akondi A., R. Aliberti A., A. Amoroso A., Q An, Ω H An, β Bai B., Δ Bakina O., Е R Bao H., X L Bao M, M Barbagiovanni M, V Batozskaya V, K Begzsuren K, N Berger N, M Berlowski M, M B Bertani M. A., д D Bettoni D. A., Л F Bianchi F. A., К E Bianco E. A., A Bortone A. C., I Boyko I, R Briere R, A Brueggemann A, D Cabiati D. C., H Cai H M, Ω X Cai X Y Chai J F Chang T T Chang G R Che Y Z Che C H Chen Chao Chen G Chen H S Chen H Y Chen M L Chen S J Chen S M Chen T Chen W. , X R chen, X T chen, X Y chen Y B chen Y Q chen Z K chen J Cheng L N Cheng S K Choi X Chu G Cibinetto F Cossio J Cottee-Meldrum H L Dai J P Dai X C Dai A Dbeyssi R E de Boer D Dedovich C Q Deng Z Y Deng A Denig I Denisenko M Destefanis F De Mori E Di Fiore X X Ding Y Ding Yi Ding J Dong L Y Dong M Y Dong X Dong Z J Dong M C Du S X Du Shaoxu Du X L Du Y Q Du Y. , Y. H Fan J Fang Jin Fang S S Fang W X Fang Y Q Fang L Fava F Feldbauer G Felici C Q Feng J H Feng L Feng Q X Feng Y T Feng M Fritsch C D Fu J L Fu Y W Fu H Gao Xu Gao Y N Gao Y. , Y. Y Gao Yunong Gao Z Gao S Garbolino I Garzia L Ge P T Ge Z W Ge C Geng E M Gersabeck A Gilman K Goetzen J Gollub J B Gong L Gong W X Gong W Gradl S Gramigna M Greco M D Gu M H Gu C Y Guan A Q Guo H Guo J N Guo L B Guo M J Guo R P Guo X. , X. Y. Li, X Z Li Y Li20 Y H Li48 Y B Li85 Y C Li66, Y G Li71, Y P Li38 Z H Li42 Z L Ji66 Z L Ji89 Z X Ji48, C Liang C. C Lin D X Lin T Lin B J Liu B X Liu F H Liu Feng Liu G M Liu H. J. Lu X L Lu Y Lu Y P Lu Q M Li Q X Li R Li18 S Li 89 S X Li 89 S Y Li 89 Shanshan Li i T. L i55 T. Y. li W D li1 W G li1 X H li79 X K li51 X L li55, X Y. Zhuang M Zhuge J H Zou J Zu, BESIII Collaboration
Institute of High Energy Physics · Beihang University · Bochum Ruhr-University · Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics SB RAS (BINP) · Carnegie Mellon University · Central China Normal University · Central South University · Chengdu University of Technology · Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz · Е Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
We present the first amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement of D+ to K S 0K L 0π+ decay. The analysis uses a dataset corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb-1, which was recorded at a center-of-mass energy 3.773 GeV by the BESIII detector. The measured branching fraction is B(D+ to K S 0K L 0π+)=(5.780 plus or minus0.085 plus or minus 0.052) times10-3, where the first uncertainty is statistical and the second is systematic. Using the known value of B (D+ to ϕπ+,,ϕ to K+K-), we determine the relative branching fraction between ϕ to K S 0K L 0 and ϕ to K+K- to be B(D+ to ϕπ+, ϕ to K S 0K L 0)/B(D+ to ϕπ+, ϕ to K+K-)= 0.628 plus or minus0.022 plus or minus 0.015 plus or minus0.017, where the third uncertainty is related to B(D+ to ϕπ+, ϕ to K+K-). This result is significantly lower than the previous world average and is consistent with the isospin expectation for the ϕ meson's coupling to charged and neutral kaon pairs.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L 0 pi+".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents the first amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement of D+ → K0SK0Lπ+ decay using BESIII data, which is significant because it provides a crucial estimate for the ratio RϕKK, addressing a long-standing puzzle regarding isospin symmetry breaking in phi meson couplings Measurement of the Branching Fraction The measured branching fraction for the decay D+ → K0SK0Lπ+ is B(D+ → K0SK0Lπ+) = (5.780 ± 0.085 ± 0.052) × 10−3 The branching fraction is determined using a dataset corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb−1 recorded at a center-of-mass energy of 3.773 GeV by the BESIII detector Determination of the Ratio RϕKK Using the known value of B(D+ → ϕπ+, ϕ → K+K−), the relative branching fraction between ϕ → K0SK0L and ϕ → K+K− is determined to be B(D+ → ϕπ+, ϕ → K0SK0L)/B(D+ → ϕπ+,ϕ→K+K−) = 0.628 ± 0.022 ± 0.015 ± 0.017 This result is significantly lower than the previous world average and is consistent with the isospin expectation for the ϕ meson’s coupling to charged and neutral kaon pairs Probing Isospin Symmetry Breaking The ratio RϕKK, defined as B(ϕ → K0SK0L)/B(ϕ → K+K−), indicates significant isospinsymmetry breaking
1: Under isospin symmetry RϕKK is naively unity, but this prediction must be corrected for the difference between the K+ and K0 masses Even after considering additional sources of isospin-breaking, theoretical predictions remain inconsistent with measurements
2–6: Amplitude Analysis Details The analysis uses an isobar model formulated with covariant tensors to describe the total amplitude M = Pρne iφn An, which is a coherent sum over the decay amplitudes An of n intermediate processes A maximum-likelihood fit determines the parameters of this amplitude model, and various resonances such as ϕπ+, K0LK∗(892)+, and K0SK∗(892)+ are added to the fit one at a time The only significant contributions found are from ϕπ+, K0LK∗(892)+, and K0SK∗(892)+ Comparison with Existing Results The resulting RϕKK average in charm decays is consistent with that reported in Ref.
17: but exhibits a significant tension of 3.4 standard deviations with the current world-average of direct measurements The result disagrees by 2.5 standard deviations with the RϕKK result obtained by the PDG from a fit to ϕ branching fraction and partial width measurements
1: Determination of B(ϕ → K+K−) By combining the charm-based result for RϕKK with the average of previous results for B(ϕ → π+π−π0)/B(ϕ → K+K−) = 0.228 ± 0.014
18, 19: and the total BF of other known ϕ decays, unitarity is used to find B(ϕ → K+K−) = (53.54 ± 0.76)% This value is significantly higher than the values measured in e+e− annihilation experiments
1: Constraints on Dynamical Models Measurements of the branching fraction for D+ → K0SK0Lπ+ provide constraints on dynamical models of charmed meson decays The amplitude analysis also probes D+ → K¯ 0S,LK∗(892)+, K∗(892)+ → K0L,Sπ+ decays Tagging and Selection Criteria A tagging technique is used to measure the absolute BF and select high-purity samples for amplitude analyses The selection involves a double-tag (DT) sample where the D+ meson is reconstructed through the signal-decay mode K0SK0Lπ+ and an associated D− through one of the tag modes The final-state particle fourmomenta are constrained by a kinematic fit, which must converge and satisfy χ2 < 100 Total Uncertainty Estimation The total uncertainty in the BF measurement is determined by adding all contributions in quadrature, resulting in a total uncertainty of 0.9% The dominant sources of systematic uncertainty arise from varying the background model and Blatt-Weisskopf barrier factors Final Results Summary The BF measurement yields B(D+ → K0SK0Lπ+) = (5.780 ± 0.085 ± 0.052) × 10−3 The average RϕKK in charm decays is obtained as 0.611±0.023, which is consistent with the average of previous results Comparison of Theoretical Predictions Figure 5 shows RϕKK as a function of the ϕK+K− and ϕK0K¯ 0 coupling ratio g+/g0, where the colored bands show ±1σ intervals The measurement of RϕKK from charm decay yields a g+/g0 consistent with unity This is in contrast to the PDG average and fit values which imply a g+/g0 significantly less than 1 Future Directions A future comprehensive re-evaluation of all ϕ decay BFs by the PDG, including the CMD2, CMD3 and BESIII results, would be most welcome Further measurements of the ϕ meson branching fractions are required to understand this difference The phase difference between the amplitudes for D+ → K0SK∗(892)+ and D+ → K0LK∗(892)+ is measured to be nearly π radians, consistent with the theoretical expectation under CP conservation Reference List
1: S.
Mira: Navas et al.
Kai: (Particle Data Group), Phys.
Title and authors: Kai: We started by looking at the full title of this paper: "Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L zero pi+". It’s a detailed study using BESIII data.
Mira: It really is an amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement for the decay D+ → K0SK0Lπ+. The main thing they want to convey is how this specific measurement helps us figure out the ratio RϕKK, which addresses that long-standing puzzle about isospin symmetry breaking in phi meson couplings.
Lev: From an engineering point of view, it’s important to understand the context of that decay. They’re using data integrated over twenty point three femtobarns at a center-of-mass energy of three point seven seven three GeV, which is the exact environment we’d need to design for if we were trying to run something like this with real hardware.
Kai: And they built their analysis using an isobar model formulated with covariant tensors to describe the total amplitude M = Pρne iφn An, which is a coherent sum over decay amplitudes An.
Mira: They found that the only significant contributions in that fit came from ϕπ+, K0LK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+, and K0SK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ resonances. That’s a pretty narrow set of physics driving the fit.
Lev: If you’re trying to constrain dynamical models of charmed meson decays, you need to remember that these constraints come from a model fit using those resonances they identified in the amplitude analysis.
Lev: If you look at determining B(phi → K+K−), they combined their charm-based result for RϕKK with other known results using unitarity, and they found a value of B(phi → K+K−) of fifty-three point five four percent.
Kai: So we’re looking at how this measurement of B(D+ → K0SK0Lπ+) at five point seven eight zero times ten to the minus three and the average RϕKK in charm decays is zero point six one one plus or minus zero point twenty three.
The paper's summary: Kai: So we’re summarizing what this paper is about: it presents the first amplitude analysis and branching fraction measurement of D+ to K0SK0Lπ+. It’s a measurement using BESIII data.
Mira: Right, and that measurement gives them a specific number for RϕKK, which is this ratio of how often phi decays into those different kaon pairs.
Lev: They used data integrated over twenty point three femtobarns at a center-of-mass energy of three point seven seven three GeV. That’s the machine setup we’d have to design for if we were trying to run something like this with real hardware.
Kai: And they used an isobar model, which is this kind of mathematical tool, formulated with covariant tensors to describe the total amplitude M = Pρne iφn An.
Mira: They found that the only significant contributions came from a few specific resonances: phi pi plus, K0LK* eighty-nine two plus, and K0SK* eighty-nine two plus. That’s a pretty narrow set of physics driving the fit.
Lev: If you were building an error correction system for this, you'd need to make sure our model captures those specific intermediate states correctly because they are the ones dictating what the fit even sees as significant.
Kai: The result for RϕKK from charm decays is zero point six one one plus or minus zero point twenty three.
Mira: That number is consistent with previous results from charm decays, but it shows a tension of three point four standard deviations when compared to the world average from direct measurements.
Lev: A three point four sigma tension means that whatever the underlying theory predicts for RϕKK, it doesn't quite match what’s being seen in these charm decays. That suggests our assumptions about isospin breaking might be incomplete or there’s some physics missing in the model description.
Kai: They also looked at a coupling ratio g plus over g zero, and they found that this ratio was consistent with unity when looking at the results from charm decay.
Mira: That contrasts with what the PDG average and their fit values imply is significantly less than one for that ratio.
Lev: If you’re trying to constrain dynamical models of charmed meson decays, you need to remember that these constraints come from a model fit using those specific resonances they identified in the amplitude analysis.
Kai: They also measured the phase difference between the amplitudes for D+ to K0SK* eighty-nine two plus and D+ to K0LK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+, and that difference was nearly pi radians.
Mira: That phase information is important because it confirms a certain symmetry in the decay dynamics, but that tension around RϕKK still points to where the real issue lies with isospin symmetry breaking.
Lev: So this work gives us constraints on dynamical models by probing the decays of D plus to Kbar0S LK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ and K* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ to K0L,Spi+.
Kai: The total uncertainty they put on the branching fraction measurement is zero point nine percent, with systematic uncertainties coming mainly from varying the background model and those Blatt Weisskopf barrier factors.
Lev: To sum up, this study of "Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L zero pi+" provides a concrete measurement and a ratio RϕKK that gives us a specific value, but it also flags a persistent disagreement with other measurements, which tells us where we need more data on phi meson branching fractions.
The paper's improvements: Kai: This part of the discussion is about what they suggest to do next with these results from "Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L zero pi+". They are pointing toward a comprehensive re-evaluation of all phi decay branching fractions by the PDG, including CMD two, CMD three and BESIII.
Mira: That makes sense because the current tension around RϕKK is driven by inconsistencies between different measurement approaches, so combining more data should help resolve that.
Kai: They also stress that further measurements of the phi meson branching fractions are required to truly understand this difference we saw between charm decays and electron-positron annihilation experiments.
Mira: They also mentioned needing more data on the K plus and kaon pair ratios to properly constrain dynamical models of charmed meson decays.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, having more constraints from different decay modes means a richer set of observables to test our error correction schemes against, which is what we need for real hardware fidelity.
Kai: They also noted that the phase difference between the amplitudes for D+ to K0SK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ and D+ to K0LK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ was nearly pi radians, which is consistent with what we expect under CP conservation.
Lev: If you look at determining B(phi → K+K−) using their charm results and other known decays, they found a value significantly higher than what was measured in electron-positron annihilation experiments.
Kai: That finding suggests that future experimental focus needs to be on getting more precise measurements of these specific phi meson branching fractions from both charm and e plus minus experiments.
Mira: The goal is to move past this inconsistency and get a unified picture of how the phi meson couples to kaons in different environments.
Lev: For the error correction team, having a clearer picture of the underlying physics—especially with better constraints on those coupling ratios means we can build more accurate models for handling those kinds of systematic uncertainties that plague these decays.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this discussion on "Study of phi to K in the amplitude analysis of D+ to K S 0K L zero pi+". We have a measurement of B(D+ → K0SK0Lπ+) at five point seven eight zero times ten to the minus three, and the average RϕKK in charm decays is zero point six one one plus or minus zero point twenty three.
Mira: Basically, they found a specific measurement for RphiKK from charm decays and showed that it shows a tension with the world average.
Lev: They also provided constraints on dynamical models by measuring the decay D+ to Kbar0S LK* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ and K* (eight hundred ninety-two)+ to K0L,Spi+.
Kai: The core implication is that we need more data on phi meson branching fractions from both charm and electron-positron experiments to resolve this tension.
Mira: If we get those new measurements, it should help us understand the true isospin breaking in phi meson couplings and guide our theoretical models better.
Lev: For error correction, having these constraints means we can build more accurate models for handling the systematic uncertainties that plague these kinds of decays when building real hardware.
Kai: This paper gives us concrete numbers for RϕKK and shows exactly where the experimental gaps are right now.
Mira: It's a solid piece of work because it directly tackles a long-standing puzzle about isospin symmetry breaking in phi meson couplings using high-precision data from BESIII.
Lev: It's important that we keep building these precise tools because the fidelity of our measurements will be what eventually allows us to resolve this tension between different measurement techniques.
Kai: We’ve covered the measurement, the numbers, and what this means for understanding those couplings.
Mira: Next time, we’ll be looking at some new results from a different area of particle physics that might offer a fresh perspective on these same symmetry breaking issues.
More episodes
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2512.21290-Model-independent ZH production cross section at FCC-ee
- 2610.21982-First Observation of the Radiative Decay D 0 to gamma omega
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2512.08065-Searches for Light Dark Matter and Evidence of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering of Solar Neutrinos with the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Experiment
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2508.18022-Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider
- 2512.23992-Prospect for measurement of CP-violating parameters of B s 0 to phi gamma at the Tera Z factory