Constraints on a Long-Lived X17 Vector Boson with FASER

summary

The gist

The combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches excludes electron couplings in the range 2 × 10−8 <ϵe < 3 × 10−4 for a protophobic vector boson of mass mX = 17 MeV…

In short

Searches for a 17 MeV protophobic vector boson (X17) motivated by ATOMKI anomalies using FASER data combined with ALP searches. The combination excludes low-coupling electron couplings ($ ext{2} imes ext{10}^{-8} < ext{εe} < ext{3} imes ext{10}^{-4}$), leaving only the high-coupling window viable for this particle.

Key concepts

ATOMKI Anomaly
These are puzzling observations in low-energy physics that suggest a new particle, X17 with a mass of 17 MeV and weak couplings to nuclei and electrons. This anomaly motivates the search for this specific hypothetical particle.
Protophobic Vector Boson Model
This model describes the X boson as a massive spin-1 gauge boson that couples non-chirally to Standard Model fermions. To explain anomalies without violating constraints on pion decays, it assumes a strict protophobic limit where proton couplings are zero.
FASER Search Combination
The study combines results from FASER's dark photon search and ALP search. Null results from both searches, when interpreted as the X17 particle, constrain its possible electron couplings based on the expected background noise in each channel.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Constraints on a Long-Lived X17 Vector Boson with FASER · Read on arXiv

Roshan Mammen Abraham, Xiaocong Ai, Saul Alonso Monsalve, John Anders, Emma Kate Anderson, Akitaka Ariga, Tomoko Ariga, Jeremy Atkinson, Florian U. Bernlochner, Jianming Bian, Tobias Boeckh, Eliot Bornand, Jamie Boyd, Lydia Brenner, Angela Burger, Franck Cadoux, Haichuan Cao, Roberto Cardella, David W. Casper Charlotte Cavanagh Shiyang Chen Xin Chen Xing Cheng Dhruv Chouhan Emily Chown Andrea Coccaro Fabio Cufino Stephane Déebieux Ansh Desai Sergey Dmitrievsky Radu Dobre Monica D’Onofrio Sinead Eley Yannick Favre Carlo Alberto Fenoglio Didier Ferrere Max Fieg Wissal Filali Elena Firu Haruhi Fujimori Edward Galantay Stephen Gibson Sergio Gonzalez-Sevilla Yuri Gornushkin Yotam Granov Jinjing Gu Carl Gwilliam Elie Hammou Daiki Hayakawa Michael Holzbock Shih-Chieh Hsu Tomohiro Inada Luca Iodice Sune Jakobsen Cesar Jesus-Valls Arash Jofrehei Enrique Kajomovitz Alex Keyken Daniela Köck Jelle Koorn Umut Kose Peter Krack Susanne Kuehn Lorne Levinson Botao Li Jiaxi Liu Yi Liu Joern Mahlstedt Toni Mäkelń Yasuhiro Maruya Anna Mascellani Lawson McCoy Josh McFayden Andrea Pizarro Medina Hiroaki Menjo Toshiyuki Nakano Laurie Nevay Ken Ohashi Hidetoshi Otono Lorenzo Paolozzi Annabelle Parry Pawan Pawan Brian Petersen Titi Preda Markus Prim Junkai Qin Michaela Queitsch-Maitland Juan Rojo Hiroki Rokujo André Rubbia Osamu Sato Cristiano Sebastiani Anna Sfyrla Davide Sgalaberna Mansoora Shamim Yosuke Takubo Kakeru Tanaka Simon Thor Eric Torrence Serhan Tufanli Oscar Ivan Valdes Martinez Svetlana Vasina Emanuele Villa Benedikt Vormwald Chi Wang Yuxiao Wang Eli Welch Aaron White Monika Wielers Benjamin James Wilson Zhongyi Wu Yue Xu Heng Yang Lekai Yao Daichi Yoshikawa Shunliang Zhang Yuxuan Zhang Xingyu Zhao and Zijian Zhao, orgs_list_1, orgs_list_2, brief

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Irvine · School of Physics, Zhengzhou University · Institute for Particle Physics, ETH Zurich · University of Liverpool · CERN · Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics Laboratory for High Energy Physics at the University of Bern Department of Physics at Chiba University Kyushu University Universität Bonn Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics L2IT Université de Toulouse CNRS/IN2P3 Department of Physics Tsinghua University University of Manchester School of Physics and Astronomy INFN Sezione di Genova University of Oregon Weizmann Institute of Science Nagoya University Particle Physics Department and Astrophysics Weizmann Institute of Science Department of Physics & Astronomy University of Sussex Nagoya University Dipartimento di Fisica Ettore Pancini Universita di Napoli Federico II National Institute of Technology KOSEN STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory Royal Holloway University London

The ATOMKI anomalies motivate the possibility of a new particle, the X17, with a mass of 17 MeV and weak couplings to nuclei and electrons. Such a particle may be produced at the LHC, travel 480 m in the far-forward direction, and decay to e+e- in FASER. In this paper, previous FASER searches for dark photons and axion-like particles (ALPs) are combined and interpreted as searches for a candidate X17 particle, the protophobic vector boson. The searches use data collected from pp collisions at sqrt s = 13.6 TeV in LHC Run 3 from 2022 for the dark photon search and from 2022-2023 for the ALP search. No excess events are found above the expected background, and the combined null results exclude a previously-unconstrained "low-coupling window" with electron coupling 6 times 10-5 < ε e < 1.2 times 10-4. A "high-coupling window" remains.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Constraints on a Long-Lived X17 Vector Boson with FASER".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches excludes electron couplings in the range 2 × 10−8 <ϵe < 3 × 10−4 for a protophobic vector boson of mass mX = 17 MeV, leaving only the high-coupling window as a viable possibility ATOMKI Anomaly Motivation The ATOMKI anomalies motivate the possibility of a new particle, the X17, with a mass of 17 MeV and weak couplings to nuclei and electrons This particle may be produced at the LHC, travel 480 m in the far-forward direction, and decay to e+e− in FASER Previous FASER searches for dark photons and axion-like particles (ALPs) are combined and interpreted as searches for a candidate X17 particle, the protophobic vector boson Protophobic Vector Boson Model The X boson is a massive spin-1 Abelian gauge boson that couples non-chirally to Standard Model fermions with chargesϵf in units of e To allow the X couplings to be large enough to explain the ATOMKI anomalies without violating stringent constraints on exotic pion decays π0 → Xγ, ϵp must be smaller than ϵn by an order of magnitude In this work, the strict protophobic limit, where ϵp = 0, will be assumed, and hence ϵd = −2ϵu Subsequent research revealed additional constraints arising from rare charged-pion decays

26: Avoiding them, while explaining the anomaly, requires adding both small proton and axial-vector couplings

18: FASER Search Combination The paper combines the dark photon search from Ref.

23: and the ALP search from Ref.

24: , and interprets these null results as searches for the protophobic vector boson FASER’s Dark Photon Search observed no events in this signal region, consistent with the total expected background of (2.3 ± 2.3 (tot.)) × 10−3 events FASER’s ALP Search observed one event in the signal region, consistent with the expected neutrino background of 0.44 ± 0.39 (tot.) events Exclusion Results The resulting exclusion in the (mX,ϵe) plane is shown in the left panel of Fig.

Kai: 2 FASER excludes the low-coupling window by showing that for a potential 17 MeV vector boson, this analysis completely excludes the low-coupling window, leaving only the high-coupling window as a viable region of parameter space This work shows that the combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches excludes electron couplings in the range 2 × 10−8 <ϵe < 3 × 10−4 for a protophobic vector boson of mass mX = 17 MeV Consequently, the low-coupling window for a protophobic explanation of the X17 is excluded by existing FASER data, leaving only the high-coupling window as a viable possibility Systematic Uncertainties The dominant experimental uncertainties arise from the modeling of the detector response in the Monte-Carlo simulation The uncertainty associated with the damping factor was found to be dominant in the region of interest, accounting for approximately a 40% uncertainty on the total signal production Production Mechanisms The differential cross section for X production in proton bremsstrahlung can be written as dσ dzdp2T=ϵ2n σnsdpp(s′) w(z, p2T) The interference term is included, so that wF2 = w1F12 + w2F22 + w1,2Re(F1F∗ 2) This also explains why X can be produced in proton bremsstrahlung: although F1(0) = 0 by construction, both form factors are non-zero for mX > 0 and, therefore, allow efficient production through proton bremsstrahlung FASER Detector Description The FASER detector is located approximately 480 m downstream of IP1 in the TI12 tunnel that used to connect the LHC with the Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) The decay volume and tracking spectrometer are immersed in a 0.57 T magnetic field, bending charged-particle trajectories in the vertical direction Search Signatures If the decay occurs within the decay volume, the resulting e+e− produces a pair of charged tracks in the spectrometer, making the event a candidate for the dark photon search Alternatively, if the decay occurs downstream of the decay volume, the event becomes a candidate for the axion-like particle (ALP) search FASER observed no events in this signal region, consistent with the total expected background of (2.3 ± 2.3 (tot.)) × 10−3 events The ALP search utilized 57.7 fb−1 of data, comprising the dataset used in the dark photon search, as well as additional data collected in 2023

24: The ATOMKI anomalies are some of the most tantalizing anomalies in particle physics A protophobic vector boson has been proposed as a possible explanation of the observed excess, with the current experimental constraints leaving two regions of parameter space with potentially viable couplings This work shows that the combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches excludes electron couplings in the range 2 × 10−8 <ϵe < 3 × 10−4 for a protophobic vector boson of mass mX = 17 MeV Consequently, the low-coupling window for a protophobic explanation of the X17 is excluded by existing FASER data, leaving only the high-coupling window as a viable possibility Acknowledgments We thank CERN for the excellent performance of the LHC and the technical and administrative staff members at all FASER institutions for their contributions to the success of the FASER experiment We thank the ATLAS Collaboration for providing us with accurate luminosity estimates for the Run 3 LHC pp collision data We also thank the CERN STI group for providing detailed FLUKA simulations of the muon fluence along the LOS This work was supported in part by Heising-Simons Foundation Grant Nos.

Paper summary: Kai: To build on that, the paper "Constraints on a Long-Lived Xseventeen Vector Boson with FASER" lays out exactly how they did this combination of searches. They take the null results from the previous dark photon and ALP searches and interpret them through the lens of this protophobic vector boson model >

Mira: The thesis is that if you assume this X boson couples non-chirally to Standard Model fermions with charges epsilon f, and we set a strict protophobic limit where the proton coupling is zero, then we get specific constraints on electron couplings >

Lev: Specifically, they assume the neutron coupling is twice the up quark coupling and subtract that from the proton coupling to define the electron and down quark couplings based on that model >

Kai: They then look at what this means for experimental reach. They find that in their setup, FASER observed no events in this signal region for dark photons, consistent with the expected background of two point three plus or minus two point three times one to the power negative three events > <ref:2611.03904#pg1>

Mira: And they also note that the ALP search observed one event in its signal region, which is consistent with some expected neutrino background of zero point four four plus or minus zero point three nine times one to the power negative three events >

Lev: The way they combine these null results is what drives the exclusion. They plot this out in a two dimensional plane where you have the mass of X and its electron coupling, epsilon e >

Kai: And the key finding is that this combination of searches excludes electron couplings between two times ten to the power negative eight and three times ten to the power negative four for a protophobic vector boson with a mass of mX equal to seventeen MeV > <ref:2611.03904#pg1>

Mira: So, while they haven't found the particle, they have strongly constrained where it could be hiding in terms of its electron coupling strength given what FASER measured >

Lev: The main caveat here is that this exclusion relies on a strict assumption about the proton coupling being zero, which is part of their protophobic limit >

Kai: Right. It shows that the low-coupling window for this specific explanation of the Xseventeen is effectively closed off by existing FASER data >

Mira: It also points towards the high-coupling window as being a more likely place to find this particle, given these current constraints >

Lev: So what’s next for them? They are essentially saying that if you want to explain the ATOMKI anomalies with this model, you probably need a stronger coupling than they just ruled out >

Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up this paper "Constraints on a Long-Lived Xseventeen Vector Boson with FASER," the authors are essentially using the combination of FASER dark photon and ALP searches to place hard boundaries on the parameter space for their proposed Xseventeen particle >

Mira: They’re confirming that for a protophobic vector boson with mass of seventeen MeV, existing experimental data excludes electron couplings in the range from two times ten to the power negative eight up to three times ten to the power negative four > <ref:2611.03904#pg1>

Lev: The implication for us is that if this Xseventeen is indeed what’s causing those ATOMKI anomalies, we should probably be focusing our efforts on finding a high-coupling scenario >

Kai: Precisely. They are narrowing down the possibilities from a wide range to just one region of viability based on current data >

Mira: So they are suggesting that the low-coupling window for explaining the Xseventeen anomaly is now excluded by FASER, leaving only the high-coupling window as a possible option >

Lev: It’s an important step because it tells us where to look next for experimental confirmation of this particle hypothesis >

More episodes

← Home