Identification of Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models

summary

The gist

This paper introduces Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models (RI-ARUMs), a novel class of econometric models based on Matˇejka and McKay (2015) that incorporates additive unobserved…

In short

This paper introduces Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models (RI-ARUMs) to analyze behavioral biases in decision-making. The model extends classic choice models by adding unobserved heterogeneity to payoffs, information costs, and priors. It shows that certain systematic components can be identified nonparametrically even when the distributions of these unobserved variables are unknown.

Key concepts

Rational Inattention
This concept describes a decision-maker's tendency to focus their attention on only a subset of available options rather than considering all possibilities. This leads to making decisions based on incomplete information, as the agent cannot process every piece of information simultaneously.
Additive Random Utility Models (ARUMs)
These are econometric models that extend standard choice models by incorporating unobserved heterogeneity in three key areas: the payoffs themselves, the cost of obtaining information, and the decision-maker's prior beliefs. This allows for a more flexible analysis of complex behavioral patterns.
Nonparametric Identification
This is a method used to identify unknown parts of a model without assuming specific functional forms for those unknown components. The paper demonstrates that under certain conditions, key parameters like the conditional prior and realized payoffs can be identified even if their underlying distributions are completely unknown.
Conditional Choice Probabilities (CCPs)
CCPs represent the probability that a decision-maker chooses one option over another given their current knowledge. The paper uses convex optimization theory to show how optimal CCPs are determined, which helps in deriving rules for identifying model components.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Identification of Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models · Read on arXiv

Dennis Kristensen, Ruolei Zhu

University College London

This paper introduces a novel class of econometric models, called Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models. It is based on the discrete choice rational inattention model of Matvejka and McKay (2015) with additive unobserved heterogeneity incorporated. We show that some of the systematic components of the primitives of the model are nonparametrically identified even if the distributions of unobserved variables and the prior of decision makers are both unknown to the Econometrician. If additional information about the prior is known to the Econometrician, even stronger identification results become available.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Identification of Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. This paper introduces Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models (RI-ARUMs), a novel class of econometric models based on Matˇejka and McKay (2015) that incorporates additive unobserved heterogeneity to analyze behavioral biases in decision-making processes The paper shows that some systematic components of the model are nonparametrically identified even if the distributions of unobserved variables and the prior of decision makers are both unknown to the Econometrician Model Framework and Components The authors propose a general class of RI-ARUMs as an econometric toolkit for analyzing empirical behavioral biases The model extends the classic representative agent model by allowing Decision Makers (DMs) to have knowledge about parts of the uncertain payoffs, replacing the unconditional prior with a conditional one based on existing knowledge This results in three key components modeled additively in observed and unobserved heterogeneity: "The conditional prior of the payoffs, the cost of information, and the realised payoffs" The model contains a special case corresponding to the classic full-information ARUM or a degenerate prior Theoretical Insights into Choice Probabilities The authors provide theoretical new insights into features and properties of rational inattention discrete choice models by analyzing conditional choice probabilities (CCPs) using convex optimization theory They note that optimal CCPs may be situated on the boundary of the probability simplex, which is important for subsequent identification analysis The optimal signal rule is derived by maximizing an objective function involving expected payoffs and information cost The resulting optimal CCPs are characterized by a multinomial mixed–logit model where the integrated CCPs enter as alternative-specific weights Nonparametric Identification Results The paper develops nonparametric identification results for the unknown conditional prior, cost of information, and realized payoffs under four scenarios regarding unobserved heterogeneity In the most benevolent sub-scenario—where DMs have correct beliefs about payoffs—strong identification results are achieved In a more testing environment where the Econometrician has no knowledge of the DM’s prior, only certain features of the model can be identified The identification results extend existing nonparametric identification results for ARUMs to allow for rational inattention Identification with Unobserved Heterogeneity When unobserved heterogeneity is added to all three components (payoffs, information cost, and prior), the authors rely on the identity involving the composite mapping Π which is integrated with respect to the distribution of unobserved variables Fε They show that for certain components like u1, identification can be achieved under specific assumptions by leveraging properties of this integrated mapping However, identification of u0 in the case where the prior is completely unknown and unrestricted remains difficult without very strong restrictions on the deviation of subjective beliefs from the physical law Identification Strategies for Structural Functions The paper presents general results for identifying composite functions of the form Φ(w, z) = Ψ(ν(w), z) under increasing number restrictions on the model The final identification result shows that under specific support conditions and normalisations, structural functions like u0 are identified on certain index regions The analysis demonstrates that while some components like u1 can be identified even with unobserved heterogeneity, identification of u0 is much more challenging unless the prior is not too badly misspecified Finally, the paper concludes that identifying the DM’s prior πV1 remains largely unachievable without very strong restrictions Based on the discrete choice rational inattention model, a flexible class of econometric models is developed with a comprehensive identification analysis showing what can and cannot be identified under different scenarios The authors establish that functions u0, u1, and λ are identified even when unobserved heterogeneity is present under suitable assumptions However, identifying the prior πV1 remains largely unachievable without very strong restrictions References Allen R.

Ruth: and Rehbeck J.

Warren: (2019) Identification with additively separable heterogeneity.

Ruth: Econometrica, 87(3):1021–1054 Allen R.

Title and authors: Ruth: So we’re looking at this paper now, "Identification of Rational Inattention-Additive Random Utility Models." It’s pretty dense, but the core idea is bringing additive random utility models and rational inattention together.

Warren: Yeah, it builds on Matˇejka and McKay's work from two thousand fifteen but adds this additive unobserved heterogeneity <ref:2611.14752#pg1>. The main thing they’re showing is that even if you don't know the distribution of the unobserved variables or what the decision makers’ prior belief is, you can still identify some parts of the model.

Iris: Exactly, and that's where it gets interesting for us as econometricians. They are proposing this general class of models called RI-ARUMs as a toolkit for analyzing behavioral biases in decision-making processes.

Ruth: So, what does that actually mean when we translate it into something we can use? It seems like they're tackling the problem of how people make choices when they aren't perfectly informed about what’s on the other side of those options.

Warren: They do that by modeling three additive components: the conditional prior, the cost of information, and then the realized payoffs. That structure is key to how they build their toolkit for empirical work.

Iris: And they also dive into choice probabilities using convex optimization theory to find out what the optimal choice probabilities look like in this rational inattention setting.

The paper's summary: Ruth: In essence, the paper is filling a gap in the literature because there wasn't much theoretical work on the econometrics of rational inattention discrete choice models before this.

Warren: Right, and they lay out four different scenarios for how unobserved heterogeneity can be present. The most benevolent one is when decision makers have correct beliefs about the payoffs, which gives them strong identification results.

Iris: And then there’s the more testing environment where the econometrician has no knowledge of the prior belief at all, and in that case, they’re only able to identify certain features of the model. That’s a crucial limitation for practical application.

Ruth: The paper suggests that their approach provides a general blueprint for taking these complex structural representative agent models and actually turning them into data analysis tools.

Warren: And one of the main contributions is showing that some systematic components of these primitives are nonparametrically identified even if you don't know the distributions or the prior belief.

Iris: That’s a big deal because it means we don't always need perfect knowledge of everything to do identification in these complex models, provided you stick to certain assumptions.

The paper's improvements: Ruth: Now let's talk about what they suggest improving or extending from the original model setup. They focus on how you can identify specific parts of the model under different conditions.

Warren: They develop nonparametric identification results for the unknown conditional prior, the cost of information, and realized payoffs across four scenarios involving unobserved heterogeneity. That’s a lot to manage.

Iris: The paper explores how they handle this uncertainty when unobserved heterogeneity is added to all three components—the payoffs, the information cost, and the prior belief. They rely on an identity involving a composite mapping called Pi which is integrated over the distribution of those unobserved variables.

Ruth: And while that integrated mapping helps identify some things like u1 under specific assumptions, they admit that identifying u0 in the case where the prior is completely unknown remains difficult without very strong restrictions on how much subjective beliefs can deviate from physical laws.

Warren: They also present general results for identifying composite functions of a form called Phi of w and z, which means they can identify structural functions like u0 on certain index regions under increasing number restrictions.

Iris: The final point is that they conclude that identifying the decision maker’s prior, Pi V1, remains largely unachievable without very strong restrictions on how far the subjective beliefs misspecify the actual law.

Conclusion: Ruth: So to wrap up, this paper introduces a flexible class of econometric models with a comprehensive identification analysis showing what can and cannot be identified under different scenarios for rational inattention.

Warren: The main implication is that they’ve established that functions u0, u1, and lambda are actually identified even when unobserved heterogeneity is present under suitable assumptions.

Iris: That’s a strong statement because it means you get identification for those specific components even with uncertainty about the environment. But identifying the prior belief Pi V1 still needs very strict restrictions to work reliably.

Ruth: So, they provide a comprehensive analysis showing what works and what doesn't in this framework, which is really helpful for anyone trying to build these models from scratch.

Warren: It sets a clear direction for future research into how we can make these RI-ARUMs more robust when applied to real data where priors are messy.

Iris: Yeah, it’s a solid paper that gives us the tools to test the limits of rational inattention models and see where the identification breaks down.

More episodes

← Home