Investigating production of TeV-scale muons in extensive air shower at 2400 m underground

summary

The gist

Deep underground experiments present a new avenue to probe the first interactions in extensive air showers or hadronic interactions in the extreme forward phase space The results show discrepancies…

In short

Deep underground experiments measured muon fluxes from extensive air showers at 2400 meters depth, finding a 40% excess compared to leading hadronic interaction models. This discrepancy suggests either a harder spectrum for charged hadrons or a smaller hadron multiplicity in the first interaction. The results favor a lighter cosmic ray composition in the TeV to PeV energy range.

Key concepts

Extensive Air Showers (EAS)
These are cascades of secondary particles created when high-energy cosmic rays strike the Earth's atmosphere. The paper studies how these showers develop as they propagate through the atmosphere and underground, specifically looking at how muons are produced during this process.
Hadronic Interaction Models
These are theoretical frameworks used to predict how cosmic rays collide with atmospheric nuclei. The study compared results from three models (SIBYLL2.3d, QGSJET-II-04, and EPOS-LHC) to understand the physics of these initial collisions.
Muon Flux Discrepancy
The measured number of muons detected underground was about 40% higher than what the standard models predicted. This significant difference, exceeding a 2-sigma statistical threshold, is the central finding that prompts investigation into the underlying physics of cosmic ray interactions.
Mass Composition Inference
By testing different interaction models against experimental data, researchers could infer whether cosmic rays are predominantly composed of lighter or heavier particles. The data analysis indicated a preference for a lighter primary component in the 10 TeV to PeV energy range.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Investigating production of TeV-scale muons in extensive air shower at 2400 m underground · Read on arXiv

Department of Engineering Physics & Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University Department of Engineering Physics & Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University Key Laboratory of Particle & Radiation Imaging (Tsinghua University) School of Physics Nankai University School of Physics & Electronics Hunan University School of Physical Sciences University of Chinese Academy of Sciences Institute of Frontier and Interdisciplinary Science Shandong University

Deep underground experiments present a new avenue to probe the first interactions in extensive air showers or hadronic interactions in the extreme forward phase space. The China Jinping Underground Laboratory, characterized by a vertical rock overburden of 2,400 m, provides an exceptionally effective shield against cosmic muons with energies below 3 TeV. The surviving high-energy muons, produced in the first interactions of extensive air showers, open a unique observational window into primary cosmic rays from tens of TeV up to the PeV scale and beyond. This distinctive feature also enables detailed studies of charged hadron production in the earliest stages of shower development. Using 1,338.6 live days of data collected with a one-ton prototype detector for the Jinping Neutrino Experiment, we measured the underground muon flux originating from air showers. The results show discrepancies of about 40% corresponding to significances of more than 2 σ, relative to predictions from several leading hadronic interaction models. We interpret these findings from two complementary perspectives: (i) by adopting the expected cosmic-ray spectra, we constrain the modeling of the first hadronic interactions in air showers and provide novel insights into resolving the long-standing muon puzzle; and (ii) by assuming specific hadronic interaction models, we infer the mass composition of cosmic rays, and our data favor a lighter component in the corresponding energy range. Our study demonstrates the potential of deep underground laboratories to provide new experimental insights into air shower physics and cosmic rays.

DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-026-16340-5

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Investigating production of TeV-scale muons in extensive air shower at 2400 m underground".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Deep underground experiments present a new avenue to probe the first interactions in extensive air showers or hadronic interactions in the extreme forward phase space The results show discrepancies of about 40% corresponding to significances of more than 2σ, relative to predictions from several leading hadronic interaction models Experimental Setup and Data Collection The study utilized data collected with a one-ton prototype detector for the Jinping Neutrino Experiment, which operates in the China Jinping Underground Laboratory characterized by a vertical rock overburden of 2,400 m This setup provides an exceptionally effective shield against cosmic muons with energies below 3 TeV The detector collected data from July 31, 2017, to March 27, 2024 The main component of the one-ton prototype detector is a 10-cm-thick spherical acrylic vessel containing one ton of liquid scintillator as the detection target To ensure a pure muon sample, the reconstructed energy is required to be greater than 90 MeV to exclude low-energy backgrounds A total of 547 muon events were selected from data for subsequent direction reconstruction and flux analysis Modeling and Analysis Framework A GEANT4-based simulation framework was developed to study muon detection and enable precise predictions This framework consists of three parts: muon production in EAS, propagation through the mountain, and detection in the one-ton prototype detector The simulation employs the Matrix Cascade Equations (MCEq) package to numerically solve coupled cascade equations that describe the EAS development Three phenomenological interaction models, SIBYLL2.3d and QGSJET-II-04 were developed explicitly for EAS simulations, whereas EPOS-LHC was primarily designed for collider experiments but can also be applied to EAS simulations The primary CR energy spectra are derived from the state-of-the-art Global Spline Fit (GSF) model, which relies weakly on theoretical assumptions Discrepancy and Interpretation The measured underground muon flux exceeds model expectations by approximately 40%, with a significance of more than 2σ when including model-related uncertainties This discrepancy is interpreted from two complementary perspectives: (i) by adopting the expected cosmic-ray spectra, the authors constrain the modeling of first hadronic interactions in air showers and provide novel insights into resolving the long-standing muon puzzle (ii) by assuming specific hadronic interaction models, they infer the mass composition of cosmic rays, and their data favor a lighter component in the corresponding energy range The variations among the three hadronic models suggest potential phenomenological explanations for the observed discrepancy The discrepancy reported herein may indicate a harder spectrum for charged hadrons and a smaller hadron multiplicity in the first interaction of EAS Alternatively, a modest enhancement in charged K or prompt meson production can also increase the yield of high-energy muons Assuming a percent-level enhancement of charged K production starting from sub-PeVscale interactions, both the GeV-muon content excess for CRs above tens of PeV and the TeV-muon excess observed in this study can be consistently explained The measured fluxes systematically exceed the GSF predictions across all tested hadronic interaction models, favoring a lighter primary composition for CRs within 10 TeV–PeV range Final Measurement and Uncertainties

Title and authors: Kai: The paper we're looking at is titled "Investigating production of TeV-scale muons in extensive air shower at two thousand four hundred m underground". It’s trying to figure out what these high energy muons are doing when they penetrate that depth.

Mira: The authors are a big group from institutions like Tsinghua University and others, and they’re using a one-ton prototype detector situated in the China Jinping Underground Laboratory which has a two thousand four hundred meter vertical rock overburden.

Lev: That setup is designed to be an extremely good shield against lower energy cosmic muons, specifically those below three teraelectronvolts.

Kai: The core idea of the study is using these deep underground measurements as a unique probe for the first interactions in extensive air showers or hadronic interactions in that extreme forward phase space.

Mira: They are testing predictions from several leading hadronic interaction models and finding about a forty percent discrepancy, which they say has a significance of more than two sigma relative to those predictions.

Lev: This is important because it helps constrain the modeling of first hadronic interactions in air showers, which is where our understanding is still quite weak.

Kai: The framework they built uses GEANT4 simulations to model muon detection, propagation through the mountain, and finally detection in that one-ton liquid scintillator vessel.

Mira: To get their predictions right, they used the Matrix Cascade Equations package to solve coupled cascade equations describing how the extensive air shower develops.

Lev: They also explicitly developed two phenomenological interaction models, SIBYLL two point three d and QGSJET two zero four for the EAS simulations, alongside applying EPOS LHC which is typically used for collider experiments.

Kai: The primary cosmic ray energy spectra they are using come from a state of the art Global Spline Fit model, which is useful because it relies weakly on theoretical assumptions.

Mira: And to make sure their data quality was good, they monitored electronics fluctuations and photon detector occupancy, excluding about five percent of the data before selecting those five hundred forty seven muon events for direction reconstruction and flux analysis.

The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what they found, the measured underground muon flux exceeds the model expectations by approximately forty percent, which is a statistically significant finding at more than two sigma when considering all model-related uncertainties.

Mira: They are interpreting this discrepancy from two complementary angles: first, by sticking to the expected cosmic ray spectra and constraining how we model those first hadronic interactions in air showers.

Lev: Second, by assuming specific hadronic interaction models, they can infer the mass composition of the cosmic rays and their data favors a lighter component in that energy range.

Kai: So it’s not just one thing; the variation among those three interaction models suggests there could be different phenomenological explanations for why we are seeing this difference.

Mira: The conclusion is that this discrepancy might indicate a harder spectrum for charged hadrons or a smaller hadron multiplicity in the first interaction of air showers.

Lev: Alternatively, they also suggest that a modest enhancement in charged kaon or prompt meson production can increase the yield of those high energy muons.

Kai: Assuming you have a percent-level enhancement of charged kaon production starting from sub pevscale interactions, both the excess GeV-muon content for cosmic rays above tens of pev and the TeV-muon excess observed in this study could be consistently explained.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests that by adopting the expected cosmic ray spectra, they can constrain the modeling of first hadronic interactions in air showers and provide novel insights into resolving the long standing muon puzzle.

Mira: They also suggest that if you assume specific hadronic interaction models, you can infer the mass composition of cosmic rays and their data favors a lighter component in that energy range.

Lev: The authors also point out that by using a data driven Global Spline Fit model, they can constrain primary cosmic ray energy spectra and mass composition while minimizing theoretical assumptions.

Kai: They also propose a way to investigate the dependence of the muon flux excess on zenith angle by calculating the flux using the formula phi theta equals N theta over epsilon theta S theta T.

Mira: That formula lets them check if there's any potential dependence of that flux excess on the angle at which you look, so it helps map out where we might find these effects.

Lev: And they also suggest quantifying the effect of latest hadronic model revisions, such as QGSJET three or SIBYLL and EPOS LHC R, by simulating air showers using CORSIKA to see if the resulting enhancement in muon production above three teraelectronvolts is marginal.

Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up the paper "Investigating production of TeV-scale muons in extensive air shower at two thousand four hundred m underground", we see a consistent forty percent excess over leading model predictions for the underground muon flux.

Mira: This excess points toward possibilities like a harder spectrum for charged hadrons or an increase in charged kaon production that could explain both the high energy and lower energy excesses.

Lev: Ultimately, they conclude that their measured fluxes systematically exceed the Global Spline Fit predictions across all tested hadronic interaction models, favoring a lighter primary composition for cosmic rays within the ten teraelectronvolt to pev range.

Kai: It’s an important step because it tells us exactly what we need to focus on when we design our next generation of simulations and detectors for this physics.

Mira: We're going to keep watching these results, because they give us a clearer picture of the physics happening at those initial high energy interactions.

Lev: I just think the way they used the data selection criteria to isolate pure muon samples was really thorough for getting that clean measurement from the prototype detector.

More episodes

← Home