Probing the nature of the chi c1(3872) state using radiative decays

summary

The gist

The radiative decays of the χc1(3872) state into ψ(2S)γ and J/ψγ are used to probe its nature using proton-proton collision data collected with the LHCb detector…

In short

Researchers studied radiative decays of the chi c1(3872) state into ψ(2S)γ and J/ψγ using LHCb data. The measured ratio Rψγ was 1.67, which contradicts pure molecular interpretations and strongly suggests the chi c1(3872) has a significant compact charmonium or tetraquark component.

Key concepts

Rψγ Ratio
This is a specific ratio comparing the partial decay widths of the chi c1(3872) decaying into ψ(2S)γ versus J/ψγ. The value measured was 1.67, and it's used to test different theoretical models about what the chi c1(3872) state fundamentally is.
Molecular Hypothesis
This hypothesis suggests the chi c1(3872) state is primarily a loosely bound molecule made of two D0D*0+ particles. Calculations based on this model predict a very small Rψγ ratio, which contradicts the experimental measurement.
Compact Component
This refers to a significant part of the chi c1(3872) structure that is compact, meaning it's not just a simple molecule. The large measured Rψγ value supports models where the state has a substantial compact charmonium or tetraquark structure.
Radiative Decays
These are processes where the chi c1(3872) state decays by emitting a photon (gamma). By measuring how often it decays into different final states like ψ(2S)γ and J/ψγ, scientists can gain clues about its internal structure.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Probing the nature of the chi c1(3872) state using radiative decays · Read on arXiv

LHCb collaboration

European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)

The radiative decays χ c1(3872) toψ(2S)γ and χ c1(3872) to J/ψγ are used to probe the nature of the χ c1(3872) state using proton-proton collision data collected with the LHCb detector, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9fb-1. Using the B+ to χ c1(3872)K+ decay, the χ c1(3872) to ψ(2S)γ process is observed for the first time and the ratio of its partial width to that of the χ c1(3872) to J/ψγ decay is measured to be Γ χ c1(3872) to J/ψγ = 1.67 plus or minus 0.21 plus or minus 0.12 plus or minus0.04, where the first uncertainty is statistical, the second systematic and the third is due to the uncertainties on the branching fractions of the ψ(2S) and J/ψ mesons. The measured ratio makes the interpretation of the χ c1(3872) state as a pure D 0 D bar*0+ D bar 0D*0 molecule questionable and strongly indicates a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark component within the χ c1(3872) state.

DOI: 10.1007/JHEP11(2024)121

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Probing the nature of the chi c1(3872) state using radiative decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The radiative decays of the χc1(3872) state into ψ(2S)γ and J/ψγ are used to probe its nature using proton-proton collision data collected with the LHCb detector, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9 fb−1 The measured ratio makes the interpretation of the χc1(3872) state as a pure D0D∗0+ D0D∗0 molecule questionable and strongly indicates a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark component within the χc1(3872) state Experimental Observation and Ratio Measurement The process χc1(3872) → ψ(2S)γ is observed for the first time using the B+ → χc1(3872)K+ decay, and the ratio of its partial width to that of the χc1(3872) → J/ψγ decay is measured to be Γχc1(3872)→ψ(2S)γ / Γχc1(3872)→J/ψγ = 1.67 ± 0.21 ± 0.12 ± 0.04 This measured ratio makes the interpretation of the χc1(3872) state as a pure D0D∗0+ D0D∗0 molecule questionable and strongly indicates a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark component within the χc1(3872) state The measured Rψγ value of 2.46 ± 0.64 ± 0.29 is in good agreement with the value obtained by the BaBar collaboration Theoretical Predictions and Model Dependence Calculations for the ratio of partial radiative decay widths, Rψγ ≡ Γχc1(3872)→ψ(2S)γ / Γχc1(3872)→J/ψγ, vary widely depending on the hypothesis considered for the nature of the χc1(3872) state Table 1 summarizes these predictions across various models, showing that large values of this ratio Rψγ ≳ 1 are expected under conventional charmonium χc1(2P) models while calculations based on the pure DD∗-molecular hypothesis give much smaller values, Rψγ ≪ 1 Signal Determination and Statistical Significance Signal yields of both B+ → (χc1(3872) → ψγ) K+ and B+ → (χc1(3872) → J/ψγ) K+ decay channels are determined using extended unbinned maximum-likelihood fits to two-dimensional distributions of mψγ and mψγK+ The statistical significance for the B+→ (χc1(3872)→ ψ(2S)γ) K+ signal is found to be 4.8 and 6.0 standard deviations for the Run 1 and Run 2 data-taking periods, respectively Systematic Uncertainties in Ratio Calculation The total relative systematic uncertainties on the ratio of branching fractions Rψγ are calculated as the sum in quadrature of all the values described above, resulting in + 8.0 − 9.2 % for Run 1 and + 8.7 − 7.9 % for Run 2 data-taking periods These uncertainties include contributions from the fit model, parameterization of background components, and finite size of the simulated sample The combined ratio of partial radiative widths from this study is below the upper limit set by the Belle collaboration and consistent with previous measurements by the BaBar and LHCb collaborations However, it is notably in tension with the upper limit set by the BESIII collaboration The large measured value of the Rψγ ratio is generally inconsistent with calculations based on the pure DD∗ molecular hypothesis for the χc1(3872) state unless some special assumptions are made On the contrary, it agrees with a broad range of predictions based on other hypotheses of the χc1(3872) structure, including conventional cc charmonium, ccqq tetraquark, and molecules mixed with a sizeable compact component This measurement provides a strong argument in favour of a compact component in the χc1(3872) structure The combined ratio of partial radiative widths from this study is found to be Rψγ = 1.67 ± 0.21 ± 0.12 ± 0.04 The results for the Run 1 and Run 2 data-taking periods are combined using the best linear unbiased estimator accounting for correlated systematic uncertainties, yielding Rψγ = 1.67 ± 0.21 ± 0.12 ± 0.04 The obtained value for the ratio Rψγ is found to be below the upper limit set by the Belle collaboration and consistent with previous measurements by the BaBar and LHCb collaborations However, it is notably in tension with the upper limit set by the BESIII collaboration Figure 2 Interpretation Figure 2 summarizes experimental results for the ratio of the partial decay widths for the radiative χc1(3872) → ψ(2S)γ and χc1(3872) → J/ψγ decays, showing that the combined ratio of partial radiative widths from this study is below the upper limit set by the Belle collaboration and consistent with previous measurements by the BaBar and LHCb collaborations The results from this analysis for the Run 1 and Run 2 data sets are shown as red points with error bars Final Conclusion The study of the radiative decays of the χc1(3872) state into the ψ(2S)γ and J/ψγ final states provides an alternative way to probe its nature This measurement provides a strong argument in favour of a compact component in the χc1(3872) structure The ratio Rψγ is in good agreement with (and supersedes) the value of Rψγ = 2.46 ± 0.70, obtained in the previous study The combined ratio of partial radiative widths from this study is below the upper limit set by the Belle collaboration and consistent with previous measurements by the BaBar and LHCb collaborations However, it is notably in tension with the upper limit set by the BESIII collaboration The large measured value of the Rψγ ratio is generally inconsistent with the calculations based on the pure DD∗ molecular hypothesis for the χc1(3872) state unless some special assumptions are made On the contrary, it agrees with a broad range of predictions based on other hypotheses of the χc1(3872) structure, including conventional cc charmonium

67,69,71,84–90: , ccqq tetraquark

92: , and molecules mixed with a sizeable compact component

82, 83, 93–95: The measurement provides a strong argument in favour of a compact component in the χc1(3872) structure Acknowledgements We express our gratitude to our colleagues in the CERN accelerator departments for the excellent performance of the LHC We thank the technical and administrative staff at the LHCb institutes We acknowledge support from CERN and from the national agencies including CAPES, CNPq, FAPERJ and FINEP (Brazil), MOST and NSFC (China), CNRS/IN2P3 (France), BMBF, DFG and MPG (Germany), INFN (Italy), NWO (Netherlands), MNiSW and NCN (Poland), MCID/IFA (Romania), MICINN (Spain) We acknowledge the computing resources that are provided by CERN, IN2P3(France), KIT and DESY(Germany), INFN(Italy), SURF(Netherlands), PIC(Spain), GridPP (United Kingdom) We are indebted to the communities behind the multiple open-source software packages on which we depend The LHCb collaboration is listed with authors including R.

Kai: Aaij, S.

Mira: W.

Kai: Abdelmotteleb, C.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper by the LHCb collaboration titled "Probing the nature of the chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) state using radiative decays" <ref:2406.17006#pg1,Probing the nature of the>. Essentially, they're using proton-proton collision data collected with their detector over an integrated luminosity of nine femtobarns to look at how this particle decays.

Mira: The big claim here is that by measuring the ratio between two specific decay modes, they get a strong indication that the chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) state isn't purely a simple molecule made of D and D* mesons <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Lev: I mean, what they're really doing is comparing two things: the decay into a psi two S gamma, and then it decaying into a J psi gamma. This measurement is supposed to tell us if the state has a compact charmonium or tetraquark component mixed in with whatever molecular structure might be there.

Kai: The specific ratio they're measuring, gamma chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) to psi(2S) gamma / gamma chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) to J/psi gamma, comes out to one point six seven with uncertainties like plus or minus zero point two one, plus or minus zero point one two, and plus or minus zero point zero four <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Mira: That number is quite significant because it makes the interpretation of the chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) state as a pure D zero D*zero molecule questionable, especially when you look at what other models predict <ref:2406.17006#pg1,D^0 D^{*0}$ molecule questionable>.

Lev: Before we get into the math, I want to say that this measurement isn't just some isolated number; it's tied to the experimental setup at LHCb and the specific decays they observed for the first time, like B+ to chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two)K+ where they saw this psi(2S) gamma decay <ref:2406.17006#pg1,observed for the first time>.

Kai: Right, so if we look at what the paper says about how this ratio compares to other models, it shows that conventional charmonium models expect a larger ratio, maybe greater than one.

Mira: And the pure D D* molecular hypothesis predicts a much smaller ratio, less than one. This measured value of one point six seven falls right in the middle of those two extremes and strongly favors having a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark component inside that chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) structure <ref:2406.17006#pg1,a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark component>.

Paper summary: Lev: From my side, when I think about running this on real hardware, the overhead for these kinds of measurements is manageable, but we have to be careful about those systematic uncertainties they mention—the uncertainty on the branching fractions of the psi two S and J psi mesons adds to it.

Kai: The paper also notes that their combined ratio, when you account for all those systematic uncertainties from Run one and Run two data-taking periods, settles around one point six seven with an uncertainty spread of about eight point zero to nine point two percent for the first run and eight point seven to seven point nine percent for the second run <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Mira: That uncertainty is important because it means we have to be careful when we compare this result to other experiments, like BaBar and LHCb, which found a value of two point four six for that same ratio.

Lev: So, when you put the pieces together—the measured one point six seven, the theoretical expectations being split between pure molecule and compact component—it points toward a structure that's more complex than just a simple loosely bound pair of mesons <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Kai: The paper also mentions that this combined ratio is below the upper limit set by the Belle collaboration, which is good because it's consistent with previous measurements from BaBar and LHCb.

Mira: But there's one tension point they bring up, and it’s that this result is notably in tension with the upper limit set by the BESIII collaboration.

Lev: So what does this mean for us? It means that while this measurement points strongly toward a compact component, we still have to reconcile it with those other constraints from different experiments.

Kai: The paper itself isn't just about reporting one result; it’s about using these radiative decays to probe the nature of the state. The methodology they used involves extended unbinned maximum-likelihood fits to two dimensional distributions of the mass of that psi gamma and the mass of that J psi gamma plus a K plus meson.

Paper summary: Mira: That method is how they extract those signal yields from the background noise in proton-proton collisions, which is a real challenge when you're looking for something narrow.

Lev: For running this on hardware, we'd need very good control over the detector resolution because if the resolution isn't tight enough, all these subtle differences between the decay channels get washed out.

Kai: The overall conclusion of this paper is that the large measured value of that ratio, one point six seven, is generally inconsistent with calculations based on a pure D D* molecular hypothesis unless you make some special assumptions about the structure <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Mira: Conversely, it aligns well with predictions from other hypotheses, specifically those involving conventional charmonium states, tetraquarks made of two charm quarks and two light quarks, and even molecules that have a sizeable compact component.

Lev: So for someone who only listens to this show, what does this translate to? It suggests that the chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) isn't just one simple thing; it’s likely a mix of different things—a molecular piece plus something more compact <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Kai: The title of the paper, "Probing the nature of the chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) state using radiative decays," sets up exactly that mission: using these specific decay channels to figure out what this particle actually is underneath all that mass and width information we've gathered over the last couple of decades <ref:2406.17006#pg1,Probing the nature of the>.

Mira: The authors are basically showing that looking at how it transitions into different final states with photons gives us a much clearer picture than just looking at the mass spectrum alone.

Lev: And for future work, I think they'll need to refine those systematic uncertainties further and maybe try to get better constraints from other decay channels to pin down exactly what that compact component looks like in terms of its internal structure.

Kai: So, we have this measurement of one point six seven, which challenges the simple molecular picture and points toward a more mixed structure, and now we know what kind of assumptions are needed to make those models fit the data <ref:2406.17006#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about looking at how the chi c1 three eight seven two state decays to psi two s gamma and j psi gamma, and what that tells us about its true structure.

Mira: It's a deep dive into whether this particle is just a simple molecule or if it has something more compact hidden inside.

Lev: We're looking at the results from the LHCb data, which means we have some high statistics here to even begin with.

Kai: The authors are using those specific decay ratios to test different theories about what this state actually is.

Mira: They find that conventional charmonium models predict one ratio value, but molecular hypotheses suggest a completely different one.

Lev: And the measurement they got comes out at about one point six seven, which sits right in that middle ground between the two extremes.

Kai: That number is what makes this paper interesting because it pushes us away from just saying it’s a pure molecule.

Mira: It strongly suggests there's a sizeable compact charmonium or tetraquark piece mixed in with whatever molecular structure might be there.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means the theoretical framework needs to account for that extra component, which adds complexity to the simulation needed to run these things on real hardware.

Kai: So we have this measured ratio of one point six seven, and it's not fitting the simple molecule picture very well.

Mira: It’s a strong argument for a more mixed structure, which means we need models that allow for that extra compact component.

Lev: If we're building real detectors to measure this, we have to design our analysis to be sensitive enough to see those subtle differences in the decay distributions.

Kai: But there's still some tension with other collaborations on the upper limits from BESIII, so it’s not a totally settled picture yet.

Mira: Yeah, that tension is where the real physics debate lives right now about this state.

More episodes

← Home