Improved search for psi(3770) to gamma eta c(1S, 2S) radiative transitions

summary

The gist

Improved search for psi(3770) → γηc(1S, 2S) radiative transitions is presented using an improved data sample to set upper limits on branching fractions and partial decay widths.

In short

This study improved the search for radiative transitions from psi(3770) to gamma eta c(1S, 2S) using a larger dataset from BESIII data. The search set upper limits on branching fractions and partial decay widths. The results suggest that the upper limit on the decay width is consistent with some theoretical predictions but larger than others.

Key concepts

psi(3770)
This is a specific particle studied in particle physics experiments, often produced in electron-positron annihilation. In this context, it's the initial state resonance being searched for transitions from it to other particles.
gamma eta c(1S, 2S)
This refers to a specific decay channel where the psi(3770) particle decays into a photon (gamma) and an excited state of the charmed meson, denoted as eta c(1S or 2S). This is the signal being looked for.
Branching Fraction
The branching fraction represents the probability that a specific particle decay will occur. The paper sets upper limits on this probability, meaning they are constraining how often psi(3770) decays into gamma eta c(1S or 2S) compared to other possible decays.
Partial Decay Width
The partial decay width is a measure of the probability of a particle decaying into a specific final state. The study calculated upper limits on these widths, which are related to the branching fractions and provide constraints on the strength of this particular decay process.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Improved search for psi(3770) to gamma eta c(1S, 2S) radiative transitions · Read on arXiv

M. Ablikim, M. N. Achasov, P. Adlarson, X. C. Ai, C. S. Akondi A B, R. Aliberti A C, A., Q., α An, ε Anderson M S, Ι Bai Y O Bakina H R Bao X L Bao M Barbagiovanni V Batozskaya K Begzsuren N Berger M Berlowski M B Bertani D Bettoni F Bianchi E Bianco A Bortone I Boyko R A Briere A Brueggemann D Cabiati H Cai M Cai X Cai G F Cao N Cao S Cetin X Y Chai J F Chang T T Chang G R Che Y Z Che C H Chen Chao Chen G Chen H S Chen H Y Chen M L Chen S J Chen S M Chen T. , what_researchers_did, The researchers performed an improved search for the radiative transitions of the psi(3770) resonance to γc(1S, 2S) using data from the BESIII detector., supporting_evidence, No significant signal was observed with 90 percent confidence level upper limits on the product branching fractions set to be 5.0 x 10^-6 for the γc(1S) transition and 3.7 x 10^-6 for the →㬼(2S) transition., surprising_detail, The improved measurements using a seven times larger integrated luminosity lowered the upper limits by approximately a factor of three and two for the γc(1S) and εc(2S) transitions, respectively., why_it_matters, This work provides improved constraints on theoretical predictions for charmonium radiative decays to test nonperturbative mechanisms., limitations, The study relies on a data sample with an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb-1 and assumes the use of a specific reconstruction method for γc(1S, 2S)., confidence_or_uncertainty, medium

Institute of High Energy Physics · Beihang University · Bochum Ruhr-University · Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics SB RAS · Carnegie Mellon University · Central China Normal University · Central South University · Chengdu University of Technology · Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz

Based on an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb-1 of e+e- annihilation data collected at a center-of-mass energy of 3.773 with the BESIII detector operating at the BEPCII collider, an improved search for the radiative transitions ψ(3770) to γη c(1S, 2S) is performed using the hadronic decays η c(1S, 2S) to K 0 S K plus or minus π minus or plus. No significant signal is observed. The corresponding 90 % confidence level upper limits on the product branching fractions are set to be 5.0 times 10-6 for the η c(1S) transition and 3.7 times 10-6 for the η c(2S) transition. The 90 % confidence level upper limits on the partial decay widths are also reported to be Γ(ψ(3770) to γη c(1S)) < 5.5 keV and Γ(ψ(3770) to γη c(2S)) < 29.4. With about seven times larger integrated luminosity than used previously, these results lower the upper limits by approximately a factor of three and two for the η c(1S) and η c(2S) transitions, respectively.

DOI: 10.1103/ml3k-2pss

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Improved search for psi(3770) to gamma eta c(1S, 2S) radiative transitions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Improved search for psi(3770) → γηc(1S, 2S) radiative transitions is presented using an improved data sample to set upper limits on branching fractions and partial decay widths.

Kai: Experimental Setup and Data Utilization The search was conducted using an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb−1 of e+e− annihilation data collected at a center-of-mass energy of 3.773 GeV with the BESIII detector operating at the BEPCII collider.

Mira: The signal decay channels ψ(3770) → γηc(1S, 2S) are reconstructed via ηc(1S, 2S) → K0SK±π∓.

Kai: This reconstruction benefits from a large branching fraction, high reconstruction efficiency, and a low combinatorial background level.

Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this discussion on "Improved search for psi(three thousand seven hundred seventy) to gamma eta c(1S, 2S) radiative transitions," what does it really mean for the field <ref:2609.33606#pg1>? The main thing is that they've managed to reduce those upper limits on the partial decay widths by about thirty and fifty percent compared to previous results.

Mira: That reduction is significant because it brings them closer to some of the theoretical predictions, specifically for psi three seven seventy zero into gamma eta c one S. The upper limit on that partial decay width is now within a one sigma range of calculations from lattice quantum chromodynamics and other models.

Lev: But they also found that the upper limit on the second transition, psi three seven seventy zero into gamma eta c two S, is about ten times larger than what some of those lattice calculations predict. It's significantly larger than what you get when you use the relativistic BS equation method with its large relativistic corrections.

Kai: So it’s a mixed message then. We have better constraints on one channel, but the other one is still quite open, or maybe that theoretical prediction for the second transition is just not quite matching what we see here.

Mira: Exactly. The paper shows that while the search method itself has improved, there's still a gap between what we measure and what some of our theoretical methods predict for those specific decay widths.

Lev: The limitation they state is that their uncertainty on the product branching fractions is quite large, with multiplicative uncertainties reaching up to sixty three point five percent. That means when you interpret those final numbers, you need to be very careful about how much weight you give them.

Kai: So, the paper is a solid step forward in the experimental side of things because they've pushed those limits down by a lot and provided concrete numbers for these specific transitions.

Mira: It’s not a complete solution, though. The paper clearly shows that the second transition limit is still quite high compared to what some established theoretical frameworks suggest for the eta c two S state.

Lev: The implication is that either we need better experimental sensitivity in those regions, or we need to refine our theoretical models for those specific decay widths.

Kai: So, in short, it’s an improvement on the search, but it highlights where the current theoretical understanding might still be incomplete regarding these radiative decays.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about improving how we look for two specific radiative transitions from the psi three seven seventy zero state to eta c one S and eta c two S states.

Mira: Yeah, they used a better data sample than before to set upper limits on those branching fractions and partial decay widths.

Lev: What did they actually do in terms of the experiment? Were there new detector settings or something?

Kai: They used twenty point three femtobarns of e plus e minus annihilation data from the BESIII detector at three point seven seven three giga electron volt with a center of mass energy.

Mira: And they reconstructed these decays by looking for eta c one S and eta c two S states decaying into kaon, sigma, and pion.

Lev: The reconstruction method uses charged tracks detected in the mdc to be within the polar angle range of less than zero point nine three cosine theta.

Kai: They modeled the signal using a probability density function that includes factors like e seven gamma times big omega of m times f d of e gamma times epsilon of m tensor G delta m sigma.

Mira: The background estimation used tools called topo ana to look at inclusive monte carlo samples, and they found four main sources for the background.

Lev: Those include psi three seven seventy zero decaying into d zero bar zero and e plus e minus annihilation into pi naught kaon sigma k plus minus pion minus.

Kai: They also accounted for the radiative tail of the psi three six eight six resonance, which is going to produce some peaking backgrounds in the signal regions.

Mira: The unbinned maximum likelihood fits gave statistical significances of one point one sigma for eta c one S and one point zero sigma for eta c two S.

Lev: Since they didn't see a significant signal for either state, they calculated ninety percent confidence level upper limits on the number of signal events.

Kai: Specifically, the upper limit on the product branching fractions is less than five point zero times ten to the minus six at ninety percent confidence level.

Mira: That means that for both channels, the upper limit on those partial decay widths are less than five point five kilo electron volt and twenty nine point four kilo electron volt respectively.

Lev: The upper limit on eta c one S is within one sigma of some calculations from lattice quantum chromodynamics and other models, but it's larger than what you get from the relativistic bs equation method that has large relativistic corrections.

Kai: And for eta c two S, the upper limit is about ten times larger than those lattice predictions and way bigger than what the relativistic bs equation method gives.

Mira: The total multiplicative uncertainty for those branching fractions is about thirteen point three percent and sixty three point five percent, so you have to be careful with how much weight you give those limits.

Lev: The main conclusion is that the search for these radiative transitions has improved over previous measurements because the upper limits on the partial decay widths are reduced by about thirty and fifty percent.

Kai: So, we have tighter constraints now on these specific decays, bringing them closer to what some of our theoretical calculations predict for eta c one S.

Mira: But as Lev mentioned, the limit on eta c two S is still quite high compared to those lattice calculations and other methods we've used.

Lev: It seems like either we need better experimental sensitivity in those regions or we need to refine the theoretical models for these specific decay widths.

More episodes

← Home