Uniform price auction with quantity constraints

summary

The gist

Uniform price auction with quantity constraints studies the equilibria of uniform price auctions where many asymmetric bidders have flat demands up to their respective quantity constraints…

In short

The study investigates uniform price auctions where many bidders have fixed demands limited by quantity constraints. It introduces an iterative procedure to find a Nash equilibrium outcome and an ascending auction that achieves this outcome as a dominant strategy. The analysis reveals that low price equilibria are only possible when no bidder's constraint covers the total supply, showing demand reduction can occur.

Key concepts

Uniform Price Auction with Quantity Constraints
This is an auction format where all bidders submit a single bid for their entire quantity demand. This setup is common in markets like electricity or spectrum auctions where sellers have limits on how much they can supply, and buyers have limits on how much they can purchase.
Iterative Procedure
A systematic step-by-step method developed to find the equilibrium outcome of the auction. It involves defining maximum bids based on payoff comparisons and ranking these bids to determine when the aggregate demand covers or fails to cover the supply, leading toward a stable result.
Low Price Equilibrium
A market state where bidders strategically reduce their demand or accept a very low price because obtaining their full demand at a higher price is less profitable than getting only part of it at a lower cost. This equilibrium is only possible if no single bidder's capacity constraint is large enough to cover the entire supply.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Uniform price auction with quantity constraints · Read on arXiv

Kiho Yoon

Korea University

We study the equilibria of uniform price auctions where many asymmetric bidders have flat demands up to their respective quantity constraints. We present an iterative procedure that systematically finds an equilibrium outcome as well as an ascending auction that has this outcome as a dominant strategy equilibrium outcome. Demand reduction and low price equilibrium may occur since it is advantageous for a bidder to give up some of his/her demand and get the remaining demand at a low price rather than to get his/her entire demand at a higher price. We show that a low price equilibrium is the only possible equilibrium when no bidder's quantity constraint is large enough to cover the supply.

DOI: 10.1515/bejte-2025-0074

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Uniform price auction with quantity constraints".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. Uniform price auction with quantity constraints studies the equilibria of uniform price auctions where many asymmetric bidders have flat demands up to their respective quantity constraints <ref:2409.04047#pg2> We present an iterative procedure that systematically finds an equilibrium outcome as well as an ascending auction that has this outcome as a dominant strategy equilibrium outcome <ref:2409.04047#pg4> Demand reduction and low price equilibrium may occur since it is advantageous for a bidder to give up some of his/her demand and get the remaining demand at a low price rather than to get his/her entire demand at a higher price <ref:2409.04047#pg4> A low price equilibrium is the only possible equilibrium when no bidder’s quantity constraint is large enough to cover the supply <ref:2409.04047#pg4>.

Ruth: Auction Environments and Context The study focuses on uniform price auctions common in real-world markets such as wholesale electricity markets, spectrum auctions, and securities markets <ref:2409.04047#pg3> Quantity constraints arise from demand/supply conditions or regulations, such as retailers with limited final consumer demand or spectrum caps imposed by the government <ref:2409.04047#pg2> The analysis extends to procurement auctions where sellers compete to satisfy a buyer's demand, mirroring the buyer-seller auction environment <ref:2409.04047#pg2> Equilibrium Characterization Procedure The paper introduces an iterative procedure for finding an equilibrium outcome and an ascending auction that has this outcome as a dominant strategy equilibrium <ref:2409.04047#pg4> The procedure involves several steps, including defining the maximum bid ˆb1i based on comparing payoffs from overbidding versus bidding zero <ref:2409.04047#pg9> The process continues by ranking these maximum bids and dividing cases based on whether the aggregate demand of others covers the supply <ref:2409.04047#pg9> Results on Equilibrium Outcomes The analysis reveals that a low price equilibrium is only possible when no bidder’s quantity constraint is large enough to cover the supply <ref:2409.04047#pg4> The procedure can lead to several outcomes, including cases where bidders drop out at specific price points or where the final equilibrium price is set at one of the bidders’ marginal values <ref:2409.04047#pg9> Furthermore, it is shown that if every bidder's quantity constraint is less than the total supply, a low price equilibrium is the only possible outcome <ref:2409.04047#pg4>.

Warren: Dynamic Implementation and Extensions The paper describes a dynamic implementation using an English auction with quantity constraints where bidders have private information about their values <ref:2409.04047#pg9> The equilibrium strategy in this ascending auction is weakly dominant to remain active if and only if the bid is less than or equal to a calculated maximum bid value <ref:2409.04047#pg9> Extensions are discussed, including incorporating a positive reserve price and analyzing the scenario where sellers adopt a discriminatory pricing rule instead of uniform pricing <ref:2409.04047#pg4>.

Ruth: The latter is strategically equivalent to price competition in a capacity-constrained oligopoly <ref:2409.04047#pg4>.

Title and authors: Ruth: To recap, this paper, "Uniform price auction with quantity constraints," investigates how many bidders with flat demands up to certain limits behave in uniform price auctions and introduces a procedure to find both an equilibrium outcome and an ascending auction that has that outcome as a dominant strategy equilibrium.

Warren: And they highlight the possibility of demand reduction because sometimes it's smarter for a bidder to settle for less demand at a lower price than aiming for their full demand at a higher one.

Iris: They also make the strong statement that if no single person's quantity constraint is big enough to meet the total supply, then a low price equilibrium is the only possible outcome in this setting.

Ruth: It's interesting because it suggests that capacity constraints fundamentally change how bidders react to pricing in these auctions.

Warren: And they set up an iterative procedure involving comparing payoffs from overbidding versus bidding zero to figure out the maximum bid for each bidder.

The paper's summary: Iris: The core of their analysis involves this iterative procedure, which starts by defining a maximum bid for each bidder based on comparing what happens if you overbid versus if you just bid zero.

Ruth: And then they rank these maximum bids and break down the cases based on whether the total demand from everyone else covers the supply.

Warren: So they're essentially mapping out a decision tree based on who has enough quantity to meet the supply when others are bidding at a certain level.

Iris: The results show that this procedure can lead to various outcomes, including situations where bidders drop out at specific price points or when the final equilibrium price ends up being one of the bidders' marginal values.

Ruth: And they emphasize that if every bidder's quantity constraint is smaller than the total supply, then a low price equilibrium is the only possible outcome.

The paper's improvements: Warren: The paper suggests an improvement by describing a dynamic implementation using an English auction with quantity constraints where bidders have private information about their values.

Iris: In that ascending auction, the strategy for being active—staying in the game—is weakly dominant if and only if your bid is less than or equal to a calculated maximum bid value derived from the procedure.

Ruth: This means bidders can use this derived maximum bid as a real-time rule for when to participate in that ascending auction, which is a big deal for modeling behavior.

Warren: They also discuss extensions, like incorporating a positive reserve price, and they look at what happens if sellers switch from uniform pricing to a discriminatory pricing rule instead.

Iris: They note that the discriminatory pricing rule actually ends up being strategically equivalent to price competition in a capacity-constrained oligopoly, which is an important connection to other market structures.

Conclusion: Ruth: So, wrapping up this paper on "Uniform price auction with quantity constraints," they found that the equilibrium outcome isn't necessarily unique, and sometimes it results in inefficiency where a bidder with a higher marginal value ends up getting fewer units than someone with a lower marginal value.

Warren: That inefficiency seems inevitable if no single bidder's quantity constraint is big enough to cover the entire supply, which they say is the case under those conditions.

Iris: They conclude by summarizing how the equilibrium price and fulfilled demands are determined by the stopping condition of that iterative procedure, noting that the equilibrium price is always set at either one of a bidder's marginal values or zero.

Ruth: And they also point out that a challenging future research area would be constructing a procedure for general marginal values and multiple bids, which sounds like it opens up new avenues for analysis.

Warren: They end by summarizing that the procurement auction with capacity constraints under discriminatory pricing is equivalent to price competition in a capacity-constrained oligopoly.

Iris: To wrap things up, what this study really shows is how quantity constraints force bidders into certain trade-offs regarding demand reduction and low prices in uniform auctions.

More episodes

← Home