Observation of a strange J P=1- resonance K* 1(1870) in chi c1 to K+K-eta decays

summary

The gist

A partial wave analysis of the process ψ(2S) → γχc1, χc1 → K+K−η′ decays is performed using a sample of (2712.4±14.3)× 106 ψ(2S) events collected with the BESIII detector.

In short

A partial wave analysis of $\psi(2S) \rightarrow \gamma\chi_{c1}$ decays revealed a new resonance, $K^*_1(1870)$, in the $Kar{\eta}'$ system with quantum numbers $J^P=1^-$. This state was observed for the first time with a statistical significance exceeding 10$\\sigma$, providing crucial input for understanding strange-meson spectroscopy and potentially identifying a hybrid meson candidate.

Key concepts

$J^P=1^-$ Exotic Quantum Numbers
Quantum numbers describe the intrinsic properties of a particle, like its spin ($J$) and parity ($P$). States with $J^P=1^-$ are considered exotic because they cannot be easily explained by simple quark-antiquark combinations. This makes them strong candidates for hybrid mesons, which involve an excited gluonic field contributing to the hadron's structure.
$K^*_1(1870)$ Meson
This is a newly observed resonance in the $Kar{\eta}'$ system with a mass of approximately 1869 MeV/c$^2$ and a width of 167.3 MeV. Its observation, confirmed by BESIII, is significant because it suggests the existence of a strange hybrid state predicted by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD).
Partial Wave Analysis (PWA)
PWA is a sophisticated data analysis technique used to decompose complex decay processes into their constituent partial waves. By fitting the measured data from $\psi(2S) \rightarrow \gamma\chi_{c1}$ decays, researchers can extract the properties (mass, width, branching fraction) of individual resonances contributing to the final state.
Hybrid Mesons
Hybrid mesons are a class of particles in QCD where an excited gluonic field is explicitly part of the hadron's structure. These states are important because they test our understanding of non-perturbative QCD dynamics and offer a way to search for exotic matter beyond standard quark models.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Observation of a strange J P=1- resonance K* 1(1870) in chi c1 to K+K-eta decays · Read on arXiv

M. Ablikim, M. N. Achasov, P. Adlarson, X. C. Ai, C. S. Akondi A B, R. Aliberti A C B D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing · Beihang University · Bochum Ruhr-University · Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics SB RAS · Carnegie Mellon University · Central China Normal University · Central South University · Chengdu University of Technology · Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz

A partial wave analysis of the process ψ(2S) to γχ c1, χ c1 to K+K-η, with the η meson reconstructed in the π+π-γ and π+π-η decay modes, is performed using a sample of (2712.4 plus or minus 14.3) times10 6 ψ(2S) events collected with the BESIII detector. In the Kη system, a resonant contribution with quantum numbers J P=1- is observed for the first time and is denoted as the K 1*(1870) meson. Its statistical significance is 11.0σ, and its mass and width are measured to be M=(1869.0 plus or minus 14.6 plus or minus 18.6) MeV/ c squared and Γ=(167.3 plus or minus 34.0 plus or minus 24.2) MeV, respectively. The branching fraction of the χ c1 to K minus or plusK 1*(1870) plus or minus to K+K-η decay chain is determined to be (1.48 plus or minus 0.30 plus or minus 0.33) times10-5. The branching fraction of the χ c1 to K+K-η decay is measured to be (7.90 plus or minus 0.48) times10-4. Several intermediate scalar, vector, and tensor states are required to provide a good description of the data. These results provide new input for understanding strange-meson spectroscopy and investigating possible hybrid-state candidates.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Observation of a strange J P=1- resonance K* 1(1870) in chi c1 to K+K-eta decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A partial wave analysis of the process ψ(2S) → γχc1, χc1 → K+K−η′ decays is performed using a sample of (2712.4±14.3)× 106 ψ(2S) events collected with the BESIII detector.

Kai: In the Kη′ system, a resonant contribution with quantum numbers J P = 1− is observed for the first time and is denoted as the K∗1 (1870) meson.

Mira: Its statistical significance is 11.0σ, and its mass and width are measured to be M = (1869.0±14.6±18.6) MeV/c2 and Γ = (167.3 ± 34.0 ± 24.2) MeV.

Kai: The branching fraction of the χc1 → K∓K∗1 (1870)± → K+K−η′ decay chain is determined to be (1.48 ± 0.30 ± 0.33) × 10−5.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're talking about the paper "Observation of a strange J P=one- resonance K* one(one thousand eight hundred seventy) in chi c1 to K+K-eta decays" and who wrote it <ref:2611.11328#pg1,Observation of a strange J P=1- resonance K* 1(1870) in>. The team is trying to establish the existence of this new particle, this K star one eight seven zero, in that specific decay process.

Mira: And the authors are working with data from BESIII collected from psi two s events, which is a pretty big sample size for this kind of work.

Lev: From my side, I'm thinking about how they got their measurement done; it’s not just finding a peak on a graph, it involves fitting in the partial wave analysis framework to pull out that specific resonance signal.

Kai: Yeah, and the authors are using this combined partial wave analysis approach to see if there's a statistically significant signal for this K star one eight seven zero.

Mira: What this means for us is that they are probing some very specific dynamics in the strange sector, which could point toward models of how these exotic states form within Quantum Chromodynamics.

Lev: It’s interesting because if they find it, it gives us a concrete piece to test the theoretical predictions about the spectrum of hybrid mesons.

Kai: Yeah, so we're going to see what they actually found in that analysis and how strong that signal is.

The paper's summary: Mira: Okay, so looking at the summary of this paper, it boils down to them observing a resonance in the ka plus ka minus eta prime system for the first time. This resonance is labeled as K star one eight seven zero.

Kai: And they give us some very specific numbers for it. They say its statistical significance is eleven point zero sigma, which is quite strong, and they measure its mass to be around one eight six nine point zero mega electron volts per speed of light squared.

Lev: That mass measurement comes with a width, and they say the width is around one sixty seven point three mega electron volts per speed of light squared. That width tells us how long this state lives before decaying.

Mira: And they also provide the branching fraction for the decay chain involving this new resonance, which is one point four eight plus zero point three plus zero point three times ten to the minus five.

Kai: And they also measured a reference branching fraction for chi c one to K plus kaon minus eta prime decays, which is seven point nine zero plus zero point four eight times ten to the minus four.

Lev: So what this means is that they've found a new structure in the data, and it has been confirmed with more than ten sigma significance.

Mira: And they also mention that several other intermediate states are needed for a good description of the data, including scalar, vector, and tensor states in the ka plus ka minus system.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's look at what this paper suggests is better or different about the existing methods. They are pointing out that using a four constraint kinematic fit for mode one and a five constraint fit for mode two helps improve the resolution of the measurement.

Mira: And they also talk about how they handle systematic uncertainties; they vary background yields by plus or minus one sigma, and change parameters like Blatt Weisskopf barrier factors to see how much it affects the final results.

Lev: That's important because in real hardware, we have to account for that kind of uncertainty when trying to extract a clean signal from noisy data. It shows how sensitive the measurement is to these modeling choices.

Kai: And they use this systematic uncertainty estimation process to make sure their final numbers are robust, not just lucky peaks in the data.

Mira: The paper also discusses how these results feed into understanding the flavormultiplet structure of light hybrid mesons, which is what we've been looking into for a while now.

Lev: If they find this K star one eight seven zero state and it fits the theoretical predictions, then it gives us a strong constraint on where we should look for these other exotic states.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper "Observation of a strange J P=one- resonance K* one(one thousand eight hundred seventy) in chi c1 to K+K-eta decays" confirms the first observation of a J P equal one minus resonance in that system <ref:2611.11328#pg1,Observation of a strange J P=1- resonance K* 1(1870) in>.

Mira: They found the K star one eight seven zero with a mass of one eight six nine point zero mega electron volts per speed of light squared and a width of one sixty seven point three plus thirty point four mega electron volts per speed of light squared.

Lev: And the branching fraction for chi c one to K minus kaon plus k star one eight seven zero plus ka minus eta prime decays is measured at one point four eight plus zero point three plus zero point three times ten to the minus five.

Kai: This observation is significant because it provides a new piece in the puzzle of strange meson spectroscopy and helps us look for hybrid candidates, especially since their theoretical predictions for the K thirty three s one state are not consistent with what they measured.

Mira: They also note that while this finding is important, further theoretical and experimental work is still needed to fully clarify the nature of the resonant structure in the ka plus ka minus invariant mass spectrum.

Lev: It shows how crucial it is to keep pushing these analyses forward because until we get a better handle on the underlying theory, these measurements are just starting points for building real hardware tests.

More episodes

← Home