Daily Summary for 2026-11-08
daily
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: It's the eighth of November, twenty twenty-six, and this is the day's research.
Mira: 6 new papers came out today.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We'll take the day in one pass, then pull out the papers we're staying with.
Mira: Start us off with Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer.
The day's research: Kai: We are looking for new physics signals from particle collisions, especially dark matter and supersymmetric particles. What specific searches are driving this?
Mira: The key is combining searches for a protophobic vector boson with dark photon and axion-like particle signatures at the FASER experiment. This points to a 17 MeV particle.
Lev: Combining the dark photon search from Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer with constraints on a Long-Lived X17 Vector Boson with FASER helps exclude electron couplings up to three times ten to four for this 17 MeV boson.
Kai: So the low-coupling window for the protophobic explanation of the X17 is effectively ruled out by those combined FASER results.
Mira: That exclusion stems from interpreting a null result in the dark photon search, combined with an ALP search seeing one event consistent with neutrino background.
Lev: Indeed, Constraints on a Long-Lived X17 Vector Boson with FASER uses those null results to exclude that low-coupling window for the protophobic model of the X17 particle.
Kai: What about direct production searches for supersymmetric particles at thirteen teraelectron volts?
Mira: Search for supersymmetric particle pair production in final states with two oppositely charged leptons and large missing transverse momentum in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13 TeV looks for charginos, top squarks, and sleptons.
Lev: The CMS collaboration found no excess over Standard Model predictions, setting upper limits on production cross sections for these supersymmetric particles.
Kai: For example, they established an exclusion region for chargino production up to masses of eleven hundred twenty GeV and neutralino masses around four hundred ninety GeV under simplified R-parity conserving models.
Mira: The study of the up-down asymmetry in B plus to K plus pi plus gamma decay provides a model-dependent estimate in the mass region around one point one to one point three gigaelectron volts per c squared.
Lev: That study involves constructing a hadronic current using models for K1 1270 amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays and calculating the averaged up-down asymmetry using Monte Carlo methods.
Kai: The measured asymmetry is significantly below expected values when assuming a specific parameter for lambda gamma equal to one.
Mira: We are also looking at Experimental Searches for Muon to Electron Conversion in Nuclei Charged lepton flavor violation probed by muon to electron conversion.
Lev: CELEBI introduces an analysis-management framework that maintains a persistent connection between evolving analysis materials and their generated results.
Kai: The search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer demonstrates the use of a superconducting mixer for direct searches for dark photon dark matter in the meV mass range.
Mira: Search for supersymmetric particle pair production in final states with two oppositely charged leptons and large missing transverse momentum in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13 TeV was conducted for direct production of pairs of supersymmetric particles in final states featuring a pair of oppositely charged leptons and large missing transverse momentum.
Lucky paper: 2611.02734: Kai: We’re diving into Search for dark photon dark matter near one meV using a superconducting mixer. So, what exactly are we looking for here?
Mira: They are searching for a direct signal of dark photon dark matter in the meV mass range, and they used a superconducting mixer to do it.
Lev: The search focused on DPDM masses between one point zero zero four seven five seven eight and one point zero zero four seven five nine eight meV, which corresponds to frequencies around two hundred forty-two point nine four nine three five to two hundred forty-two point nine four nine eight three gigahertz.
Kai: And what was the outcome of that specific search band? Did they find anything significant?
Mira: No significant excess was found in that search band, and they set upper limits on the coupling constant chi less than one point six to one point nine times ten to nine at the ninety-five percent confidence level.
Lev: The methodology involved using a cryogenic millimeter-wave receiver based on a superconducting mixer, where the LO frequency was set to two hundred thirty-five gigahertz to down-convert signals above one hundred gigahertz to an intermediate frequency around ten gigahertz.
Kai: That sounds complex, so what's the main uncertainty they had in setting those upper limits?
Mira: The total systematic uncertainty in chi was estimated from several sources, with the biggest contribution coming from the effective aperture area uncertainty being two point four percent.
Lev: Other significant uncertainties included gain at two point nine percent and low signal bias leakage less than zero point one percent, and dark matter density at three point eight percent.
Kai: So even accounting for all that noise, what does this mean for the search right now?
Mira: The results show that SIS-mixer receivers are a promising platform for direct DPDM searches in the meV mass range.
Lev: Future searches plan to improve sensitivity by adding a parabolic focusing mirror to collect more conversion photons, which is expected to increase the effective aperture area by about three thousand eight hundred times.
Kai: So if they make those upgrades, what's the target sensitivity they are aiming for?
Mira: Developing a broadband spectrometer will allow them to scan a wide frequency range efficiently, and this combination is expected to achieve a sensitivity of chi less than three point nine times ten to twelve over a broad DPDM mass range from zero point seven meV up to one point one meV.
Lev: That would mean measurements on an eight gigahertz band for each day would be used in that broadband setup.
Lucky paper: 2611.03904: Kai: So, we're diving into Constraints on a Long-Lived Xseventeen Vector Boson with FASER. Where does this research start in terms of the physics motivation?
Mira: The ATOMKI anomalies motivate looking for a new particle, the Xseventeen which has a mass of seventeen MeV and weak couplings to nuclei and electrons. This paper is essentially combining searches for that particle using the FASER experiment.
Lev: The core idea here is combining the dark photon search from Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer with the ALP search from Constraints on a Long-Lived Xseventeen Vector Boson with FASER.
Kai: And what does that combination actually exclude?
Mira: It excludes electron couplings in the range of two times ten to eight to three times ten to four for that seventeen MeV boson.
Lev: So while there are still two regions of parameter space left open, the low-coupling window for a protophobic explanation of the Xseventeen is effectively ruled out by these combined FASER results.
Kai: That’s significant because it narrows down what we can expect to see at future experiments.
Mira: Exactly, and it comes from interpreting a null result in the dark photon search and combining it with an ALP search that saw one event consistent with neutrino background.
Lev: Furthermore, Constraints on a Long-Lived Xseventeen Vector Boson with FASER uses those null results to exclude the low-coupling window for this protophobic model of the Xseventeen particle.
Kai: Moving on to direct production, what kind of supersymmetric particles are they looking for at thirteen teraelectron volts?
Mira: They are searching for pairs of charginos, top squarks, and sleptons in proton-proton collisions where you see a pair of opposite-charged leptons along with large missing transverse momentum.
Lev: The CMS collaboration found no excess over the Standard Model predictions in that data set, which led to setting upper limits on the production cross sections for those supersymmetric particles.
Kai: Can you give us a concrete limit on what they found?
Mira: They established an exclusion region for chargino production extending up to masses of eleven hundred twenty GeV and neutralino masses around four hundred ninety GeV under simplified R-parity conserving models.
Lev: Now let's look at the B plus to K plus pi plus gamma decay study in Study of the up-down asymmetry in B+ to K+ pi++gamma using K1(one thousand two hundred seventy) → Kππ amplitude models constrained by semileptonic D Decays. What does that involve technically?
Kai: It involves constructing a hadronic current using models for K1 one thousand two hundred seventy amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D Decays and calculating the averaged up-down asymmetry using Monte Carlo methods.
Mira: That study provides a model-dependent estimate of this asymmetry in the mass region around one point one to one point three gigaelectron volts per c squared.
Lev: The measured asymmetry is significantly below the expected value when assuming a specific parameter for lambda gamma equal to one, which shows tension with the theory.
Kai: So it suggests that whatever is happening there isn't as strong as some initial models predicted.
Mira: We also have experimental searches for muon to electron conversion in nuclei charged lepton flavor violation, which probes this process where a negatively charged muon bound in a muonic atom converts into an electron while conserving total lepton number.
Lev: For background studies, CELEBI introduces an analysis-management framework that maintains a persistent connection between evolving analysis materials and their generated results.
Kai: It sounds like you're covering the experimental side now; what about the production mechanisms for that X boson? How does it actually get made?
Mira: The differential cross section for X production in proton bremsstrahlung can be written as dsigma dzdp2T equals epsilon2n sigma ns dpp(s prime) w(z, p2T).
Lev: The interference term is included, so that w F two equals w one F one two plus w two F two two plus w one, two Re of F one F star two. This also explains why X can be produced in proton bremsstrahlung because both form factors are non-zero for mX greater than zero and therefore allow efficient production through proton bremsstrahlung.
Kai: That’s a specific mathematical detail about how the production happens. Does that mean it's not just coming from simple collisions?
Mira: No, it means it can come from proton bremsstrahlung because the form factors are non-zero when the mass X is greater than zero.
Lev: The FASER detector itself is located approximately four hundred eighty m downstream of IP1 in the TI12 tunnel that used to connect the LHC with the Super Proton Synchrotron, and its decay volume and tracking spectrometer are immersed in a zero point five seven T magnetic field.
Kai: So it’s physically placed far away from the main collision point, which makes sense for this kind of search.
Mira: If the decay happens within that decay volume, the resulting e plus e minus produces a pair of charged tracks in the spectrometer, making it a candidate for dark photon search.
Lev: Alternatively, if it decays downstream of that volume, the event becomes a candidate for the axion-like particle search.
Kai: So we have two different signatures depending on where the particle decays relative to that detector setup.
Mira: Exactly, and FASER observed no events in that signal region for the ALP search, which was based on fifty seven point seven fb minus one of data, comprising both searches and additional data from twenty twenty-three.
Lev: The ATOMKI anomalies are some of the most tantalizing anomalies in particle physics, and this work shows that the combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches excludes electron couplings in the range two times ten to eight to three times ten to four for a protophobic vector boson of mass mX equal to seventeen MeV.
Kai: So, the main conclusion is that they've ruled out a large part of that specific low-coupling possibility.
Mira: That means the low-coupling window for a protophobic explanation of the Xseventeen is excluded by existing FASER data, leaving only the high-coupling window as a viable possibility.
Lev: The reach at high couplings is limited by the decreasing X boson lifetime, but also because the signal production rate scales proportional to epsilon squared, leading to a lower bound of around epsilon equal to two times ten to five for that seventeen MeV mass.
Lucky paper: 2611.03035: Kai: So we're looking at the study of the up-down asymmetry in B plus to K plus pi plus gamma using K one one thousand two hundred seventy amplitudes constrained by semileptonic D decays, Lev, what's the main puzzle here?
Mira: The main puzzle is that there is an observed up-down asymmetry H bar ud of zero point zero nine two to a point zero two three when assuming lambda gamma equals one.
Lev: That result is significant because the measured asymmetry in that mass region around one point one to one point three gigaelectron volts per c squared is significantly below the expected value when you assume lambda gamma equals one.
Kai: So that means there's a tension between what they measure and what the standard model predicts under those specific assumptions.
Mira: The paper notes that directly extracting photon polarization from this up-down asymmetry Aud is hard because of this hadronic factor H bar ud, which involves the imaginary part of the dot product of the polarization vector with the cross product of two currents.
Lev: To find that hadronic factor, they need detailed knowledge of the K one one thousand two hundred seventy to K pi plus pi-pi gamma current, including all its intermediate amplitudes and their relative phases.
Kai: That sounds like a lot of complex modeling just to figure out the uncertainty on one measurement.
Lev: They define the hadronic current J as a coherent sum of quasi two body amplitudes J mu, where J is the spatial part in the K one rest frame, and they consider states like rho seven hundred seventy K star eight hundred ninety-two omega seven hundred eighty-two and the K pi S wave.
Mira: They use a Gounaris-Sakurai model for the lineshapes of that rho seven hundred seventy resonance.
Kai: So they're using these specific hadronic models to try and build this current for calculating the asymmetry.
Lev: The average up-down asymmetry, A bar ud, is related to that hadronic factor H bar ud by a formula involving three over four times lambda gamma and H bar ud itself, which depends on the four body phase space evaluated using Monte Carlo methods.
Mira: They estimate statistical uncertainty by running one thousand alternative calculations where the complex couplings gr and the K one lineshape are varied according to their covariance matrix.
Kai: The paper also looks at potential tails from other excited kaon states, like K one one thousand four hundred to see if that can reduce the tension between the estimated and expected H bar ud values.
Lev: They revise the hadronic current J tot by adding a contribution from K one one thousand four hundred using its coupling to rho eight hundred ninety two, which lets them do a two dimensional scan over the relative phase phi and the fit fraction F FK one one thousand four hundred.
Mira: Introducing that K one one thousand four hundred contribution could significantly reduce the tension between estimated and expected H bar ud, especially for alternative models I and II where they find H bar ud values up to zero point zero six within F FK one one thousand four hundred less than thirty percent.
Lucky paper: 2611.02183: Kai: Okay, we're moving on to the search for supersymmetric particle pair production at thirteen teraelectron volts at this CMS collaboration paper. What exactly did they look for?
Mira: They were looking for direct production of pairs of supersymmetric particles in final states featuring a pair of oppositely charged leptons, which could be electrons or muons, along with large missing transverse momentum.
Lev: The analysis used proton-proton collision data at sqrt s = thirteen TeV with an integrated luminosity of one hundred thirty-eight fb minus one recorded by the CMS detector at CERN LHC.
Kai: And what was the main finding from that search strategy? Did they see any excess over the Standard Model predictions?
Mira: The analysis revealed no excess over the Standard Model predictions in the observed data, which led to setting upper limits on production cross sections for chargino, top squark, and slepton pair production.
Lev: They established an exclusion region for chargino production extending up to masses of one thousand one hundred twenty GeV and neutralino masses around four hundred ninety GeV under simplified R-parity conserving models.
Kai: That’s a pretty specific range for the chargino mass; how does that compare to what we might expect from some of the simpler theories?
Mira: Regarding top squark pair production, for mass splittings between the lighter top squark and the neutralino ranging from the W boson mass to the top quark mass, they excluded top squark masses up to five hundred minus five hundred forty GeV.
Lev: They also excluded slepton masses up to seven hundred GeV under the assumption of a massless neutralino in that analysis.
Kai: So it’s not just one search channel; they looked for chargino, top squark, and slepton pair production simultaneously by defining search regions based on lepton flavor and missing transverse momentum.
Mira: They performed a simultaneous binned maximum likelihood fit to extract the signal across those three process classes to set upper limits at ninety-five percent confidence level.
Lev: The paper details how they interpreted these upper limits as exclusion regions in the plane defined by the masses of the promptly produced supersymmetric particle and the lightest neutralino.
Kai: Does this mean that under these simplified mass spectra, we can rule out certain mass ranges for these particles?
Mira: Yes, when three slepton generations were assumed to be degenerate, they excluded chargino masses up to one thousand one hundred twenty GeV for a massless neutralino and neutralino masses up to four hundred ninety GeV for a chargino mass around eight hundred twenty GeV.
Lev: That result hinges on the assumption of simplified mass spectra, which is something the authors explicitly state.
More episodes
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2512.21290-Model-independent ZH production cross section at FCC-ee
- 2610.21982-First Observation of the Radiative Decay D 0 to gamma omega
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2512.08065-Searches for Light Dark Matter and Evidence of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering of Solar Neutrinos with the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Experiment
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2508.18022-Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider
- 2512.23992-Prospect for measurement of CP-violating parameters of B s 0 to phi gamma at the Tera Z factory