Calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution of small-radius jets using semileptonic t t bar events with the ATLAS detector

summary

The gist

A measurement of correction factors for the hadronic jet energy scale (JES) and resolution in the ATLAS detector is presented…

In short

This study measures correction factors for jet energy scale (JES) and resolution using semileptonic top quark pair production events at ATLAS. By analyzing how different JES or JER assumptions shift the reconstructed W boson mass distribution, researchers extracted optimal corrections. Results show JES corrections are below unity in Run 2 and most of Run 3, indicating simulation scales need adjustment. JER corrections are consistent with unity across jet $p_T$ bins.

Key concepts

Jet Energy Scale (JES)
JES is a correction factor applied to the energy measurements of jets produced in particle collisions. It accounts for systematic differences between how jets are simulated in computer models and how they are actually measured by the detector. This paper determines how much the simulation scale needs to be adjusted to match real data.
Jet Energy Resolution (JER)
JER describes the uncertainty or spread in the energy measurement of a jet. It quantifies how well the detector can distinguish between jets with slightly different energies. The study measures JER corrections by observing how much the reconstructed W boson mass distribution changes when assuming different resolution values.
Forward-Folding Technique
This is a method used to quantify the impact of systematic uncertainties, like JES or JER, on a final observable. It involves creating templates based on assumed corrections and comparing these templates against the actual experimental data using a likelihood fit. This allows for the extraction of optimal correction parameters.
Top Quark Pair Production Events
The analysis focuses on events where two top quarks are produced, which subsequently decay into jets and leptons. These events are used as a controlled environment to measure jet properties because the decay products (especially the hadronically decaying W boson) provide a sensitive observable for testing JES and JER corrections.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution of small-radius jets using semileptonic t t bar events with the ATLAS detector · Read on arXiv

The ATLAS Collaboration

EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN)

A measurement of correction factors for the hadronic jet energy scale and resolution in the ATLAS detector is presented. These correction factors account for differences between simulated and observed data. They are obtained by analysing a selection of top quark events collected in proton-proton collisions by ATLAS between the years 2015 and 2018 at a centre-of-mass energy sqrt s = 13 TeV as well as in 2022 and 2023 at sqrt s = 13.6 TeV. The impact of different jet energy scale or resolution corrections on the reconstructed mass of the hadronically decaying W boson from top-quark decays in simulation is quantified. The correction factors are extracted from a fit to the parameterised reconstructed W-boson mass distribution to data. The energy scale and resolution corrections are measured as a function of the jet transverse momentum between 20 and 200 GeV and absolute pseudorapidity less than 0.8. The uncertainties in the energy scale range from about 0.93% to about 1.7% for jets between 35 and 200 GeV, while for the energy resolution the uncertainties range from about 14% to 28%. The method presented will be used in conjunction with other techniques to further improve ATLAS jet energy scale and resolution precision.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution of small-radius jets using semileptonic t t bar events with the ATLAS detector".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A measurement of correction factors for the hadronic jet energy scale (JES) and resolution in the ATLAS detector is presented, accounting for differences between simulated and observed data from top quark events.

Kai: These correction factors are obtained by analyzing a selection of top quark events collected by ATLAS in proton–proton collisions at two center-of-mass energies: sqrt s = 13 TeV (Run 2, 2015–2018) and sqrt s = 13.6 TeV (Run 3, 2022 and 2023).

Mira: The core methodology involves using the forward-folding technique to quantify how different jet energy scale or resolution corrections impact the reconstructed mass of the hadronically decaying W boson originating from top-quark decays in simulations.

Kai: The correction factors themselves are extracted by fitting a parameterized reconstructed W-boson mass distribution to the experimental data.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today, "Calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution of small-radius jets using semileptonic t t bar events with the ATLAS detector." It's about how they fix the energy scale and resolution for jets specifically by looking at top quark pair production.

Mira: Right, it’s a calibration study that uses those top quark events to get correction factors for the hadronic jet energy scale and resolution in the ATLAS detector, which is pretty fundamental work since jet energy uncertainty is often one of the biggest issues in precision measurements >thirteen TeV

two–six: .

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, using top quarks is a good test because they produce well-defined jets, but we have to be careful about what we're measuring versus what the detector actually does.

Kai: Exactly. The paper presents how they got these correction factors by comparing simulated data with what they actually observed across two different center-of-mass energies, thirteen TeV and thirteen point six TeV <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

Mira: What’s interesting is the methodology—they use a forward-folding technique to see how changing the jet energy scale or resolution affects the reconstructed mass of the hadronically decaying W boson from those top quark decays in simulations <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

Lev: That sounds like they are essentially creating templates based on different assumptions about the energy scale or resolution, and then fitting those templates to their experimental data to find the best parameters <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: They fit a parameterized reconstructed W boson mass distribution to the actual data, specifically looking at jets with transverse momentum between twenty GeV and two hundred GeV and absolute pseudorapidity less than zero point eight <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

Mira: The results they found are quite telling about the energy scale itself; for instance, the central values for the jet energy scale measurement were below one in Run two data <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Lev: That suggests that if we rely on their simulation scales without these corrections, we’d need to decrease our simulated energy scale to match what we see in the data across most of the transverse momentum bins in Run three data <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: And for the jet energy resolution, they found that their correction factors were consistent with unity across all jet transverse momentum bins between twenty and two hundred GeV <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Title and authors: Mira: That consistency on the resolution side is a bit surprising; usually, you expect to see some deviation there because of how well the detector actually resolves energy, but here it looks like the primary issue is indeed the scale shift <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Lev: The uncertainties they report are about zero point nine three percent to one point seven percent for the energy scale in jets between thirty-five and two hundred GeV, but the uncertainty for the energy resolution is much larger, spanning from about fourteen percent to twenty-eight percent <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: It sounds like the dominant uncertainties affecting both the scale and resolution come from modeling things like final-state radiation and parton showering in the top quark pair process <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Mira: If they can reduce those specific top quark modeling uncertainties, this calibration technique alone could potentially reach a precision of about zero point five percent for the jet energy scale and about ten percent for the jet energy resolution <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Lev: That level of precision on the scale is definitely something to aim for, but it really hinges on how accurate those initial Monte Carlo models are; if we get better modeling there, this method could be very powerful for in situ calibration <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: So what does this mean for the actual experiment? It means we have a way to measure these corrections using real data from top quark events, which is good because it links the simulation directly to what the detector actually sees <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

Mira: It provides a direct comparison between what we expect from theory and what the ATLAS detector measured in those specific processes, which helps us refine our overall understanding of QCD at this energy scale <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Lev: For real hardware running this, the overhead would be in setting up that forward-folding process and performing those likelihood fits across the different p T bins, which is computationally intensive but feasible for a calibration tool <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: So to summarize, this paper shows how to get these correction factors by using top quark pair production data at thirteen TeV and thirteen point six TeV <ref:2512.17482#pg1>, and it highlights that the scale shift is the bigger issue than the resolution in these measurements <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Mira: It suggests that for future precision measurements, focusing on improving those final-state radiation models within top quark simulations is key if we want to use this calibration technique to get closer to a half percent energy scale uncertainty <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Title and authors: Lev: And for me, it means that when I'm building error correction algorithms for real hardware, I need to account for the fact that these corrections depend on the specific p T range you are looking at, because the results vary between twenty and two hundred GeV <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

Kai: So we’ve seen how they extract these parameters by fitting the W boson mass distribution to data, which is a clever way to disentangle the scale from the resolution effects <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Mira: It really shows that using semileptonic top quark events allows us to perform an in situ calibration of jet energy scale and resolution by measuring jets where the hadronically decaying W boson’s lineshape distribution is sensitive to both effects <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Lev: That sensitivity is what makes it useful, but as they noted, the dominant uncertainties come from that top quark modeling, so if we can nail those simulations down, this calibration method becomes a very solid reference point for everything else <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: So looking ahead, the next step is clearly combining these results with standard ATLAS calibration techniques to get the most robust corrections possible <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that shows how using top quark pair production events can provide precision competitive with established methods for jet p T greater than thirty-five GeV

Kai's improvement point: .

Lev: For the future, I'd say this method sets a baseline, but we still need to push the fidelity of those underlying parton showering and FSR models if we want to see those zero point five percent scale uncertainties <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: So that’s where we’ll be looking next—how do these findings translate into better simulations or improved detector response modeling for the next generation of experiments <ref:2512.17482#pg3>?

Mira: Exactly, because understanding the limitations of the calibration itself is as important as the calibration results, and it points us toward refining our theoretical inputs

Kai's improvement point: .

Lev: It’s a good paper for seeing how these complex corrections work in practice, even if the ultimate precision depends on fixing those modeling uncertainties you mentioned earlier <ref:2512.17482#pg3>.

Kai: We'll keep an eye on that, because getting these correction factors right is essential for making sure our reconstructed top quark mass measurements are as accurate as they can be <ref:2512.17482#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is about using top quark pair production events at two different energies to figure out how much we need to correct our jet energy scale and resolution in the ATLAS detector.

Mira: Right, they’re looking at those specific top quark events from both thirteen TeV and thirteen point six TeV collisions to get these correction factors.

Lev: It sounds like they’re trying to find a way to link what we see in data directly to how our simulations are modeling the physics of jets.

Kai: Exactly, the core idea is using a forward-folding technique, which is basically simulating what happens if you change your assumptions about energy scale or resolution and then fitting that simulation against the real data.

Mira: So they’re essentially building these templates based on different energy scale settings and seeing how well those templates match up with the actual jet information coming out of the detector.

Lev: And to do that, they use the mean values of reconstructed W boson mass distributions in different regions to figure out the energy scale parameters, and the standard deviation for resolution.

Kai: The results they got are pretty interesting because for this specific measurement, they found that if you look at their energy scale correction factors from the Run two data, those central values are below one.

Mira: That means that when we use our current simulation scales without these corrections, we would actually need to decrease the energy scale used in simulations to match what we see in the data across most of those transverse momentum bins.

Lev: And for the resolution part, they found that their correction factors were consistent with one across all those jet transverse momentum ranges from twenty GeV up to two hundred GeV.

Kai: That’s a bit surprising because you usually expect some deviation there because of how well the detector actually resolves energy, but it seems like the primary issue they found was really just the energy scale shift.

Mira: Yeah, and they quantified those uncertainties pretty well—the error on the energy scale itself is about zero point nine three percent to one point seven percent for jets between thirty five GeV and two hundred GeV.

Lev: The uncertainty for resolution is much larger, spanning from about fourteen percent up to twenty eight percent across that same range.

Kai: They pointed out that the biggest uncertainties affecting both the energy scale and the resolution come from modeling final-state radiation and parton showering within the top quark pair process itself.

Mira: If they can reduce those specific top quark modeling uncertainties, this calibration technique alone could potentially reach a precision of about zero point five percent for the jet energy scale and about ten percent for the jet energy resolution.

Lev: That level of precision on the scale is something to aim for, but it really hinges on how accurate those initial Monte Carlo models are; if we get better modeling there, this method could be very powerful for in situ calibration.

Kai: So what this means is that using semileptonic top quark events gives us a way to perform an in situ calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution by measuring jets where the lineshape distribution of the hadronically decaying W boson is sensitive to both effects.

Mira: It provides a direct comparison between our theoretical expectations from QCD and what ATLAS actually measured in those specific processes, which helps us refine our understanding of how particles interact at this energy scale.

Lev: For real hardware running this, the overhead would be in setting up that forward-folding process and performing those likelihood fits across the different transverse momentum bins, which is computationally intensive but feasible for a calibration tool.

Kai: So to wrap up this part, they’ve shown how to extract these correction factors by fitting the W boson mass distribution to data, which is a clever way to separate the scale shift from the resolution effects.

Mira: It really shows that using semileptonic top quark events allows us to perform an in situ calibration of jet energy scale and resolution by measuring jets where the hadronically decaying W boson’s lineshape distribution is sensitive to both effects.

Lev: That sensitivity is what makes it useful, but as they noted, the dominant uncertainties come from that top quark modeling, so if we can nail those simulations down, this calibration method becomes a very solid reference point for everything else.

Kai: So looking ahead, the next step is clearly combining these results with standard ATLAS calibration techniques to get the most robust corrections possible.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that shows how using top quark pair production events can provide precision competitive with established methods for jet transverse momentum greater than thirty five GeV.

Lev: For the future, I'd say this method sets a baseline, but we still need to push the fidelity of those underlying parton showering and final-state radiation models if we want to see those zero point five percent scale uncertainties.

Kai: So that’s where we’ll be looking next—how do these findings translate into better simulations or improved detector response modeling for the next generation of experiments.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we’ve talked about how they got these correction factors using top quark data at two different collision energies to fix the jet energy scale and resolution in ATLAS.

Kai: Now let's talk about what the authors suggest as improvements for this calibration method itself.

Mira: They point out that while this technique is good, it really depends on how well you model the final-state radiation and parton showering within those top quark pair events.

Lev: So they’re suggesting that if we can reduce the uncertainty in those specific top quark modeling components, this calibration method could potentially reach a precision of about zero point five percent for the jet energy scale and about ten percent for the jet energy resolution.

Kai: That means that improving our simulation models for final-state radiation and parton showering is key if we want to use this calibration technique to get closer to that half percent energy scale uncertainty.

Mira: It’s a bit of a double-edged sword, though because they also flag the uncertainties for the energy resolution as being quite high, from about fourteen percent up to twenty eight percent.

Lev: That high resolution uncertainty is what makes me think about the real hardware overhead; even if we get the scale down to zero point five percent, we’re still dealing with a significant factor of ten uncertainty on how well we measure energy at all.

Kai: So, they are suggesting that for future precision work, focusing on improving those theoretical inputs in the simulations is what really matters if you want to use this calibration technique effectively.

Mira: Exactly, because understanding the limitations of the calibration itself is as important as the calibration results we get from it.

Lev: I agree with that; if we can nail down those modeling uncertainties, this method becomes a very solid reference point for everything else in our simulations.

Kai: So, what does this mean for us in terms of actually building and cooling detectors? It means we need to make sure our detector response models are as accurate as possible to match the precision these calibration factors can provide.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at "Calibration of the jet energy scale and resolution of small-radius jets using semileptonic t t bar events with the ATLAS detector."

Mira: Basically, they showed how to use top quark pair production data from both thirteen TeV and thirteen point six TeV collisions to measure correction factors for the jet energy scale and resolution in the ATLAS detector.

Lev: They used a forward-folding technique, which means they simulated what happens if you change your energy assumptions and then fit that simulation against real data to extract those parameters.

Kai: And they found that the main issue wasn't necessarily the resolution, but really the energy scale shift in their Run two data across most of those transverse momentum bins.

Mira: Right, and they quantified that uncertainty pretty well—the error on the energy scale itself is about zero point nine three percent to one point seven percent for jets between thirty five GeV and two hundred GeV.

Lev: That means for real hardware running this, we need to be aware that those corrections depend on where you are looking in terms of momentum, because they vary across the two hundred GeV range.

Kai: The main implication is that if we want to get better precision on top quark mass measurements, we have a way to do it by tying our simulation models more closely to real data.

Mira: It suggests that for future precision work, focusing on improving those theoretical inputs in the simulations is what really matters if you want to use this calibration technique effectively.

Lev: I agree; if we can nail down those modeling uncertainties, this method becomes a very solid reference point for everything else in our simulations.

Kai: Overall, this paper shows that using semileptonic top quark events provides a way to perform an in situ calibration of jet energy scale and resolution by measuring jets where the lineshape distribution of the hadronically decaying W boson is sensitive to both effects.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that proves we can get precision competitive with established methods for jet transverse momentum greater than thirty five GeV.

Lev: For me, it’s a good demonstration of how these complex corrections work in practice, even if the ultimate precision depends on fixing those modeling uncertainties you mentioned earlier.

More episodes

← Home