Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments

summary

The gist

Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments presents a combined analysis of atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande, IceCubeDeepCore…

This episode discusses

The paper

Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments · Read on arXiv

Miaochen Jin, Carlos A. Argüelles, Pablo Fernández-Menéndez, Iván Martínez-Soler

Department of Physics & Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Harvard University · Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Instituto Galego de Física de Altas Energías (IGFAE) · Departamento de Física Teórica, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid · Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology, Durham University

We present a combined analysis of the latest publicly available atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande including all data-taking stages previous to the gadolinium phase, IceCube-DeepCore, and the six-detection-unit configuration of KM3NeT/ORCA. Our fit uses all event samples simultaneously and treats the systematic uncertainties shared among experiments as fully correlated, while detector-response uncertainties are modeled independently for each experiment. The combined data constrain the atmospheric oscillation parameters to Δm 2 31 = 2.44+0.06-0.04 times 10-3, eV squared and 2θ 23 = 0.52+0.03-0.04, with a precision of 2.2% and 6.1%, respectively, which is competitive with current accelerator-based measurements, and independently constrain the CP-violating phase to δ CP = 1.30+0.24-0.28 π. Finally, comparing the orderings of the neutrino mass spectrum, we find a preference for the normal ordering with Δχ squared = 11.0; further calibrated with pseudoexperiments, we exclude the inverted ordering at 99.95% confidence level (3.3σ). In a joint fit including 207 days of JUNO data, we further exclude the inverted ordering at Δχ squared = 15.1, corresponding to 3.9 σ.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments presents a combined analysis of atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande, IceCubeDeepCore, and KM3NeT/ORCA6 to constrain oscillation parameters and determine the neutrino mass ordering The combined data constrains the atmospheric oscillation parameters to ∆m231 = 2.44+0.06−0.04 ×10−3eV2 and sin2θ23 = 0.52+0.03−- - - -, with a precision of 2.2% and 6.1%, respectively, which is competitive with current accelerator-based measurements The combined fit yields a good description of the three experiments data within the three-flavor neutrino scenario Combined Experimental Data Set The analysis combines publicly available atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande in all its data-taking stages, the latest IceCubeDeepCore data release, and the six-detection-unit configuration of KM3NeT/ORCA6 The fit uses all event samples simultaneously and treats the systematic uncertainties shared among experiments as fully correlated, while detector-response uncertainties are modeled independently for each experiment This approach is analogous to the one introduced in Refs.

10, 39: and is described in Section III The combination of the three experiments yields a precise determination of the atmospheric mass splitting, ∆m231 = 2.44 × 10−3eV2, with a relative precision of 2.2%, comparable to the ∼ 1% precision reached by long-baseline experiments Oscillation Parameter Constraints The combined analysis yields measurements of ∆m231 and sin2θ23 that are competitive with accelerator-based results The best-fit value of the CP-violating phase is δCP = 1.30π+0.24π−0.28π, consistent with combined long-baseline results Regarding the mass ordering, the fit finds a preference for NO with ∆χ2 = 11.0, and in this case where Wilks’ theorem does not apply, it is calibrated to 3.3σ using pseudoexperiments Mass Ordering Determination The combined atmospheric data find 3.32σ evidence for the normal ordering, a preference that arises coherently from the Earth’s matter effects in three detectors with different media, systematics, and analysis chains The joint fit with JUNO data further strengthens the exclusion of the inverted mass ordering, reaching a significance of 3.9σ The normal ordering looms large over the neutrino community Joint Analysis and Future Prospects The combination of atmospheric neutrino data with recent JUNO results yields a preference for normal ordering (NO) at ∆χ2 = 4.1, corresponding to a significance of 2.0σ after calibration with pseudoexperiments When the atmospheric and JUNO data are included in a joint fit, the preference for NO increases to ∆χ2NMO = 15.1, corresponding to a significance of 3.9σ The normal ordering looms large over the neutrino community Its determination is highly relevant for the next generation of long-baseline experiments, such as DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande Systematic Uncertainty Impact The correlated treatment of the flux uncertainties tightens the combined 1σ interval by 9% in sin2θ23 and by 19% in ∆m231 relative to a trivial χ2 sum The correlated treatment is not an ornament: it improves the constraint on sin2θ23 and δCP over a naive combination of published likelihoods, because the high-statistics samples of each experiment anchor the flux and cross-section parameters for all of them The combined atmospheric data find 3.32σ evidence for the normal ordering, a preference that arises coherently from the Earth’s matter effects in three detectors with different media, systematics, and analysis chains The normal ordering looms large over the neutrino community Its determination is highly relevant for the next generation of long-baseline experiments, such as DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande Acknowledgments We thank Thomas Wester and the SuperKamiokande Collaboration for discussions and help CAA are supported by the Faculty of Arts and Sciences of Harvard University, Canadian Institute for Advanced Research (CIFAR), the National Science Foundation (NSF), the John Templeton Foundation, the Research Corporation for Science Advancement, and the David & Lucile Packard Foundation PFM is supported by RYC2024-049537-I, funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by ESF+ IMS was supported by RYC2024-050360-I, funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13.

Mira: 9/ESF+, and by grant PID25-172338NB-I00 funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13 and ERDF,EU MJ is funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF) CAREER Award 2239795 CODE AVAILABILITY AND AI POLICY The central PyNu software is public at

65: The Monte Carlo simulation of SK can be downloaded from

94: AI tools has been used in the development of this work in manuscript preparation, plot styling, code improvement and editing with human supervision and verification, based on central ideas and content developed by the authors References

1: P.

Kai: Lipari, Atmospheric Neutrinos: from the pioneering experiments to IMB and Kamiokande, in International Conference on History of the Neutrino: 1930-2018 (2018)

5: Y.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments" and the authors are Miaochen Jin, Carlos A. Argüelles, Pablo Fernández-Menéndez, and Iván Martínez-Soler. Would you say that title makes sense when you hear it out loud?

Mira: Yeah, it's pretty direct. It tells you exactly what they did: they combined atmospheric neutrino experiments to look for the normal neutrino ordering. It sounds like a solid piece of work aiming for a firm conclusion on something fundamental in particle physics.

Lev: I'm thinking about the methodology right now. They mention using Super-Kamiokande, IceCubeDeepCore, and KM3NeT/ORCA6 data simultaneously, treating the shared systematic uncertainties as fully correlated. That’s a big ask for any combined analysis to pull off.

Kai: Exactly. It's not just throwing data together; it’s about how they handle those shared systematics across different detectors and media, which is crucial for getting a clean result on the mass ordering.

Mira: And what this paper promises is that by doing this combined fit, they can constrain the oscillation parameters m two thirty-one and two theta twenty-three to be competitive with results from accelerator experiments.

Lev: That comparison is key for me. If their constraints on those mixing angles are good enough, it means the underlying three-flavor neutrino scenario they're testing is robust across different experimental setups.

Kai: Right, so we’re seeing a synthesis of data from different detection technologies to narrow down the possibilities for neutrino mass ordering based on these oscillation parameters.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now, looking at the summary section of "Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments," it lays out that they used all publicly available atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande, the IceCubeDeepCore release, and the KM3NeT/ORCA6 six-detection-unit configuration.

Mira: They emphasize that the fit uses all event samples at once and treats those shared systematic uncertainties as fully correlated, while keeping detector response uncertainties separate for each experiment. That’s a specific way they handled their analysis that they compare to previous methods in Refs. ten thirty-nine <ref:2610.12208#pg2>.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, treating flux and cross-section uncertainties as correlated across experiments is smart because those are often the biggest shared sources of error when combining datasets from different detectors.

Kai: So, the core message is that this comprehensive analysis yields a precise determination of the atmospheric mass splitting m two thirty-one at two point four four times ten-three eV squared, with a relative precision of two point two percent.

Mira: And they also get a value for two theta twenty-three at zero point five two plus or minus something, with a relative precision of six point one percent. They claim these results are competitive with accelerator-based measurements, which is significant because it validates the atmospheric data's utility here.

Lev: Competitiveness is good, but we need to look at how that relates to the mass ordering preference they find. The summary mentions a preference for NO with chi squared = eleven point zero, calibrated at three point three sigma using pseudoexperiments when Wilks' theorem doesn't strictly apply in that specific case.

Kai: So, the takeaway from this summary is that the combined data provides a good description of the three-flavor neutrino scenario, and it points toward a preference for the normal ordering based on those initial statistical tests.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Moving into how they improved things, the paper highlights several methodological enhancements. One big thing is that by treating flux uncertainties as fully correlated across experiments, they tighten the combined one sigma interval for two theta twenty-three by nine percent.

Lev: That improvement in two theta twenty-three sounds promising <ref:2610.12208#pg1>. It means their constraint on that mixing angle isn't just based on a simple sum of individual experiment errors; the shared flux parameters are really anchoring the uncertainty down.

Kai: They also improved the constraint on m two thirty-one tightening it by nineteen percent relative to a trivial chi squared sum. That suggests that their correlated treatment of systematics is not just an academic exercise but genuinely improves the statistical power of the result.

Mira: And they specifically discuss how modeling detector response uncertainties independently for each experiment while sharing flux and cross-section systematics is a robust approach, which they link back to previous work in Refs. ten thirty-nine <ref:2610.12208#pg2>.

Lev: That separation—model detector response locally but share the global flux parameters—is exactly what you need when you're building real hardware. You want the core physics signal clean, and that’s what this structure seems to achieve for extrapolating to future detectors like SK-Gd or JUNO.

Kai: So, they've refined their treatment of model dependence by explicitly modeling detector response differently while keeping the flux systematics unified across all three facilities.

Conclusion: Mira: So, wrapping up on the conclusion of "Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments," the paper finds three point three two sigma evidence for the normal ordering <ref:2610.12208#pg1,Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments>. They say this preference comes coherently from Earth's matter effects in three detectors with different media and analysis chains.

Lev: That coherence across those very different experimental setups is what gives that three point three two sigma weight, even though the individual results might have been weaker on their own <ref:2610.12208#pg1>. It’s about the consistency of the overall picture they constructed.

Kai: And then they mention that their joint fit with JUNO data further strengthens this exclusion of the inverted mass ordering, reaching a significance of three point nine sigma <ref:2610.12208#pg1>. That joint analysis is definitely where things get interesting for future experiments like DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande.

Mira: It seems the main message is that the normal ordering looms large over the neutrino community right now based on this atmospheric data, even when you factor in JUNO results.

Lev: For my work, it means when we look at running simulations for real hardware like DUNE or Hyper-Kamiokande, we need to use these constraints—the preference for NO and the measured m two thirty-one —as our baseline expectation before we start looking at new physics effects.

Kai: So, this paper, "Evidence for Normal Neutrino Ordering with Combined Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments," gives us a strong statistical handle on the mass ordering right now.

Mira: It’s a significant step in using atmospheric neutrino data to guide the next generation of long-baseline experiments.

More episodes

← Home