The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor: simulations, lab and on sky
summary
The gist
Direct imaging of Earth-like exoplanets requires strong suppression of stellar light at small angular separations…
In short
The IR-umPWFS is an infrared pyramid wavefront sensor designed for direct imaging of exoplanets by strongly suppressing stellar light. Simulations and lab tests showed it achieves high Strehl ratios (up to 60%) under challenging seeing conditions. Operating in the infrared allows for higher loop speeds, which improves temporal correction and overall image quality compared to previous systems.
Key concepts
- Adaptive Optics (AO)
- Adaptive Optics uses a deformable mirror to correct distortions in a telescope's light path caused by atmospheric turbulence. This process works by measuring how the incoming light is distorted and then rapidly changing the shape of the mirror to counteract those distortions, resulting in a sharper final image.
- Strehl Ratio
- The Strehl ratio is a measure of image quality that tells you how close your actual image is to an ideal, diffraction-limited point spread function. A higher Strehl ratio means the final image is sharper and has less blurring caused by optical imperfections or atmospheric turbulence.
- Loop Speed
- Loop speed refers to how quickly the adaptive optics system can measure wavefront errors and adjust the deformable mirror accordingly. A faster loop speed allows the system to correct rapid changes in atmospheric turbulence more effectively, leading to better temporal correction and sharper images.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
The paper
The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor: simulations, lab and on sky · Read on arXiv
Muskan Shinde, Nicolas Blind, Isaac Dinis, Sylvain Cetre, Angelie Alagao, Francisco Oyarzun, Romain Fétick, Matteo Pasinetti, Nathanaël Restori, Christophe Lovis, Vincent Chambouleyron**, and others
Geneva Observatory, University of Geneva, Chemin Pegasi 51, 1290 Versoix, Switzerland · Wakea Consulting Grenoble, France · Aix Marseille Univ CNRS CNES LAM Marseille, France · Aix Marseille Univ CNRS Pytheas OHP Observatoire de Haute-Provence
Direct imaging of Earth-like exoplanets requires strong suppression of stellar light at small angular separations, achievable with extreme adaptive optics (XAO). The pyramid wavefront sensor (PWFS) is widely used for its sensitivity but suffers from nonlinearities and limited dynamic range. Modulation extends the range but reduces sensitivity and limits loop speed. We investigate an unmodulated infrared PWFS (IR-umPWFS), where the dynamic range scales with wavelength, removing the need for modulation and enabling faster operation. We adopt a 3-sided PWFS, which eliminates the roof defect of the classical 4-sided design. We assess its feasibility and performance through end-to-end simulations, lab tests, and on-sky observations on the PAPYRUS bench at the Observatoire de Haute-Provence (OHP), and compare it with a visible modulated PWFS (VIS-mPWFS). Simulations show reliable operation, reaching Strehl ratios up to 60% at 1400 nm for seeing up to 4''. Infrared operation improves linearity, reduces optical-gain variations and modal cross-talk. Laboratory results validate the simulations and confirm the pyramid quality. On sky, stable closed-loop operation was achieved over three nights. Compared with the VIS-mPWFS at 500 Hz, the IR-umPWFS at 1000 Hz showed gains of 1.63 in Strehl ratio and 1.26 in encircled energy, and a 2.03-fold reduction in residual wavefront error. The IR-umPWFS remained robust to tip-tilt offsets up to 3 lambda/D at 1400 nm. It is a strong candidate for future XAO systems: operating in the infrared extends the linear range sufficiently to remove the need for modulation, enabling higher loop speeds no longer limited by the modulation mirror, which contributed to the improved on-sky performance. The OHP turbulence (D/r0 17 at 1400 nm) is comparable to typical VLT conditions (D/r0 20), supporting the relevance of these results for VLT/RISTRETTO.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Direct imaging of Earth-like exoplanets requires strong suppression of stellar light at small angular separations, achievable with extreme adaptive optics (XAO) The IR-umPWFS is a strong candidate for future XAO systems because operating in the infrared extends the linear range sufficiently to remove the need for modulation, enabling higher loop speeds that are no longer limited by the speed of the modulation mirror Feasibility and Performance Assessment The performance of the IR-umPWFS was evaluated through a combination of end-to-end numerical simulations, lab tests, and on-sky observations conducted on the PAPYRUS adaptive optics bench at the Observatoire de Haute-Provence (OHP) Simulations show reliable operation over a broad range of conditions, reaching Strehl ratios up to ∼60% at 1400 nm for seeing up to 4′′ Laboratory results validate the simulations and confirm the pyramid quality On sky, stable closed-loop operation was achieved over three nights.
Vera: System Comparison and Advantages The IR-umPWFS operating at 1000 Hz showed gains of ∼ 1.63 in Strehl ratio and ∼ 1.26 in encircled energy, along with a ∼ 2.03-fold reduction in residual wavefront error compared to the VIS-mPWFS operating at 500 Hz.
Jocelyn: The advantages being tested include the pyramid geometry (3- vs 4-sided, the latter with a roof defect), the sensing wavelength and the absence of modulation with the resulting higher loop speed, and different non-common path aberrations whose contribution is removed from the Strehl ratios.
Vera: The IR-umPWFS remained robust to tip-tilt offsets up to 3 λ/D at 1400 nm.
Paper summary: Vera: So, we're looking at this paper about "The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor: simulations, lab and on sky." Basically, they’re talking about how to get really good direct imaging of Earth-like exoplanets.
Jocelyn: And for that, you need extreme adaptive optics to suppress the star's light at very small angles. The paper focuses on a specific type of sensor called a pyramid wavefront sensor, or PWFS.
Subrahmanyan: Which is important because these sensors are sensitive to low-order aberrations, which are the big stuff we need to fix when trying to see faint things like Proxima b, which this paper mentions.
Vera: Right. The main point of this work is that they've designed something called the infrared unmodulated PWFS that doesn't use modulation. They claim operating in the infrared extends the range enough that you don't need modulation anymore, which lets them run at higher loop speeds without being limited by how fast a mirror can spin.
Jocelyn: It seems they’re testing this concept across simulations, lab tests, and even on-sky observations at the Observatoire de Haute-Provence. The thesis is that this infrared unmodulated sensor is a strong candidate for future adaptive optics systems because it allows for higher loop speeds without needing modulation to achieve the necessary performance gains.
Subrahmanyan: That implies that if we can get faster correction loops, we can actually achieve sharper point spread functions and better corrections in real-time, which is crucial for these direct imaging goals. What are the key claims they are making about this sensor?
Vera: They show that simulations suggest reliable operation over a wide range of conditions, reaching Strehl ratios up to sixty percent at one thousand four hundred nanometers for seeing conditions as bad as four arcseconds. On the sky, they actually achieved stable closed-loop operation over three nights.
Jocelyn: And when they compare it to an older system, like the VIS-mPWFS operating at five hundred hertz, the IR-umPWFS operating at one thousand hertz showed gains of about one point six three in Strehl ratio and about one point two six in encircled energy compared to that other system.
Subrahmanyan: That suggests a significant improvement when you increase the loop speed, especially when you look at those residual wavefront errors dropping by two point zero three fold compared to the VIS-mPWFS running at five hundred hertz. So, the gain isn't just from speed; it's also about reducing those other kinds of aberrations that aren't common path aberrations.
Paper summary: Vera: They tested different pyramid geometries and sensing wavelengths, and they found that using a three-sided pyramid actually helped avoid the roof defect issue that can plague the classical four-sided design, which they showed is about thirty one point two micrometers along the roof ridge at one thousand four hundred nanometers <ref:2611.08028#pg1>.
Jocelyn: And because of this geometry and no modulation, they were able to keep it robust even to tip-tilt offsets up to three lambda over D at one thousand four hundred nanometers <ref:2611.08028#pg1>. That’s a big piece of information for real sky conditions.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, that robustness against large tip-tilt errors at that wavelength is interesting because it means the sensor isn't overly sensitive to those kinds of errors when you're trying to correct things in the infrared. Which observation would confirm this level of stability?
Vera: The on-sky results showed that the IR-umPWFS consistently outperformed the VIS-mPWFS, with average gains of about one point six three in Strehl and about one point two six in encircled energy over those three nights.
Jocelyn: But there's a caveat here because they compared it at different loop speeds, and their comparison between five hundred hertz and one thousand hertz wasn't conclusive when looking only at the speed increase itself.
Subrahmanyan: That’s a fair point, Jocelyn. It suggests that the performance gain might not come purely from increasing the loop speed alone, but more from reducing those residual aberrations that are present in both systems.
Vera: They found that the optical gain for the IR-umPWFS is high and nearly flat at about zero point eight five, while in the VIS-mPWFS case, it varies between zero point three and zero point five.
Jocelyn: And they noted a clear drop in that optical gain for modes within the modulation radius in the VIS-mPWFS case, which is something that's absent when you remove modulation for the IR-umPWFS. That suggests that removing modulation preserves the sensor sensitivity in a way that speed alone doesn't fully capture.
Subrahmanyan: So, it seems like high loop speed helps mitigate temporal errors under poor seeing conditions, but the fundamental gain comes from how the sensor handles those aberrations at this infrared wavelength compared to visible light systems. What does this mean for our bigger picture of exoplanet characterization?
Paper summary: Vera: It means that if we can build these unmodulated sensors, we have a better tool for getting the sharp images needed to actually characterize atmospheres, like the one they are targeting with Proxima b.
Jocelyn: They are aiming for a total wavefront error below seventy nanometers RMS at seven hundred fifty nanometers, which is what's required to meet those contrast and Strehl ratio targets for observing reflected light from that type of exoplanet.
Subrahmanyan: To confirm this, we need observations that can reliably measure those low-order wavefront errors and the petal modes they are sensitive to. That would be a crucial follow-up observation to see if this sensor performs as well when looking at real targets in a complex system like an XAO setup.
Vera: So, to summarize this paper, "The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor: simulations, lab and on sky," they’ve shown that using an infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor is a promising path forward for direct imaging because it allows for higher loop speeds without modulation, leading to better performance gains in terms of Strehl ratio and encircled energy.
Jocelyn: The authors point out the importance of the pyramid's tip quality, showing that a three-sided design avoids a major issue with the four-sided pyramid structure by mitigating the roof defect. This is something we need to keep in mind when designing future wavefront sensors for these high-contrast imaging missions.
Subrahmanyan: The implication for cosmology and structure formation is less direct, but it shows that engineering solutions in adaptive optics can get extremely specific performance boosts when you look at the required sensitivity of the instruments. It confirms that we can design tools that are tuned precisely to the physics of what we're trying to observe.
Vera: So, they’ve moved this concept from just theory into concrete lab tests and on-sky validation, showing it works under realistic turbulence conditions for high contrast imaging needs.
Jocelyn: This paves the way for instruments like the VLT/RISTRETTO instrument because infrared operation removes that modulation bottleneck, letting us push those correction loop speeds even further.
Subrahmanyan: And what they’re asking for next is calibration strategy improvements and testing with an appropriate reference image to fully understand the system's performance limits. We need more data on how this sensor behaves when you try to correct things under more complex noise environments.
Conclusion: Vera: So, we're wrapping up this look at "The infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor: simulations, lab and on sky." It’s about how they proved that using an infrared unmodulated pyramid wavefront sensor is a solid way to push adaptive optics further for direct imaging.
Jocelyn: Yeah, it boils down to the fact that you don't need modulation anymore if you operate in the infrared because the range is big enough.
Subrahmanyan: From my end, it’s about engineering a system that can correct those low-order errors with higher loop speeds.
Vera: Exactly. They showed simulations and lab tests work well, and they even got stable on the sky for three nights at four arcseconds of seeing conditions.
Jocelyn: And the results were pretty compelling when they compared it to older systems, showing gains in Strehl ratio and encircled energy with that higher loop speed.
Subrahmanyan: It means we can get sharper images faster, which is crucial for catching those faint exoplanet signals. But we need to see if that gain holds up under real sky noise.
Vera: That’s the thing they're pushing next, though; they’re looking at how to improve the calibration strategy and test it with a better reference image.
Jocelyn: Right. They also have to figure out how to handle those trefoil aberrations that pop up in these systems.
Subrahmanyan: If they can nail those limitations, this sensor design could become a real workhorse for future high-contrast imaging missions across the board.
More episodes
- 2607.17929-gevolution 2.0: GPU-accelerated relativistic N-body simulations for cosmology
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2509.02657-On the synergetic use of Ariel and JWST for exoplanet atmospheric science
- 2609.10042-Modelling Fourier filtering wavefront sensors for PSD-based methods: the AOPERA tool
- 2511.05639-Performance of the AstroPix Prototype Module for the Barrel Imaging Calorimeter at the ePIC Detector and in Space-Based Payloads
- 2610.19909-RPCA: a Resolved PSF reconstruction method for undersampled images
- 2512.03440-An Analysis of LIGO Glitches Using t-SNE During the First Part of the Fourth LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Observing Run
- 2608.10284-Lunar Reflective Interferometry
- 2610.16633-Institutional broadening of the Japanese astronomy and astrophysics research community during 1996-2025