Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =510 GeV
summary
The gist
Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced π+π− and K+K− Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s = 510 GeV is an amplitude analysis of the invariant-mass…
In short
The study analyzed invariant-mass spectra of centrally produced pi+pi- and K+K- pairs from proton-proton collisions at 510 GeV to search for scalar glueball candidates, specifically f0(1500) and f0(1710). Including these resonances significantly improved the fit quality in both channels, suggesting their contribution is present. The results qualitatively match lower energy data and show flavor dependence.
Key concepts
- Central Exclusive Production (CEP)
- This process involves producing a specific final state (like two pions) while keeping the interacting protons largely intact and separated by a large gap in rapidity. This method helps isolate rare events, allowing physicists to study the fundamental interactions between the particles rather than overwhelming background noise from standard collisions.
- Invariant-Mass Spectrum
- This is a plot showing how often pairs of particles are produced at different total energies (invariant mass). By looking at these spectra, researchers can identify peaks corresponding to known or hypothesized particles, such as the f0(1500) or f0(1710), which signal the presence of new physics like glueballs.
- Amplitude Analysis
- This is a mathematical technique used to model the observed data. Instead of just fitting a simple curve, this method uses complex functions (amplitudes) that describe how different particles interfere with each other. By fitting these models to the measured spectrum, researchers can extract precise information about the properties and relative strengths of various resonances.
- Glueball Candidates
- Glueballs are hypothetical particles made purely of gluons, which are the force carriers of the strong nuclear force. The f0(1500) and f0(1710) are specific theoretical models for these particles. Observing their presence in collision data provides evidence that gluonic states exist and how they couple to quarks.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =510 GeV · Paper Radio
- A review on Glueball hunting
- A partial wave analysis of the centrally produced pi+pi- system in pp interactions at 450 GeV/c
- A partial wave analysis of the centrally produced pi0pi0 system in pp interactions at 450 GeV/c
- A partial wave analysis of the centrally produced K+K- and K0K0 systems in pp interactions at 450 GeV/c and new information on the spin of the fJ(1710)
- A study of the eta eta channel produced in central pp interactions at 450 GeV/c
- A study of the centrally produced 4pi channel in pp interactions at 450 GeV/c
- Study of central exclusive pi+ pi- production in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 5.02 and 13 TeV
- Measurement of the central exclusive production of charged particle pairs in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 200 GeV with the STAR detector at RHIC
- Study of Central Exclusive Production of pi+ pi-, K+K- and p p bar Pairs in Proton-Proton Collisions at sqrt s = 510 GeV with the STAR Detector at RHIC
- The mixing of the f0(1370), f0(1500) and f0(1710) and the search for the scalar glueball
- Production of f 0(1710), f 0(1500), and f 0(1370) in J/psi hadronic decays
- A comprehensive lattice study of SU(3) glueballs
- High-statistics study of K 0 S pair production in two-photon collisions
- Glueball Spectrum and Matrix Elements on Anisotropic Lattices
- Scalar Glueball, Scalar Quarkonia, and their Mixing
- GRANIITTI: A Monte Carlo Event Generator for High Energy Diffraction
- GRANIITTI: towards a deep learning-enhanced Monte Carlo event generator for high-energy diffraction
- Precise determination of the f0(600) and f0(980) pole parameters from a dispersive data analysis
- Partial wave analyses of J/psi to gamma pi+ pi- and gamma pi 0 pi 0
- Partial Wave Analyses of J/psi to gamma K+K- and gamma K 0 SK 0 S
The paper
Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =510 GeV · Read on arXiv
Aranya Giri, Barak Schmookler, Rene Bellwied
Department of Physics, University of Houston
We present an amplitude analysis of the π+π- and K+K- invariant-mass spectra from central exclusive pp collisions at sqrt s =510 GeV, measured by the STAR experiment with forward-scattered protons tagged in the Roman Pot detectors. The π+π- channel is described with f 0(500), ρ 0(770), f 0(980), f 2(1270), f 0(1500) and f 0(1710) resonances with χ squared/ndf=121.712/57. The fit also yields m f 0(980)=0.989 GeV and Γ=0.091 GeV. The K+K- channel is described with f 0(980), f 2(1270), f 2(1525) and f 0(1710) resonances with χ squared/ndf=14.662/15. The fiducial cross sections for the individual resonances and interference terms were calculated, together with their ratios relative to the total fitted cross section. These ratios were compared across decay channels and qualitatively with previous measurements. A consistent flavor dependence of f 0(1500) and f 0(1710) has been derived for the highest RHIC collision energies, which is in agreement with low energy data.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =510 GeV".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced π+π− and K+K− Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s = 510 GeV is an amplitude analysis of the invariant-mass spectra from central exclusive production at a high collision energy to investigate contributions from scalar glueball candidates f0(1500) and f0(1710).
Kai: Experimental Setup and Data Selection The analysis utilizes STAR experiment data collected in proton–proton collisions at √s = 510 GeV, with an effective integrated luminosity of 25.6 pb−1 after correcting for the CEP trigger efficiency The trigger required signals in the Roman Pot detectors on both sides of the interaction point, at least two hits in the Time-of-Flight (TOF) detector, and vetoes on the Beam–Beam Counters (BBC) and Zero Degree Calorimeters (ZDC) to ensure the characteristic double-rapidity-gap topology and suppress protondissociation and pile-up backgrounds During offline event selection, events were required to contain exactly two forward proton tracks reconstructed within the Roman Pot fiducial acceptance and exactly two oppositely charged primary tracks reconstructed in the Time Projection Chamber (TPC) and matched to TOF hits The exclusivity of the selected events was ensured by requiring the missing transverse momentum of the complete final state, pT,p′p′ + pT,h+h− < 0.12 GeV/c After applying all selection criteria, the final sample consisted of 86 008 π+π− candidates, 2454 K+K− candidates, and 225 pp¯ candidates Model Construction and Fitting Methodology The measured differential cross section is modeled as the convolution of the underlying invariant-mass spectrum with the detector mass-resolution function The model consists of a nonresonant double-Pomeron exchange (DPE) continuum and resonance contributions, where DPE is parameterized by Acont(m) = acont A PDF cont (m) For each resonance R, the corresponding amplitude is parameterized as AR(m) = aRe iϕR BWR(m), where aR and ϕR denote the magnitude and phase of the resonance amplitude, respectively The fit is performed using Minuit2 within the ROOT framework The coherent f0–f2 interference term is retained because restricted angular acceptance can break the effective orthogonality of the S- and D0-wave components, allowing interference between coherent f0 and f2 amplitudes to survive angular integration Results for the π+π− Channel For the π+π− invariant-mass spectrum, the baseline fit model alone provides a poor description of the data, yielding χ2/ndf = 420.757/61 = 6.898 The inclusion of the f0(1500) resonance leads to a substantial improvement in the fit quality, reducing the fit statistic to χ2/ndf = 155.542/59 = 2.636 Including the f0(1710) resonance further improves the fit by ∆χ2 = 33.830 for two additional free parameters, corresponding to a local statistical significance of approximately 5.35σ The resulting fit model including the f0(1710) resonance is retained as the final fit configuration for the π+π− invariant-mass spectrum The ratio of their fractional fitted cross sections in this channel is σf0(1500)/σtotal fit π+π− = 8.8±3.46 (stat.)±0.16 (mod.) Results for the K+K− Channel In the K+K− channel, the baseline fit model is also insufficient, yielding χ2/ndf = 92.856/17 = 5.462 The inclusion of the f0(1710) resonance significantly improves the baseline fit model, which consists of the nonresonant DPE continuum and the f0(980), f2(1270), and f′2(1525) resonances The resulting fit, shown in Fig.
Mira: 6, gives χ2/ndf = 14.662/15 = 0.977 (16) and improves the fit by ∆χ2 = 78.194 for two additional free parameters, corresponding to a local statistical significance of approximately 8.57σ The dominant contribution arises from the non-resonant continuum, followed by the f0(980) and f2(1525) resonances The analysis provides quantitative evidence for contributions associated with both leading scalar-glueball candidates, f0(1500) and f0(1710), in CEP at the highest collision energy of RHIC pp The observed pattern is qualitatively consistent with that reported by the WA102 fixed-target experiment at much lower energies, where the f0(1500) contributes more strongly to the π+π− channel, while the f0(1710) contributes more strongly to the K+K− channel The relative contribution of the f0(500) to the total fit in the π+π− final state is 0.55 Flavor Dependence and Interpretation The observed channel dependence provides information that can be considered in the context of previous measurements and phenomenological interpretations In particular, the comparatively prominent f0(1710) contribution in the K+K− channel, approximately six times larger than in the π+π− channel in the present analysis, is qualitatively consistent with its known preference for decays to KK¯ over ππ This behavior can be accommodated within different glueball–quarkonium mixing scenarios for different reasons The f0(500) is clearly observed in the π+π− spectrum, whereas no significant contribution is required in the K+K− spectrum Fiducial Cross-Section Measurement The total cross section obtained using the final fit function is consistent with the total cross section reported in the published measurement
9: within statistical uncertainties The dominant contribution to the total cross section arises from the non-resonant continuum, followed by the contributions from the f0(980) and f2(1270) resonances The interference terms exhibit both constructive and destructive contributions, demonstrating their non-negligible impact on the overall cross section The ratio of the individual cross-section contributions to the total cross section obtained from the fit provides a normalized characterization of the relative contributions of the different components Fiducial Cross-Section Measurement in K+K− The dominant contribution arises from the non-resonant continuum, followed by the f0(980) and f2(1525) resonances The largest negative interference contribution originates from the f0(980)× non-resonant continuum term, while the f2(1270)× nonresonant continuum term provides the largest positive contribution The ratios of the individual resonance contributions to the total fit are summarized in Table VIII The present analysis demonstrates that successive inclusion of the f0(1500) and f0(1710) amplitudes leads to substantial improvements in the fit quality for both decay channels The observed pattern is qualitatively consistent with that reported by the WA102 fixed-target experiment at much lower energies The relative contribution of the f0(500) to the total fit in the π+π− final state is 8.8±3.46 (stat.)±0.16 (mod.
Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper today titled "Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =five hundred ten GeV" <ref:2611.07086#pg1,Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced>. We're basically taking data from the STAR experiment at proton-proton collisions when you hit five hundred and ten gigaelectron volts to see what kind of stuff is being made centrally exclusively.
Mira: Exactly. The main idea here is that they are analyzing the invariant-mass spectra for pi plus pi minus and K plus K minus pairs, specifically looking for hints of those scalar glueball candidates, f0(one thousand five hundred) and f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) <ref:2611.07086#pg1,f0(1500) and f0(1710>. They're trying to see if these resonances actually show up in the data from this specific type of collision.
Lev: It’s important to know that they are using a very specific selection process. They require at least two hits in the Time-of-Flight detector on both sides, and they vetoed events that look like proton dissociation or pile-up by checking the Beam–Beam Counters and Zero Degree Calorimeters.
Kai: Right, so what's the core claim of this work? The paper claims that when you include these specific resonance contributions—the f0(one thousand five hundred) and the f0(one thousand seven hundred ten)—the fit quality for both channels gets substantially better <ref:2611.07086#pg1>. They found that adding the f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) actually improves the fit by a local statistical significance of about five point three sigma for the pi plus pi minus channel <ref:2611.07086#pg1>.
Mira: That’s a significant jump from their baseline, where they were struggling to describe the data with just the nonresonant background. And in terms of the K plus K minus channel, including that f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) gives them about eight point five sigma improvement over their initial model <ref:2611.07086#pg1>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that improvement means they can constrain those resonance amplitudes much better. They also mention fitting for other resonances like the f0(nine hundred eighty), the f2(one thousand two hundred seventy), and the f′two(one thousand five hundred twenty-five) in the K plus K minus channel <ref:2611.07086#pg1>.
Kai: The paper also gives them a ratio for how much of that resonance contribution is actually in each channel. For example, they find that in this pi plus pi minus channel, the fractional fitted cross section for the f0(one thousand five hundred) is about eight point eight to three point four six stat <ref:2611.07086#pg1>. plus zero point one six mod.
Mira: That flavor dependence they found between the channels is interesting because it points toward how these particles might couple differently to different quark flavors, like strange versus up and down quarks. The paper notes that the f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) contribution in K plus K minus is about six times larger than in the pi plus pi minus channel here <ref:2611.07086#pg1>.
Lev: That difference in relative size suggests a preference for the f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) to decay into strange quarks, which aligns with some older observations from fixed-target experiments at much lower energies, like WA102 <ref:2611.07086#pg1>.
Kai: So what's the big picture implication of this whole analysis? The paper essentially gives quantitative evidence for contributions from both leading scalar glueball candidates in central exclusive production at these high collision energies.
Mira: It connects the experimental data here to some theoretical predictions from lattice quantum chromodynamics calculations that predicted a glueball mass around one point five five GeV.
Lev: That LQCD prediction is interesting because it suggests a certain mass scale for the lightest scalar glueball, which is what we're trying to find in these experiments.
Kai: The paper also touches on some conflicting theoretical interpretations regarding the f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) <ref:2611.07086#pg1>. Some models suggest it's predominantly glueball, while others see it as being dominated by strange quark-antiquark pairs.
Mira: That’s where the flavor dependence comes in again; the coupling to strange quarks versus up and down quarks dictates which theoretical picture you favor for that particle.
Lev: The paper also points out a limitation in their analysis, specifically that they have to retain a coherent f0 plus f2 interference term because the angular acceptance limits can mess up the orthogonality of those S and D waves.
Kai: So, looking at this paper "Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced pi+ pi- and K+K- Pairs in pp Collisions at sqrt s =five hundred ten GeV", it shows that by including the f0(one thousand five hundred) and f0(one thousand seven hundred ten) amplitudes, we get a much better fit for the data <ref:2611.07086#pg1,Amplitude Analysis of the Invariant-Mass Spectra of Centrally Exclusively Produced>.
Mira: It’s a quantitative piece of evidence showing how these scalar states are produced in central exclusive collisions at this energy level.
Lev: And what it changes for us is that we can now put stronger constraints on the masses and couplings of these glueball candidates based on these measured cross sections.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at the data from those central exclusive collisions at five hundred and ten gigaelectron volts, and this paper is all about what they found in those specific particle pairs, pi plus pi minus and K plus K minus.
Mira: Right, it’s the amplitude analysis of those invariant-mass spectra for the central exclusive production data. The authors are really digging into how those scalar glueball candidates fit into the picture here.
Lev: They're testing if these f0 five zero zero and f0 one seven one resonances actually show up in the measured cross sections from this collision type.
Kai: Basically, they found that adding those specific amplitudes improves the fit quality significantly for both channels, which is what they were aiming for when they set up this analysis.
Mira: The key result is that the pattern of how these resonances contribute differs between the pi plus pi minus and K plus K minus channels.
Lev: They're seeing a preference, which suggests that maybe these glueball candidates couple differently to different quark flavors, like strange versus up and down quarks.
Kai: That’s interesting because it ties into what we see in other experiments at lower energies, like the WA102 work they mention.
Mira: It points to a flavor dependence in how these particles behave, which is a big clue for how we might interpret their nature as glueballs or mixed states.
Lev: And if this coupling difference is real, it tells us something about the underlying theory—maybe it's not just one simple picture of the glueball sector.
Kai: So they’ve shown that these measurements provide quantitative evidence for both leading scalar candidates in central exclusive production at this high energy.
Mira: The paper sets up a clear path for how we can use these cross section ratios to constrain those theoretical models further.
Lev: And that opens the door to figuring out if the lattice predictions about the glueball mass scale align with what we see here in particle production.
More episodes
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2512.21290-Model-independent ZH production cross section at FCC-ee
- 2610.21982-First Observation of the Radiative Decay D 0 to gamma omega
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2512.08065-Searches for Light Dark Matter and Evidence of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering of Solar Neutrinos with the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Experiment
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- 2508.18022-Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider
- 2512.23992-Prospect for measurement of CP-violating parameters of B s 0 to phi gamma at the Tera Z factory